DM Will Likely Crash During My Game Mafia - Game thread! [STANDARD]

[Clovdyx]

Do not post!

[Clovdyx]

26 minutes ago, Clovdyx said:

Vote Count!

• BFG - 3 - Sooh, Andrej, Krakalakachkn
• Krakalakachkn - 3 - BFG, TrippedOnReality, DPR

If you notice any discrepancies, PM me immediately.

 

Votes marked :00 will count, :01 will not.  Day One ends at 8:00 PM Eastern time on Friday, 6/22.  
 

 

23 minutes ago, Krakalakachkn said:

vote dpr

 

9 minutes ago, Krakalakachkn said:

vote bfg

 

4 minutes ago, Andrej said:

Vote Krak

 

Final Vote Count!

• BFG - 2 - Sooh, Krakalakachkn
• Krakalakachkn - 4 - BFG, TrippedOnReality, DPR, Andrej

If you notice any discrepancies, PM me immediately.

[Clovdyx]

End of Day One!

 

Once upon a time, near a dacha in the Urals, the young tennis star Andrey Rublev approached a crossroad at midnight. He carried his request penned in blood. The fate of the professional tennis world hung in the balance...

 

 

Oh, son of a...  

 

Krakalakackhn was lynched!  He wa

[Clovdyx]

...three days later...

 

s... - 

 

Dice probably won't sleep long enough to get mislynched, a Jailkeeper, Town-Aligned. 

 

It is now Night One, even though it really ought to be Night Seventeen or something!  You have 24 hours to get your PM's in.

[Clovdyx]

I'm trying to update the player list on the first post, but because it's the topic start, I have to do some stupid authentication with Cloudflare.  I'm stuck in an endless loop trying to do Captcha, edit, captcha.  So you guys don't get an updated roster.

 

...Actually I'll just put it in the second post.

[Lizabeth]

End of Night One!

 

I regret to inform you that your favourite mod has gone missing overnight. Best guess at this moment is he punched his fist through the computer screen in frustration while trying to get DM to cooperate with his formatting requests, and the site demons sucked him into the interwebs.

 

Don't scoff at me. It could happen!

 

Don't worry about him, though. Even if my speculation turns out to be correct, I have every confidence that he will fight his way back to you, his loyal players. Semper Gumby and all that.

 

But in the meantime....

 

Darthe was brutally mauled last night. Like seriously brutal. You do not want to see that. Dream-haunting for life kind of stuff. We had to use DNA analysis to identify the body.

 

He was

We didn't need ISOs anyway, Vanilla, Town-Aligned.

 

It is now Day Two! Post while you can!

 

Day Two ends at 8:00 PM Eastern time on Monday, 6/25.  

 

 

 

[Andrej]

Sender Gumby <3

 

Vote BFG

[Lizabeth]

Vote Count!

• BFG - 1 - Andrej

If you notice any discrepancies, PM me immediately.

 

Votes marked :00 will count, :01 will not.  Day Two ends at 8:00 PM Eastern time on Monday, 6/25.  

 

@Clovdyx

[Andrej]

This is pretty much BFG’s scum game in a nutshell imo. She’s a lovely lady but I really believe she doesn’t enjoy being scum because she’s so polite and accusing people/lying makes her uncomfortable and thus her presence in the game isn’t as impactful and her reads aren’t as ~genuine. She reminds me a lot of Spirited Away here, where we were scum buddies and she was under a lot of suspicion D1 but slipped the noose.

 

DPR fell pretty hard into her pocket, I think. I can appreciate that he doesn’t have as much experience with scum!BFG as some of us, so I am being lenient for the hard defense yesterday. His line about being due for us to flip alignments finally just seemed really genuine in the moment. I’ll make fun of him post game for it nonetheless for sucking as bad as he does.

 

I don’t believe it’s Tripped and Sooh is more or less cleared for how she handled BFG D1.

 

which leaves me with Z/Aquilla. Neither were very impactful D1. Aquilla’s read on Darthe still feels fake to me in a nutshell and Z not voting anyone D1 isn’t a good look. He’s a lot more passive as scum imo.

[Andrej]

Oh plus there’s the whole contradicting PR claims at DL - with the JK flipping Town.

 

I know Clov likes his PRs but a JK/Doc together in a 9p is pretty OP for Town. That’s a big spread of NK stopping ability for such a small roster.

[DPR]

Vote AJ

 

LOL

 

 

[Andrej]

3 minutes ago, DPR said:

Vote AJ

 

LOL

 

/saved

[DPR]

So, leading the lynch on the claimed Doc on D2 seems a bit hasty...

