[Game thread]Magic The Gathering

Nynaeve · June 9, 2017

I keep mixing up adella and tigs posts... not sure why.
Similar style, from the old days.

It's really doing my head in

Shanti · June 9, 2017

Absolutely. I'm waiting on your responses to my wall of text before I place a vote, cause I'm patient (for now).

Sucks, but I can accept this skeptical side of you atm.... please just remember how strong I feel about cuthanyn if I'm lynched or nk'd.... actually since my time is limited, let me look at your wall of text to see if I can clear things up. I'm town and I know and truly believe if you're town you will do what is best for town.

Shanti · June 9, 2017

Day didnt turn up as expected. Also fos cuth for being a filthy liar and not posting much as promised :-p I'll have to pay more attention when i look for a hydra next time around. The state of the economy just ruins everything.

i skimmed through. I'm not going to qualify mysrlf irt contribution. This is as much as you're gonna get. I wasn't kidding around when i said as much. With that said, i am going to enjoy myself what little time i have cause that's how i blowoff steam. If you dont like it and find it distracting then boo hoo poor you. It's not going to stop. And if you deem it vote worthy then 1. Lolyou 2. You're wasting your vote. 3. You suck.

On the good side of things? Kronos/killa hydra earns a solidified green, added to my previoys good feelz. No way he has the balls to vote me like that as scum. Also there were a couple of adella posts i liked and sounded earnest. So there's that. Still debating dice. Kinda muddled. Where the **** is alf? Good to see dpr jumping in and getting into the thick of it, though addmitedly im taking joy in him ripping into shad. Cass' paranoia and being all over the place seems genuine to me. I think. Hopefylly (dont go breaking my heart cass :-(). Shanti's posts kinda make my eyes glaze over and you can imagine what i think of her lol vote but addmitedly i dont know her and havent played with her so i havent decided yet if the nudge is dirty or misguided. Bfg kinda trending down. I expected her to be knee deep into the game by now being all bfg-like-ish.

This is sorta where I'm at. Unsure where exactly cuth is at reads wise. Like i said, he's gonna get a not so great hydra review when this game is over... sssshhh don't tell

And I've officially reached my limit with your posts. GG naming a bunch of people green/town though so I can't tell who your scum buddies are.

Thank you?

I aim to compliment where compliments are deserved.

DPR · June 9, 2017

Day didnt turn up as expected. Also fos cuth for being a filthy liar and not posting much as promised :-p I'll have to pay more attention when i look for a hydra next time around. The state of the economy just ruins everything.

i skimmed through. I'm not going to qualify mysrlf irt contribution. This is as much as you're gonna get. I wasn't kidding around when i said as much. With that said, i am going to enjoy myself what little time i have cause that's how i blowoff steam. If you dont like it and find it distracting then boo hoo poor you. It's not going to stop. And if you deem it vote worthy then 1. Lolyou 2. You're wasting your vote. 3. You suck.

On the good side of things? Kronos/killa hydra earns a solidified green, added to my previoys good feelz. No way he has the balls to vote me like that as scum. Also there were a couple of adella posts i liked and sounded earnest. So there's that. Still debating dice. Kinda muddled. Where the **** is alf? Good to see dpr jumping in and getting into the thick of it, though addmitedly im taking joy in him ripping into shad. Cass' paranoia and being all over the place seems genuine to me. I think. Hopefylly (dont go breaking my heart cass :-(). Shanti's posts kinda make my eyes glaze over and you can imagine what i think of her lol vote but addmitedly i dont know her and havent played with her so i havent decided yet if the nudge is dirty or misguided. Bfg kinda trending down. I expected her to be knee deep into the game by now being all bfg-like-ish.

This is sorta where I'm at. Unsure where exactly cuth is at reads wise. Like i said, he's gonna get a not so great hydra review when this game is over... sssshhh don't tell

To be fair, I'm not "ripping into" Shad or anyone else.

I'm just making observations, asking questions, and the normal.

It's like y'all are paranoid or something.

