Sailor Moon Mafia [Advanced] Game Thread

[Cory Caboose]

That meta on Darthe is honestly like a year and a half outdated Z

 

He's pretty hard to predict these days

[MrsClov]

Way too lazy to update my notes, soo just going to wing it. Going in order of player list. 

Cory/Clov- Null, but could easily go slight town on. Cory's giving off an excitement to play that I tend to associate with his town games. I said before I don't think Scum!Clov openly gives Eldrick a town read. I also don't know that he'd go through the trouble of explaining his thoughts regarding Ted/Sooh character claim ordeal. Still need to see more before I can feel really comfy putting them as town though. 
 

Sooh- I can not see her being scum in this game. I thought she was hinting at her character when Ted claimed, the confirmation puts her pretty solid in my town bean bag chairs. I just can't see scum being that bold D1, plus she's been the voice of reason which is something I associate with Sooh as a person. Case in point explaining herself to Spades, trying to calm Z down, giving Scruffington a chance. 

Eldrick- Pretty firmly null. He's made some comments I like, but nothing that's particularly made me go mm yeah he's townie or scum. I still don't feel like he's fully in the game. Clov seems really confident that Eld is town, and I know he has a great track record of reading Eldrick so if I get a full town vibe on Cordyx I may sheep the Eldrick read. *shrug*

Bop/Spade- I think it'd be really hard to keep up the aggressive game solvey posts they've being doing. Especially as a hydra. I think at some point there'd be like a slip that'd kill the momentum. I've been pretty in line with their thoughts and they can sit on the townie bean bags, but kind of away from Sooh in case the three decide to get fighty again.

Zander- I'm really going back and forth on Z. I've heard a lot about his meta but I've never experienced it myself. If what I heard is true, it'd be really hard to keep up as scum. That being said, I don't feel like he's been trying to solve. I don't know if that's because he's town and feels confident he caught scum in bop and spades or if he's scum and just needs to look like he's trying to find scum. Regardless, the circle that resulted from it didn't really feel productive to me at all. We asked him to back off, and he did and made a comment about getting crap for asking questions. I have no problem with asking questions, but my problem with this is the fact that the questions were answered, and then repeatedly asked over and over again with little content today on anyone else. He gave a reads list, but it felt safe to me. 

Cuth- ????

Darthe- Darthe's actually felt like a bit of a voice of reason this game and I don't know what to do with it. He seems chill, and I've liked some of the posts he's made recently... but nothing to really move him out of Null for me.

Ted Bundy- Null... The claim drop really doesn't mean much to me this game since we know mafia has fake claims. 

Ironeyes- I want to ISO Marsh. I've no clue how to read him from the one? game we've played together. His posts seem.. safe... I don't really know how to expand on it more than this. Like they're okay but maybe a little calculated? Eh. Need to marinate on this more. 

Aquilla- ????

Scruffington- I almost kind of want to unvote him to give him a chance, but the fact that he's very clearly not read the thread is driving me insane. So I guess I need to figure out does Scum dare not read the thread or does town? 

[Cory Caboose]

Darthe is very self-aware and people like that change playstyles and approaches constantly. You're far better looking back 1-2 games to see if they are learning from their mistakes as a villager or just emulating what people expect of them.

[Darthe]

Cory was wrongish tho. You've done that for ten games and the result in all ten had been scum according to you grasping to make that read work.

 

The Problem with it imo is that I'm Always the psychologist. Always. That's my nature.

 

But as a wolf I have to try really hard to fame being a patient. Its a natural aspect of my town game because here I actually want to be understood even when I slack off.

[MrsClov]

 

This lineup tho

 

<3

 

i'm going into the fourth dimension of readmaking and from there Sooh's entrance on 1-2 and her very genuine excitement about the game's potential forms the shape of a promising start. will be informative to see if it stays consistent

 

I'm also super thankful Linz is IC because she's someone I've legitimately struggled reading in the few games I've played with her :P I have no experience with her wolfgame, pretty much every game I remember her being in, she was a villager

 

 

Remember that time on Wafia in Arkham when you day vigged me and I took you down with me. Good times.

 

It's been so long since I've played scum that I don't know if I remember how to play.

[Darthe]

Darthe is very self-aware and people like that change playstyles and approaches constantly. You're far better looking back 1-2 games to see if they are learning from their mistakes as a villager or just emulating what people expect of them.

self awareness can only take me so far so perhaps you see something in me that I can't see in myself but I would disagree with you here that the psychologist patient metaphor the you used so long to go doesn't still have at least some place in determining me since its very core to my approach that I interact and analyze from ttys inside out.

[Darthe]

The, not ttys

[Sooh]

Darthe is very self-aware and people like that change playstyles and approaches constantly. You're far better looking back 1-2 games to see if they are learning from their mistakes as a villager or just emulating what people expect of them.

My recollection of his latest games are YOLO and barely there, so this is drastically different.

[bopolis]

 

 

 

So I perused a bit of scruffington's games on MU( a light game and a champs game) And the first few pages of a game on his homesite(battlestar galactica). From what I can tell random day 1 voting isnt a thing but scruffington was freely throwing his vote around as a way to apply pressure but with reason. He also doesnt list the reason in the same post he votes always. He'll either already be sussing the person(in bsg he was critical of someone then later voted) or he quoted a post of someone with a vote and later explained he didn't like the post

Maybe it's just me, but I think the stakes would be higher in a champs game than a random game on a forum he might never visit again. 

 

 thats why i looked at the other games

 

yeah, but you looked at a forum where he knows everyone and a champs game. Neither of those are very comparable to this game IMO.

