[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

[Zander?]

Apparently my vote was missed. Nothing tricksy in play.

 

And apologies to Nol, I still have difficulty understanding why he voted DPR over Darthe on D3 but apparently it was a mysterious town mindset as opposed to Scum!Nol. *sigh*

 

Well if your vote was missed then Nol and DPR should have went to rand/org so whats being done about it?!?!!?

[Clovdyx]

Official mod post!

 

As always, I remain your game moderator.  Any questions best answered by a game moderator should be directed towards a game moderator in a private communication.  As a reminder, it is considered inappropriate (read: don't effing do it) to discuss private moderator communication in the game thread.

[ed2funy]

Clov has already made some vote mistakes this game? I think with dice or bfg D1?

Until we get clarification on confirmed, I'm taking it as he forgot.

 

I only asked about Tress cause Hallia wasn't really active and Seph wasn't around at End of Noms, so I'm not surprised they didn't vote.

 

Unless Mafia did have a recruit and decided to off one of their own and janitor them for a big giant gambit...yes, I think she was Town.

[ed2funy]

I shouldn't click the thread and wait five minutes to reply, but I get busy.

Imma back away from the sore subject of vote missing. Baaaiiiii

[Songstress]

Agreed with Ed on Sooh. She was being widely townread, I wavered between watching her and watching BFG N1 and chose BFG.

 

Most logical assumption is she was town and janitored.

[ed2funy]

Also anyone still think DPR is Town?!?!?!?!?!

Honestly, not really at this point. He's been up three times now... so Darthe/DPR is looking like it a legit thing

[Zander?]

Clov has already made some vote mistakes this game? I think with dice or bfg D1?

Until we get clarification on confirmed, I'm taking it as he forgot.

 

I only asked about Tress cause Hallia wasn't really active and Seph wasn't around at End of Noms, so I'm not surprised they didn't vote.

 

Unless Mafia did have a recruit and decided to off one of their own and janitor them for a big giant gambit...yes, I think she was Town.

 

This is pretty flimsy reasoning Ed because they had 18 hours to vote and theyd both been around some during the latter part of the day yesterday iirc.

 

And ya wont mention the vote thingy till its clarified.

 

And ya I think she was too I just want to hear if anyone thinks she was wasnt Town and why.

[Zander?]

Agreed with Ed on Sooh. She was being widely townread, I wavered between watching her and watching BFG N1 and chose BFG.

 

Most logical assumption is she was town and janitored.

 

Ya again more then likely.

 

 

 

 

Also anyone still think DPR is Town?!?!?!?!?!

Honestly, not really at this point. He's been up three times now... so Darthe/DPR is looking like it a legit thing

 

 

Tress, well everyone please answer this for me!!!!!

[Zander?]

Well im still kinda unsure with the uncertainty of whats going on right now.

 

But assuming it ws just an error, Im somewhere like this atp:

 

Tress

Iron

 

Ed/Dice

 

seph/hallia

 

DPR

[Zander?]

Would like to see a reads list from everyone else now too please!!!!

[ed2funy]

@Zander, at this point, can you honestly, with full conviction, think Hallia would be active enough to check that often? Cause I don't.

 

Seph, Seph should have, though

[Zander?]

@Zander, at this point, can you honestly, with full conviction, think Hallia would be active enough to check that often? Cause I don't.

 

Seph, Seph should have, though

 

irt Hallia,

 

I know Hallia quite well both in game and away from game.

 

I know she can get busy in rl but she just said the other day her roomie was away and shed have more free time and yes i do believe that Hallia would have had a chance over 18 hours to vote.

 

Obv aware things can pop up but ya I do think she should have had a chance to.

[ed2funy]

I remember that post (though I didn't know who she meant). So, of you think she had time to vote, you think she deliberately didn't? This is why I voted her yesterday. Inactive players this late trend more toward being scum than anything.

 

Full reads list soon. Just got off work (10 hours because I need to bank hours for JordanCon!) and taking nice long relaxing sticky poop

[Zander?]

I remember that post (though I didn't know who she meant). So, of you think she had time to vote, you think she deliberately didn't? This is why I voted her yesterday. Inactive players this late trend more toward being scum than anything.

 

Full reads list soon. Just got off work (10 hours because I need to bank hours for JordanCon!) and taking nice long relaxing sticky poop

 

Im not saying for sure she DELIBERATELY didnt vote but its a possibility and one that needs to be considered.

 

And regardless with Tress voting DPR but it not counting he slipped the noose again....no matter WHAT (unless by some freak chance DPR dies tonight and flips Town) DPR HAS TO BE 1 OF THE 2 tomorrow!!!!

[Zander?]

