DSage Presents: Heroes vs Villains Mafia - GAME OVER, HEROES WIN!!!!

[Smash]

I take back my last post. IF Nae was a Jester she had to be working alone. Since she was not lynched she can't win, Verbal. But this changes what I was thinking. The Villians could very well have a day kill and used it to kill Nae because they thought she was the finder role. So the Villians lost their NK but still have a day kill.

 

DSage cant tell us because if he does he gives away exactly who has the day kill.

[Thorum]

[glow=red,2,300]smash[/glow]

 

Because he suddenly is much more active than in the beginning of the game, types huge posts, says not very much in them, and then changes his/her vote

[The Crusher]

Excuse me Mr Moderator its me, Crusher.

 

 

 

Is Naenn aligned and part of the mafia or is she like a solo villian?  not asking about her win requirements just wondering if she has a solo or mafia alignment. 

 

I think this is where Mr. Moderator tells Crusher PAFO.

[Toy and Minion]

That, I can answer, Crusher.

 

Solo Win.

[cosmicpanda]

wow 2 villians how cool is that .

 

[glow=red,2,300]unvote Meesh[/glow]

 

Looks like the Villians had a NK and we have a Day Kill . Pandy what are you up too ? Im guessing you will now unvote yourself.

 

No. I am on Meesh's team, and I have decided that if town really wants one of us to die in order to prove our roles, I am less valuable.

[Smash]

lurking. No time to think. See my previous post ;)

 

Very busy couple of days. I'll try catching up tomorrow. Don't modkill me just yet ;D

 

I've catched up - okay, that probably has to be 'catched up', and I'll vote [glow=red,2,300]Naeann[/glow] for now as per appearing most scumishish. I trust her reveal less of all

 

[glow=red,2,300]smash[/glow]

 

Because he suddenly is much more active than in the beginning of the game, types huge posts, says not very much in them, and then changes his/her vote

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vote Thorum[/glow]

 

 

For someone who didnt have time and needed to catch up your profile sure does show a lot of posts the last few days. Then you show up and vote for a possible finder (Nae)with no explanation. Then last but not least you vote for me with another ridiculous accusation.

 

If this is not scummy Im not sure what is.

 

 

[Smash]

That, I can answer, Crusher.

 

Solo Win.

 

So since she is solo there is no way of finding out if she was killed by a villian or a hero. I think If a hero killed her they should reveal so we know what were dealing with. What do you guys think ?

[cosmicpanda]

No. Then they'll be nightkilled.

[peacesells]

wow 2 villians how cool is that .

 

[glow=red,2,300]unvote Meesh[/glow]

 

Looks like the Villians had a NK and we have a Day Kill . Pandy what are you up too ? Im guessing you will now unvote yourself.

 

No. I am on Meesh's team, and I have decided that if town really wants one of us to die in order to prove our roles, I am less valuable.

 

Panda, I believe Meesh has stated she is on a Miller team with you.  Now you are stating that you are not on her team.  Now if that is the case how does Voting you confirm Meesh?

[peacesells]

That, I can answer, Crusher.

 

Solo Win.

 

So since she is solo there is no way of finding out if she was killed by a villian or a hero. I think If a hero killed her they should reveal so we know what were dealing with. What do you guys think ?

 

This is highly suspect and worth a vote imo.

 

Vote Smash

[Naeann]

BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.  HA.  That is all.

[Smash]

Peace can you explain why its highly suspect ? If we already lynched a NKer and there was NO NK last night why would it hurt us to know who killed NAe ? Its very possible the Villians lost their NK.

[peacesells]

Peace can you explain why its highly suspect ? If we already lynched a NKer and there was NO NK last night why would it hurt us to know who killed NAe ? Its very possible the Villians lost their NK.

 

You are making a large assumption that the mafia no longer has a night kill.  Most likely it just defaults to one of the other mafia members.

 

 

[mcs0083]

OR there may be more then one group of villains, and heroes too.

[Thorum]

I'll post this now, even though there are 7 new replies

 

your profile sure does show a lot of posts the last few days.

 

I think you should study the dates and contents of my last posts a bit closer. The no-modkill-please post was exactly that: I knew I would be able to catch up, and didn't want to be modkilled for being inactive in this threat for 3 whole days. Except for very quick responses waiting for a program at work starting up; and some more elaborate responses to one or two new posts in imo very interesting discussions, I did not post during that time.

 

Either I play maffia, or I don't. I don't intent posting in a mafia threat without having read it.

