Create-a-Role Mafia Game Thread: Game Over!

[Moghedian]

Wes, give me a direct question and I'll give you a direct answer.

[DPR]

 

Okay. Here are three:

 

1. Why did you go against Mynd's plan on day 1 and vote for Barm?

2. What made you decide to link yourself to your two targets?

3. Why did you choose DJ on night 1?

[Moghedian]

1. Because I didn't read the pages between 2 and 6 where it was mentioned. Sad, but true... :-\

2. To find out more about the game, I didn't think the silencing thing would happen twice.

3. I didn't...  ::) I chose him on Night 2, after a day of being almost completely out of the game I wanted to talk with the finder to discover what was actually happening in the game. Again, I didn't think I would be silenced twice.

 

Did anyone create a matchmaker role and if so, could you clarify the terms of it to me? Thanks.  :)

 

[Myndrunner]

*points to DPR, smirking* This guy! lol

 

Did you guys actually read my posts, or am I still on ignore with some of you?  My point was that since DJ's Finder role has not been contested, it is rather convincing that he is indeed what he claims, on top of the fact taht DJ tends to play straight up Mafia rather than using spin jargon and the gift of storytelling like some folks I know. 

 

As I stated earlier for those not vision impaired, I am curious why folks are NOT voting with DJ.  It is obvious why Danya is not, because DJ is voting Danya. 

 

You all tickle me.  It is painfully obvious that out of five suspicious peoples (DPR, Danya, Moggy, Talya, and Barmathor) that our finder has chosen Danya.  Not because he read Mafia, but because of process of elimenation. 

 

...but we need to get a majority lynch.  It's the only way we are gonna get information and it could even be endgame at this point.  I will vote with the majority if folks change their mind, but for now, Im sticking with our Finder's choice. 

[Talya]

How can you folow someones hunch, because thats all it is. He hasn't viewed at least three of us left alive, by the looks of things. Then gave us three names that we know he hasn't viewed. And out of those he goes with Danya and he much be right.  :-\

 

He is making a guess at the moment because he hasn't got an evil yet. So it is not necessarily a good thing to follow him because he is the finder. If he came out with an evil name then yes, but he hasn't!

 

This isn't getting us nowhere, out of the other two with Votes I'm going with [glow=red,2,300]Unvote, vote Moggie[/glow] she has been on my list behind Barm for being mafia. I'm not sure how much time we have left to vote! it can't be that long!

 

 

[cosmicpanda]

Vote Count No. 15

 

A lynch has been decided!

 

Vote Count:

 

Moggy (3) - DPR, Danya, Talya

Talya (0)

Danya (2) - DJ, Mynd

Barmy (0)

Mynd (0)

DJ (0)

DPR (0)

 

Not voting - Moggy, Barm

 

 

With 7 alive, it takes 4 votes to lynch.

 

Moggy is dead. She was the Innocent Matchmaker.

 

It is now night. You have 48 hours to send in your night actions. Deadline:

 

http://www.timeanddate.com/counters/customcounter.html?month=2&day=12&year=2009&hour=10&min=22&sec=00&p0=0

 

[cosmicpanda]

Wow, that was quick.

 

Nobody died during the night. You eye each other uneasily. Who's scum? Who's innocent? Who's the SK?

 

I'll give you all a hint: nobody can trust anybody else - not even those you think you can. Be very careful with your lynch today, it might decide the game.

 

With six alive, it takes four votes to lynch. I'll put a deadline up if discussion flags.

 

It is now Day Five.

[Barmacral]

Soo... to start this day off, to sum up:

 

Talya will vote me, she seems to want me dead, Mynd will vote DPR, he seems to think DPR is his enemy. DPR could go any which way, DJ thinks Danya is mafia, though hopefully he'll have tagged a mafia last night, and Moggy turned out to be telling the truth.

[Moghedian]

Moggy is dead. She was the Innocent Matchmaker.

 

HA! :P

 

[Myndrunner]

Not to prove the Boob wrong, but I am actually gonna sit back and see what everyone has to say this time.  CP made a very interesting comment about not trusting each other.....and how people vote this day will answer some new questions that I have..... ;)

[DPR]

 

I'm just talking here - throwing out the pieces of the puzzle that I see so that it may help us figure out what pany has put together.  Feel free to add to the list or correct if you know something is wrong.

 

Here's our dead list:

 

Barmy - Roleblocking Rainbow Scum

Lia - Innocent Vote-Giver

Hybrid - Janitor Controller Symp

Verbal32 - Nearly Vanilla Townie

Dae - Healing Mason

Moggy - Innocent Matchmaker

 

* Only Lia and Moggy are actually named as innocent.

* Neither Verbal or Dae were named as innocent.

* Using that same logic, Pandy started the game by telling everybody that Barm was Scum - but he did not name him mafia.

 

Now Pandy says that nobody can trust anybody and to be careful who we lynch.

 

We know that we are down to two mafia or less, but I suspect there may be only one because Pandy says that "no one can trust anyone else." This also tells me that the mason group is down to its last member.

 

"Be careful with your vote, it might end the game" has bomb written all over it.

 

DJ is still alive, which may be good, or it may not be: We know that Dae was a "Healing Mason", so why would there be another healer in the game?

 

With no healer, DJ was the obvious target, but he's still here. That leads to a lot of scenarios from a roleblocker to him being mafia with crazy role restrictions. I don't know.

 

Throw those suspicions out there. We have no deadline, so let's put this thing together.

[Dark Justice]

[glow=red,2,300]WES/DPR[/glow] is scum.

