[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

[dicetosser1]

Dice? You scum thanking me for being so bad y'all win? lol

 

Iron, I just said in a recent post that I lied about the schedule and that I chose Odd nights over Even to be able to commute. Which means if we can get an actual scum lynched today, I'm the NK tonight because it'll be easier to sow WIFOM with the remaining two town who everyone more or less admits they can't read well this game. 

 

throws bananas at ed. it was for answering. im not gonna be polite to uu anymore if thats what i get.

[Ironeyes]

 

Dice? You scum thanking me for being so bad y'all win? lol

 

Iron, I just said in a recent post that I lied about the schedule and that I chose Odd nights over Even to be able to commute. Which means if we can get an actual scum lynched today, I'm the NK tonight because it'll be easier to sow WIFOM with the remaining two town who everyone more or less admits they can't read well this game. 

I must have missed that post. I'll go back and look for it

 

You meant this post I believe. I think I skimmed over it the first time

 

 

 

 

 

No offense, but DPR knows my claim is more valid than anyone's. He even dissed out a dead Tress to throw shade at Zander because he knew Zander's claim was pretty legit (obviously beforehand, it's more difficult than anything to prove, so I'm not trying to say I'm a hard yes townie by proof of some sort). I get that, but so does DPR.

 

Now you're going legit scummish - I don't think your claim is legit at all. I think it's something you and Darthe cooked up and you've been there at every opportunity to sell it. Every. Opportunity.

 

I "dissed" Tress for putting together a tinfoil mess, wasting everyone's time and attention, making it easier for scum to lay low.

 

Zander's claim was easier to prove because it was already proven. Tress saw him. We just didn't know *what* he was.

 

Your claim requires our complete faith. You revealed your schedule after Tress died.

Except it wasn't every opportunity. I first started to try and protect Tress by drawing the NK. Also, I've lied about my exact schedule. I could have picked Even or Odd nights and picked Odd. I mentioned it so much N4 to try to keep the Mafia off of me so I could stay alive and help Town win.

 

You also haven't explained how you think Commuter is opposite Darthe's false Coroner claim in any way. But keep saying it like it'll magically resolve in people's heads.

 

There was no reason to claim my schedule before Tress died. Why would I give thrnmafia more info so they could select who to kill easier????

 

 

 

[DPR]

 

Home now on my computer and I keep trying to reply to all of this mess and hit each point. Stop flooding the thread. Thanks. 

 

Iron, what do you think about Seph's blatant lies about believing Darthe? 

 

Also, looking for my notes on Darthe and Cuth, but they're not in my Word doc. Checking my spreadsheet where I made day-by-dat notes during that catchup 

Blatant lies? Um... I don't really know. I'm getting more confused by the minute. And with all of us snapping at each other like eels it's tough to sort out what's true

 

 

 

Eels? 

[dicetosser1]

so im back at work drugged up a bit and getting a headache and these last few pages have my head spinning.

 

 

 

@ed  you said that it maybe balanced the baby sitter.. How?

[Ironeyes]

 

 

Home now on my computer and I keep trying to reply to all of this mess and hit each point. Stop flooding the thread. Thanks. 

 

Iron, what do you think about Seph's blatant lies about believing Darthe? 

 

Also, looking for my notes on Darthe and Cuth, but they're not in my Word doc. Checking my spreadsheet where I made day-by-dat notes during that catchup 

Blatant lies? Um... I don't really know. I'm getting more confused by the minute. And with all of us snapping at each other like eels it's tough to sort out what's true

 

 

 

Eels? 

 

"like eels in a bucket" is the metaphor. I picked it up from the Way of Kings, which I'm reading in between refreshing the page. 

[ed2funy]

Below quotes to show Seph and DPR tried setting a train on me D3. Interesting tidbit. 

 

[V] ed [/v]

 

 

LOL at ed. After the game I'll tell you where your first slip was. For now, I'm not going to fight the tide.

 

Vote Darthe

Vote ed

 

 

Below to show Dice also believed Dice at first. 

 

 

 

 

so FTR  are you ccing darthe?

Oh heck no.

 

I don't believe there is a coroner role in the game, fwiw.  From what I know about game balance, it makes no sense from a setup perspective.