Shanti · June 9, 2017

Day didnt turn up as expected. Also fos cuth for being a filthy liar and not posting much as promised :-p I'll have to pay more attention when i look for a hydra next time around. The state of the economy just ruins everything.

i skimmed through. I'm not going to qualify mysrlf irt contribution. This is as much as you're gonna get. I wasn't kidding around when i said as much. With that said, i am going to enjoy myself what little time i have cause that's how i blowoff steam. If you dont like it and find it distracting then boo hoo poor you. It's not going to stop. And if you deem it vote worthy then 1. Lolyou 2. You're wasting your vote. 3. You suck.

On the good side of things? Kronos/killa hydra earns a solidified green, added to my previoys good feelz. No way he has the balls to vote me like that as scum. Also there were a couple of adella posts i liked and sounded earnest. So there's that. Still debating dice. Kinda muddled. Where the **** is alf? Good to see dpr jumping in and getting into the thick of it, though addmitedly im taking joy in him ripping into shad. Cass' paranoia and being all over the place seems genuine to me. I think. Hopefylly (dont go breaking my heart cass :-(). Shanti's posts kinda make my eyes glaze over and you can imagine what i think of her lol vote but addmitedly i dont know her and havent played with her so i havent decided yet if the nudge is dirty or misguided. Bfg kinda trending down. I expected her to be knee deep into the game by now being all bfg-like-ish.

This is sorta where I'm at. Unsure where exactly cuth is at reads wise. Like i said, he's gonna get a not so great hydra review when this game is over... sssshhh don't tell

Why? Because you didn't get a NK for whatever reason?

DPR · June 9, 2017

Ima change my avatar. I think it's just too scary.

Nynaeve · June 9, 2017

You talk a very big talk for someone who's never played with me before. If you're scum, your buddies should have better advised you though. I'm no lynchbait, sweetcheeks.

Shanti · June 9, 2017

You talk a very big talk for someone who's never played with me before. If you're scum, your buddies should have better advised you though. I'm no lynchbait, sweetcheeks.

You're not lynchbait, hun. You're scum and I fully intend to fight to get you lynched until the end. ;)

DPR · June 9, 2017

Here we go, how is this one?

Nynaeve · June 9, 2017

Day didnt turn up as expected. Also fos cuth for being a filthy liar and not posting much as promised :-p I'll have to pay more attention when i look for a hydra next time around. The state of the economy just ruins everything.

i skimmed through. I'm not going to qualify mysrlf irt contribution. This is as much as you're gonna get. I wasn't kidding around when i said as much. With that said, i am going to enjoy myself what little time i have cause that's how i blowoff steam. If you dont like it and find it distracting then boo hoo poor you. It's not going to stop. And if you deem it vote worthy then 1. Lolyou 2. You're wasting your vote. 3. You suck.

On the good side of things? Kronos/killa hydra earns a solidified green, added to my previoys good feelz. No way he has the balls to vote me like that as scum. Also there were a couple of adella posts i liked and sounded earnest. So there's that. Still debating dice. Kinda muddled. Where the **** is alf? Good to see dpr jumping in and getting into the thick of it, though addmitedly im taking joy in him ripping into shad. Cass' paranoia and being all over the place seems genuine to me. I think. Hopefylly (dont go breaking my heart cass :-(). Shanti's posts kinda make my eyes glaze over and you can imagine what i think of her lol vote but addmitedly i dont know her and havent played with her so i havent decided yet if the nudge is dirty or misguided. Bfg kinda trending down. I expected her to be knee deep into the game by now being all bfg-like-ish.

This is sorta where I'm at. Unsure where exactly cuth is at reads wise. Like i said, he's gonna get a not so great hydra review when this game is over... sssshhh don't tell

Why? Because you didn't get a NK for whatever reason?

I was talking about friday... my rl day.. and not having as much free time. What's your childhood trauma?

Nynaeve · June 9, 2017

You talk a very big talk for someone who's never played with me before. If you're scum, your buddies should have better advised you though. I'm no lynchbait, sweetcheeks.

You're not lynchbait, hun. You're scum and I fully intend to fight to get you lynched until the end. ;)

Gl with that

Nynaeve · June 9, 2017

Here we go, how is this one?

Highly distirbong xD

Nynaeve · June 9, 2017

And also disturbing

Nynaeve · June 9, 2017

>.>

DPR · June 9, 2017

I liked distirbong. I think it says a lot.

