[Basic C9++] Murder Mystery Mafia D5

[ed2funy]

 

 

[monstrman]

i still want to lynch tigraine

[ed2funy]

A lot of people noted Ed cares about his reads and is generally impactful as a villager even if he isn't super serious. This is my first game with him so I've never got to see it live but he's been relatively fixated on a few people and ignoring others and his filler:real content level is low. I'm not sure how accurate that element of his meta is, but nothing really screams "villagery" about what he's focused on.

 

Shad noted back he has some serious Serial Killer equity as well, and hitting the SK today would be a boon (would eliminate a NK) even if we shouldn't really focus on that element because SK hunting at least for me is fairly hard

The problem is no one really knows my meta like they think. Just saying.

 

Real life and the massive thread size with mostly new players to me got the best of me.

[Cory Caboose]

LOL PACERS LOL

[Kaylee]

Official Vote Count

 

DPR (3): Darthe, Ed, Manbat

 

Darthe (1): DPR

 

Not Voting (4): Tress, Tig, Killashandra, Shadory

 

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch

 

ONCE AGAIN DPR IS AT L-2

 

DEADLINE IS SET FOR APRIL 22TH AT 8:30PM PST

 

[monstrman]

hardclaim double voter

[Cory Caboose]

Manbat has achieved vote nirvana by moving so much. It is at all places at once.

[monstrman]

[v]edpr [/v]

[DPR]

Quick read of Town to Scum going down. Loosely. Still evaluating final positions, but I just know I'm a top. Will pull some ISOs and reaffirm what could just be shoddy memory. Feel free to correct me so I can correct you. 

 

ed2funy - honest to god the sexiest villager I've ever seen, and I've seen his cannoli. 

 

Shadory (cory caboose & Shad_) - Not even going to lie, the hydra thing is annoying, but only because you are both active. I actually have Cory higher town than you, but you're one entity. I'm not 

 

DPR (DreadPirateRoberts) - Sexiest pirate and with hell of a detachable stump (it has batteries, guise). As I stated before, I actually have been agreeing with him a lot. From Bro Job Club (please don't reply to this aspect - I read all of the back and forth and can see the merits of both arguments, but still generally agree with DPR while understanding if any of you caught the other looking at your hand, you'd pick it up and slap them) to Killa being given too much town cred for her posts to thinking I'm hawt shit. I insofar haven't been leaning scum on him. Probably because of the whole trying really hard not to fight everyone, which I appreciate. I still view the game as find scum by scummy actions before trying to clear town. It makes more sense to me, because paranoia. 

 

SoJames (Sooh & E James Todd) - Sooh, I feel pretty comfy with (James doesn't exist). She's asking questions without trying to lead from what I recall. 

 

manbat - manmeat has a lot of content, but has been sitting more null in my book. Most unremarkable manmeat I've ever seen. 

 

seph - I already know he's going to sulk at me, but he's mainly low on my list because of my early perceptions of him. Honestly pending a move on my list on some re-skim. 

 

Tigraine - I think I've already explained my views on her a couple of times. Tigs sits lower because from what I recall, she should have handled that whole debacle better. I also have know Tigs the longest and probably have played the most with her. The biggest thing holding me back besides not having as many content-scum-reads as knowing-Tigs-reads (Hey, are we a Bro Club?!) is Tress saying no lynching her. 

 

Killashandra - I'm really not seeing what everyone is hard on Town for her. I will do more of an ISO to illustrate and point out my thoughts. Last post didn't help.

 

Songstress - I have her so low because she doesn't love me and I can't really remember why. Biggest thing I remember thinking at some point is that she is trying to play to her town meta (not that I know it, but from interactions)

 

Darthe - Honestly not even my most suspect person to try to Lynch. He just naturally fits as a bottom, and he's been coasting more than anything. Not as much pot stirring as usual.

 

Dead Players

Clov (Clovdyx) - FancyPants McGee and Vanilla Town - NK N1

WolfbrotherKronos - Toussaint Le Breton and Vanilla Town - D2 Lynch

Niniel - Beauregard Jackson and Mafia Goon - D1 Lynch

Gonna type here.

 

 

Vote Counts: Town in Blue; Mafia in Red. In case you're DPR or have lost use of half of your brain. 