 

Darthe made a convenient claim to get out of a lynch, and hasn't bothered to come back and answer legitimate questions. And as a claimed power role, he lived through the night, which kinda adds to my not believing him.

 

I mean, do you honestly believe him?

 

 

its more i dont NOT believe him you know? Sooh has no flip  we are all assuming she was janitored so a coroner, being the opposite of a janitor makes sense to me. I dont know why you say it doesnt make sense balance wise    and i think dpr said something like that too??  but then im not a mod person so im probably missing something.

 

as for why he isnt dead   im wondering if he worth killing to the mafia. I mean how much damage can a coroner do? role wise i mean. It can stuff them up if they dont know about it for sure  but now? just means they cant use the info they janitored. 

 

Plus its Darthe. As you are an example of  even with a claim people dont trust him. So he sows discord.

 

and theres always the chance that he goes full derf.

 

 

Below quotes to show relevant quotes and my reactions to them. I didn't quite trust Tress, but not enough to vote her. Didn't make it on in time to switch a vote to Darthe. 

 

 

Still waiting to hear from Darthe.

There is no reason for him to not give details of his claimed role other than he wants to not be pinned down by tonight's results.

It's weird to be saying this when the person hasnt shown up. Youre complaining about me not giving you the info you want when I wasnt here to gove it, and a natural reaction is to complain about me not being here.

Tldr this isnt an actual concern, it's a push.

 

 

 

 

I've still a bad taste in my mouth for you, Tress. As much as you're going back and forth, a coroner claim makes sense in this game with a janitor role. If he latter is limited, perhaps his is too. Either way, why are you pushing him so hard?

Now, Darthe's reactions are just making me think y'all are running a gambit, but I haven't played with him in so long. Ugh.

Or maybe you're just trying to get in the ring with him because DPR is scum and you're protecting him.



What does POE mean?

 

Process of Elimination.

 

I'm pushing Darthe so hard because I'm trying to figure out who his teammates are.

 

If I was scum trying to keep DPR out of the ring, why would I have let D1 happen the way it did without voting?  DPR, Cuth and I were all tied at 4 votes at EOD, the only reason I wasn't in the ring D1 was because random.org picked DPR and Cuth.   We know Cuth was town.  Darthe had 3 votes.  If I was mafia with DPR, in what world would I not have voted Cuth to put him in the lead, and Darthe to give random.org a better chance of keeping me and my teammate out of it? 

 

D1 I was not feeling well and at a total loss.   Today, I have a much clearer head, and I'm volunteering to duke it out with Darthe myself which is completely not self-preservatory if that's a word.

 

I'm not entirely sure DPR is town, but Darthe's push on him gives me a pretty good idea he is.  I don't so much care if DPR gets into the ring with Darthe, though, if you want to keep him there.

 

Thing is, Darthe goes down.  If you vote DPR during the fight, you might as well just claim scum now.

 

 

 

At the risk of being modkilled for not posting about 2000's emo music, about which i know nothing   , it's time to tell you what I do know.

 

I'm not claiming cop.  And I'm certainly not counterclaiming Darthe.

 

Hardclaim: Town Watcher

 

Night 1 I watched my strongest town read - BFG.  Mafia chose to kill Sooh, but I did see one person target BFG that night.  My assumption at the time was that person was town and probably targeted her for the same reason I did, because she was clearly town. 

 

Night 2 I really thought hard about whether to believe Darthe.  I almost watched him.  Finally decided I was going to go with my gut and watch BFG again. Guess who I saw target her the night she died?

 

Darthe.

 

So now Darthe can come in with his "oh clearly she's lying" speech... or maybe he'll be smart and not cast doubt on me because anyone who has played with me before knows this is not my scum game.  And he'll probably raise the WIFOM of a bus driver because he desperately needs you not to lynch him today.  

 

If I were you, I wouldn't let him walk again.

 

 

 

Final Vote Count!

• Darthe - 6  - Songstress, Seph, DreadPirateRoberts, Nolder, Ironeyes, Dicetosser1
• DreadPirateRoberts - 4 - ed2funy, Nolder, Ironeyes, Darthe
• Seph - 1 - ed2funy
• ed2funy - 2 - Seph, DreadPirateRoberts
• Songstress - 2 - Darthe, Dicetosser1

[dicetosser1]

im seriously thinking of voting ed and dpr just so i hear more to try and make a decision

[DPR]

 

 

 

Home now on my computer and I keep trying to reply to all of this mess and hit each point. Stop flooding the thread. Thanks. 