Cass · June 9, 2017

Can we get a tiered/reads list from you Shad?

low effort not current drop is something like

Cass

BFG

Shanti ~feels good so far, if she's a wolf she nailed her town tone from the get-go

Cuth+Nyn ~Nyn needs to step up and play ball because I'm going to reach higher confidence on her one way or another than I'm likely to on Cuth

Killa+Kronos ~in need of a reread

Dice ~Dice has gotten better at Dicing as scum so we'll see, the stubbornness is a good look, needs a lot more content

Adella ~mostly liked how she handled my questions, haven't seen a reply to the last one yet

Tigraine ~lack of anything glaring so far where I would half expect there to be

LedZepMan ~curious about the people claiming this looks like his last town game, because I thought he was pretty unreadable there and then he got peeked town

DreadPirateRoberts ~nothing yet

Darthe ~nothing yet, that pop-in vote and disappearance could be anything

Alfred Jodocus ~distinguished from DPR/Darthe because he seemed eager to get going and then didn't

WRT Shanti - Her play is totally different to Peg + Cat?

WRT LZM - IMO it looks like his last Town game because he's not forming cases etc early. It doesn't look like his last Town game because there's been no questioning/reads and his only real comments so far are 'watching' you and a meta comment that I'm different.

I don't hate these bottom four, but it bothers me somewhat as a WTL since they're all the lowest volume players. The ?possiEZ clearing of Shanti and Dice, and to some extent myself and BFG bothers me here.

I think I'd put Tig above Dice/Adella at this point, and move Shanti down.

When did you decide my play was TOTALLY different when lir you said it was pretty much the same just rapid fire difference?

I said your tone was pretty much the same, the rapid fire I did/do take as completely different, gave examples later on. This is me questioning Shad's total green read on you and basing it on tone, when I'd expect him to include considerations about your play as well.

He answers here

Popcorn for your thoughts on that.

Nynaeve · June 9, 2017

I liked distirbong. I think it says a lot.

#phonetyping

Cass · June 9, 2017

Ima change my avatar. I think it's just too scary.

I am legit scared lol

By both

I think the puppy horrifies me more

Nynaeve · June 9, 2017

Ima change my avatar. I think it's just too scary.

I am legit scared lol

By both

I think the puppy horrifies me more

^^

Shanti · June 9, 2017

@Adella

So from

[Game thread]Magic The Gathering

Posted by Adella on 07 June 2017 - 05:26 AM in DM Mafia Games

These are VERY light and general reads, nothing in depth. It's my bed time.

1. Shad - Good activity so far, prodding questions to keep people talking, seems townie.
2. Darthe - Where you at? You did this last game and were scum... >.>
3. Shanti - So far I'm getting town, for above stated reason.
4. Tigraine - YOU SCARE ME! I don't see anything that says you're not mafia...
5. LedZepMan - Seems consistent with the last game so far, which is town.
6. DreadPirateRoberts - Need more to read
7. Adella - Clearly town imho
8. CuthaNyn (Cuth+Nyn) - Cuth is feeling town to me, but not much from Nyn yet
9. Alfred Jodocus - Need more to read
10. Killanos (Killa+Kronos) - So far Killa reminds me of Shanti, and I'm actually having a hard time telling their posts apart without having to go back and check who said what.
11. BFG - Came out pretty strong with probing questions in all directions, which I'm learning is generally a town thing to do.
12. Cass - Town so far, seems consistent with other couple of games we have played.
13. Dice - I am unsure on this, because I tend to read Dice as scummy no matter what (even in 2 broke girls where I was scum)

Which said reason was :

[Game thread]Magic The Gathering

Posted by Adella on 06 June 2017 - 08:06 PM in DM Mafia Games

Cass is seeming pretty Cass, but I also haven't played with her as scum so idk how different that would be.

So far Shanti is being consistent, nothing to point out as untownie, so I'm leaning town.

Tigs... Honestly, I'm so paranoid, I'm pretty much saying guilty until proven innocent.

Cuth came in with a gif right off the bat, so that seems pretty good LOL (it's a joke, FYI)

Amongst a few other things... you immediately went to me of all people being your top scum after night, which was when I went after Shad_ and CuthaNyn...