 

Then you show up and vote for a possible finder (Nae)with no explanation.

 

I've catched up - okay, that probably has to be 'caughed up', and I'll vote [glow=red,2,300]Naeann[/glow] for now as per appearing most scumishish. I trust her reveal less of all.

And I was even followed by rose, pandy, and mcs.

 

Then last but not least you vote for me with another ridiculous accusation.

Because he suddenly is much more active than in the beginning of the game, types huge posts, says not very much in them, and then changes his/her vote

.

Which was based on a couple of your posts a couple of pages ago.

 

Thanks for confirming my vote change by allowing me to refute your entire post  :-*

[Smash]

Peace can you explain why its highly suspect ? If we already lynched a NKer and there was NO NK last night why would it hurt us to know who killed NAe ? Its very possible the Villians lost their NK.

 

You are making a large assumption that the mafia no longer has a night kill.  Most likely it just defaults to one of the other mafia members.

 

 

which is exactly why I asked for opinions.

[Thorum]

I think If a hero killed her they should reveal so we know what were dealing with. What do you guys think ?

Never reveal unless it is useful for the town. Even if you get lynched because of it (as long as you're not a finder or more powerful - healers are doubtful). That is my opinion, which is not shared by everyone. I realise that. That's why this did NOT influence my vote on you. It's merely an answer to your question.

 

peace, you must glow your votes. Not bold :P

[mmeeshal]

wow 2 villians how cool is that .

 

[glow=red,2,300]unvote Meesh[/glow]

 

Looks like the Villians had a NK and we have a Day Kill . Pandy what are you up too ? Im guessing you will now unvote yourself.

 

No. I am on Meesh's team, and I have decided that if town really wants one of us to die in order to prove our roles, I am less valuable.

 

Panda, I believe Meesh has stated she is on a Miller team with you.  Now you are stating that you are not on her team.  Now if that is the case how does Voting you confirm Meesh?

He actually said he IS on a team with me, Peace.  And if people won't believe we're on the same team and both millers unless one of us is lynched, then he's offering himself as a lynch because he's less valuable to the town.

[peacesells]

wow 2 villians how cool is that .

 

[glow=red,2,300]unvote Meesh[/glow]

 

Looks like the Villians had a NK and we have a Day Kill . Pandy what are you up too ? Im guessing you will now unvote yourself.

 

No. I am on Meesh's team, and I have decided that if town really wants one of us to die in order to prove our roles, I am less valuable.

 

Panda, I believe Meesh has stated she is on a Miller team with you.  Now you are stating that you are not on her team.  Now if that is the case how does Voting you confirm Meesh?

He actually said he IS on a team with me, Peace.  And if people won't believe we're on the same team and both millers unless one of us is lynched, then he's offering himself as a lynch because he's less valuable to the town.

 

Ah I have reading comprehension failure...that clears that up.

 

And to correct my vote...(differents sites/different rules)  [glow=red,2,300]Vote Smash.[/glow]

[Talya]

I was just going to say to Peace that exact thing Meesh. This has really thrown the cat amongst the pigeons. So did Nae just pluck Meesh's name out of the air and was lucky that she has a millers role (if she does).

 

If anyone stands out to me at the moment, it's MCS and for some reason I don't know why. There was something he said or the way he said it and I can't remember what it was.

 

We still have a day to go I think.

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

I think what you are referring to Talya is when he had one vote and said the town would be sorry.

[Thorum]

Anyone got a votecount?

 

The knights who say 'Ni' have just arrived ;D

 

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

Peace can you explain why its highly suspect ? If we already lynched a NKer and there was NO NK last night why would it hurt us to know who killed NAe ? Its very possible the Villians lost their NK.

 

*Crosses arms* I said basically the same thing and everyone jumped on me and said Mafia. Oh well, A lot has happened since I checked this thread, the Jester got day killed, so they may be a solo which is the most likely or we may be dealing with two mafia teams. I am going to withhold my vote for now until I get a vibe on someone or a pick up on something.

[Smash]

Anyone got a votecount?

 

The knights who say 'Ni' have just arrived ;D

 

Seem a little anxious

[a pale tanned lover]

So Nae was a Jester but did she still have the finder ability?

 

So since she is solo there is no way of finding out if she was killed by a villian or a hero. I think If a hero killed her they should reveal so we know what were dealing with. What do you guys think ?

Sounds suspiciously mafia that smash.

 

I'm voting [glow=red,2,300]pandy[/glow]for the information, if he turns up mafia then we lynch meesh next.