 

Iron, what do you think about Seph's blatant lies about believing Darthe? 

 

Also, looking for my notes on Darthe and Cuth, but they're not in my Word doc. Checking my spreadsheet where I made day-by-dat notes during that catchup 

Blatant lies? Um... I don't really know. I'm getting more confused by the minute. And with all of us snapping at each other like eels it's tough to sort out what's true

 

 

 

Eels? 

 

"like eels in a bucket" is the metaphor. I picked it up from the Way of Kings, which I'm reading in between refreshing the page. 

 

 

 

I see. It wasn't something that I'd ever heard in Boston, so I figured I'd ask.

[ed2funy]

 

Ed was only one to not only believe Darthe claim, but actually fought for him, and voted people besides himm for the fights up until he was lynched.

I think darthe has been town and 100% believe his claim, until cced. It makes sense and his posts since his return have not been bad either imo.

 

Nold. Why do you say that? I'm not the best at looking towards that kind of thing, and I actually thought coroner seemed like a likely role to have?

Right...

 

 

 

 

Home now on my computer and I keep trying to reply to all of this mess and hit each point. Stop flooding the thread. Thanks. 

 

Iron, what do you think about Seph's blatant lies about believing Darthe? 

 

Also, looking for my notes on Darthe and Cuth, but they're not in my Word doc. Checking my spreadsheet where I made day-by-dat notes during that catchup 

Blatant lies? Um... I don't really know. I'm getting more confused by the minute. And with all of us snapping at each other like eels it's tough to sort out what's true

 

 

Seph was one of the first ones to post he believed Darthe. 

[ed2funy]

 

Dice? You scum thanking me for being so bad y'all win? lol

 

Iron, I just said in a recent post that I lied about the schedule and that I chose Odd nights over Even to be able to commute. Which means if we can get an actual scum lynched today, I'm the NK tonight because it'll be easier to sow WIFOM with the remaining two town who everyone more or less admits they can't read well this game. 

 

throws bananas at ed. it was for answering. im not gonna be polite to uu anymore if thats what i get.

 

 

Dice. I shan't ever stop joking or laughing, even in the face of death and town being at risk of losing this game. I am what I am. 

[dicetosser1]

 

 

Dice? You scum thanking me for being so bad y'all win? lol

 

Iron, I just said in a recent post that I lied about the schedule and that I chose Odd nights over Even to be able to commute. Which means if we can get an actual scum lynched today, I'm the NK tonight because it'll be easier to sow WIFOM with the remaining two town who everyone more or less admits they can't read well this game. 

 

throws bananas at ed. it was for answering. im not gonna be polite to uu anymore if thats what i get.

 

 

Dice. I shan't ever stop joking or laughing, even in the face of death and town being at risk of losing this game. I am what I am. 

 

 

thumbs up

[Ironeyes]

 

 

 

 

Home now on my computer and I keep trying to reply to all of this mess and hit each point. Stop flooding the thread. Thanks. 

 

Iron, what do you think about Seph's blatant lies about believing Darthe? 

 

Also, looking for my notes on Darthe and Cuth, but they're not in my Word doc. Checking my spreadsheet where I made day-by-dat notes during that catchup 

Blatant lies? Um... I don't really know. I'm getting more confused by the minute. And with all of us snapping at each other like eels it's tough to sort out what's true

 

 

 

Eels? 

 

"like eels in a bucket" is the metaphor. I picked it up from the Way of Kings, which I'm reading in between refreshing the page. 

 

 

 

I see. It wasn't something that I'd ever heard in Boston, so I figured I'd ask.

 

Oh hey, you familiar with Boston? I don't really speak like someone from here, cause I've lived here less than a year, but I do love this city

[ed2funy]

so im back at work drugged up a bit and getting a headache and these last few pages have my head spinning.

 

 

 

@ed  you said that it maybe balanced the baby sitter.. How?

 

Dice, if the Babysitter was protecting someone and got shot, they both died, yes? That means two townies would be dead. If he protected me and got shot, I wouldn't die. And the mafia have less chance to kill me throughout the game than a VT, so it would balance the possibility of baby sitter taking out another townie with him. 