[Game thread]Magic The Gathering

Posted by Adella on Today, 05:01 AM in DM Mafia Games

1. Shad - Early gameplay still reads as town for me. You're open to responding to everyone, answering questions easily, no odd answers or over-reactions. The more talkative and casual, the more I'm getting town from you, talking too much leaves room for error with slips. Nothing much for me to comment on until D2 started. Minor freak out about something that seems to be on ongoing issue (r u ok bro?) about the expected level of activity from you. Suddenly Shanti is all over you like white on rice, but I like your reactions. You react, without freaking out or getting defensive. You talk and answer questions, but appear totally unworried. I honestly feel pretty strongly that you are town.

3. Shanti - Started off with typical D1 spam, which just looks like you're getting used to the game by now, which you even state at one point. (Glad you're getting more comfortable, it's a great game!) Your reasoning on LZM feels weak to me. First you talked about needing more from his, and how he just wasn't sitting right, with a mention of lacking substance (which he absolutely did in P+C too) and then 45 minutes later you did an ISO from P+C and talked about how he was town, but seemed scummy, and then said he had way more substance there (I don't remember that at all, he hardly said anything that game). So, with his quiet gameplay seeming quiet-er, you place your vote. When asked for a reason you just repeat yourself and roll with the playstyle being different. Alright.

Let's talk D2... Overly strong reaction for N1, especially considering it looks like the mafia didn't get their NK (unless it was Darthe I guess). And you immediately go for Shad. From the start your line of questioning isn't too bad, asking for reasoning and such. You talk about how you voted for him, but stand by your reasons, which is all scum can do when they lynch town, but you brought it up, no one questioned you IIRC. Painting a target on the "hammer" is classic scum. I understand you're on a road trip, but your scum to town read list isn't going to do anyone any good. You're also dropping phrases like "us townies" a lot and it feels... When you start to geingenuine. t answers to your questions, you say you understand but don't let up. At all. And then you add Cuth to it. "If you're saying I'm scum, you're wrong" no one said it, but ok... And then you hop super easily over to Cuth when Shad gives solid townie responses, and place your vote without really talking to him about it, especially since he is here to talk to. And then you're trying to put Shad and Cuth together. Oh and my favorite, which I will quote:

You type out this wonderful paragraph of me overreacting, No Mafia didn't get their NK, but I was wrong about LZM being mafia, AND we lost Darthe...two town losses when I expected none. I go for Shad because he was a last minute switch, which in previous games people mentioned being scummy, sorry for trusting vet players. I stand by my reasons because they were legit reasons, he DID seem scum, I went ahead and defended myself and put the information out there because well, who wouldn't question someone on the lynch train? My scum to town list is better than sitting back and letting everyone make assumptions when I feel strongly about something and want to point it out. That isn't my style and never will be.

Huh? To the highlighted red part.

And to me saying that to Cuth it was actually both Shad and Cuth that I was stating it to and they were starting to twist my words and confusion into making me look guilty and like I was catching myself up in lies.

I didn't jump quickly, Shad's arguments were just better than Cuth's and they were both top scum reads so that is just grasping at straws.

Cass · June 9, 2017

Lack of interest at eod suggests that Alf was town for lolreasons, and I'd not put huge amounts of faith in it
Alf's been absent for so long at this point I'm not sure I'd put any stock into that.

Trying to figure out what both of you are saying - do you think alf is town or scum?

I think there's a decent chance he's scum.

It's not like that's a read I can develop further because he's not here.

He was excited to play and then didn't play. Way more people dislike being scum than don't and I've seen multiple other strangers peace out shortly after reading a scum role pm. There's less of a guilt compulsion to stick it out for your team when no one knows who you are anyway.

Or he could just be busy. /shrug The immediate shift in his interest level and his subsequent disappearance is all I have to work with.

@BFG generic apathy about being lynched doesn't really count if the player doesn't care about the game in general. Thoughts on that?

@ Shad - why do you think he's scum? You've expressed that opinion quite a bit, so please don't come back with reasons why you can't list reasons. Just lay 'em out.

@Shad and @DPR

Should Alf be lynch candidate today?

