The Founding of Quahog (Peter's Progress) Mafia - Game Over

[Verbal32]

Is it wrong that I'm tempted to drop a vote on Darthe and then peace the thread until Monday?

[Shad_]

No worse than me thinking I'd lynch Darthe over Tiink as things stand based solely on the fact that I strongarmed a mislynch on Tiink last game so I'd feel worse if he flipped town

[Verbal32]

Heh, that's fair.

 

Ok, I'm not actually going to vote yet.  I'm out, but I will try to be online to catch up before DL if possible.  Ciao.

[Sooh]

I think I'm out too. At least off the comp. Phone in bed, however...

[Gentled Ben]

@Shad I hope they play Flood for you, although it would have to be a medley or take up a whole set.

 

I’ve seen Sooh as a wolf. She lurked and then subbed out.

[Shad_]

They have a 15ish minute live version so it's possible.

 

I've seen them three times before.  Their single-song opus albums don't pop up live often, but they did play Feedbacker in its entirety for me at SXSW.

 

It's also being advertised as their 25th Anniversary tour so maaaaaaaaybe their most famous song makes it into the setlist even if it's long.

 

I could just cheat and google the set-list but that takes the fun out of it.

 

One of the great things about seeing a band that you know really really well is no matter what they play it's familiar. 

[Andrej]

I skimmed all of that.

 

#modlife

[Andrej]

Vote Count

 

Shad_ - 2 - Clovdyx, Gentled Ben

Sooh - 1 - Turin Turambar

 

5 to lynch

 

Deadline in ~21.5 hours

[Clovdyx]

Ben - why are you lynching Shad?

[Clovdyx]

 

Her tone was solid in the exchange.

 

Not as important as how she sounds towards more relevant topics (she could get frustrated there in either slot) but a good look.

If by solid you mean it doesn't make me think she's mafia, I agree with all of this :P

 

 

Coming back to this because I'm a glutton for punishment I'm stupid I hate myself I wanted to follow up on it

 

I'm pretty happy with Sooh from the jester thing.  Part of me asking what her read on Turin was is because I wanted to see if it fit with the way she was handling his concerns/push on her.  She said annoying town and addressed him like he was a town read that she was just frustrated with.  I remember somebody said something about getting frustrated as either alignment (not sure if it was in regards to this or something else, I think something else) and I can imagine that Mafia!Sooh thought she was being pushed over something completely innocent and honest, but she's at least consistent.

[Clovdyx]

You can ignore the previous question.

 

 

 

Don't like the shade here. If you were trying to get a reaction out of me other than what you received, you could just as easily have said so. Instead, you called my response "unorthodox." How is it unorthodox? You connect unorthodox responses with my mafia game, then anticipate that I will stick with my response (because why wouldn't I?)  and call that scummy too before pretending to back off with a backhanded note that without being awake yet, it looks NAI. This makes the entire exchange that you started with me feel like a set up and puts you into the scum pile for me.

 

might want to reread that one boo because I never called anything you did scummy.  BFG called something you said villagery; I said, well, not really.

 

Yes, and coupled with claiming wolf with me to start the game, it is a push. For whatever reason, you decided to come at me out of left field to start this game. My initial thought was that you did it to get a read on me, but atp, it is starting to feel like you just came out of the wolf den with the intent of taking me down right away if you could, or leaving me bleeding and set up for a mislynch later if you couldn't.

 

Taken in that context, I suppose faking an attempt to figure me out is all you really can do, since the only thing you don't know is if I have a PR or not.

 

 

...If he was pushing you at the start of the game by claiming to be a wolf with you, wouldn't he be pushing himself?

 

I don't understand how he was setting you up for a mislynch by it, unless he planned on dying and expected everyone to immediately look at the person he was claiming to be partnered with the entire game.  That seems pretty damn unlikely to me.

[Gentled Ben]

Ben - why are you lynching Shad?

Best scum read I have. Everyone else is null or town, but I feel like he’s pushing me right out of the gate and until he said I’m “probably town,” tunneling on it. I think I explained my vote pretty well before I cast it.

 

If he looks more town than scum by DL or a scummier candidate comes along, I’m fine with changing the vote, but so far, that hasn’t happened yet.

 

What reads do you have so far?

[Clovdyx]

 

But I still have a scum lean on you. Be more villagery, and help me lynch scum, please. 

lol

 

"You're scum until you lynch all the scums. Then I *might* let you into my village."

 

*pictures Ben with squinty eyes looking at suspicious Shad*

 

 

I'm glad I'm not the only one who noticed that.

[Clovdyx]

 

Ben - why are you lynching Shad?

Best scum read I have. Everyone else is null or town, but I feel like he’s pushing me right out of the gate and until he said I’m “probably town,” tunneling on it. I think I explained my vote pretty well before I cast it.