 

Day 1 Lynch

Final Vote Count

Niniel (7): Ed, Darthe, SoJames, Shadory, Seph, Tress, Clov

Darthe (3): DPR, Niniel, Kronos

Tigraine (1): Manbat

Not Voting (2): Tigraine, Killashandra

 

Day 2 Lynch

Final Vote Count

Kronos (6): Shadory, Seph, Kronos, SoJames, Darthe, Manbat

Not Voting (5): Tress, Ed, Tig, DPR, Killashandra

 

 

Here's ed's read on me as of lunch today. 

 

This goes directly against the things he's said tonight.

[Shad_]

Ollie's still up at 10pm again.

Easter is canceled, forever.
 

[Kaylee]

hardclaim double voter

[Kaylee]

Manbat has achieved vote nirvana by moving so much. It is at all places at once.

  

[v]edpr [/v]

You both can lick my...*censored*

 

Lol That's what happens when I update while watching tv.

[Shad_]

If we go by mod-confined roles and actions, we can get a more accurate picture and we don't need to spec. Things are already a mess - why make them worse? That's why I said ed knows I'm town - which he does - because I'm usually all over the spec and I'm making a serious effort to not do the after last game.

I'm not sure what this has to do with your alignment.

 

Why in your opinion should this constitute hard evidence from Ed's POV that you are a villager?

[Shad_]

You got nothing on your claim. No proof at all. Which is why you did it.

 

if I was Doc, I wouldn't counter right now.

You keep saying this. It sounds game-throwing crazy to me but I'll ask: why?

[monstrman]

 

Manbat has achieved vote nirvana by moving so much. It is at all places at once.

  

[v]edpr [/v]

You both can lick my...*censored*

Lol That's what happens when I update while watching tv.

careful now don't proposition me too hard

 

i might just oblige

[Kaylee]

*waggles eyebrows*

[Shad_]

it might have been poop

[Shad_]

Now that this thread has gone to the abyss, lunch time anyone?

[Shad_]

Tress any deep thoughts? Your tone has been pure as daisies but I still can't quite escape the feeling that you're skating through without the level of investment I would expect.

[DPR]

 

If we go by mod-confined roles and actions, we can get a more accurate picture and we don't need to spec. Things are already a mess - why make them worse? That's why I said ed knows I'm town - which he does - because I'm usually all over the spec and I'm making a serious effort to not do the after last game.

I'm not sure what this has to do with your alignment.

 

Why in your opinion should this constitute hard evidence from Ed's POV that you are a villager?

 

 

 

Because ed has seen my scum game enough times to know when I'm being genuine - he knows a number of things that I would have employed if I was scum. 

 

That and his lunchtime read on me.

[Shad_]

I suppose calling for a hammer and then stating that wasn't particularly fair.

 

Yeah we can use the clock if it helps down the road.

[ed2funy]

 

 

Ed SK makes a lot of sense yeah

to you and ShaD...how?

 

And if I was SK, I'm not gonna lie, I'd have shot DPR N1 because I'm a petty batch of cookies like that.

 

But instead, you chose to post reads of me being town/not a suspect. Uh huh.

Because you weren't at the time and I'm not the SK or Mafia.

*clicks tongue* soooooo

[ed2funy]

 

Quick read of Town to Scum going down. Loosely. Still evaluating final positions, but I just know I'm a top. Will pull some ISOs and reaffirm what could just be shoddy memory. Feel free to correct me so I can correct you.

 

ed2funy - honest to god the sexiest villager I've ever seen, and I've seen his cannoli.

 

Shadory (cory caboose & Shad_) - Not even going to lie, the hydra thing is annoying, but only because you are both active. I actually have Cory higher town than you, but you're one entity. I'm not

 

DPR (DreadPirateRoberts) - Sexiest pirate and with hell of a detachable stump (it has batteries, guise). As I stated before, I actually have been agreeing with him a lot. From Bro Job Club (please don't reply to this aspect - I read all of the back and forth and can see the merits of both arguments, but still generally agree with DPR while understanding if any of you caught the other looking at your hand, you'd pick it up and slap them) to Killa being given too much town cred for her posts to thinking I'm hawt shit. I insofar haven't been leaning scum on him. Probably because of the whole trying really hard not to fight everyone, which I appreciate. I still view the game as find scum by scummy actions before trying to clear town. It makes more sense to me, because paranoia.