Shanti · June 9, 2017

Day didnt turn up as expected. Also fos cuth for being a filthy liar and not posting much as promised :-p I'll have to pay more attention when i look for a hydra next time around. The state of the economy just ruins everything.

i skimmed through. I'm not going to qualify mysrlf irt contribution. This is as much as you're gonna get. I wasn't kidding around when i said as much. With that said, i am going to enjoy myself what little time i have cause that's how i blowoff steam. If you dont like it and find it distracting then boo hoo poor you. It's not going to stop. And if you deem it vote worthy then 1. Lolyou 2. You're wasting your vote. 3. You suck.

On the good side of things? Kronos/killa hydra earns a solidified green, added to my previoys good feelz. No way he has the balls to vote me like that as scum. Also there were a couple of adella posts i liked and sounded earnest. So there's that. Still debating dice. Kinda muddled. Where the **** is alf? Good to see dpr jumping in and getting into the thick of it, though addmitedly im taking joy in him ripping into shad. Cass' paranoia and being all over the place seems genuine to me. I think. Hopefylly (dont go breaking my heart cass :-(). Shanti's posts kinda make my eyes glaze over and you can imagine what i think of her lol vote but addmitedly i dont know her and havent played with her so i havent decided yet if the nudge is dirty or misguided. Bfg kinda trending down. I expected her to be knee deep into the game by now being all bfg-like-ish.

This is sorta where I'm at. Unsure where exactly cuth is at reads wise. Like i said, he's gonna get a not so great hydra review when this game is over... sssshhh don't tell

Why? Because you didn't get a NK for whatever reason?

I was talking about friday... my rl day.. and not having as much free time. What's your childhood trauma?

My childhood is relevant to you being scum, how? Maybe in a game where there are night phases and day phases you should elaborate on what is rl and what is game? Just a thought there.

You talk a very big talk for someone who's never played with me before. If you're scum, your buddies should have better advised you though. I'm no lynchbait, sweetcheeks.

You're not lynchbait, hun. You're scum and I fully intend to fight to get you lynched until the end. ;)

Gl with that

Meh, either people will see I'm right and we will lynch or you/your scummates will frame me or nk me... either way you'll still be scum and I'll still be town.

DPR · June 9, 2017

Lack of interest at eod suggests that Alf was town for lolreasons, and I'd not put huge amounts of faith in it
Alf's been absent for so long at this point I'm not sure I'd put any stock into that.

Trying to figure out what both of you are saying - do you think alf is town or scum?

I think there's a decent chance he's scum.

It's not like that's a read I can develop further because he's not here.

He was excited to play and then didn't play. Way more people dislike being scum than don't and I've seen multiple other strangers peace out shortly after reading a scum role pm. There's less of a guilt compulsion to stick it out for your team when no one knows who you are anyway.

Or he could just be busy. /shrug The immediate shift in his interest level and his subsequent disappearance is all I have to work with.

@BFG generic apathy about being lynched doesn't really count if the player doesn't care about the game in general. Thoughts on that?

@ Shad - why do you think he's scum? You've expressed that opinion quite a bit, so please don't come back with reasons why you can't list reasons. Just lay 'em out.

@Shad and @DPR

Should Alf be lynch candidate today?

Depends on what he comes back with, no?

It's important that he shows up and plays, but there doesn't seem to be much to draw form so far - he's new to the site so no big deal if he's taking a minute to get acclimated.

If he stays gone, he becomes a liability. If he shows up and makes bad points, he's a liability. If he shows up and contributes, he deserves a fair shot.

Killashandra · June 9, 2017

The last page and 1/2 has been hilarious. Scum or town Nyn is always good for overall game amusement.

Her greening me and Kronos means pretty much nothing if she is scum Shanti. Two Hydra on scum team would be a little unbalanced I think and I doubt Sooh would do that.

Also wth you expected none? how to you expect none after a night phase unless you know something we don't? If we mis lynch day one 2 is standard even if we get scum day one that means one and sometimes 2 night kills.

Careful with all that passion you might get burned out fast like I did. That's why me and Kronos are hydra so we dont have as much pressure and I can ease back in after Ghost in the Shell did my head in. That is not game related just some advice.

Nynaeve · June 9, 2017

Looks like they found a new tunneling endorser. Nice. I see some zandwrism similarities too which is both intetesting and unfortunate. xD

[Game thread]Magic The Gathering

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook