Dirty Cops Mafia - GAME OVER!!!

[cosmicpanda]

1) Your strange vote for Mynd

 

2) Your unhelpful reaction to it that night

 

3) Your editing posts without truthfully telling us what was edited.

[Myndrunner]

My apologies cosmicpanda. 

 

I think that we will have a lot to go on if we get a handy-dandy coroner report on MCS; however, Catina seems to have something vital to share with us.  I do hope that she does before Day ends here. 

 

Regardless, lynching MCS will tell me what I need to know to proceed tonight.  I suggest everyone view themselves on Night 2 if they haven't already, it should help confirm what kind of cop you are. 

[CUBAREY]

1) Your strange vote for Mynd

 

cospicpanda why are you still trying to protect Mynd? It seems that six other players had good enough reason to vote for him and frankly I may have made a mistake in not switching to lynch him at the end of Day 1. You and Tayla are the only ones who seem hell bent on protecting him now, why is that?

[Hybrid]

Since everyone seems to be having problems typing each other's names, I thought I'd clarify mine too (for the record).  It's Hybrid: H-Y-B-R-I-D.  Not Hybird.  You can also address me as "Lord Hybrid" or "Sir Hybrid" or "Sir Lord Hybrid" or "Lord Hybrid Sir" or any other honorary title if you wish to.  Though it won't gain you any favors.

[Verbal32]

Night 1 NK.  Doh.

 

*dies*

[cosmicpanda]

1) Your strange vote for Mynd

 

cospicpanda why are you still trying to protect Mynd? It seems that six other players had good enough reason to vote for him and frankly I may have made a mistake in not switching to lynch him at the end of Day 1. You and Tayla are the only ones who seem hell bent on protecting him now, why is that?

 

Remind me of the case against him, again?

[Myndrunner]

I love how when someone picks out the flaws in one person's case, they are seen as defending someone else.  Is it possible, Cube, that maybe Talya and cosmicpanda don't think I'm mafia because they have good reason to? 

 

Remind me, what was your reason for lynching Danya again?

[Thorum]

2) I also don't get why he would trust mcs the most and why he is less likely to be mafia.

Note that this was before he made his second mistake.

 

And why he would want someone to reveal their findings BEFORE that person decided those findings were useful or important.

Misinterpretation

 

Finally, there's his helpful compilation of Verbal's posts.  This bugs me for some reason.  He didn't post a conclusion about his thoughts on Verbal's alignment or anything, and Verbal hasn't really come under much scrutiny.  So why post it?  I'm conflicted on this one.  It is helpful (and could just be altruism), but it feels like he was simply trying to appear helpful without making an actual case on someone.

Of course I' not making a post of Verbal. He's confirmed innocent, remember.

For conclusions, they are before the list of posts.

 

1) I found his reasoning behind his unvote on Danya and vote for Mynd Day 1 to be contradictory - he said he did so to help get a majority, but he was unvoting the person with the most votes at the time.

No, they had an equal amount of votes, with Mynd having a much better chance of getting lynched at that time, since much more people seemed to half agree on a mynd-lynch than on a Danya-lynch.

 

I will be changing my vote to [glow=red,2,300]mcs[/glow] for now. One mistake is possible, twice is difficult, three is deadly.

[mcs0083]

Oh so your looking at the opinion of someone else, and taking the same action as them. I believe that is called hoping on the bandwagon.

[Barmacral]

Hey, just checking in, I've been here, I'm just recovering from some sickness and haven't been posting as much.

[mcs0083]

Also what are you all going to do if you get hurt? Lynching me isn't exactly in the best interest of every one in the game.

[Thorum]

Oh so your looking at the opinion of someone else, and taking the same action as them. I believe that is called hoping on the bandwagon.

 

Where am I doing that? Hybrid voted me, and I defended myself.

 

Than I voted you for repeating your mistake

 

 

[mcs0083]

When did I repeat my mistake? I only made ONE mistake. I edited it accordingly and explained what happened.

[Thorum]

This is the first one:

 

Aaaaaaaand caught up.

