DSage Presents: Heroes vs Villains Mafia - GAME OVER, HEROES WIN!!!!

[The Crusher]

I also want to hear more from the lurkers. A brief look at the playerlist suggests that they're Thorum, Rose, Talya and Crusher.

 

myhomekeyboardbrokenspacebar

 

nokidding

 

iwilldomore

 

aftergettingtowork

 

 

iwaswaitingforyou

 

toconfirmordeny

 

othermillerclaim

 

bebackinabit

[Thorum]

lurking. No time to think. See my previous post ;)

[Smash]

Dragon Nae and Meesh are three to look at. Nae (who accused 3 people to start out) is claiming Finder and pointing at Meesh, after Meesh made a case aganist Dragon. Meesh is claiming Pandy can confirm her innosence. My initial vote (day 1) was on Nae because of the behavior listed but the only person in this trio that cant prove anything right now is Nae.

 

I think we have to Lynch Nae and if she comes up finder we lynch Meesh the next day with a close eye on Pandy who she claims is aware of her situation.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote [/glow]

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vote Naeann [/glow]

 

Smash, can you explain why you think it's a good idea to lynch a potential finder? If someone else claims, then I can see it, but if she's the only one, she's likely the real finder. Losing her, however odd her behavior has been, isn't good for the town, IF she is the finder. I'm kind of new at this game, but I don't see the logic here. Can you explain it to me, please?

 

 

I wanted to see both Nae  and Pandys reaction. They have all claimed, although Pandys role is cloudy, he does not seem to be what Meesh claimed him to be. Meesh said Pandy can confirm her, and that they had the same roles, then Pandy comes out and says Meesh is not Mafia but I cant Claim in fear of Mod Kill. If their Roles are the same and they are connected in some Mason group why would Meesh be able to talk and Pandy not ?  Why would Meesh put him in that position ?

 

This all started when Meesh made her case aganist Dragon so the 4 people involved in this little fiasco are Dragon, Nae, Meesh, Pandy. One or more of them is lieing IMHO. I think the vote has to go on either Nae or Meesh but now Im heavily leaning toward Meesh because of the position she put Pandy in. If Meesh comes up Mafia Pandy would be the obvious next day lynch and that would clear Dragon and Nae.

 

After reading through the thread again I came across this (below) just a few posts before Meesh claimed Miller and that Pandy could claim her as an innocent. He was asking this question to Dragon, the player they both touted as Mafia and both had voted for. Why would Pandy ask Dragon what he thought of Meesha ? It seems to me we could find out alot of Information by voting for Meesha and if shes just a Miller we really wont be losing a serious role if she comes up Innocent.

 

I think you're probably mafia.

 

What do you think of Meesha?

 

Then this quote below by Pandy. Keep in mind that no one died last night so if the Mafia attempted a kill on the Doc and failed this would be the perfect scenario to get the Doc Killed tonight for sure since they probably know exactly who the Doc is. Sure we lynched a mafia player with a NK, but that does not mean the mafia does not have a team NK. Pandy should'nt you assume the Doc would protect the Finder ? Why did you feel the need to tell the Doc to protect Nae ? Are you trying to help the town or are you trying to set up the Doc for an easy kill tonight ?

 

Makes sense. There should be a doctor - protect Nae tonight.

 

Nae just for the record in NO WAY was I trying to counter claim you with my vote, I got the reactions I wanted.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote Nae[/glow]

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vote Meesh [/glow] I think this vote will give the town the most information at the current time with the least amount of damage if she is the Miller.

[The Crusher]

Nice to be at my spotless office keyboard.  Damn you home minions with your sticky fingers and your Nick.com.

 

 

For the record I wasn't lurking I was waiting to see how Panda reacted to the second miller claim. 

 

A lot of nonsense happening here.  We are at the point in the game where I think we need to lynch for information rather than guessing who is mafia who isn't.  My list of potentials matches Smash's besides one that jumped out at me the beginning of the last day. 

 

Right now I think Pandy or Meesh has to go.  We need a coroner report on one of them and this will add light to the others.

 

Naenn is playing either a very brilliant game as a mafiaso or really is the finder.  Lynching her with potential of killing the finder without a counterclaim is silly.  Though I did appreciate Smashs move. 

 

I actually really bought into Meesh giving LZM up and thought no way mafia does that.  I have to assume they have other ways to kill or LZM's killing transfered.  So lets slab Meesh up and see what we get.  [glow=red,2,300]vote meesh[/glow]

[The Crusher]

Nice to be at my spotless office keyboard.  Damn you home minions with your sticky fingers and your Nick.com.