I veiwed him tonight.

[Myndrunner]

[glow=red,2,300]WES/DPR[/glow] is scum.

I veiwed him tonight.

 

Do you still believe our finder is who he says he is, DPR?

[Talya]

Pandy said to question about who we vote for and though it is tempting to just go for Wes, I wonder why DJ wasn't killed last night. I can't believe the mafia would have let him live. Now there could be somre reasons that I don't think I could guess at.

 

So left are:

 

Wes

Barm

Mynd

Danya

Me

 

It's a gues that maybe there are two mafia left as if we get this wrong, thats what Pandy could have meant by it being endgame. Or as Wes says a bomb!

 

Scum is usually used with the term Mafia Wes, so I would imagine it highly unlikely that Barm was an innocent. There maybe have been some shady roles and some innocent ones, but I still think Barm was mafia! We did have 12 to start and that would suggest 3 mafia to start. If there were 3 left they would have won by now. The fact that there hasn't been a kill every night suggests that they have some kind of weird things going on with their roles too, as the others did.

 

Actually I've just read that list of the dead, it looks more like they are normalish roles there with just a few twists on them. I would like to see what others say.

 

 

 

[Dark Justice]

the reason Im alive, is because there is one more healer out there.

 

[Talya]

Okay, that seems a bit odd. But they might have odd roles. There are enough here.

 

I still want to hear from everyone else though!

[Dark Justice]

when I view someone I get the role aswell. I know there is another.

 

[DPR]

Well isn't that convenient?

 

I was prepared for DJ to point the finger at Danya or to claim  that he still didn't have any info. That led to two questions:

 

1. Is it possible that Dj has a role where he may or may not get the right read? Maybe 50/50 chance of it being correct, etc.?

 

2. Or is it possible that my post above rattled him and he's not who he says he is at all. This is the first definitley call he's made all game. Funny how that happens when I point out that the mod told us we can't trust anybody.

 

We all know how this goes; I can blah blah blah all day long but as a suspect, but you can't listen to me.

 

Ya'll have to go with your gut here. I'm definitely not mafia (I know -  :P ) but, nowI know that he is either not a real finder, or one that get's the wrong info. I'm leaning towards him being the mafia, hence Pandy's warning.

 

I'm tempted to vote for Dj for being a finder who never found anything until now and magically did not die, even though you've been outed the entire game. With the healer dead, your cover is blown.

 

I don't think we have a real finder in the game folks, but I really can't claim to know what Pandy has set up. Do what you have to do. I'll understand.

 

[Talya]

Okay fair enough. I think I might know who it is.

 

So [glow=red,2,300]WES[/glow]

[Barmacral]

Setup details:

 

You may appreciate these few snippets of information before the game begins.

 

2 mafia

1 symp

 

1 serial killer

 

8 townies, including a super miller.

 

Every player has some sort of power role, not mentioned in this dialogue. Also, you have some idea of what role you submitted, but be warned that some have been substantially changed in order to make this game playable. I have put every role in, though, in some shape or form.

 

Talya, taken directly from the first post of the game. We started with a total of 2 mafia.

 

Wes, so far a smoothly played game, but I am going to trust our finder here. [glow=red,2,300]Vote: Wes[/glow]

[Dark Justice]

well, WES, your post incriminates you even further.

I was also vaguely suspitious about my view, but your post makes me sure of it being correct.

 

The reason I was vaguely suspitious of my read was that I always get roles. On WES I only got MAFIA. So I thought someone might have tampered with my viewing or something.

I just wanted to see WES´s response before admitting this.

 

 

I'm tempted to vote for Dj for being a finder who never found anything until now and magically did not die, even though you've been outed the entire game. With the healer dead, your cover is blown.

 

I told you. There is another healer. This is whu nobody died. If I was mafia, wouldnt I have been sure to kill off somemone? There was no nightkill. There is a healer. I know who it is. The mafia tried to kill me.

 

For the no sertain reads, I got the symp on night one. After that I have viewed two innocents. Then I viewed you. So. There you go.

[DPR]

I know, I know. And I'm not even going to whine about it.  :-*

 

But I won't go out without a fight!

 

[glow=red,2,300]DJ[/glow]

 

1. He never found anything until me  :P

2. He stayed alive even though the healer is dead.  :P

3. He claims we have two healers in a 12 person game with 2 mafia. Uh huh

4. The mod said we couldn't trust anybody.

[DPR]

well, WES, your post incriminates you even further.

I was also vaguely suspitious about my view, but your post makes me sure of it being correct.

 

The reason I was vaguely suspitious of my read was that I always get roles. On WES I only got MAFIA. So I thought someone might have tampered with my viewing or something.

I just wanted to see WES´s response before admitting this.

 

 

I'm tempted to vote for Dj for being a finder who never found anything until now and magically did not die, even though you've been outed the entire game. With the healer dead, your cover is blown.

 

I told you. There is another healer. This is whu nobody died. If I was mafia, wouldnt I have been sure to kill off somemone? There was no nightkill. There is a healer. I know who it is. The mafia tried to kill me.

 

For the no sertain reads, I got the symp on night one. After that I have viewed two innocents. Then I viewed you. So. There you go.

 

bleh. My post only incriminates you further. Now you are admitting that you don't get the right info.

tsk, tsk, tsk.

[Talya]

[glow=red,2,300]UNVOTE[/glow]

[Talya]

Sorry just had to get that in before Pandy came along, I will read these posts again! That was very quick behind me there Barm.

It maybe the finder has been recruited by the Mafia and he goes with a healer as for not dying.