[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

[Zander?]

 

 

I legit can't remember what you're referring to exactly.

 

Zander, stop freaking out, kthx? I already have you as assumed Doc type role. That does NOT mean you're immune to questioning or explaining your reasoning on things. It helps us understand what happened so we can narrow down scum.

 

Also, you might be wanting to see if anyone else claims healer type to pinpoint who is working with DPR and will presumably counter claim you. I personally think you should claim before. We're still gonna have people provide feedback on claims and glean info from it.

 

The other good option for the other scum to try to claim is VT with how much DPR has tried setting up that there's lots of VTs

Im not freaking out and I dont mind being questioned.

 

Im more then willing to step into the ring with DPR today if thats what people want.

 

I do have a plan with what Im doing.

 

Once everyone claims, Ill claim and my explanation should put all doubts about me to bed.

 

Also if you dont remember ISO me and take a check for yourself,

Yet you don't answer. And I can't ISO on mobile, no? I don't even remember how to isolate someone's posts on full version.

 

 

What do you want me to answer?!!?!?

 

I said Id claim last.

 

Did I miss another question? 

[Zander?]

 

But there are lots of VT's.

 

Including me, 4 so far.

Yeah, and then more VTs flip, the less likely there are left in the game. I don't think the town is super power heavy unless the Mafia has crazy power roles too and it seems there was already a limited janitor, apparently a possible roleblocker, and of course a godfather to kill.

 

But we had watcher, Commuter, and healing type Pokémon so far. Could reasonably be another.

 

 

Come again?!?!?!?!

 

You claimed commuter.....?!?!?!?!

[DPR]

 

 

 

 

 

But there are lots of VT's.

 

Including me, 4 so far.

Yeah, and then more VTs flip, the less likely there are left in the game. I don't think the town is super power heavy unless the Mafia has crazy power roles too and it seems there was already a limited janitor, apparently a possible roleblocker, and of course a godfather to kill.

 

But we had watcher, Commuter, and healing type Pokémon so far. Could reasonably be another.

 

Lol nice pokemon reference. But seriously, I'm not sure at all what the balance is on this game. Watcher is weaker than regular cop by a lot, which is somewhat balanced by your role, but still, town has to have something more unless the mafia team also has comparatively weak roles. Which it doesn't look like they do. 

 

What if Sooh had something big and we don't know it? 

 

 

Iron, why do you say the mafia team doesn't look like they have weak roles? 

Bouncing off what Ed said. We assume there's a janitor, and a roleblocker is still a good possibility. Just between those two, that's powerful compared to the town roles we know about. 

 

 

 

Okay, but we're not really assuming there's Janitor - Sooh's kill had no info, so it was Janitored, be it by mod or team. The fact that it's only happened 1 time is a good reason to think it was a 1x, but we'll have to see.

 

That makes 1 known mafia role. Everything else is just spec, right?

 

So, on table, we got proof of a 1x Janitor on the mafia side, and 1 Watcher on the town side. That's all we know for sure.

[Ironeyes]

Dude if you claim last you'll never claim. Hallia is non-existent and Seph isn't here that much either. 

[Ironeyes]

 

 

 

 

 

 

But there are lots of VT's.

 

Including me, 4 so far.

Yeah, and then more VTs flip, the less likely there are left in the game. I don't think the town is super power heavy unless the Mafia has crazy power roles too and it seems there was already a limited janitor, apparently a possible roleblocker, and of course a godfather to kill.

 

But we had watcher, Commuter, and healing type Pokémon so far. Could reasonably be another.

 

Lol nice pokemon reference. But seriously, I'm not sure at all what the balance is on this game. Watcher is weaker than regular cop by a lot, which is somewhat balanced by your role, but still, town has to have something more unless the mafia team also has comparatively weak roles. Which it doesn't look like they do. 

 

What if Sooh had something big and we don't know it? 

 

 

Iron, why do you say the mafia team doesn't look like they have weak roles? 

Bouncing off what Ed said. We assume there's a janitor, and a roleblocker is still a good possibility. Just between those two, that's powerful compared to the town roles we know about. 

 

 

 

Okay, but we're not really assuming there's Janitor - Sooh's kill had no info, so it was Janitored, be it by mod or team. The fact that it's only happened 1 time is a good reason to think it was a 1x, but we'll have to see.

 

That makes 1 known mafia role. Everything else is just spec, right?

 

So, on table, we got proof of a 1x Janitor on the mafia side, and 1 Watcher on the town side. That's all we know for sure.

 

I suppose you're right. But it's all spec anyway, since we're talking about balance and setup.

