Dirty Cops Mafia - GAME OVER!!!

[CUBAREY]

Before I switched votes, this is what DSage said:

 

Lynching Ballot

 

Danya (4): Catina, Thorum, Cubarey, Myndrunner

 

Myndrunner (3): Verbal, Dark Justice, Mcs

 

 

Mcs (2): Pandy, Liathiana

 

Liathiana (1): Jeran

Hybrid (1): Talya

Cubarey (1): Barmacral

Jeran (1): Peace

 

With 15 alive, it takes 8 votes to Lynch.

 

Day 1 ends Friday 20 at 3:00 PM (MST) - That is in 16 Hours and 45 Minutes.

 

First change of vote: Danya votes for Mynd to go off.

 

Which makes the both of you equal on four, with two out of the last three votes for Mynd.

 

Which gave the Mynd-vote better dynamics.

 

How does a vote by Danya against the only other viable choice build momentum? Only two actual votes with any meaning occured, one for Danya and one for Mynd.

 

I am not saying that Mynd is guilty, only that your logic makes no sense.

 

 

[mcs0083]

lol

Nice CUBAREY

[Barmacral]

ATTENTION - NO EDITING POSTS FOR ANY REASON WHATSOEVER. I DON'T CARE IF THAT ANNOYING TYPO IS IN THERE, OR IF YOUR QUOTES ARE BROKEN. DO NOT EDIT YOUR POSTS. This has been said several times now. Consider this a friendly warning from the board Mod.

 

My opinions on the game will come after I'm home from school.

[CUBAREY]

DOH, I'M STUPID. Put my comment on Thorum's post in the middle of his post, then edited it to correct it. I did to hit in the head a few times (but not lynched).

[Thorum]

How does a vote by Danya against the only other viable choice build momentum? Only two actual votes with any meaning occured, one for Danya and one for Mynd.

 

I am not saying that Mynd is guilty, only that your logic makes no sense.

 

Can you elaborate on this? I don't understand a word of it. It probably looked much better before the editing.

 

From now on I'll switch my vote every post I make [glow=red,2,300]CUBAREY[/glow]

[Dark Justice]

Sorry for being inactive over the weekend guys. Ill be more around this week...

 

I have to go with [glow=red,2,300]MCS[/glow] here...

lying lyars should always be lynched.

[MsDanya]

yeah seriously, if you see a mistake in your post, make a new one, dont edit your post. This is also why we have the oh so wonderful [glow=red,2,300]Preview button[/glow] , right next to the post button. Thats a good one to see if your glow works correctly, the same with your quoting. Specially your quoting, as there's alot of it in a game like this and we all like easy to read posts!

 

 

Also what are you all going to do if you get hurt? Lynching me isn't exactly in the best interest of every one in the game.

 

MCS, what exactly are you implying here?  Are you trying to say you are the healer?

Who knows? I'm just saying that offing me wouldn't be a very good idea.

 

lol, yes who indeed ;)

[peacesells]

I'm witholding all thoughts until Catina decides to post....if she isn't scared off. 

[mcs0083]

Sorry for being inactive over the weekend guys. Ill be more around this week...

 

I have to go with [glow=red,2,300]MCS[/glow] here...

lying lyars should always be lynched.

I didn't lie...... I didn't fully explain what I was doing but in the end my intentions were told to everyone. Obviously everyone didn't read that and went straight to lynching me. ::)

[Thorum]

then you may want to post a quote of that post, cause maybe it's one of the things you edited away...

[Myndrunner]

MCS, you definitely get the FACEPALM award for this game, with Cube the runner up.  I'm not sure what to do with you.  On one hand, you have given me every reason to lynch you and my gut is screaming scum ....well, its screaming from the buffalo wings I had last night, but still.  I could just be the Naive Cop or maybe the Crazy Cop and that would explain a lot.

 

Without revealing the findings, I hope more than one person got a read on MCS last night.  Lynching MCS seems to be the best option. 

 

Threatening to lynch Catina before she posts her results seems like a scum move if you ask me.  What do you have to be afraid of, Talya?

