FIDDLETON-UNDER-LYME ~ Werewolf mafia game

[Dark Justice]

Thougt of the same thing. But Im very paranoid in these games..

[Xefan]

So, the question is:

 

DSage/Vemy, or Questionable Other?

[Toy and Minion]

You know what, X?  That's really good.  Especially for a first timer.  I got nothing to counter that with.

[Vemynal]

X seems to take after players like Dude who are well known for their accurate hunches

 

Kryos seems to be really good at analysing and seems to take after players like Kivam (lmao, easy much to guess who he is? XD)

 

but you both lack the play experiance to use these correctly it seems cuz me no evil.

 

GOOD NEWS!~

 

I decided to stop in and check the thread while I'm at school (we have a library with over 100 top quality computers^^) but I'm leaving for home and should be there in a half hour! I'll be able to reread the thread then and I should have finished in 4 hours!

 

cya in a half hour when I'm home^^

[Naeann]

I agree Xefan... and since [glow=red,2,300]Vemy[/glow] already has 3 votes on him.....

[Amethea]

With nothing really to separate them in terms of who is Mafia, and with far too many variables and possibilities as to who did what and why, I'm going to vote for [glow=red,2,300]DSage[/glow], although I'll change my vote if I have to.  For me, it came down to Leelou or DSage last time, so if I vote for DSage today, it'll clarify things.  Hopefully.

[Kryos]

Trust me, I so badly want to vote for Vemy... everything points to Vemy, but come on people? It's one of those oh too obvious things right now. Granted, I have terrible suspicions about Vemy, but alas, there is too much doubt tossed in there thanks to the killing of CLoud. The theory behind that can truly go either way, so as such, I am going to sit back and let that one boil over for a day. But I am thinking.... thinking.... And I'll give some reasonings later on this one...

 

[glow=red,2,300]Dark Justice[/glow]

[Vemynal]

Vemmy constantly asks for people to give advice to the finder.  I agree it's a noob game and people need to know how to play but you do not have to be so specific in your requests.  You, several times, mention for the finder to search you.  Normally a person would get night killed for what you have been saying.

 

Guys, I reread the entire thread and this is what I came up with on my reread.

 

He went after me for fearing that the target would be night killed. From that I would guess they thought he might have been the finder.

 

Think about it: He’s a good annalist, it makes me look guiltier, *and* he might have been the finder. Win, win, win. This doesn’t prove my innocence in the slightest but it does give some added reasoning and insight.

 

Now, to why I’m good and you should all unvote, and geez I thought we wouldn’t need to bring this up. Guys? Where is the finder claiming I’m evil hmm? Not even a symp claiming! (least yet, if you guys take your votes off me watch him/her come out of the wood works)

 

*EVERY* single player has posted at *least* once, and *no one* has claimed that I’m evil.

 

1 thing I noticed while reading the thread was that the second Raena said “its up between Vemy and Dsage” and dark agreed with her Dsage voted me like someone lit a fire under him. Another thing is what kryos mentioned about him killing cloud to make himself look less evil (good pick up on that one Kryos, I actually hadn’t thought of that).

 

Dark has also been going on and on about how it must be me and/or Dsage who is evil. What if me and Dsage are both good hmm? Maybe its rather dark, who has been pushing for our deaths who is evil because he knows we are both suspicious looking.

 

I can’t tell who is really evil or not so I want to do my review before I vote, that always helps clear my head.

 

I start school tomorrow and will be gone my time from 9am to 10:30pm likely. I’ll have a 2 hour break and a 1 hour break both late in the day between classes where I can check in but no time to do a review. So I’ll be doing it either tomorrow night if I have the energy left or I’ll be doing it Wednesday morning. I want to ask we not lynch anyone until I get my chance to review (promise this time to have it actually be worth while^^, we actually have data!)

 

In the mean time:

 

11 of you are left. 6 votes to lynch

 

Vemynal(4): Dsage, Dude, Dark, Nae

Dsage(2): Xefan, Amethea,

Dark(1): Kryos

Not voting: Vemynal, Damane, Raena, Loreina,

 

[Raena]

Now' date=' to why I’m good and you should all unvote, and geez I thought we wouldn’t need to bring this up. Guys? Where is the finder claiming I’m evil hmm? Not even a symp claiming! (least yet, if you guys take your votes off me watch him/her come out of the wood works)[/quote']

 

But there is a possibility that the finder didn't view you. Also, why would the symp declare themselves?