[DPR]

Matter of fact, depending on what Zander did, maybe he got roleblocked and that's why tress died. 

 

By that logic, anything could have happened. 

[Zander?]

Cuth-VT

BFG- VT

Nolder- VT

Tress- Watcher

Darthe- Mafia Goon

 

 

Sooh- ??? (Assuming Town)

 

Iron claims VT

DPR claims VT

 

Zander- Roled

 

Am I missing any other claims right now?!?!?!?!

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

 

 

But there are lots of VT's.

 

Including me, 4 so far.

Yeah, and then more VTs flip, the less likely there are left in the game. I don't think the town is super power heavy unless the Mafia has crazy power roles too and it seems there was already a limited janitor, apparently a possible roleblocker, and of course a godfather to kill.

 

But we had watcher, Commuter, and healing type Pokémon so far. Could reasonably be another.

 

Lol nice pokemon reference. But seriously, I'm not sure at all what the balance is on this game. Watcher is weaker than regular cop by a lot, which is somewhat balanced by your role, but still, town has to have something more unless the mafia team also has comparatively weak roles. Which it doesn't look like they do. 

 

What if Sooh had something big and we don't know it? 

 

 

Iron, why do you say the mafia team doesn't look like they have weak roles? 

Bouncing off what Ed said. We assume there's a janitor, and a roleblocker is still a good possibility. Just between those two, that's powerful compared to the town roles we know about. 

 

 

 

Okay, but we're not really assuming there's Janitor - Sooh's kill had no info, so it was Janitored, be it by mod or team. The fact that it's only happened 1 time is a good reason to think it was a 1x, but we'll have to see.

 

That makes 1 known mafia role. Everything else is just spec, right?

 

So, on table, we got proof of a 1x Janitor on the mafia side, and 1 Watcher on the town side. That's all we know for sure.

 

 

Again with DPR pretending to be dumb.

 

He's knows Mods dont just not give a flip for no reason man.

 

Dudes been trying to purposely sow bits of WIFOM ALL GAME!!!!

[DPR]

Dude if you claim last you'll never claim. Hallia is non-existent and Seph isn't here that much either. 

 

I'm pretty sure that's the idea.

 

There is no good, realistic reason why he'd hold back info.

[Zander?]

Dude if you claim last you'll never claim. Hallia is non-existent and Seph isn't here that much either. 

 

 

I get that man but they will have to post before DL Id imagine man.

[Ironeyes]

 

Matter of fact, depending on what Zander did, maybe he got roleblocked and that's why tress died. 

 

By that logic, anything could have happened. 

Well yeah. 

[Zander?]

 

Dude if you claim last you'll never claim. Hallia is non-existent and Seph isn't here that much either. 

 

I'm pretty sure that's the idea.

 

There is no good, realistic reason why he'd hold back info.

 

 

Yes there is.

 

And you will know it when I do. 

 

Its not gotta matter tho youre Scum and not getting past today anyways, 

[DPR]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

But there are lots of VT's.

 

Including me, 4 so far.

Yeah, and then more VTs flip, the less likely there are left in the game. I don't think the town is super power heavy unless the Mafia has crazy power roles too and it seems there was already a limited janitor, apparently a possible roleblocker, and of course a godfather to kill.

 

But we had watcher, Commuter, and healing type Pokémon so far. Could reasonably be another.

 

Lol nice pokemon reference. But seriously, I'm not sure at all what the balance is on this game. Watcher is weaker than regular cop by a lot, which is somewhat balanced by your role, but still, town has to have something more unless the mafia team also has comparatively weak roles. Which it doesn't look like they do. 

 

What if Sooh had something big and we don't know it? 

 

 

Iron, why do you say the mafia team doesn't look like they have weak roles? 

Bouncing off what Ed said. We assume there's a janitor, and a roleblocker is still a good possibility. Just between those two, that's powerful compared to the town roles we know about. 

 

 

 

Okay, but we're not really assuming there's Janitor - Sooh's kill had no info, so it was Janitored, be it by mod or team. The fact that it's only happened 1 time is a good reason to think it was a 1x, but we'll have to see.

 

That makes 1 known mafia role. Everything else is just spec, right?

 

So, on table, we got proof of a 1x Janitor on the mafia side, and 1 Watcher on the town side. That's all we know for sure.

 

 

Again with DPR pretending to be dumb.

 

He's knows Mods dont just not give a flip for no reason man.

 

Dudes been trying to purposely sow bits of WIFOM ALL GAME!!!!

 

 

People used to start every game with a death, many times with no alignment info. Some games used to be "no coroner" games.

