[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

[BFG]

 

 

hoqueso

 

darthe jumps into game without much preliminary stuff

 

one game-related post, one chatting about drinking, and then all game related stuff

 

seriousish

 

this tends more towards scum ime, as they, myself included, have a hard time feeling very natural and sliding in thread and being all jokey like town often does

 

lines up with any perceived difference in darthe's playstyle this game as opposed to the last two without being based thereon

 

then he votes DPR and says 3p? his first accusation is 3p and not scum

 

makes 0 scumreads, one 3p

 

idk

 

village tends to think scum>3p rather than the other way around

 

thereafter a soft defense of wifi

 

after a legitimate point by ed that she was backpedaling, he says he disagrees, but not really

 

just a soft, open read that leaves itself open to be interpreted any way in the future

 

does the good old "that's a big leap for page 7 bfg is hard to read" thing, and immediately follows it up with "i want more cold hard reads", however serious that is or not

 

so several soft defenses and attacks, not hard, very cautious

 

except for one vote apparently on suspicion of 3p

 

these things add up in my mind, sooh

 

they really do

Your tone here doesn't really match your insistence on getting him lynched? If you're so confident why are you sort of down playing your read with a idk?

 

Additionally you seem more interested in getting him lynched than resolving/addressing your read on him which seems at odds with your behaviour towards LizClov in Western and closer to you trying to vote Sooh Day 1 in Lego, I appreciate 2 games is a poor sample size and also that Darthe hasn't been around for you to interact but this still reads oddly

 

i used idk earlier as well

 

this is the best explanation that i can give; like i pointed out earlier my feeling is much stronger than the evidence for it

 

I sort of understand, but as dumb as I know it is the entire idk thing is reminding me of the 'meh' thing you had going last game. It's a sort of distancing thing from your read 'meh here's my read take it or leave it' which is fine except it's contradicting your confidence in how much you're pushing for it

[BFG]

I'm never analyzing votes again bfg...

???

[Songstress]

Just tried to reread and I'm kinda too unfocused to formulate reads.  I hate being useless.

 

Feeling vaguely ok about BFG, maybe Dice, possibly Sooh.  DPR is DPRing it up and can't be pinned down this early because he won't be meta'd.  Not sure how I feel about Cuth and his Darthe fixation - it's the thing that stuck out to me the most while reading but I can't decide if it makes sense or not.  And I never know what to think about Darthe.  WiFi had me a little concerned with the apparent overreaction to DPR's vote but I've read enough games of hers to know that's not going to be useful in figuring out if she's mafia.

 

 

I know we have less than an hour and a half to narrow it down to the 2 fighters for the day but to be brutally honest I'm pretty sure I'm going to be utterly unhelpful with that decision.

[seph]

 

Talk to me about dpr cuth. Why do you have him as town?

 

mmmmostly because who's voting him and who he's voting :P

This makes 0 sense from a town perspective on day 1 where we are making our own info and nothing concrete.

Please expand a bit on this for me to understand.

Dr voted Darth because he hasn't came back into the thread and has made 0 posts or progression there. How besides he is voting your suspect is that townie?

 

Your then adding him to town for being voted by your suspect who you have 0 knowledge about.

 

Cuth this doesn't make sense???

[unvote crusher]

 

[V] cuth [/v]

[Cuth]

 

I sort of understand, but as dumb as I know it is the entire idk thing is reminding me of the 'meh' thing you had going last game. It's a sort of distancing thing from your read 'meh here's my read take it or leave it' which is fine except it's contradicting your confidence in how much you're pushing for it

 

the idk was not about the strength of the read, it was about trying to explain the reasons i was feeling it well

 

that said, i get it, you haven't played with me enough to know, and it is fair that you see a correlation there given the limited sample size

[seph]

[unvote] crusher

[V] cuth [/v]

[BFG]

 

 

[v]Cuth[/v]

 

Mostly the above, the talking about as opposed to too is rubbing me the wrong way

 

Beyond that I don't want to lynch Sooh, Seph, Marsh, WiFi or Dice

Probably add Ex to this

 

talking about darthe rather than to darthe?

 

When reading Western you were my strongest town read from early on because of how you were resolving LizClov, you dug at them nd talked to them and eventually moved elsewhere. When you voted NB you had less hesitation in your vote than here even though you pushed it less.

 

Your first vote in Lego was on Sooh and you weren't trying to resolve her you were trying to get her lynched. Sooh kept digging at you and you changed your read etc but it was in response to Sooh as opposed to you being proactive.

 

I dislike using 2 games as 'meta' but

[seph]

 

I'm never analyzing votes again bfg...

???

the wild west game lol

[BFG]

 

I sort of understand, but as dumb as I know it is the entire idk thing is reminding me of the 'meh' thing you had going last game. It's a sort of distancing thing from your read 'meh here's my read take it or leave it' which is fine except it's contradicting your confidence in how much you're pushing for it

the idk was not about the strength of the read, it was about trying to explain the reasons i was feeling it well

 

that said, i get it, you haven't played with me enough to know, and it is fair that you see a correlation there given the limited sample size

 

Ok, that makes ~more sense

[Sooh]

Vote Darthe & Sooh

 

Darthe because he hit & run, Sooh because she's trying too hard to push her points on D1. 

 

What points am I pushing?

[Cuth]

 

 

Talk to me about dpr cuth. Why do you have him as town?

mmmmostly because who's voting him and who he's voting :P

This makes 0 sense from a town perspective on day 1 where we are making our own info and nothing concrete.

Please expand a bit on this for me to understand.

