The Founding of Quahog (Peter's Progress) Mafia - Game Over

[BFG]

Sooh looking spicy this round

Spicy how?

[Sooh]

Sooh looking spicy this round

Must be the cayenne.

[Shad_]

 

My take on Ben is he hasn't started playing yet so I have no take on him.

1 hot read?

 

I don't understand this question. 

[BFG]

 

My take on Ben is he hasn't started playing yet so I have no take on him.

1 hot read?

Why Turin?

[Sooh]

 

 

I mean, I can tickle you, but like Chris said, anyone who claims wolf as town would also most likely claim wolf as wolf, so reading it as anything but NAI is a bit of a stretch to me.

 

It looks like you're having fun, and honestly my first thought was "oh no, Shad randed Jester".

I mean there's the superficial tier "a player did x and can do x as either alignment so NAI" and then there's the deeper reading into intent, but this post is fine.

 

 

Sooh talking about generalities when she's specifically seen you claim wolf as wolf reads oddly, but that games already been brought up so it's probably not important but I'm not sure what's fine as opposed to null?

 

I have?

[BFG]

Argh, I hit delete before quote in the above post, so my phone did both (it doesn't ask me to confirm before deleting)

 

It's quoted twice by me and Shad, if there's a problem then huge apologies :(

[Shad_]

Why Turin?

Least likely to be complacent with a slow roll.

 

Not in terms of post count but in terms of content. He tends to be one of the first people to proactively try to get the game rolling.

[Shad_]

Argh, I hit delete before quote in the above post, so my phone did both (it doesn't ask me to confirm before deleting)

 

It's quoted twice by me and Shad, if there's a problem then huge apologies :(

o_o

 

I could have sworn Turin's post was the first on this page.

 

I was honestly starting to freak out about it.

 

Like

 

Am I finally losing my s--- for real?

 

It was just you, you troll. 

[Verbal32]

 

I must be bad at this, im taking the guy at face value

 

In all seriousness though, I want to hear Darthe's explanation for this.  I have no trouble believing that he could actually be doing it as town, but I'm fairly confident I saw Shad do something ~similar as scum in another game (though I can't for the life of me think of what it was).

 

Same goes for Verb.

 

 

My explanation is:  why bother as a townie?  What good does it do?  For other townies, it draws unnecessary attention, and for scum it draws mostly the same.  I can't see a solid reason for doing this as a townie, but I DO see a solid reason for doing it as scum - TWTBAW.  It was just my initial take on it.

 

I'll admit that since then Shad seems to be doing more "ordinary" posting in an effort to appear town.

[Verbal32]

 

Why Turin?

Least likely to be complacent with a slow roll.

 

Not in terms of post count but in terms of content. He tends to be one of the first people to proactively try to get the game rolling.

 

 

Wasn't he trying to get it going, though?  His jester questions felt like an attempt to move the game....

[Turin Turambar]

@Shad, reasonable take if wrong.

 

Why do you think I voted Darthe?

[Shad_]

I took it as a joke vote tbh

[Shad_]

Wasn't he trying to get it going, though?  His jester questions felt like an attempt to move the game....

It crossed my mind. If it hadn't been about 3P stuff I probably would have waited a bit.

[Shad_]

I'll admit that since then Shad seems to be doing more "ordinary" posting in an effort to appear town.

Can you explain more specifically what was going through your head irt "in an effort to appear town"?

[Turin Turambar]

Fair enough. I guess that may be the consensus since no one asked about it.

 

Even jokes can serve a purpose tho.

 

So do you think I'm really Stewie or Chris? (NotClov)

[BFG]

Lol I'll be back after work

 

@Sooh yes, in your magic game

[Shad_]

Character claims don't really interest me. They can sometimes matter in validating role claims but I try to avoid thinking in that direction unless it's smacking me in the face.

[Verbal32]

 

I'll admit that since then Shad seems to be doing more "ordinary" posting in an effort to appear town.

Can you explain more specifically what was going through your head irt "in an effort to appear town"?

 

 

Sure.  My initial impression from your previous posts were that it would more likely come from scum than town.  That isn't enough of a read to vote somebody on D1, so I'm sitting on it.  Your subsequent posts seem more indicative of what I'd expect from town!Shad.

[Shad_]

I was interested more in the verbiage but ok

[Sooh]

Lol I'll be back after work

 

@Sooh yes, in your magic game

You should know as well as anyone here that I don't remember specific meta- things.

 

And when I'm hosting? Forget about it.

[Shad_]

I asked because "in an effort to appear town" generally implies scum motive but you stated it as a positive thing.

 

At least it implies motive of some sort. Doesn't necessarily have to be scum motive, but most people would default to that assumption.

[Shad_]

Could just be your manner of speaking. You aren't a particularly easy person for me to read in general.

[Shad_]

Sooh talk to me

[Shad_]

You just played a game in which I was a wolf and every active player in the game had me as solid town on D1. Have you seen anything different here and if so what do you read into that?

[Turin Turambar]

Sooh, do you truly expect that there is a jester in this game?