PotC Mafia Game - mafia won!!

[dicetosser1]

IO know she was driving this morning and she is sick too so it might be a little bit

[Nynaeve]

Calder has been lynched. He was...

 

A damn good pirate and a

vanilla townie

 

 

It is now night. You have 21 hours to submit your NAs.

[Nynaeve]

Cant do colors on my phone 

[Darthe]

That was a long shot. Wolves won this D1 I think.  I'd like to know if you guys think that this is a game where early claims would help.  I'm kinda considering it.

[Darthe]

Saying that at night is bad, but it's worth discussion imo

[amegakure]

@Darthe why eldrick? Besides Caldar not helping his case and getting lynched why do you think wolves won d1? Was thre an interaction that got your attention? 

 

Should we consider calders read on cass? 

[Eldrick4221]

11 hours ago, dicetosser1 said:

language please.

 

I considered bleeping it too, but thought it was ok 

[Eldrick4221]

Blah! Really thought I had something there. Sorry Calder :(

 

[Eldrick4221]

30 minutes ago, amegakure said:

Should we consider calders read on cass? 

 

Yes we should consider it, but it carries as much weight as any townie. He had a gut feeling on her, and never expressed why. It's practically null.

 

That's partly why I was digging at him. His read was pointless without knowing why he felt that way. She's as much of a potential scum as she was before he died.

 

Eldrick2 

[Eldrick4221]

6 hours ago, Darthe said:

That was a long shot. Wolves won this D1 I think.  I'd like to know if you guys think that this is a game where early claims would help.  I'm kinda considering it.

 

Definitely not at night. If you guys wanna reveal in the morning, go for it.

[Eldrick4221]

Ok this question is bothering me. Why would early reveals be a good idea?

[Eldrick4221]

I'm trying to wrap my brain around Darthe's read on me. I was one of the two people he was WTL at EoD, and I'm not sure why.

 

There were a couple times he mentioned having mixed feelings on me, and they read as town trying to sort things out, so I left him to do his thing and to see how it got sorted.

 

I ended up at the bottom, and would like to know why. Would like to figure out if he's scum throwing shade on a vocal townie or townie simply getting his read wrong.

 

@Darthe Why do you want to lynch me?

 

Eldrick2 

[amegakure]

Good question I'm curious on how this plays out. I based my darthe read off his interaction with you. 

 

 Starting to feel like we have misinformation going through this thread.

 

who do you want to lynch eldrick? 

 

 

[Eldrick4221]

7 minutes ago, amegakure said:

Good question I'm curious on how this plays out. I based my darthe read off his interaction with you. 

 

 Starting to feel like we have misinformation going through this thread.

 

who do you want to lynch eldrick? 

 

 

 

I'm not sure. I was so expecting Calder to be scum.

 

I'm feeling decent about you. You make a lot of sense and its easy to follow what you're saying, but others aren't, and it makes me wonder if I'm missing something.

 

I like Cass so far, but she's one that is easier to figure out later. Not gonna forget that Calder thought she was scum for #reasons, but not gonna let it be a large factor because we don't know why.

 

Dice is a tough one. I could see myself maybe going there, but I dunno. He's probably lowest on my list because of the "backpedalling". Like I said I'm not sure if it's scum motivated or not. If he stays stuck on you, that might be something.

 

BG is one that I need to look at more closely. Need more input from him. If he coasts, he could be scum.

 

Kat is also tough. I liked her catchup post. She's having trouble playing, but handling it well. I think she's probably town, but it's way too soon to have a confident read there. 

 

My read on Darthe is largely based on how he handles recent questions. I was back and forth during D1. His question about mass reveals is concerning, as is his sudden WTL on me. Miiight go there.

 

So I guess my current WTL is BG, dice and Darthe. Not strongly on any of them.

 

Eldrick2 

[Eldrick4221]

Oh crap. Dragoon. 

I forgot he was in the game lol.

Yeah I'm not sure about him. I didn't mind his read on Calder. It looks a little worse with the hindsight of Calder flipping town, but he could have just as easily been wrong for the townie reason he clained.

 

Eldrick2 

[Eldrick4221]

What's your WTL?

 

Eldrick2 

[Eldrick4221]

If Dragoon is scum, we should look at the trains he opted to not vote instead of Calder. Good chance his teammate was there and he was voting to save them. I believe they were Amega and Dice at that point.

 

Eldrick2 

[Eldrick4221]

Same goes to look at Dragoon if either of them flip scum.

 

Eldrick2 

[amegakure]

Im not ready to lynch a newbie. Hell be easy to figure out later once we have a confirmed wolf. Newbies are an easy target and a bad read it's normal with them. Kinda makes me wanna look at you differently for the suggestion. 

 

I never make sense. What you talking about?

 

 

[amegakure]

Dice, bg maybe cass or darthe. Need more info. Still waiting on an honest reply to my questions. 

[Eldrick4221]

22 minutes ago, amegakure said:

Im not ready to lynch a newbie. Hell be easy to figure out later once we have a confirmed wolf. Newbies are an easy target and a bad read it's normal with them. Kinda makes me wanna look at you differently for the suggestion. 

 

I never make sense. What you talking about?

 

 

 

I'm not suggesting we lynch him, and you implying that I did looks bad.

 

I said that if he flips scum, there's a possible link to his teammate being on the trains he saved by voting Calder (you and dice). Likewise, if either of you flip scum, he has a chance of being your teammate by the same reasoning.

 

Eldrick2 

[Eldrick4221]

Also the newbie card only goes so far. Sure some things you should write off as "they don't know what they're doing yet", but new people get scum rands too. They shouldn't be written off conpletely 'because they are new.

 

Eldrick2  

[amegakure]

I agree I'm just not worried about him being scum come end of game if he is. Id much rather find the real wolves first then worry about the newbie. 

 

You can think that looks bad if you like but it seemed an off place to focus attention. So it got my attention. 

[Eldrick4221]

It's what came to mind with the knowledge of Calder's alignment. Dragoon's vote.

 

There's also the fact that dice switched to Calder off of you right at the end, but I couldn't make sense of what that could mean.

 

Eldrick2 

[Eldrick4221]

Actually that's not true. It's what I thought about after going over my read on him (because you asked who i wanted to lynch) and how it has changed with the knowledge of Calder's alignment.

 

That thought led to the possible connection. 

 

Eldrick2