Morning Ithi 🙂

I would like to see more from Ithi about other players. Her "I saw one thing and I'm pushing that to the exclusion of all else" would feel a little too similar to last game. It also means there would be nothing to get a read on except that one wolf read, and everyone can be wrong about a D1 wolf read. That said I like her reasoning mostly, but my read is thrown by her antagonistic style. Will go with a town lean for now, though not without suspicions.

Sinister confuses me. The whole lightning rod thing makes him the centre of the conversation. With Darthe's read list I didn't notice Sinister wasn't on it, and if I had, I wouldn't have cared. Too easy a mistake to make, too little implication. So the claim that this now is the basis for everything that happening and the death of Darthe just seems totally wild. And while it would be easy to say, this is totally not wolf behaviour, we know Sinister can play like this as a wolf, though possibly it is actually NAI. I want to say Sinister is TWTBAW, yet that was my gut feeling last time. About the only the thing I feel a little good about is that Sinister feels a bit more rattled this time than last when he was chill Pete the cat, or whatever that was. Though that might be because this game he has Ithi on his case, lol. I can can see that disconcerting a lot of people.

VOTE TEPH I'm not a big fan of his vote, but we'll see how that pans out - either it is a prod to encourage activity or an elimination attempt. If the latter, don't approve at this point. Not keen on his "that's what a wolf would say" posts that don't really count as wolf hunting to me. Has been awkward in the thread, seems to be trying to coast rather than play. I'm not definitely convinced, but I would like to see reads and reasoning to get a better "feel". Asking other players to be more active and being reactive with one liners just seems like trying to go under the radar too much.

That isn't very fair. I'm sussing Shad for making lots of posts I don't like, in particular with you is not that he was sussing you, but that he was "accusing" you of bussing Darthe (so last game) which was sussing you without actually sussing you. That was point. It was the sus without any content. I think you are pretty sus all in all, it is just that doesn't mean that you aren't being targetted as low hanging fruit. But we have time to see how things progress, it is very early doors so far.

Plus remember, I'm incredibly shy and non-confrontational. Here I have to be mean and call people liars and everything. This is probably as natural as I get.

Shad, Ithi and Teph? But we only find out if we eliminate them all? Though Shad calling me Town is obviously top class play, so maybe we can drop him out of the suspect list, lol. This is me concentrating. And past my bedtime, possibly. Maybe I should have some warm milk.

But does help not being dead. I am quite sure that er, well, sure is maybe going a bit far, but fairly sure Dice said in our first game here that he policy eliminated anyone that stated they were a wolf due past experiences. And your reply absolutely does not relate to the point at discussion. *scratches head*

You know you can start playing anytime you want and gives reads 👍

Actually I haven't liked a single post of Shad's. Especially with that sussing on Sinister that wasn't sussing at all. What are your thoughts on Ithi, Shad?

I think my thought process was that someone that opens with "I am wolf" does not seem to be in a strong position to criticize other people's opening posts. Imho, obviously.

The sketch must have taken a while, I understand. So aggressive Ithi is aggressive. The case though is quite good for the age of the game, but the vehemence seems out of place. Though I have to say I as kind of burned last game giving Sinister the benefit of the doubt, lol. Really don't like Shad's pointless post that looks like it is throwing shade on Sinister though.

Do people actually take notes? For realsies? I tried and it was just a mess of unrelated words and arrows and page numbers... Hats off to anyone that can do that successfully, lol.

Have to say the change of Ithi from memeing to militant is quite discordant.

@Ithillian Turambar what is your case against Sinister? Or is this just a gut feeling? (votes not in red don't look right)

That doesn't make any sense. Why would a wolf be guilty? Unless you are fishing - though I didn't notice a vig, but it is a very long list of roles, lol - at least make your accusations sensible.

i mean I suppose as long as most people keep their vote town will always have the vote advantage but... oh well, we'll see lol. It should be interesting at least to find out how this plays out.

OK, not who has which role - though that has not hurt them that much so far, but without flips how are we going to read? We can be really sus of someone, but eliminating them isn't going to tell us anything. I just have difficult time seeing how the game is going to evolve, but only one way to find out. I'm not being all woe is me, lol, its just the prognosis is looking a bit bleak, though the main thing is the uncertainty of how the game will play, cos in a worst case scenario we are looking at an endlessly repeating D1, lol.

This does seem like the worst possible outcome, doesn't it? As the mafia will still know everything. *sighs*

Why, I don't mind if I do, thank you.

Yup. I don't suppose anyone has a guilty conscience and want to confess to killing Darthe? Letting emotions like guilt bottle can be damaging for your health I know.

So we have Darthe's list, and Shad's not really an interaction with him to go on. Hmm. Well, who would have thought this game would have been confusing. It looked so straightforward from the set-up.

Thank you for your vote of confidence that I am trustworthy 🙂 However, you quoting my joke yet ignoring the rest of the post where I specifically ask not to be given any roles (which is kind of sus of me, I admit, reverse psychology and all that) is hugely suss. Why ignore the point that a wolf wouldn't want to appear to eager for roles? You seem to be flailing to try and make some sus stick without putting a lot of effort into it. All very sus.

Bubblebath

Yeah but first it is night actions and the first round of pass the parcel. So actually we aren't looking for wolves yet, we should be looking for trustworthy, young, dashing Accepteds... Er, I mean players to give our roles to. Except me. I don't need any responsibility. You saw what I did with my 1* investigate last time.