Jump to content

DRAGONMOUNT

A WHEEL OF TIME COMMUNITY

Create-Your-Own-Role Mafia II - Game Over


cosmicpanda

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 270
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Posted

I totally did not read the role description of my own submission so I didn't see that the three people were listed.  Which makes me a little leery of Mynd's vote on Blig Blog - would Mynd really miss something like that?  I mean, this is Mynd we're talking about.

Posted

Wow...fancy.

 

Okay, so the thing with the first day, is that we have nothing much to go on. With that in mind, I'm voting [glow=red,2,300]Carywn[/glow]. Completely retaliatory. :D

Posted
  Quote

Wait - do we want to lynch any of the people listed in the JB2 role? I mean, we could potentially be losing a powerful uber-townie.  and the only ones who would want to cripple the town would be mafia. And, until there is evidence that these 3 are mafia, I'm going to have to throw my vote to [glow=red,2,300]Cuba[/glow]

 

Why do you think Mynd might be one of the JB2 roles?

Posted

Well, he may not be a JB2 role now. But when the role was first posted, he was listed as one of the 3. So, I found it quite interesting that you would vote for him and potentially cripple a strong townie - without any evidence that Mynd is mafia.  That sort of strategy just reeks of mafia to me.

 

and, I realize that the role has been changed, and Mynd is no longer known to be part of the 3.

 

And the only other people to vote for the 3 are Mynd (can't vote for him since that would just destroy my current reasoning) or Hybrid.  I flipped a coin....you came up the loser.

Posted

MOD please clarify.... If the messenger roled person can only post under the alt... the Verb's vote on Messenger WOULD count right? 

 

 

Your current reasoning, Mn, is now thrown out since we no longer know who the three people are.

 

 

Posted

Plus, the MOD might have just kept them the same...or changed just one...or changed just two. He might have changed all 3 but I would keep a couple the same to confuse people.  8)

Posted

No, my reasoning is still valid.  It doesn't matter if Thorum, Mynd and Blig Blog are no longer parties of JB2.  The fact remains that when we did know who those 3 were, Cuba and Hybrid both were willing to vote for 1 of those individuals, which would cripple the JB2, who is a potentially uber-townie. The only reason to do that is if Cuba and Hybrid were mafia. Destroy the support structure of the town (doctor & finder in a vanilla game), then pick off the rest of the town. 

 

now, if it were to become known that 3 different players (Joe, Billy and Frank for lack of better names) were now part of the JB2 and Tammy were to vote for one of them without evidence they were mafia, I would suspect her to be mafia.

 

***names have been changed to protect the innocent***

Posted

VOTE COUNT 2

 

Blig Blog (2) - Mynd, Hybrid

Nae (1) - Thorum

Mynd (1) - Cubarey

Hybrid (1) - Blig Blog

Cubarey (1) - Rose

FDM (2) - Messenger, Cat

Cat (1) - FDM

Messenger (1) - Verbal

 

Not voting: DJ, Lia, DS, Jeran, Nae

 

deadline

Posted
  Quote

No, my reasoning is still valid.  It doesn't matter if Thorum, Mynd and Blig Blog are no longer parties of JB2.  The fact remains that when we did know who those 3 were, Cuba and Hybrid both were willing to vote for 1 of those individuals, which would cripple the JB2, who is a potentially uber-townie. The only reason to do that is if Cuba and Hybrid were mafia. Destroy the support structure of the town (doctor & finder in a vanilla game), then pick off the rest of the town. 

 

now, if it were to become known that 3 different players (Joe, Billy and Frank for lack of better names) were now part of the JB2 and Tammy were to vote for one of them without evidence they were mafia, I would suspect her to be mafia.

 

***names have been changed to protect the innocent***

 

MN just to clarify. I vote to Lynch Mynd on the first day of any game is not a sign that the voter is mafia it's a sign that he is sane! ;D

 

The first few votes of on day one of any game are not only not based on any evidence they tend to be done in fun.

  • Moderator
Posted

I think the vote on Mynd is something to note, but I don't think it necessarily screams "mafia", as CUBA is right - it is only Day 1.

Posted

I continue to chuckle when people declare with fervor that "You can't tell anything from Day 1 randomness" and submit themselves to this.  You can tell a LOT about how people vote, when they vote, and when they act slightly different than they normally do. 

 

OVER-justification of a "random" vote is a huge red flag.  Also, continuing to profess that you can't tell anything from Day 1 randomness can also be considered as a mafia trying to look innocent.  The mafia tend to give themselves away in their own posts, especially on day one. 

Posted
  Quote

  Quote

[glow=red,2,300]FDM[/glow]

 

No reasoning? No nothing?

 

I chose her because... well, it is the first day and she is shifty like that.

 

<_<

>_>

<_<

Guest dragonsworn1991
Posted
  Quote
OVER-justification of a "random" vote is a huge red flag.  Also, continuing to profess that you can't tell anything from Day 1 randomness can also be considered as a mafia trying to look innocent.  The mafia tend to give themselves away in their own posts, especially on day one.

 

You're over analysis of first day post is kind of suspicious. You seem to be trying to spread out other people's votes, which would result in a random kill. Since there are more townies than mafia the odds would be in the mafias favor.

 

That is why I am voting Mynd

Posted

I dont know if Im allowed to reveal who I am.. Id prefer not to be modkilled then tell who I am.

 

I have silencing ability when night comes, and lets just say Im not palnning on using it... I cant see any reason to silence anyone. (even if it might be tempting to silence Mynd...  ;) )

Just because I wouldnt want to silence the mafia, since it is through their activity we can get to them...

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...