[Myndrunner]

WHAT? Are you guys editing MY posts now?

 

« Last Edit: Today at 11:30:01 AM by CUBAREY »

[Talya]

 

Threatening to lynch Catina before she posts her results seems like a scum move if you ask me.  What do you have to be afraid of, Talya?

 

She has to post her viewings now, so I'm not scared of anything. She has won the vote and Dsage says that they have to say what they had. If I was mafia and wanted her lynched, she would be getting out that I'm mafia asap! so I wouldn't win if I do vote for her or if I don't, makes no different. Unless she is  paranoid cop, or whatever then if she finds me mafia she is lying. But no matter who she says the only way we can find out for sure is by lynching her and getting the coroners report. If she comes back as a basic innocent cop then we know her viewing to be true and we have one caught. It will also look like mcs could be mafia, or someone using him to make him look guilty. Which means it was more then likely someone on at that time, we just have to look who posted around then and look into them.

 

I may have got it wrong about Her having to come up with something. If she is innocent she will give all the info she can to help them. If she isn't she will lie through her teeth. It sounds harsh but we get a lot more info on lynching her than we do on mcs. However we can still keep him in the forefront of our minds for the next one.

 

If there is a healer, maybe there are other roles out there too, a Mafia Godfather, a symp, an assasin, maybe it's not just paranoid cop etc... :-\

[peacesells]

 

Threatening to lynch Catina before she posts her results seems like a scum move if you ask me.  What do you have to be afraid of, Talya?

 

She has to post her viewings now, so I'm not scared of anything. She has won the vote and Dsage says that they have to say what they had. If I was mafia and wanted her lynched, she would be getting out that I'm mafia asap! so I wouldn't win if I do vote for her or if I don't, makes no different. Unless she is  paranoid cop, or whatever then if she finds me mafia she is lying. But no matter who she says the only way we can find out for sure is by lynching her and getting the coroners report. If she comes back as a basic innocent cop then we know her viewing to be true and we have one caught. It will also look like mcs could be mafia, or someone using him to make him look guilty. Which means it was more then likely someone on at that time, we just have to look who posted around then and look into them.

 

I may have got it wrong about Her having to come up with something. If she is innocent she will give all the info she can to help them. If she isn't she will lie through her teeth. It sounds harsh but we get a lot more info on lynching her than we do on mcs. However we can still keep him in the forefront of our minds for the next one.

 

If there is a healer, maybe there are other roles out there too, a Mafia Godfather, a symp, an assasin, maybe it's not just paranoid cop etc... :-\

 

You've just done an absolutely terrific job at keeping anyone else from nominating themselves as a finder from here on out. 

[Thorum]

That may even be his point ...

[glow=red,2,300]mcs[/glow]

[Hybrid]

WHAT? Are you guys editing MY posts now?

 

« Last Edit: Today at 11:30:01 AM by CUBAREY »

Cute, Mynd, but it's not supposed to be bolded.  ;)

[Barmacral]

Tayla - Where does it say that she HAS to post her viewings? In fact, if I correctly recall, she doesn't have to, however, she's wasting the day for everyone and won't get another chance to reveal her findings after day ends unless we vote for her again.

[Barmacral]

It's clear to me that I have left some matters untouched in my rules.  So, I will clarify them here and add them into the rules.

 

If, by the end of the Day a majority has not been reached on the Lynching Ballot, the Day will end with no death.  If the same happens to the Finding Ballot, no Findings will be revealed.

 

You, as the Players, want to get the Finding Ballot done well before the deadline.  If the Player who 'wins' on the Finding Ballot does not post his/her Finding results (real or imagined) by the end of the Day, they will lose their chance to reveal and will need to start fresh the following Day - meaning volunteering themselves for the Ballot and going through the entire process again.

 

If a player is Modkilled, their alignment status will not be revealed.

 

I hope that clears up some issues.

 

Here Talya, to back it up.