That's the way I see it. Plus, if there's a RBer w/1x Janitor, it would make sense they couldn't block me, but could block "watered down cop and doc"

 

imo, but wait for DPR to yell at me about mechanics and game balance.

[ed2funy]

@Iron - what about my post on Seph's lies? I quoted it again for you. 
Stop skimming; y'all keep missing what I'm saying (thus the bitchy post I made that DPR tried to call gloating).

[dicetosser1]

ok. thanks ed

 

 

waits for DPR to throw things at bananaboy.

[dicetosser1]

tbh ed im not voting seph here cause im not doing this whole random between 3 or 4 people thing

[DPR]

 

 

 

 

 

Home now on my computer and I keep trying to reply to all of this mess and hit each point. Stop flooding the thread. Thanks. 

 

Iron, what do you think about Seph's blatant lies about believing Darthe? 

 

Also, looking for my notes on Darthe and Cuth, but they're not in my Word doc. Checking my spreadsheet where I made day-by-dat notes during that catchup 

Blatant lies? Um... I don't really know. I'm getting more confused by the minute. And with all of us snapping at each other like eels it's tough to sort out what's true

 

 

 

Eels? 

 

"like eels in a bucket" is the metaphor. I picked it up from the Way of Kings, which I'm reading in between refreshing the page. 

 

 

 

I see. It wasn't something that I'd ever heard in Boston, so I figured I'd ask.

 

Oh hey, you familiar with Boston? I don't really speak like someone from here, cause I've lived here less than a year, but I do love this city

 

 

 

Wife is from around those parts. Cool town.

[Ironeyes]

 

 

Ed was only one to not only believe Darthe claim, but actually fought for him, and voted people besides himm for the fights up until he was lynched.

I think darthe has been town and 100% believe his claim, until cced. It makes sense and his posts since his return have not been bad either imo.

 

Nold. Why do you say that? I'm not the best at looking towards that kind of thing, and I actually thought coroner seemed like a likely role to have?

Right...

 

 

 

 

Home now on my computer and I keep trying to reply to all of this mess and hit each point. Stop flooding the thread. Thanks. 

 

Iron, what do you think about Seph's blatant lies about believing Darthe? 

 

Also, looking for my notes on Darthe and Cuth, but they're not in my Word doc. Checking my spreadsheet where I made day-by-dat notes during that catchup 

Blatant lies? Um... I don't really know. I'm getting more confused by the minute. And with all of us snapping at each other like eels it's tough to sort out what's true

 

 

Seph was one of the first ones to post he believed Darthe. 

You're right. I consider it one of the weakest parts of his case though, in part becasue I believed Darthe too. 

[dicetosser1]

vote ed and dpr.

 

they will talk which will help my head get around this. 

[ed2funy]

DPR, only part I started leaving breadcrumbs. After Tress claimed and Darthe was lynched

 

Tress, I think you'll be fine tonight

Nol, Tress is obviously asking if you think Darthe and DPR were running a gambit.

 

 

Here! Was baby sitting yesterday and had a long night of waking up and falling right back asleep trying to check my phone (damn pain pills get ya all messed up, man).

Been busy besides that mostly drinking cause my best friend takes off tonight to leave for Korea for a year. And it's my first day back at work.

^ basically, back and will be more active to debunk this thought of me being scum. I'm town and Mafia knows this. It's why they won't kill Tress.

 

 

I am counting on that

 

 

 

End of Night Three!

Soap!

 

Fight Club only exists between the hours that Fight Club stats and Fight Club ends.  Who you were at Fight Club is not who you are the rest of the time.  Fight Club didn't take place at night, so there was no Fight Club.  

 

I've always thought "Way Away" was the best Yellowcard song, but I have to be honest, "Breathing" is really growing on me.  I'll fight (club) anyone that says Ocean Avenue is better.  #ForYouAndYourDenial #theoneImadeupatworkthatsraciallyinsenstivebuthilariousPMfordetails

 

 

Nobody died.

 

It is now Day Four.  Day Four - Nomination Phase ends at 11:00 PM on Tuesday, 3/28!  If you did not receive a PM and think you should have, notify me immediately.

 

 

 

Btw guys, I'm not claiming healer/Doctor. Saying that now

 

So yeah, I did say it first. Thought someone had asked about it, but I was wrong. 

