[Basic] Peg + Cat Mafia -- TOWN WIN

[Eldrick4221]

This game has been a headache and a half. My top 2 scum reads are now off the table if Hally is seer. I'm feeling better about tigs from the effort she put into her reads.

 

I really think right now that it's darthe/ed, but don't have much as to why

[Eldrick4221]

And I REALLY don't get dice's response to my Darthe vote

[dicetosser1]

I'll commit when I find what I want to commit to. I don't know your alignment. And I don't need to give my thoughts to you. You could be scum.

 

so could you 

 

How do you expect other players to clear you if u sit there and say nothing, give no thoughts?

[Eldrick4221]

I'm counting this as a personal win if it really is darthe/ed.

 

Dying with the right reads counts too.

[Spadeszee]

We need to be careful, Ed might do another attempt at drive by voting (and not missing the mark this time).

I really don't think it's Dice/Cass, as much as I could be wrong, everything has been leading me to Ed/Edlrick right now.

[Eldrick4221]

I don't have much on ed. What I noticed from him was really from interactions of other people.

 

Alex had him as his peek. Could go either way.

 

Lzm's interactions with him, or lack thereof, is weird. But meaningless if he's town.

 

Other than that. He's been largely absent. Which is null being I don't know his normal activity level.

[LedZepMan]

I dont expect others to clear me. I expect nothing but lynch or be lynched.

 

I feel it's a pass or fail kinda class.

[Eldrick4221]

Darthe, on the other hand, is way less involved than he usually is.

 

And his treatment of me really is something to take into account.

 

I gave him as my n0 peek. As such, I treated him as town. Someone suggested that I was pocketing him, and he jumped on that concept.

 

Then nothing. I've been in his scum list since then for 0 reason.

[Spadeszee]

I don't have much on ed. What I noticed from him was really from interactions of other people.

 

Alex had him as his peek. Could go either way.

 

Lzm's interactions with him, or lack thereof, is weird. But meaningless if he's town.

 

Other than that. He's been largely absent. Which is null being I don't know his normal activity level.

How do you put him on your scum list above and then say you don't have anything on him here? This is why I'm voting you. You contradict yourself so much.

[Cass]

 

 

@Tigs - in this type of setup the seer starts the game with the name of one confirmed vanilla townie in their role PM, known as a N0 peek - it's randomized by the mod.

That's why so many of us were hard clearing someone as town D1, to lay down cover for the actual seer to be able to reveal their results.

 

Okay I get that, spades said she was Hallia's N1 so where does Dice/Cass fall into scum role?

She said "Early on good feels, asking questions etc/ Dice being fluffy to start – Then Cass slips into it seems only question asking/answering mechanics mode, which can be done regardless of alignment"

 

It doesn't state what is wolfy exactly, but is says why they aren't cleared in her mind. As seer maybe self pres as well, I don't know and I myself don't see them scummy.

  

 

@Tress, I really need your help here. My gut tells me to trust your instincts and experience right now.

Eldrick is screaming wolf at me, but Ed is also. I don't see Cass-Dice, but I don't know them well like you do.

Cass is coming across as very town. The only thing about her play that worries me is the fact that she was able to give a detailed explanation of why mafia would have considered Redd to be seer over anyone who gave a clear N0 peek.

Cass has been known to fool me, so I don't trust my town read on her too much.

Dice, however, is someone I have a long history of gut reading correctly when he's town, when a lot of other people struggle with it. There have been times I missed him as mafia, but those games were ones where I had a milder town read on him and got distracted looking elsewhere.

This game I haven't gotten that strong gut town read from him, and it worries me. I don't expect everyone else to go with it, but I can't shake it.

I'm willing to switch if necessary, there are 2 mafia alive and I have at least a couple of people I am not comfortable with as town.

FTR the underlined bold "Question/answer mechanics mode" isn't correct and feels like wolfy spin coupled with fearmongering/fear. I've contributed more freely this grange than perhaps any other, ever. Not something I'd do as wolf. Dice gut strength hampered by hydra.

 

There is NO reason why we should be lynched today over 'fear' / possibility instead of players like Adella/Ed/?Tig/LZM

ok to leave off Halleh for now but :/ at this when we've been actively solving and I feel the same about Eldrick really.

 

People pushing us over those not contributing is -_- and needs deep investigation

[Shanti]

As much as I hate to say this, I'm liking Elds logic more and more.

 

I went back and ISO'd Darthe once again amd he seems even more scummy than LZM atm. Which is saying something.

 

[v] Darthe [/v]

 

Let's do this.

[Spadeszee]

 

I don't have much on ed. What I noticed from him was really from interactions of other people.

 

Alex had him as his peek. Could go either way.

 

Lzm's interactions with him, or lack thereof, is weird. But meaningless if he's town.

 

Other than that. He's been largely absent. Which is null being I don't know his normal activity level.