 

 

For the record I wasn't lurking I was waiting to see how Panda reacted to the second miller claim. 

 

A lot of nonsense happening here.   We are at the point in the game where I think we need to lynch for information rather than guessing who is mafia who isn't.  My list of potentials matches Smash's besides one that jumped out at me the beginning of the last day. 

 

Right now I think Pandy or Meesh has to go.  We need a coroner report on one of them and this will add light to the others.

 

Naenn is playing either a very brilliant game as a mafiaso or really is the finder.  Lynching her with potential of killing the finder without a counterclaim is silly.  Though I did appreciate Smashs move. 

 

I actually really bought into Meesh giving LZM up and thought no way mafia does that.  I have to assume they have other ways to kill or LZM's killing transfered.  So lets slab Meesh up and see what we get.  [glow=red,2,300]vote meesh[/glow]

 

OOPS!  I meant END of the last day.

[Verbal32]

I can't find any holes whatsoever in Smash's logic, and I agree 100%.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote

Meesh[/glow]

[Kivam]

Nice to be at my spotless office keyboard.  Damn you home minions with your sticky fingers and your Nick.com.

 

Not commenting on the game.  But Crusher blaming a sticky keyboard on someone other than him needs to be noted, challenged, and laughed at!

[Thorum]

I've catched up - okay, that probably has to be 'catched up', and I'll vote [glow=red,2,300]Naeann[/glow] for now as per appearing most scumishish. I trust her reveal less of all

[mnwhiterose]

Sorry - I was at my mom's house and her computer is slower than a turtle in winter. So, I wouldn't have been able to get on.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Naeann[/glow]

 

For one reason and one reason only - you aren't the finder. I'm not claiming to be the Finder, but I do have a great town role that I used on Nae, so if she were the Finder, she wouldn't have gotten any results.

[The Crusher]

Nice to be at my spotless office keyboard.  Damn you home minions with your sticky fingers and your Nick.com.

 

Not commenting on the game.  But Crusher blaming a sticky keyboard on someone other than him needs to be noted, challenged, and laughed at!

 

 

Im sad your not playing.

 

 

 

 

 

So i could kill you.  By the way nice catch.  LOL

[Talya]

I'm not lurking neither Pandy...I was asleep when some of this went on and the rest of the time at work (I have a new job and can't get on here except in the evenings for the moment) So I have had my tea and have just read this.

 

I'm not sure what to think at the moment. We have a lot of people claiming roles. And at this point it is getting vey confusing.

 

Pandy and Meesh claim Miller.

Nae claims Finder

And now Rose claims some kind of Blocker role.

 

At first I wasn't sure there would be two Millers on one game, but it seems there are a few powers out there, not just the normal ones. Meesh might have given up her team mate. It would look good to get rid of one that has a nightkill attached to the role. Then not night kill anyone but still have the ability to kill.

 

Nae could be lying, but I ask, how could she have known that Meesh was mafia, she would have had to view here at some point. She couldn't have guessed it. And them Meesh says that she is a Miller. Of course all three could be on the same team, which would explain Nae's sudden unvote of Meesh after claiming She wouldn't have needed to have any role. If that is the case then Pandy, Meesh and Nae are all on the same team. And this would be very a dangerous game to play. To be so out in the open, but that is what they are hoping for.

 

We have to Lynch on of those three. It won't answer all out questions but it may help us see more.

 

It could also be that Rose is lying to make Nae look like she is lying, which would probably put Meesh, Pandy and Rose on a team.

 

So to try and work out what is going on I'm not going to do for a (so far) unchallenged Finder, so it will have to be one of the other two. So I will go for [glow=red,2,300]Meesh[/glow]

[cosmicpanda]

Eh... I reckon I would be a better test case than Meesha. Lynch me instead. When I die, believe what she says about the miller team.

 

[glow=red,2,300]unvote, vote Pandy[/glow]

 

[cosmicpanda]

Sorry - I was at my mom's house and her computer is slower than a turtle in winter. So, I wouldn't have been able to get on.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Naeann[/glow]

 

For one reason and one reason only - you aren't the finder. I'm not claiming to be the Finder, but I do have a great town role that I used on Nae, so if she were the Finder, she wouldn't have gotten any results.

 

[glow=red,2,300]unvote, vote Nae[/glow]

 

Actually, this seems more useful. I can't see why Rose would lie.

[mcs0083]

I'll go ahead and vote [glow=red,2,300]Naeann[/glow], on the grounds that I'm the one who gave the original reason toward her getting voted for, and more then one person agrees.

[Talya]

So no one else comes forward as Finder and you are all willing to believe Rose and take her word for what she supposedly did. If Nae is the finder we have lost ours...not good for the innocents. If she is lying then we will soon know for definate. But ask yourself. How did she know Meesh was Mafia (even though she said she was a miller). She got the finding of Mafia from somewhere! That doesn't stop her being evil of course, she may have  a funny kind of mafia role.

 

But I still don't like the idea of lynching a claimed finder until we can find out more. We still have a fair bit of time left.

[Toy and Minion]

Time: 5:53 AM (SFT) - 8:22 AM (SFT)

 

The day started off heated.  The one named Mmeeshal was quickly gaining votes, and it seemed inevitable that she would be the next victim.  Naeann was the one who had started it, calling Mmeeshal a villain.  Others agreed, though most stayed quiet, trying to think it through.

 

Suddenly Naeann froze.  Her eyes were wide.  You studied her, not knowing what was going on.  Then, as suddenly as she had frozen, she began to convulse.  Her hands grabbed her head, shaking it vehemently.  You didn't know what to do, so you just watched.  She cried out.  One long, awful, note.  Then she fell to the ground, limp.

 

You walked over to her, heart pounding.  You check her pulse, only to find none.  You look at the rest of the group, they look just as stunned as you are.

 

"She's dead." You say simply.  Then the red comes again, blocking your vision.  It clears and you look down.  Your breath is lost.  Like someone hit you with a bullet train.  You stand up, completely confused.

 

 

The Jester (Naean), the Jester, has been Day Killed.

[Toy and Minion]

Post Count

 

mmeeshal (4): Smash, Crusher, Verbal, Talya

 

dragonsworn (2): mmeeshal

 

cosmicpanda (1): dragonsworn

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch.

 

Not voting: cosmicpanda, peacesells, Thorum, Pale Merlot, mcs, mnwhiterose, LilyElizabeth

 

Deadline:  15th Thursday, 5:00 PM (MST)

 

[cosmicpanda]

[glow=red,2,300]unvote, vote Pandy[/glow]

 

guess we're back to this again, then.

 

*whistles*

 

Eh... I reckon I would be a better test case than Meesha. Lynch me instead. When I die, believe what she says about the miller team.

[Smash]

Time: 5:53 AM (SFT) - 8:22 AM (SFT)

 

The day started off heated.  The one named Mmeeshal was quickly gaining votes, and it seemed inevitable that she would be the next victim.  Naeann was the one who had started it, calling Mmeeshal a villain.  Others agreed, though most stayed quiet, trying to think it through.

 

Suddenly Naeann froze.  Her eyes were wide.  You studied her, not knowing what was going on.  Then, as suddenly as she had frozen, she began to convulse.  Her hands grabbed her head, shaking it vehemently.  You didn't know what to do, so you just watched.  She cried out.  One long, awful, note.  Then she fell to the ground, limp.

 

You walked over to her, heart pounding.  You check her pulse, only to find none.  You look at the rest of the group, they look just as stunned as you are.

 

"She's dead." You say simply.  Then the red comes again, blocking your vision.  It clears and you look down.  Your breath is lost.  Like someone hit you with a bullet train.  You stand up, completely confused.

 

 

The Jester (Naean), the Jester, has been Day Killed.

 

Is this a Detective jester or is it the mafia role jester ?

 

The Superhero "The Jester" was a Detective.

 

The "Mafia Jester" is anti town.

 

Can you confirm this please DSage.

[peacesells]

Yeah..I was wondering if by being daykilled she fullfilled some kind of win condition?

[Toy and Minion]

Villain.

[mnwhiterose]

Dude. What just happened? Do we have a day killer out there?

[Smash]

wow 2 villians how cool is that .

 

[glow=red,2,300]unvote Meesh[/glow]

 

Looks like the Villians had a NK and we have a Day Kill . Pandy what are you up too ? Im guessing you will now unvote yourself.

[Verbal32]

Looks like Nae was the Jester in name AND role.  But Jesters usually win when lynched, and she was Day Killed.

 

DSage, can you confirm the status of Nae's win condition?  Did she fulfill it, or did somebody kill her and she's out?

[Toy and Minion]

DSage, can you confirm the status of Nae's win condition?  Did she fulfill it, or did somebody kill her and she's out?

 

No comment.