 

and the light game as i said which is a 48/24 and i dont think he knew/knows the people on mu when it was played.

 

which i think is pretty similar to this one. 

 

And in that game he voted people without giving reasons and responded to people asking him why with snark.

 

not dissimilar to here.

[Clovdyx]

Way too lazy to update my notes, soo just going to wing it. Going in order of player list. 

 

Cory/Clov- Null, but could easily go slight town on. Cory's giving off an excitement to play that I tend to associate with his town games. I said before I don't think Scum!Clov openly gives Eldrick a town read. I also don't know that he'd go through the trouble of explaining his thoughts regarding Ted/Sooh character claim ordeal. Still need to see more before I can feel really comfy putting them as town though. 

 

TBF I know that I'm expected to always be right about Eldrick, so if I were scum and he was town, I'd probably townread him because I don't want to have to deal with explaining how I misread him.  

 

And pffft, I care way more as scum than I do as town.

[Cory Caboose]

 

Darthe is very self-aware and people like that change playstyles and approaches constantly. You're far better looking back 1-2 games to see if they are learning from their mistakes as a villager or just emulating what people expect of them.

self awareness can only take me so far so perhaps you see something in me that I can't see in myself but I would disagree with you here that the psychologist patient metaphor the you used so long to go doesn't still have at least some place in determining me since its very core to my approach that I interact and analyze from ttys inside out.

 

 

you're just doing that thing where you disagree with stuff

[Cory Caboose]

VILLAGERY

[Sooh]

 

 

 

 

So I perused a bit of scruffington's games on MU( a light game and a champs game) And the first few pages of a game on his homesite(battlestar galactica). From what I can tell random day 1 voting isnt a thing but scruffington was freely throwing his vote around as a way to apply pressure but with reason. He also doesnt list the reason in the same post he votes always. He'll either already be sussing the person(in bsg he was critical of someone then later voted) or he quoted a post of someone with a vote and later explained he didn't like the post

Maybe it's just me, but I think the stakes would be higher in a champs game than a random game on a forum he might never visit again. 

 

 thats why i looked at the other games

 

yeah, but you looked at a forum where he knows everyone and a champs game. Neither of those are very comparable to this game IMO.

 

and the light game as i said which is a 48/24 and i dont think he knew/knows the people on mu when it was played.

 

which i think is pretty similar to this one. 

 

And in that game he voted people without giving reasons and responded to people asking him why with snark.

 

not dissimilar to here.

 

Alright. Fair enough. I am just hoping to get him to post tbh.

[Cory Caboose]

I think Darthe is sliding into an existential crisis

 

I'm here for you Derf

 

let me love you

[Sooh]

I have played one turbo with Aquilla. Has anyone else played more with him?

 

Would he peace out as a townie the way he has done here? 

 

It's concerning.

[Darthe]

 

 

Darthe is very self-aware and people like that change playstyles and approaches constantly. You're far better looking back 1-2 games to see if they are learning from their mistakes as a villager or just emulating what people expect of them.

self awareness can only take me so far so perhaps you see something in me that I can't see in myself but I would disagree with you here that the psychologist patient metaphor the you used so long to go doesn't still have at least some place in determining me since its very core to my approach that I interact and analyze from ttys inside out.

you're just doing that thing where you disagree with stuff

I dont think thats true

[Darthe]

Does aquila deserve the amount of attention he is getting itt?

[Cory Caboose]

Does aquila deserve the amount of attention he is getting itt?

 

probably not, but most people have been villagery so far

[Cory Caboose]

tis a conundrum~

[Darthe]

Fair point. We're you serious about marsh earlier?

[Zander?]

 

@ Linz

@ Sooh

@ Eld

 

Reads?

Tons of nulls, some towns

 

Town:

Linz

Zander

Eldrick

 

mmmmSpades

Clovdyx (*fingers crossed*)

 

Darthe (*bites nails*)

 

Nulls

 

Ted

 

Mafia:

-

 

 

Pretend for a sec you knew for certain Cordyx, me and ofc no pretending but Linz are all Town.

 

GTH give me a Scum read with reasoning or even maybe a 3 person WTL?

[Cory Caboose]

Fair point. We're you serious about marsh earlier?

 

I didn't like the reads post on first glance. Read very much like a "busywork" type wolf post, but I need to re familiarize myself with Marsh before making a really serious read on the slot.

[bopolis]

I have played one turbo with Aquilla. Has anyone else played more with him?

 

Would he peace out as a townie the way he has done here? 

 

It's concerning.

i've played a champs game with him and i know of his meta. Apparently he's only played on MU and was a wolf once in the DM3 forumgame and from what i hear from dlgn and others he has a ridiculous volume tell so the fact that he isn't doing anything becomes concerning to me the longer it goes on. especially when he is on other social media places chatting away like a silly eagle all week.

[Cory Caboose]

I'm just going to read Spades as if I were reading Tress

 

Im a genius

 

Update: I really need to dig through Spades villager games just to get a better sense of her approach. This isn't really going to cut it. Trying to decipher Spades on stress level is probably a futile process

[Sooh]

 

 

@ Linz

@ Sooh

@ Eld

 

Reads?

Tons of nulls, some towns

 

Town:

Linz

Zander

Eldrick

 

mmmmSpades

Clovdyx (*fingers crossed*)

 

Darthe (*bites nails*)

 

Nulls

 

Ted

 

Mafia:

-

 

 

Pretend for a sec you knew for certain Cordyx, me and ofc no pretending but Linz are all Town.

 

GTH give me a Scum read with reasoning or even maybe a 3 person WTL?

 

I don't have one yet.