 

If he looks more town than scum by DL or a scummier candidate comes along, I’m fine with changing the vote, but so far, that hasn’t happened yet.

 

What reads do you have so far?

 

 

People I am not going to lynch today:

Shad

Sooh

 

People I am fine lynching today:

Everybody else

 

 

If EoD was right now, I don't know that I don't vote you.  There's a reasonable chance you flip town, but I don't understand how you go from fighting with Shad for two or three pages and swearing up and down his entire gameplay has been to sink you and then tell him "Be villagery, and help me lynch scum."  If you're that confident he's mafia, why the hell would you ever expect him to help you lynch scum?  Your argument is HE's scum.

[Clovdyx]

Verb - talk to me about your reads? 

[Clovdyx]

 

Ben - why are you lynching Shad?

Best scum read I have. Everyone else is null or town, but I feel like he’s pushing me right out of the gate and until he said I’m “probably town,” tunneling on it. I think I explained my vote pretty well before I cast it.

 

If he looks more town than scum by DL or a scummier candidate comes along, I’m fine with changing the vote, but so far, that hasn’t happened yet.

 

What reads do you have so far?

 

 

Now that I'm caught up, can you show me where this happened?  He's said he's mafia with you for really most of the game, but I don't think I've seen anything that gives me the impression he genuinely was calling you mafia or attempting to get you lynched.  Going back through his ISO, he literally said he didn't have a read on you either way.  The closest thing he's done to actually argue for you being scum is give his assessment of your playstyle/abilities.  

 

I think YOU, on the other hand, have absolutely been tunneling on him.  It took Sooh to point out in big letters that Shad's posts were hypotheticals, even though Shad had been arguing it for like three pages or something.  

[Clovdyx]

I'd guess Verb is probably town too.  I'm not nearly AS comfortable with him, but his questioning of Shad looks okay?

 

And I'm definitely not kind of garbage reading him for his question about me. 

[Andrej]

[Clovdyx]

[unvote]

[Gentled Ben]

 

 

Ben - why are you lynching Shad?

Best scum read I have. Everyone else is null or town, but I feel like he’s pushing me right out of the gate and until he said I’m “probably town,” tunneling on it. I think I explained my vote pretty well before I cast it.

 

If he looks more town than scum by DL or a scummier candidate comes along, I’m fine with changing the vote, but so far, that hasn’t happened yet.

 

What reads do you have so far?

People I am not going to lynch today:

Shad

Sooh

 

People I am fine lynching today:

Everybody else

 

 

If EoD was right now, I don't know that I don't vote you. There's a reasonable chance you flip town, but I don't understand how you go from fighting with Shad for two or three pages and swearing up and down his entire gameplay has been to sink you and then tell him "Be villagery, and help me lynch scum." If you're that confident he's mafia, why the hell would you ever expect him to help you lynch scum? Your argument is HE's scum.

Okay, first off, it’s early yet and there isn’t much content from other players, so I am open to a better candidate, and I am open to changing my opinion of Shad if that proves to be warranted. Every game, every villager that isn’t willfully stubborn will go back and forth on some players, and it’s disingenuous for you to pretend not to know that and to act like I am incapable of adapting my reads as I process new information, but your hard defense if Shad is noted.

 

If you know why I am voting to lynch Shad, then why ask, and why erupt with fake indignation when I answer it? Your whole post feels forced and constructed. Not a good look.

[Clovdyx]

I go back and forth on players all the time.  What I don't do is expect people I'm convinced are scum help me.

 

 

I didn't know why you were lynching Shad.  I was clearly catching up, and when I got to a point that I saw everything, I literally told you to ignore me asking.

[Andrej]

Vote Count

 

Shad_ - 1 - Gentled Ben

Sooh - 1 - Turin Turambar

 

5 to lynch

 

Deadline in 19 hours.

[Tiinker]

PSA:Taking a flight at 7pm GMT. I think that's deadline ish time. Will check in before.

[Clovdyx]

PSA:Taking a flight at 7pm GMT. I think that's deadline ish time. Will check in before.

 

Do you have any reads right now?

[Clovdyx]

Okay, first off, it’s early yet and there isn’t much content from other players, so I am open to a better candidate, and I am open to changing my opinion of Shad if that proves to be warranted. Every game, every villager that isn’t willfully stubborn will go back and forth on some players, and it’s disingenuous for you to pretend not to know that and to act like I am incapable of adapting my reads as I process new information, but your hard defense if Shad is noted.

If you know why I am voting to lynch Shad, then why ask, and why erupt with fake indignation when I answer it? Your whole post feels forced and constructed. Not a good look.

 

 

 

Can you talk about your other reads?  Why town on Turin?  Who else do you have reads on?