 

#1: it's LiAth. THERE IS AN A IN MY NAME. It's not Lith PLEASE STOP TYPING IT LIKE THAT. It's really annoying :P Just to clarify once more it is LIATH. Thank you ;D

 

Now I've seen the vote someone off because they're inactive vote before and I'm not plussed by it. You don't get any information but you can move on to active players in the game.

 

So I'm voting [glow=red,2,300]mcs[/glow] for spelling my name wrong consistently. Like I said...it's really frakking annoying :P

I'm sorry you feel that way Liath. If it helps I say frack a lot too. lol

I didn't even know how to say it so I just went with that. And there were others who said it wrong too.

hahahaha!  Is everyone just making stuff up in this game?  I wasn't offended by anyone's vote.  Most of you know that I often get votes on me because of my playstyle.  Thorum has his vote on you, in case you didn't notice.....but I do understand if RL is getting the best of you.

 

Dark Justice, on the other hand, I'm not sure exactly what the reason behind his vote was.  Same with MCS.

Your evidently the master of making scum excuses. Calling the kettle black isn't going to get you anywhere.

Lynching Ballot

 

Danya (4): Catina, Thorum, Cubarey, Myndrunner

 

Myndrunner (3): Verbal, Dark Justice, Mcs

 

Mcs (2): Pandy, Liathiana

 

Liathiana (1): Jeran

Hybrid (1): Talya

Cubarey (1): Barmacral

Jeran (1): Peace

 

With 15 alive, it takes 8 votes to Lynch.

 

Day 1 ends Friday 20 at 3:00 PM (MST) - That is in 16 Hours and 45 Minutes.

Oh my I have two votes. I feel soooooo dirty ::)

 

And you didn't explain why you lied about what happened the second time. Unless Talya and Mynd are both maffia and they want you busted.

[mcs0083]

Are you kidding me? Ok, Liath got her point across by voting to lynch me and I'm not going to misspell her name again, but how could you use THIS to lynch me? And I did explain about the FIRST time.

[mcs0083]

So I'm not allowed to change my vote? :-\ I forgot the glow the first time anyway before you saw it. I did forget to unvote though. :-[

[mcs0083]

Well I forgot to say unvote :(

[Thorum]

Are you kidding me? Ok, Liath got her point across by voting to lynch me and I'm not going to misspell her name again, but how could you use THIS to lynch me? And I did explain about the FIRST time.

 

And we spent at least one page to say you are NEVER allowed to do it again.

 

You didn't explain why you lied about your second edit (under the above-stated edition).

[Talya]

So I'm not allowed to change my vote? :-\ I forgot the glow the first time anyway before you saw it. I did forget to unvote though. :-[

 

I saw the post, you had glowed Mynds name and said that you thought what he said was interesting and wanted to hear more. So this isn't quite true. It wasn't about glowing your vote or forgeting to put unvote. You change the whole post vote and all.

 

The first mistake was when I corrected you on day one for editing your post. You said sorry and wouldn't do it again. And the above is about you editing your post after that so the SECOND time!

 

I forgave you the first time, but the second looks like you had something to hide.

 

Okay back to the voting I think Cantina has enough on her to reveal her viewings. So lets see what she has to say.

 

I also think that the best way to get quite a bit of info is to lynch Cantina. She seemed to be waiting for Dsage to some in with his night result and then puts herself forward. By Lynching her we can find out about the information she gives (whether paranoid cop etc). If she is Mafia or innocent. If she is Mafia I would say mcs is another mafia or symp! If she is Innocent, it maybe she was set up with the mcs thing and I would look to Mynd for that! or maybe one of the others who was on at that time.

 

Also what are you all going to do if you get hurt? Lynching me isn't exactly in the best interest of every one in the game.

 

In this one mcs seems to be hinting he may have some sort of role.  ::)

 

At the moment I'm going to go with [glow=red,2,300]Cantina[/glow] because I see this as getting more information out of it. Though I would be willing to change my vote to mcs.

 

[Myndrunner]

No, they had an equal amount of votes, with Mynd having a much better chance of getting lynched at that time, since much more people seemed to half agree on a mynd-lynch than on a Danya-lynch.

 

This is not true! Danya had more votes at the time, and DSage had even posted a recent update.  It is likely that Danya is your mafia buddy and you saw the bandwagon getting out of control. 