[Lizabeth]

No More Posting!!
 

[ed2funy]

Well, guess me and the silver tongue are gonna go at it. 

I look forward to proving your scumminess, DPR. 

[DPR]

DPR, only part I started leaving breadcrumbs. After Tress claimed and Darthe was lynched

 

Tress, I think you'll be fine tonight

 

Nol, Tress is obviously asking if you think Darthe and DPR were running a gambit.

 

 

Here! Was baby sitting yesterday and had a long night of waking up and falling right back asleep trying to check my phone (damn pain pills get ya all messed up, man).

 

Been busy besides that mostly drinking cause my best friend takes off tonight to leave for Korea for a year. And it's my first day back at work.

 

^ basically, back and will be more active to debunk this thought of me being scum. I'm town and Mafia knows this. It's why they won't kill Tress.

 

 

I am counting on that

 

 

 

End of Night Three!

Soap!

 

Fight Club only exists between the hours that Fight Club stats and Fight Club ends.  Who you were at Fight Club is not who you are the rest of the time.  Fight Club didn't take place at night, so there was no Fight Club.  

 

I've always thought "Way Away" was the best Yellowcard song, but I have to be honest, "Breathing" is really growing on me.  I'll fight (club) anyone that says Ocean Avenue is better.  #ForYouAndYourDenial #theoneImadeupatworkthatsraciallyinsenstivebuthilariousPMfordetails

 

 

Nobody died.

 

It is now Day Four.  Day Four - Nomination Phase ends at 11:00 PM on Tuesday, 3/28!  If you did not receive a PM and think you should have, notify me immediately.

 

 

 

Btw guys, I'm not claiming healer/Doctor. Saying that now

 

So yeah, I did say it first. Thought someone had asked about it, but I was wrong. 

 

 

I'm in large red above.

 

You do a lot of babysitting?

[Clovdyx]

Final Vote Count!

 

• IronEyes - 2 - DreadPirateRoberts, Seph
  
• ed2funy - 3 - DreadPirateRoberts, Seph, Dicetosser1
  
• DreadPirateRoberts - 3 - IronEyes, ed2funy, Dicetosser1
  
• Seph - 1 - ed2funy
  

Day Six - Nomination Phase is now over!

 

I am Jack's Emo Song.

[Clovdyx]

I'm not going to apologize for any movie spoilers in this.  The movie's almost 20 years old, and if you haven't seen it yet, I'm disappointed in you enough to justify ruining it.  This is your fault.

 

End of Day Six!

Soap!   Goes boom.

 

 

DreadPirateRoberts and ed2funy looked at each other.  Each man raised their fists, ready to fight.  But this wasn't going to be another fight.  Fight Club had been going on for months.  It had grown.  It had evolved.  It was something different now.

 

Did you know that life insurance pays off triple if you die on a business trip?

 

The first punch landed squarely on one of the men's chins.  It might have been ed2funy.  It might have been DreadPirateRoberts.  It might have been your imaginary friend, suddenly strong enough to knock you unconscious for hours and leaving you wondering where you've been.  These things happen.

 

Both DreadPirateRoberts and ed2funy froze.  Somebody had stopped the fight - or, more specifically, something.  A single gunshot echoed over the sound of the cheers encouraging both men to beat each other senseless.  All of their eyes shifted towards their leader sitting alone in the corner of the room.  Blood poured from a hole in his cheek.  Several men dressed in all black ran to him.  He shooed them away.

 

Both DPR and ed walked away, knowing the fight was over - for good.  The remaining members of the group would follow closely behind.  Nobody would ever see any of them again.

 

DreadPirateRoberts is dead!  He was - 

 

Chloe, Vanilla, Town-Aligned!

 

 

Ed2funy is dead!  He was - 

 

Jack's Broken Heart, Odd/Even Night Commuter, Town-Aligned!

 

 

Seph is dead!  He was - 

 

Irvine, Vanilla, Town-Aligned

 

 

I am Jack's Wasted Village.

 

Soap! to the remaining mafia!  

 

Dice has won!  He was - 

A member of Project Mayhem, 1x Janitor, Mafia-Aligned

 

Ironeyes has won!  He was - 

 

 

A member of Project Mayhem, Redirector, Mafia Aligned

 

 

 

 

You may soap! post!