 

To your earlier question, yeah, as mod I absolutely differentiate findings with "your target had no visitors last night" and "your view has no results". No question about it. 

 

When do you think you'll stop stalling? I'm trying to plan breaks...

[DPR]

 

 

Matter of fact, depending on what Zander did, maybe he got roleblocked and that's why tress died. 

 

By that logic, anything could have happened. 

Well yeah. 

 

 

We have hard info - things we know for sure. We're getting on into the game. Why wouldn't we build expectations based on what has happened and not on what might be? 

 

Anyway, we seem to agree that Zander needs to spill.

[DPR]

 

 

Dude if you claim last you'll never claim. Hallia is non-existent and Seph isn't here that much either. 

 

I'm pretty sure that's the idea.

 

There is no good, realistic reason why he'd hold back info.

 

 

Yes there is.

 

And you will know it when I do. 

 

Its not gotta matter tho youre Scum and not getting past today anyways, 

 

 

This is Darthe level BS.

 

You really think you can figure things out better rather than the entire town looking at it?  You think Hally is going to show up and for the first time, give us something useful? 

 

Sounds legit.

 

And if I'm scum, where's your case? You got all of this magical info, but I know you don't have anything on me, now don't I? 

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

But there are lots of VT's.

 

Including me, 4 so far.

Yeah, and then more VTs flip, the less likely there are left in the game. I don't think the town is super power heavy unless the Mafia has crazy power roles too and it seems there was already a limited janitor, apparently a possible roleblocker, and of course a godfather to kill.

 

But we had watcher, Commuter, and healing type Pokémon so far. Could reasonably be another.

 

Lol nice pokemon reference. But seriously, I'm not sure at all what the balance is on this game. Watcher is weaker than regular cop by a lot, which is somewhat balanced by your role, but still, town has to have something more unless the mafia team also has comparatively weak roles. Which it doesn't look like they do. 

 

What if Sooh had something big and we don't know it? 

 

 

Iron, why do you say the mafia team doesn't look like they have weak roles? 

Bouncing off what Ed said. We assume there's a janitor, and a roleblocker is still a good possibility. Just between those two, that's powerful compared to the town roles we know about. 

 

 

 

Okay, but we're not really assuming there's Janitor - Sooh's kill had no info, so it was Janitored, be it by mod or team. The fact that it's only happened 1 time is a good reason to think it was a 1x, but we'll have to see.

 

That makes 1 known mafia role. Everything else is just spec, right?

 

So, on table, we got proof of a 1x Janitor on the mafia side, and 1 Watcher on the town side. That's all we know for sure.

 

 

Again with DPR pretending to be dumb.

 

He's knows Mods dont just not give a flip for no reason man.

 

Dudes been trying to purposely sow bits of WIFOM ALL GAME!!!!

 

 

People used to start every game with a death, many times with no alignment info. Some games used to be "no coroner" games.

 

To your earlier question, yeah, as mod I absolutely differentiate findings with "your target had no visitors last night" and "your view has no results". No question about it. 

 

When do you think you'll stop stalling? I'm trying to plan breaks...

 

 

Im not stalling, I said Im waiting to claim last.

 

The 2nd line is not what i said, i said you know that mods dont just not give flips no no reason. 

 

If it was a no corner game it would have been announced beforehand or there wouldnt have been any flips aafter which there was.

 

This is what I mean my sidestepping.

 

And again you shade me with saying im stalling, but yet no mention of seph or hallia!?!?!

 

Come on man.

 

Youre just spouting a bunch of random possibilities to try and crate WIFOM and fear mongering which is a Scum tactic.

 

Youre way too experienced imo to come up with this kind of stuff as Town,

[ed2funy]

I don't think there's a cop. And godfather=killer in my book. Especially for official watching purposes.

 

To some extent, you have a point. But I'm sure you know some of the reactions/pushing/speculating you've been doing has been scummy.

Heh @ the comments. Personally, I enjoy them because it amuses me, but I'm sure you also realize that plays into perceptions of your town/scumness.

DPR, the bitchy Mafia diva.

 

I mean, I don't really know how to prove a passive role. I had three nights I could commute. N3, with my obvious play was my WIFOM attempt to get the Mafia to target me and not tress. Which is why I really hoped I was the reason why there was no kill. If the Mafia targeted me, their kill would have been wasted. There's so many things that could have happened, but it'd really tickle my jimmies if the Mafia wasted their NK cause of me.

 

You've got my thoughts on Hallia and Zander in recent posts and my vote. The others I need to review a teensy bit before formulating more concrete thoughts or moving them on my list.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

Dude if you claim last you'll never claim. Hallia is non-existent and Seph isn't here that much either. 