Oh ya....about inactive being Scum.

 

In some cases for sure.

 

But thats kinda where Meta kicks in,  players like Hallia, Dice, Nolder Pral, are all noteable low posters regardless of alignment,

 

And also irt Hallia, again someone i know and read well, lately shes been even a tad more inactive as both alignments so this is Null at best but the longer the game goes, the longer shes alive and the less she posts especially after Town reading me is cause for concern imo.

[Ironeyes]

 

Why Tress no vote?!

 

Zander, you think you should be auto cleared with Iron?

 

If DPR is Scum Iron and I should both be cleared on the vote alone imo.

 

Why are you only mentioning Tress, Hallia and seph didnt either?!?!?!?

 

Whoa, there, slow down. While I don't mind being cleared myself (and I'm already totally sure you're town), one vote shouldn't be the sole reason for taking someone out of the POE. Just a note of caution. As I said, I already know you're town, and obviously I know I am as well. 

 

Would like to see a reads list from everyone else now too please!!!!

Here you go:

Ironeyes

Tress

Zander

Ed

Dice

Seph

Hallia

DPR

[ed2funy]

IronEyes has a point. Not even trying to say that to save my own skin. Although, I'd like to save my own skin so the town can win, actually yes

[Zander?]

@ Iron and Ed

 

I was asked a question and I answered it.

 

If DPR is Scum Iron should be lock cleared, why because:

 

 

 

Final Vote Count!

• DreadPirateRoberts - 4 - Nolder, Ironeyes, Zander, Songstress
• Nolder - 7 - Dicetosser1, Nolder, Ironeyes, ed2funy, Zander, Songstress, Dreadpirateroberts
• Hallia - 4 - Seph, ed2funy, Dicetosser1, Dreadpirateroberts

 

 

Day Four - Nomination Phase is now over!

 

 

He votes Nolder as well.

 

Scum have no idea really how its gonna play out because votes are private, if he didnt vote Nolder as well I wouldnt have felt as strong about it.

 

Because he voted Nolder into the fight he could have totally voted Nolder if he and DPR are Scummates without any suss because he was his other choice.

 

No again theres bussing and a bunch of other things but like this is as close imo as you can get to being confirmed without actually being in the DPR is Scum scenario.

 

And again this is only if DPR is Scum if he's Town then obv not cleared.

[Ironeyes]

OK that makes sense. 

[Zander?]

Iron I know its not by much but I still dont feel like i have a full handle on this game but why is Ed higher then Dice for you?

[Ironeyes]

Iron I know its not by much but I still dont feel like i have a full handle on this game but why is Ed higher then Dice for you?

Cause I'm about 85% sure he's a town PR. The other 15% is me being unsure if I misinterpreted what I thought was hint dropping. 

[ed2funy]

I've flat stated I'm one in my own read list and then dropped hints. Just haven't been explicit. Lol

 

Point made. By that logic, or a similar one, I voted Noldy and Hallia and still felt Noldy was the worse of the two. #devilsadvocate

[seph]

@Zander, at this point, can you honestly, with full conviction, think Hallia would be active enough to check that often? Cause I don't.

Seph, Seph should have, though

I'm really sorry guys I thought I had time to vote once I woke up... I forgot it was 18 not 24hrs, but if it matters I think I would have chosen nold tbh.

 

This is where I am at, at the momemt..

.completely lost lol

 

I really did think there was a good chance of there being a mafia in dpr and nold tbh, and it's a bit early to tinfoil at the moment towards tress.

 

Tress

Zander

Ed

Dice

 

Iron

Hallie

Dpr. If he is town it either iron and hallia. Or tress and one of those

[Zander?]

 

@Zander, at this point, can you honestly, with full conviction, think Hallia would be active enough to check that often? Cause I don't.

Seph, Seph should have, though

I'm really sorry guys I thought I had time to vote once I woke up... I forgot it was 18 not 24hrs, but if it matters I think I would have chosen nold tbh.

 

This is where I am at, at the momemt..

.completely lost lol

 

I really did think there was a good chance of there being a mafia in dpr and nold tbh, and it's a bit early to tinfoil at the moment towards tress.

 

Tress

Zander

Ed

Dice

 

Iron

Hallie

Dpr. If he is town it either iron and hallia. Or tress and one of those

 

 

Why Iron iyo seph?

 

Especially since you have DPR as your top suspect.  You think Scum!Iron votes Scum!DPR over Town!Nolder??!?!?!

 

And again if youre Town I;m sorry but missing the vote is pretty meh man reasoning. 

[Zander?]

Been interested in the fact DPR and Dice have been in checking this thread numerous times since the flip but not commenting....

 

Just food for thought....