 

SoJames (Sooh & E James Todd) - Sooh, I feel pretty comfy with (James doesn't exist). She's asking questions without trying to lead from what I recall.

 

manbat - manmeat has a lot of content, but has been sitting more null in my book. Most unremarkable manmeat I've ever seen.

 

seph - I already know he's going to sulk at me, but he's mainly low on my list because of my early perceptions of him. Honestly pending a move on my list on some re-skim.

 

Tigraine - I think I've already explained my views on her a couple of times. Tigs sits lower because from what I recall, she should have handled that whole debacle better. I also have know Tigs the longest and probably have played the most with her. The biggest thing holding me back besides not having as many content-scum-reads as knowing-Tigs-reads (Hey, are we a Bro Club?!) is Tress saying no lynching her.

 

Killashandra - I'm really not seeing what everyone is hard on Town for her. I will do more of an ISO to illustrate and point out my thoughts. Last post didn't help.

 

Songstress - I have her so low because she doesn't love me and I can't really remember why. Biggest thing I remember thinking at some point is that she is trying to play to her town meta (not that I know it, but from interactions)

 

Darthe - Honestly not even my most suspect person to try to Lynch. He just naturally fits as a bottom, and he's been coasting more than anything. Not as much pot stirring as usual.

 

Dead Players

Clov (Clovdyx) - FancyPants McGee and Vanilla Town - NK N1

WolfbrotherKronos - Toussaint Le Breton and Vanilla Town - D2 Lynch

Niniel - Beauregard Jackson and Mafia Goon - D1 Lynch

Gonna type here.

 

 

Vote Counts: Town in Blue; Mafia in Red. In case you're DPR or have lost use of half of your brain.

 

Day 1 Lynch

Final Vote Count

Niniel (7): Ed, Darthe, SoJames, Shadory, Seph, Tress, Clov

Darthe (3): DPR, Niniel, Kronos

Tigraine (1): Manbat

Not Voting (2): Tigraine, Killashandra

 

Day 2 Lynch

Final Vote Count

Kronos (6): Shadory, Seph, Kronos, SoJames, Darthe, Manbat

Not Voting (5): Tress, Ed, Tig, DPR, Killashandra

 

Here's ed's read on me as of lunch today.

 

This goes directly against the things he's said tonight.

But they actually haven't. I still admit I was agreeing with you on those points. But then I take into account the way you've been trying to set this up and came at me after. I didn't just flip around. You were higher up on my list and then you dropped after your actions.

Also, another point coming up in next quote.

[ed2funy]

 

If we go by mod-confined roles and actions, we can get a more accurate picture and we don't need to spec. Things are already a mess - why make them worse? That's why I said ed knows I'm town - which he does - because I'm usually all over the spec and I'm making a serious effort to not do the after last game.

I'm not sure what this has to do with your alignment.

 

Why in your opinion should this constitute hard evidence from Ed's POV that you are a villager?

 

I can't remember if I replied to this already. Before you even said this, I'm pretty sure, I said you're a player who can still hide being scum under the guise of trying to change up your playstyle because of the last game. All to help the town.

But your actions have been purely out of self-preservation and pushing this today.

[Shad_]

 

 

If we go by mod-confined roles and actions, we can get a more accurate picture and we don't need to spec. Things are already a mess - why make them worse? That's why I said ed knows I'm town - which he does - because I'm usually all over the spec and I'm making a serious effort to not do the after last game.

I'm not sure what this has to do with your alignment.

 

Why in your opinion should this constitute hard evidence from Ed's POV that you are a villager?

 

 

 

Because ed has seen my scum game enough times to know when I'm being genuine - he knows a number of things that I would have employed if I was scum. 

 

That and his lunchtime read on me.

 

 

That's fine and Ed doesn't exactly look like a top tier villager right now.  "I'm refraining from doing something that hurt the town (or wasn't effective or whatever you were getting at, didn't read the game myself) last time I was town" doesn't equate to "I"m town" for me and that seemed to be the dot you were saying he should have connected.  I guess a general "I am being honest about this particular thing and he knows it" could have some alignment relevance in a meta sphere that I'm oblivious to. 

 

I've seen enough wolves skate by being open and sincere about things that don't really impact their alignment that it doesn't sway me in a vacuum. 

 

Ed what's your response to this?