 

I'm pretty sure that's the idea.

 

There is no good, realistic reason why he'd hold back info.

 

 

Yes there is.

 

And you will know it when I do. 

 

Its not gotta matter tho youre Scum and not getting past today anyways, 

 

 

This is Darthe level BS.

 

You really think you can figure things out better rather than the entire town looking at it?  You think Hally is going to show up and for the first time, give us something useful? 

 

Sounds legit.

 

And if I'm scum, where's your case? You got all of this magical info, but I know you don't have anything on me, now don't I? 

 

 

And again back to the trying to use stuff to fit your own narrative and throwing shade.

 

I didnt say that or anything resembling that.  I said I was going to be the last to claim,

 

Hallia at least posted once every phase so yes I do expect her to pop in.

 

She's also the other person I want in the ring with you if its not gonna be me to make sure you get the noose today.

[ed2funy]

Last reply was to this

 

 

 

But there are lots of VT's.

 

Including me, 4 so far.

Yeah, and then more VTs flip, the less likely there are left in the game. I don't think the town is super power heavy unless the Mafia has crazy power roles too and it seems there was already a limited janitor, apparently a possible roleblocker, and of course a godfather to kill.

 

But we had watcher, Commuter, and healing type Pokémon so far. Could reasonably be another.

 

Possible role blocker. Godfather? You think we got a Watcher and a Cop?

 

Look, I'll chill with the comments, but at some point we gotta start making sense.

 

I can't help that I've had one person after another linking me to tinfoil nonsense since D1 - no one has even made an actual case against me. I have no idea why Nolder was such a flake, and I don't know why Tress wanted to spend all day yesterday putting together a 3-way-tinfoil scenario.

 

What we do have are 5 flips with 1 role, and a weak role at that.

 

You're claiming Commuter, but we have no proof. I believe you, but that's not proof...

 

We got Zander who we know has a role, but he won't tell us what it is because he "has a plan".

 

We got Hally who said she was going to post lots, and never did.

 

We got Seph who cooled his jets and has been scarce for days now.

 

What do you make of it?

[Zander?]

I don't think there's a cop. And godfather=killer in my book. Especially for official watching purposes.

 

To some extent, you have a point. But I'm sure you know some of the reactions/pushing/speculating you've been doing has been scummy.

Heh @ the comments. Personally, I enjoy them because it amuses me, but I'm sure you also realize that plays into perceptions of your town/scumness.

DPR, the bitchy Mafia diva.

 

I mean, I don't really know how to prove a passive role. I had three nights I could commute. N3, with my obvious play was my WIFOM attempt to get the Mafia to target me and not tress. Which is why I really hoped I was the reason why there was no kill. If the Mafia targeted me, their kill would have been wasted. There's so many things that could have happened, but it'd really tickle my jimmies if the Mafia wasted their NK cause of me.

 

You've got my thoughts on Hallia and Zander in recent posts and my vote. The others I need to review a teensy bit before formulating more concrete thoughts or moving them on my list.

 

Ed claiming Commuter, is an interesting development.

[Zander?]

Cuth-VT

BFG- VT

Nolder- VT

Tress- Watcher

Darthe- Mafia Goon

 

 

Sooh- ??? (Assuming Town)\

 

Ed claims Commuter

Iron claims VT

DPR claims VT

 

Zander- Roled

 

Am I missing any other claims right now?!?!?!?!

 

Updated.

[DPR]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

But there are lots of VT's.

 

Including me, 4 so far.

Yeah, and then more VTs flip, the less likely there are left in the game. I don't think the town is super power heavy unless the Mafia has crazy power roles too and it seems there was already a limited janitor, apparently a possible roleblocker, and of course a godfather to kill.

 

But we had watcher, Commuter, and healing type Pokémon so far. Could reasonably be another.

 

Lol nice pokemon reference. But seriously, I'm not sure at all what the balance is on this game. Watcher is weaker than regular cop by a lot, which is somewhat balanced by your role, but still, town has to have something more unless the mafia team also has comparatively weak roles. Which it doesn't look like they do. 

 

What if Sooh had something big and we don't know it? 

 

 

Iron, why do you say the mafia team doesn't look like they have weak roles? 

Bouncing off what Ed said. We assume there's a janitor, and a roleblocker is still a good possibility. Just between those two, that's powerful compared to the town roles we know about. 

 

 

 

Okay, but we're not really assuming there's Janitor - Sooh's kill had no info, so it was Janitored, be it by mod or team. The fact that it's only happened 1 time is a good reason to think it was a 1x, but we'll have to see.

