Ship Wreck Mafia - game thread-

[DPR]

 

I've stated my case and I think that [glow=red,2,300]Kison[/glow] is the best shot we have at bagging an evil.

 

If no one else thinks that the 2 Evil Players + 1 Symp scenario is possible (with Kivam being the Symp), then I would also be willing to switch votes on to a Kivam lynch.

 

I don't think taking a "stab in the dark" at any one of the low-layers is statistically sound move. I'd rather base a lynch on what information we have, and I think we have plenty.

 

[Talya]

Okay, I think I will go for...[glow=red,2,300]Kison[/glow] at this time. He stands a little more than evil than Wes...lol...in my eyes at the moment. And Wes I have also thought that Kivam maybe symp too...If he is then he would still be worth lynching sometime as he counts with the evils. :-\

[Kivam]

That puts 3 votes on Kison. Again, if Kison isn't dead in the next couple of hours it will be because he is either guilty or because 2 of the 3 votes on him already are guilty. I'll give people 12 hours to consider taking up my Boyo suggestion, but if nobody will, I'll roll the dice and vote Kison as well.  And if Kison comes up innocent, lets cross our fingers, hope for a healer miracle, and lynch DPR and Naeann the next two days (since they are the two who are on both the original Kison lynch and this one).

 

If Kison is guilty, we cross off Naeann and DPR and lynch Boyo and Loki. 

[loki redfern]

i make 12 hours 1 hour past the deadline?

[Naeann]

If Kison is guilty I'm going after YOU not Loki....

[SBoydW]

[glow=red,2,300]Kison[/glow]

[Kivam]

If Kison is guilty I'm going after YOU not Loki....

 

I had a feeling someone would say that.  I've put all my arguments in - its your call at this point.  But knowing that I'm innocent, I hope you rethink that.

[Kivam]

*poke* why it sounds so ludicrous is why it would work or has worked if naeann turns out to be evil and if you could please find actual flaws instead of quoting meaningless acronyms at me. loki logic works in loki's head but it's a bit agoraphobic

and id rather look at every option first before i just go along with the 'likely' you have been doing the preaching and implementing the 'likely' all game and how many evils have we lynched yet? lets count .. oh wait none :P

so perhaps the unlikely is worth just the smallest of passing glances.

 

WIFOM is from Princess Bride, stands for "wine in front of me".

 

The "its so ludicrous it just might work" logic is an endless circle.  What if I know that you know that I know that you know that I know that's what you would think?  What if I know that you know that I know that you know that I know that you know that I know that's what you would think?  And so on ad infinitum.

 

You've played with me before - do I ever go in for "so ludicrous it just might work"??

 

 

and vemy isnt the hardest of players to get lynched is he

 

Yes, he is, since he's damn good at this game.

 

and until you pointed out beckys reveal.. and im perhaps not the sharpest spork in the box but it was pretty damn obscure.. probaly nobody would have noticed

 

Really?  Anyone else notice the reveal or was I the only one?

 

and why was talya looking suspicious again?

Voting for a confirmed innocent, using WIFOM logic

 

 

[Kison]

You guys are ridiculous.

 

Just go after the wagoners tomorrow.

 

Seriously.

 

I'm not even going to try to convince you guys because I know it's not going to work.

[Kivam]

You guys are ridiculous.

 

Just go after the wagoners tomorrow.

 

Seriously.

 

I'm not even going to try to convince you guys because I know it's not going to work.

 

If you're innocent, vote Boyo.  I'm not putting vote 5 on you unless there's less than 4 on Boyo by 9pm.

[loki redfern]

why, do you want to not look like an evil piling on kivam? it seem your just trying a bit hard here?

 

and i for one do not have the patience to wait until 3 in the morning just to see if anybody wants to vote boyo when everybody here pretty much thinks kison is evil and they dont seem that likly to change there minds at this point so:  [glow=red,2,300]Kison[/glow]

 

[Kivam]

why, do you want to not look like an evil piling on kivam? it seem your just trying a bit hard here?

 

and i for one do not have the patience to wait until 3 in the morning just to see if anybody wants to vote boyo when everybody here pretty much thinks kison is evil and they dont seem that likly to change there minds at this point so:  [glow=red,2,300]Kison[/glow]

 

 

For the same reason I've said before - Kison is the risky play, Boyo is the lock, and therefore the smarter play (IMO).