 

And I agree with Kryos here. I want to vote for Vemynal, but it seems too obvious. That leaves DSage, but I'm not sure about him either. Bleh.

 

 

[Talya]

*drums fingers on desk*

 

Okay votes so far

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vemynal (4): [/glow] Dsage, The Dude, Dark Justice, Naeann

 

[glow=red,2,300]Dsage (1): [/glow] Xefan, Amethea

 

[glow=red,2,300]Dark Justice (1):[/glow] Kryos

 

Now get voting....6 votes to lynch

[Kryos]

Well, I myself implore everyone to not vote for Vemy. If I'm not going to vote for Vemy, then something must be up? We all know I pretty wanted to see Vemy lynched. Why? Because in the suspicious eyes, Vemy was always the one most likely to be evil from the beginning, at least that is how I see it. However, the current events makes everything look that much more in favor of Vemy being evil, but alas, all the signs are way too obvious and blatant. So, it is that outright cry of Vemy being evil that has left me questioning. And quite honestly, even if Vemy does turn out to be evil and this is all an elaborate scheme to make him look oh so innocent, he can always be lynched another day.

 

Surely everyone is able to see such facts at least. Trust me, I want nothing more than to see Vemy be evil, but alas, I don't think that day will be today. So, why is my vote Dark Justice now? Well, still am rereading everything to put everything together for review so everyone can know why I made my decision. But just for the time being, that's how it will stand.

[Toy and Minion]

Okay, I may have jumped on Vemy too soon.

 

UGH!  This'll probably get my lynched...

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote[/glow]

 

I'm going to have to do a couple rereads before I make a decision now.

[damane]

[glow=red,2,300]Votes Vemy[/glow]

[the dude]

You know, I think we should just off Vemy (no offense, man).  Really, where there's smoke, there's fire.  If he's looking evil (and the consensus seems to be so), then why not lynch him and find out for sure?  Leave him around for a couple more days?  That's symp/cohort talk.  We've got a candidate, and the debate seems kind of one-sided.  We've got 2 or 3 defenders of Vemy, and the rest are all on the fence or against him.  Myself, I'd say that we've let the debate go on long enough:

 

1)  Either he's evil, and the people defending him will suddenly start talking really fast, or

 

2)  He's good, and the people trying hardest to kill him will have a lot of explaining to do.

 

Win-win, man.  There are enough clues laid out right now that I don't even need hunches.  Let's just do it.

[damane]

[glow=red,2,300]Unvotes Vemy [/glow]

[damane]

[glow=red,2,300]Votes the Dude [/glow]

[the dude]

Care to explain there, damane?  8)

[Amethea]

I must admit, it's an interesting choice.  I'd also be interested to hear why you picked The Dude, Damane, as it could make a lot of difference.

[the dude]

I'd certainly be interested to know.  8)

 

I'm talking logic here; we're in doubt, we've got a candidate.  Damane was all for voting Vemy until I posted; obviously something I said sat wrong with her; I'd love to know what.

[Kryos]

The problem though Dude is we've lost two innocents already, and with as much doubt as I have about vemy right now, we can't really afford to lose another innocent at all. And we have yet to find a single werewolf... I'd rather take the chance and preserve someone whom I have significantly strong doubts about being evil now than just lynch him and say oh well we'll find out once he is lynched.

[the dude]

Doesn't seem to my, Kryos, that there's any better case against DSage or anyone else.  The Gut says, vote for Vemynal.  I'm gonna go with that; those who've played with me in the past know that the Gut is a good bet.  's all I'm sayin'.

[Raena]

I'm also interested to know why you voted for dude, damane. I'm also interested to know why Kryos is voting for Dark Justice.

 

 

[Dark Justice]

As would I. Both of those votes is a bit weird to me. I agree that I have goone fron defending Vem to attacking him. I have also voted/unvoted him several times. But cant really see anything suspitious about it.

[Toy and Minion]

Well, this is very strange.  damane vote the dude out of the blue with no explination.  Okay, not out of the blue, but still.  Hmmm...  Maybe I can find something after all...

[Kryos]

I know damane changed her vote right after The Dude made his little blurb about Vemynal, and voila, instant change of mind.