 

That makes 1 known mafia role. Everything else is just spec, right?

 

So, on table, we got proof of a 1x Janitor on the mafia side, and 1 Watcher on the town side. That's all we know for sure.

 

 

Again with DPR pretending to be dumb.

 

He's knows Mods dont just not give a flip for no reason man.

 

Dudes been trying to purposely sow bits of WIFOM ALL GAME!!!!

 

 

People used to start every game with a death, many times with no alignment info. Some games used to be "no coroner" games.

 

To your earlier question, yeah, as mod I absolutely differentiate findings with "your target had no visitors last night" and "your view has no results". No question about it. 

 

When do you think you'll stop stalling? I'm trying to plan breaks...

 

 

Im not stalling, I said Im waiting to claim last.

 

Stalling. Nobody so far agrees that you should wait. it's a BS move. 

 

The 2nd line is not what i said, i said you know that mods dont just not give flips no no reason. 

 

I don't understand what you are saying here? This could be a 1x Janitor role, or it could be a mod mechanic - either is possible.

 

If it was a no corner game it would have been announced beforehand or there wouldnt have been any flips aafter which there was.

 

I never said that. i said that there are lots of possibilities and used an example of a more extreme circumstance.

 

This is what I mean my sidestepping.

 

I honestly have no idea what you mean by sidestepping. 

 

And again you shade me with saying im stalling, but yet no mention of seph or hallia!?!?!

 

Since you subbed in, you've shaded me the entire time. You spent all day yesterday pumping Tress' tinfoil theory. Then you get caught with a role and won't say what it is? Shade coming your way brotha.

 

I just asked ed specifically about Seph and Hally. You really ought to read up. 

 

Come on man.

 

I'm on.

 

Youre just spouting a bunch of random possibilities to try and crate WIFOM and fear mongering which is a Scum tactic.

 

I spouted a recruit theory. I've had more tinfoil thrown over me than leftovers after Thanksgiving. A lot of it by you.

 

Youre way too experienced imo to come up with this kind of stuff as Town,

 

It's all I got. VT's don't get any info. 

 

 

 

Blue.

[DPR]

 

 

 

 

Dude if you claim last you'll never claim. Hallia is non-existent and Seph isn't here that much either. 

 

I'm pretty sure that's the idea.

 

There is no good, realistic reason why he'd hold back info.

 

 

Yes there is.

 

And you will know it when I do. 

 

Its not gotta matter tho youre Scum and not getting past today anyways, 

 

 

This is Darthe level BS.

 

You really think you can figure things out better rather than the entire town looking at it?  You think Hally is going to show up and for the first time, give us something useful? 

 

Sounds legit.

 

And if I'm scum, where's your case? You got all of this magical info, but I know you don't have anything on me, now don't I? 

 

 

And again back to the trying to use stuff to fit your own narrative and throwing shade.

 

OMG - IT'S A LEGIT QUESTION! You're wasting time! Not everybody is on as much as others! Town could be reviewing your info, but no... you'll leave us with 10 minutes to figure out whatever you lay out. No bueno.

 

I didnt say that or anything resembling that.  I said I was going to be the last to claim,

 

Hallia at least posted once every phase so yes I do expect her to pop in.

 

Well, based on her posts so far, I'm not sure what you feel like you need to wait for.

 

She's also the other person I want in the ring with you if its not gonna be me to make sure you get the noose today.

 

 

Blue.

[Zander?]

Youre either an awful Towny or Scum DPR

 

I refuse to believe its the former, Ive played some with you and your rep is something that everyone talked about before I actually got to met/play with you,.

 

This game you been whining playing the Poor Me, everyones sussing me for no reason bs.

 

AND AGAIN YOURE NOT ANSWERING/RESPONDING TO WHAT I SAY DIRECTLY

 

ex: The last response in blue, "im vt thats all the info i got".  you know thats not what im referring to.  youre just playing dumb,

 

Mods dont not give flips for no reason- yet you say its a possibility, youve mention this recruitment theory out of the blue.

 

You went balls out against nolder and were certain he was Scum....he wasnt, yet thts fine but me and tress sussing you is shading...but ofc Tress was also TOWN and I know obv that I am too.

[Lizabeth]

Vote count!

 

• DeadPirateRoberts -3 - Ironeyes, Zander, ed2funy,
  
• Hallia - 3- Ironeyes, Zander, ed2funy,
  
• Zander -1 - Zander
  

 

Day Five nomination phase ends at 11pm Eastern Friday, March 31