 

 

 

[Andrej]

You just had a JK flip Town.

 

you think both roles are present here on a 9p roster? You’re smarter than that Pirate.

[Andrej]

BFG being the lead wagon and claiming a PR going into DL is like the most convenient thing ever. The best I’d call it is NAI. Either she’s legit or she’s scum and knew claiming anything but a PR meant it’s curtains.

 

So - is there anything from her play that makes you think she is Town besides claiming Doc?

 

Like she wagoned Krak while saying she had no read. Her SR on Darthe was the weakest thing ever. She made no real attempt to really interact or sort with anyone D1.

 

This isn’t Town!BFG

[DPR]

1 minute ago, Andrej said:

You just had a JK flip Town.

 

you think both roles are present here on a 9p roster? You’re smarter than that Pirate.

 

Okay. Let's play "How Do You Think The Game is Set Up?"

 

Go

[DPR]

Also, I don't really see a speed lynch happening here, so slow your roll there cowboy. 

[Andrej]

Nobody is hurrying anything. I’m not calling for a hammer lol. I am just making this known from the get go, and I really wish I would’ve stayed out yesterday and let the lynch go random.

 

Tell you what, as this phase progresses, I want you to be on the look out for BFG and see if she really starts to bring it or continues to float with the occasional pop-in series of posts that ask some questions and gives some reads but doesn’t really go anywhere.

[DPR]

But what is the setup tho? 

 

Just so I know where your head is at. 

[Andrej]

9p, flipped JK.

 

JK9 anyone? Which doesn’t have a Doc btw.

[DPR]

We're headed out for the evening.

 

Catch you tomorrow, heh. 

[Sooh]

7 hours ago, Andrej said:

9p, flipped JK.

 

JK9 anyone? Which doesn’t have a Doc btw.

is JK9 a specific setup? 

[DPR]

So, I googled it, and found:  https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=JK9

 

Looks like 8 games played on MafiaScum from 2009 thru 2013. Scum usually wins.

 

If this is the case - and I grant that with a JK and 9 players it definitely could be - I can't help but think that our solution is easy. Tracker stays anonymous and peeks BFG tonight - if she doesn't visit anyone, or if the person she visits dies, we got ourselves a scum. Simples. 

 

And that begs the question...

 

If AJ recognizes this setup, why wasn't the above his first suggestion? Even if a player was 99% sure that BFG was scum, why take a chance on killing them when you can easily prove it? Hunt the other wolf instead, no?

 

 

 

 

[Sooh]

1 hour ago, DPR said:

So, I googled it, and found:  https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=JK9

 

Looks like 8 games played on MafiaScum from 2009 thru 2013. Scum usually wins.

 

If this is the case - and I grant that with a JK and 9 players it definitely could be - I can't help but think that our solution is easy. Tracker stays anonymous and peeks BFG tonight - if she doesn't visit anyone, or if the person she visits dies, we got ourselves a scum. Simples. 

 

And that begs the question...

 

If AJ recognizes this setup, why wasn't the above his first suggestion? Even if a player was 99% sure that BFG was scum, why take a chance on killing them when you can easily prove it? Hunt the other wolf instead, no?

 

 

 

 

Why wait? As you say, if a tracker is directed the team knows who's being tracked, so obviously BFG would never do that kill. If you have a clear suspect, then go for it I say. 

 

My non vote vote is on BFG.

[Zander?]

14 hours ago, Andrej said:

This is pretty much BFG’s scum game in a nutshell imo. She’s a lovely lady but I really believe she doesn’t enjoy being scum because she’s so polite and accusing people/lying makes her uncomfortable and thus her presence in the game isn’t as impactful and her reads aren’t as ~genuine. She reminds me a lot of Spirited Away here, where we were scum buddies and she was under a lot of suspicion D1 but slipped the noose.

 

DPR fell pretty hard into her pocket, I think. I can appreciate that he doesn’t have as much experience with scum!BFG as some of us, so I am being lenient for the hard defense yesterday. His line about being due for us to flip alignments finally just seemed really genuine in the moment. I’ll make fun of him post game for it nonetheless for sucking as bad as he does.

 

I don’t believe it’s Tripped and Sooh is more or less cleared for how she handled BFG D1.

 

which leaves me with Z/Aquilla. Neither were very impactful D1. Aquilla’s read on Darthe still feels fake to me in a nutshell and Z not voting anyone D1 isn’t a good look. He’s a lot more passive as scum imo.

 

I fell asleep watching Luke Cage so I'm sorry for that.

 

Why did you switch your vote to Krak right before DL if you were and still are so certain on BFG being Scum?!?!?