[Kivam]

well, lets hope Kison is evil :-X

[Kison]

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote[/glow]

[glow=red,2,300]Vote : Boyo[/glow]

 

Simply because I know I'm innocent, and there's obviously a better shot at it.

 

I would FULLY support going after Leelou for previous reasons, and Talya for pulling a fast one.

 

You guys are ridiculous if you think my voting patterns have me pegged.

 

Therefore, like I said, if I wind up lynched, you fools better get the wagoners.

[Guest nephitess]

Current Votes:

 

Kison (5): Naeann, DPR, Talya, Soyo, Kison

Soyo (3): Leelou, Kivam, Kison

 

Looks like everyone has voted. I looked at the first page and did not expressly say that you need to unvote to change your vote. If a majority have a problem with me letting Loki's vote go through without unvoting please let me know and I'll change it. I know it is basically an unspoken rule. *nods*

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

 

Day 4 ends on Tues Jan 22, at 8pm MST/10pm EST (2 hours 15 min)

[Kivam]

Current Votes:

 

Kison (5): Naeann, DPR, Talya, Soyo, Kison

Soyo (3): Leelou, Kivam, Kison

 

Looks like everyone has voted. I looked at the first page and did not expressly say that you need to unvote to change your vote. If a majority have a problem with me letting Loki's vote go through without unvoting please let me know and I'll change it. I know it is basically an unspoken rule. *nods*

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

 

Day 4 ends on Tues Jan 22, at 8pm MST/10pm EST (2 hours 15 min)

 

You have Kison voting for himself

[Guest nephitess]

Damit...sorry guys...i wrote Kison instead of Loki. *la sigh*

 

Kison (5): Naeann, DPR, Talya, Soyo, loki

Soyo (3): Leelou, Kivam, Kison

 

and since no one has objected i'll let his vote stand.

 

Be right back with an other message from you friendly neighborhood MOD. :P

[Guest nephitess]

This day has been long...you have all come together to discuss options and candidates for whom you think should be lynched next. You all feeling a little nervous but can feel the mafia gloating. you don't know who they are yet....but you feel their energy.

 

There are periods where you have felt the presence of an other. You have felt the chills of their eyes on you...creepy. yo have shrugged it off for now...but what if they come back? You begin to ponder this.

 

Finally after much debate yo have come to a consensus...Kison must must go. You all gather around him with DPR leading the way. Hands grab him and you put the noose around his neck. The job is done quickly as you are all experts at this now. After he is dead you search his pockets and other things. You find nothing.

 

Kison a role less innocent has been lynched.  

[glow=green,2,300]

Please send in Night actions by 8PM EST Wednesday (23.5 hours from now). Night will end 10:30 PM EST Wednesday. 26 hours from now.[/glow]

[Kivam]

Well, can we all just admit that I'm innocent now?  Boyo and Naeann clearly have to go.  Then its a tossup between DPR and Loki.  Talya - good luck with your choice tonight

[Naeann]

Augh who the heck are the da...rn evils in this game  >:(

 

Kivam it's game over anyways unless Talya performs a miracle.

[DPR]

 

This is crazy.

 

And Kivam, what would posses you to talk about who to vote for tomorrow? Is this something you can share with the enitire class?  Becuase right now, it looks like an 85% chance that we won't see the sunrise.

[Kivam]

 

This is crazy.

 

And Kivam, what would posses you to talk about who to vote for tomorrow? Is this something you can share with the enitire class?  Becuase right now, it looks like an 85% chance that we won't see the sunrise.

Considering your position on my suspect list, I don't think I'll tell you anything.  When we survive until morning, I'll explain

[DPR]

 

 

If we were on Giligan's Island, that would kind of make you The Professor. (sorry, it was the first thing that popped into my head, and I thought it was funny)

 

Although, this one would be the episode where The Professor is evil...  :o

 

That means Leelou and Naeann could be Ginger and Mary Ann, I think Boyo and Talya could be a respectable Mr. and Mrs. Thurston Howell, and Loki and I can flip a coconut to see who gets to be Skipper and who has to be Giligan.

 

So I guess we'll all just sit right back, and get ready to enjoy a tale!

 

[Naeann]

Oooh Can I be Mary ann?  I always liked her better than Ginger...

[Leelou]

Sure...I'll be Ginger.  :D