How do you put him on your scum list above and then say you don't have anything on him here? This is why I'm voting you. You contradict yourself so much.

 

This is the reason I am also voting you over Ed right now. 

[Eldrick4221]

As I said before, he knows how this setup works. He knows that I would be treating him as town because I peeked him.

 

As scum, he would also know I was lying. So maybe he was trying to pocket whoever said I was trying to picket him.

[Cass]

CFD to Adella?

[Shad_]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Eldrick (3) - Adella, Dice/Cass, Spades

 

Dice/Cass (2) - Hallia, Tress

 

Darthe (2) - Eldrick, Shanti

 

Not Voting: Darthe, LedZepMan, ed2funy, Tigraine

 

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

 

[Cass]

Darthe loves scumming. He'd likely be here

[Tigraine]

 

 

 

@Tigs - in this type of setup the seer starts the game with the name of one confirmed vanilla townie in their role PM, known as a N0 peek - it's randomized by the mod.

That's why so many of us were hard clearing someone as town D1, to lay down cover for the actual seer to be able to reveal their results.

 

Okay I get that, spades said she was Hallia's N1 so where does Dice/Cass fall into scum role?

She said "Early on good feels, asking questions etc/ Dice being fluffy to start – Then Cass slips into it seems only question asking/answering mechanics mode, which can be done regardless of alignment"

 

It doesn't state what is wolfy exactly, but is says why they aren't cleared in her mind. As seer maybe self pres as well, I don't know and I myself don't see them scummy.

 

@Tress, I really need your help here. My gut tells me to trust your instincts and experience right now.

Eldrick is screaming wolf at me, but Ed is also. I don't see Cass-Dice, but I don't know them well like you do.

Cass is coming across as very town. The only thing about her play that worries me is the fact that she was able to give a detailed explanation of why mafia would have considered Redd to be seer over anyone who gave a clear N0 peek.

Cass has been known to fool me, so I don't trust my town read on her too much.

Dice, however, is someone I have a long history of gut reading correctly when he's town, when a lot of other people struggle with it. There have been times I missed him as mafia, but those games were ones where I had a milder town read on him and got distracted looking elsewhere.

This game I haven't gotten that strong gut town read from him, and it worries me. I don't expect everyone else to go with it, but I can't shake it.

I'm willing to switch if necessary, there are 2 mafia alive and I have at least a couple of people I am not comfortable with as town.

FTR the underlined bold "Question/answer mechanics mode" isn't correct and feels like wolfy spin coupled with fearmongering/fear. I've contributed more freely this grange than perhaps any other, ever. Not something I'd do as wolf. Dice gut strength hampered by hydra.

 

There is NO reason why we should be lynched today over 'fear' / possibility instead of players like Adella/Ed/?Tig/LZM

ok to leave off Halleh for now but :/ at this when we've been actively solving and I feel the same about Eldrick really.

 

People pushing us over those not contributing is -_- and needs deep investigation

I agree on all points. Even myself....I've been trying the last little but but you have all game. I can't trust gut feelings when there is nothing to base it on.

[Shad_]

page bump

 

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Eldrick (3) - Adella, Dice/Cass, Spades

 

Dice/Cass (2) - Hallia, Tress

 

Darthe (2) - Eldrick, Shanti

 

Not Voting: Darthe, LedZepMan, ed2funy, Tigraine

 

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

 

[LedZepMan]

I'm ok with a [v]Darthe[/v] lynch.

[Eldrick4221]

 

I don't have much on ed. What I noticed from him was really from interactions of other people.

 

Alex had him as his peek. Could go either way.

 

Lzm's interactions with him, or lack thereof, is weird. But meaningless if he's town.

 

Other than that. He's been largely absent. Which is null being I don't know his normal activity level.

How do you put him on your scum list above and then say you don't have anything on him here? This is why I'm voting you. You contradict yourself so much.

I said I didn't have much, not that I didn't have anything.

 

What what I had was subjective. I had lzm and Ed as a pair, mainly because of lzm's lack of interaction with him, even though there's clear history there.

[Shad_]

 

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Eldrick (3) - Adella, Dice/Cass, Spades

 

Dice/Cass (2) - Hallia, Tress

 

Darthe (3) - Eldrick, Shanti, LZM

 

Not Voting: Darthe, ed2funy, Tigraine

 

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

 

[dicetosser1]

CFD to Adella?

 

i dont want to

[Tigraine]

[v] Darthe [/v]

 

At least eld is here

[dicetosser1]

Can we not do random again plz?  anyone around to consolidate?

[Shad_]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Eldrick (3) - Adella, Dice/Cass, Spades

 

Dice/Cass (2) - Hallia, Tress

 

Darthe (4) - Eldrick, Shanti, LZM, Tigraine

 

Not Voting: Darthe, ed2funy

 

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.