[Hybrid]

Finally, there's his helpful compilation of Verbal's posts.  This bugs me for some reason.  He didn't post a conclusion about his thoughts on Verbal's alignment or anything, and Verbal hasn't really come under much scrutiny.  So why post it?  I'm conflicted on this one.  It is helpful (and could just be altruism), but it feels like he was simply trying to appear helpful without making an actual case on someone.

Of course I' not making a post of Verbal. He's confirmed innocent, remember.

For conclusions, they are before the list of posts.

This was my mistake - I forgot that Verbal had been the one night killed.  So obviously you're not going to be making a conclusion about his alignment, since it's already proven, but instead about what his thoughts were.

 

1) I found his reasoning behind his unvote on Danya and vote for Mynd Day 1 to be contradictory - he said he did so to help get a majority, but he was unvoting the person with the most votes at the time.

No, they had an equal amount of votes, with Mynd having a much better chance of getting lynched at that time, since much more people seemed to half agree on a mynd-lynch than on a Danya-lynch.

Well, that's your opinion, I guess.  On the one hand, Mynd does jump around a bunch, so his accusations do make it easier for people to decide to lynch him.  On the other, Danya already had the most votes, and some of the people who jumped on Mynd's wagon at the last minute were only doing so to get a majority.

 

Most of your explanations are starting to make sense, so [glow=red,2,300]Unvote Thorum[/glow].

[Hybrid]

Talya, you seem awful eager to lynch Catina (no n before t)  ;).  She's probably got school or something right now and hasn't been able to get online.  It's not like she's been really inactive - she posted yesterday.  Like Jeran said, we've got some time still, so let's wait and see whether she comes online.  If we get closer to the deadline, I'm all for lynching her for inactivity after nominating herself for the finder ballot.

[Talya]

I've just reread that again, thanks Barm, I could have sworn it said she had to. I've had that my head the whole time. Well I keep that on there, incase she decideds not to reveal anyway after being so quick to jump up with voting for herself.

 

You've just done an absolutely terrific job at keeping anyone else from nominating themselves as a finder from here on out. 

 

Why don't you read all my posts on the subject peacesells, because I said that it would give us the most information THIS time and that it would change after the night and we can get more info from other things. I said this wouldn't be something we do all the time. Just this time

 

Oh and sorry Catina, I guess I watch too much Star Wars >.>

 

 

[peacesells]

I've just reread that again, thanks Barm, I could have sworn it said she had to. I've had that my head the whole time. Well I keep that on there, incase she decideds not to reveal anyway after being so quick to jump up with voting for herself.

 

You've just done an absolutely terrific job at keeping anyone else from nominating themselves as a finder from here on out.   

 

Why don't you read all my posts on the subject peacesells, because I said that it would give us the most information THIS time and that it would change after the night and we can get more info from other things. I said this wouldn't be something we do all the time. Just this time

 

>.>

 

I've read all of your posts...don't assume I haven't.  And, just because you say "this time" doesn't mean the impact isn't there.  You've done a wonderful job here. 

 

 

[Myndrunner]

Mynd's observations this round:

 

Talya seems bent on lynching Catina, and despite reasons not to, she is pushing for it hard.  There are other ways to see if Catina is telling the truth.

 

MCS.....what else can I say? I think he's the most likely to lynch at this point.  My only concern is the off chance that, for once, he is telling the truth about being the healer.  Still, even then, it would shed a lot of light on what kind of Cop I am if we got a confirmed coroner report.

 

Cubeary, acting an awful lot like MCS lately, editing posts and such, and you continue to seem like you are defending him.  Wonder if the two of you are in cohoots. 

 

That is all for now.....*looks at watch*.....I hope Cantina gets here soon.  ;D

[Talya]

I;m not sure what you mean, it's been a long day and I'm confused. I assume you mean that the impact of people not revealing. I think if anyone has only the good of the innocents in mind then they won't mind revealing it, hopefully it will put of those that arent innocent! ;)

 

I see it as we don't have hardly any info from day one, so it would be good to use this opportunity to get information on three people at once.

 

And what other ways are there Mynd, that prodce quite a bit of infor before we go to night?

[Talya]

Oh and Mynd, I haven't seen anyone come up with a good reason not to!