 

Also what are you all going to do if you get hurt? Lynching me isn't exactly in the best interest of every one in the game.

 

MCS, what exactly are you implying here?  Are you trying to say you are the healer?

 

When did I repeat my mistake? I only made ONE mistake. I edited it accordingly and explained what happened.

 

You lied about it.  You claimed you made the edit to add the green glow, but you changed your vote as well.  That is why we have the no edit rule.  How can we take anything you say as even remotely true now?

 

Okay back to the voting I think Cantina has enough on her to reveal her viewings. So lets see what she has to say.

 

I also think that the best way to get quite a bit of info is to lynch Cantina. She seemed to be waiting for Dsage to some in with his night result and then puts herself forward. By Lynching her we can find out about the information she gives (whether paranoid cop etc). If she is Mafia or innocent. If she is Mafia I would say mcs is another mafia or symp! If she is Innocent, it maybe she was set up with the mcs thing and I would look to Mynd for that! or maybe one of the others who was on at that time.

 

 

At the moment I'm going to go with [glow=red,2,300]Cantina[/glow] because I see this as getting more information out of it. Though I would be willing to change my vote to mcs.

 

Ok, Mrs. Pot, I was with you until this part of your post.  You want to lynch the person who reveals her info?  In a normal mafia game, the most effective way to get info is indeed the lynch; however, we are all cops (well, most of us) so like a fast mafia, its only a matter of time before we all figure out what kind of cops we all are and who is scum.  I find your premature bloodlust quite disturbing.  Let's at least find out what the girl has to say, or she may be afraid to reveal now that a lynch is waiting for her.  Nice going, you probably scared the poor girl into going back into hiding.

 

...hmmm, or maybe that was your plan?

[Thorum]

Before I switched votes, this is what DSage said:

 

Lynching Ballot

 

Danya (4): Catina, Thorum, Cubarey, Myndrunner

 

Myndrunner (3): Verbal, Dark Justice, Mcs

 

Mcs (2): Pandy, Liathiana

 

Liathiana (1): Jeran

Hybrid (1): Talya

Cubarey (1): Barmacral

Jeran (1): Peace

 

With 15 alive, it takes 8 votes to Lynch.

 

Day 1 ends Friday 20 at 3:00 PM (MST) - That is in 16 Hours and 45 Minutes.

 

First change of vote: Danya votes for Mynd to go off.

 

Which makes the both of you equal on four, with two out of the last three votes for Mynd.

 

Which gave the Mynd-vote better dynamics.

[Jeran]

Considering there are about 3.5 days until the deadline I'm going to wait a bit before lynch voting unless Catina takes too long to post her findings (unless something new and revealing shows up before then, of course).  I think most of the current suspicions have been covered by people other than myself so I'm not going to repeat them.

 

Now let's hope that because it is a school day again Catina has time to post.

[Talya]

Mr Kettle, hopefully we will find out what type of cop we are (except for those who already know they are mafia) but there untill we know what we are, then we can trust our own viewings we still don't know about Cantina. And the trouble is we can all say anything, at the moment nothing it certain. I'm not advocating we do this every time. But this time we have no way of knowing what she says is true, we don't know if she has had an odd reading. Her lynch can show us:

 

1. How we can take her viewing, whether paranoid etc.

 

2. whether she is Mafia or not, which means it was more than likely a lie.

 

3. It may give us a bit more of a clue to mcs too!

 

So we get a lot more info this way. Going by the results of her lynch then we have choices on who to lynch the next day. And then we will have some idea as to what kind of cops we are and can go from there.

 

Just on a side note. Do you think that the Mafia may have viewings too, after all they are still cops, maybe to find other roles that maybe out there. If so they may also be Paranoid etc!

[Talya]

I forgot, I believe that Cantina HAS to give some kind of reply now that she has been chosen. She cannot devote herself.

[mcs0083]

 

Also what are you all going to do if you get hurt? Lynching me isn't exactly in the best interest of every one in the game.

 

MCS, what exactly are you implying here?  Are you trying to say you are the healer?

Who knows? I'm just saying that offing me wouldn't be a very good idea.