Dr voted Darth because he hasn't came back into the thread and has made 0 posts or progression there. How besides he is voting your suspect is that townie?

 

Your then adding him to town for being voted by your suspect who you have 0 knowledge about.

 

Cuth this doesn't make sense???

[unvote crusher]

 

[V] cuth [/v]

 

i'm not sure if you understand

 

i feel very strongly about my scum reads

 

that is shaping my perspection of the rest of the game

 

also i looked at DPR in between

 

and you can NOT tell me that there's anything scummy about what he's posted or done

 

it's just that there's no substance

 

that is literally the only complaint you could make

 

and that's probably worse than rand for lynching people d1

 

nevertheless

 

darthe is voting DPR and DPR is voting darthe

 

somehow i doubt they would do this if both were scum

[BFG]

 

 

I'm never analyzing votes again bfg...

???

 

the wild west game lol

 

[BFG]

Vote Darthe & Sooh

 

Darthe because he hit & run, Sooh because she's trying too hard to push her points on D1.

Your read on Cuth?

[Cuth]

 

 

 

[v]Cuth[/v]

 

Mostly the above, the talking about as opposed to too is rubbing me the wrong way

 

Beyond that I don't want to lynch Sooh, Seph, Marsh, WiFi or Dice

Probably add Ex to this

 

talking about darthe rather than to darthe?

 

When reading Western you were my strongest town read from early on because of how you were resolving LizClov, you dug at them nd talked to them and eventually moved elsewhere. When you voted NB you had less hesitation in your vote than here even though you pushed it less.

 

Your first vote in Lego was on Sooh and you weren't trying to resolve her you were trying to get her lynched. Sooh kept digging at you and you changed your read etc but it was in response to Sooh as opposed to you being proactive.

 

I dislike using 2 games as 'meta' but

 

no, that's incorrect

 

i dug at them because i saw that as a potential slip

 

then i released and slipped into a more lurky mode, i totally meh'd with QB

 

i repeatedly said that there was very little on him, even after I ISO'd him

 

i was surprised he flipped scum, like i said after he flipped, because there was little evidence, but rather meh tone and one questionable vote

 

and what hesitation do i have on my read of darthe this game? i see none

 

the idk was, as i said, part of the fact that again there's not really OVERWHELMING evidence that darthe is scum, and trying my best to show why i feel so strongly about that read, but not actually doubting that read

 

i voted him right away

[dicetosser1]

 

 

 

i'm not taking them as 100% serious

 

but i'm trying to see if they make sense as town, and if they line up with perspectives and such

 

and as a result i have determined him to be probably scum? :P

Fair enough.

 

...

 

and ergo you should vote there :D

 

 

 

 

A belated good evening all <3

hello

 

may i suggest a vote on darthe

 

I thought you were towny until this happened. Little eager are we? [v]Cuth[/v]

 

 

vote ironeyes and cuth

[seph]

Regardless how you feel I'm having trouble viewing your perspective coming from a town aligned one. I'm still reading a bit and I'll update this thought as I catch up

[Cuth]

i'm all for a thunderdome with darthe, if you guys would like to vote the both of us up

[BFG]

Just tried to reread and I'm kinda too unfocused to formulate reads.  I hate being useless.

 

Feeling vaguely ok about BFG, maybe Dice, possibly Sooh.  DPR is DPRing it up and can't be pinned down this early because he won't be meta'd.  Not sure how I feel about Cuth and his Darthe fixation - it's the thing that stuck out to me the most while reading but I can't decide if it makes sense or not.  And I never know what to think about Darthe.  WiFi had me a little concerned with the apparent overreaction to DPR's vote but I've read enough games of hers to know that's not going to be useful in figuring out if she's mafia.

 

 

I know we have less than an hour and a half to narrow it down to the 2 fighters for the day but to be brutally honest I'm pretty sure I'm going to be utterly unhelpful with that decision.

Anything's helpful lol :)

[BFG]

i'm all for a thunderdome with darthe, if you guys would like to vote the both of us up

Been considering that lol

 

[unvote]

[dicetosser1]

i'm all for a thunderdome with darthe, if you guys would like to vote the both of us up

 

id rather you and marsh actually.  

[BFG]

Really wish Hallia would come and explain that post

 

Also concerned that DPR is voting Sooh for pushing points when ignoring Cuths tunnel and voting with him

[Cuth]

anything that 

 

 

i'm all for a thunderdome with darthe, if you guys would like to vote the both of us up

 

id rather you and marsh actually.  

 

i want to hear a little bit more from him before i'd want to thunderdome him

 

he's definitely in my top candidates for scum though

 

i would be very surprised if not two in darthe/iron/sooh, in that order

[BFG]

anything that 

 

 

 

i'm all for a thunderdome with darthe, if you guys would like to vote the both of us up

 

id rather you and marsh actually.

 

i want to hear a little bit more from him before i'd want to thunderdome him

 

he's definitely in my top candidates for scum though

 

i would be very surprised if not two in darthe/iron/sooh, in that order

 

Why Sooh?

[Cuth]

but like i said i really want to see more from iron, because he could easily swing the other way fairly quickly

 

just from what i know now

 

myeah

[Sooh]

anything that 

 

 

i'm all for a thunderdome with darthe, if you guys would like to vote the both of us up

 

id rather you and marsh actually.  

 

i want to hear a little bit more from him before i'd want to thunderdome him

 

he's definitely in my top candidates for scum though

 

i would be very surprised if not two in darthe/iron/sooh, in that order

Ok?

So far I've heard a bunch about Darthe. Can you elaborate on Iron/me?