[Advanced] Lost Mafia--Game Over!

[Tiinker]

Thinking of voting tink still, thats a super tilting line of reasoning he has, or it's an attempt to aggress to get me off him.

 

If so it worked last night

 

Which line? Let's talk about it.

[Eldrick4221]

I think the difference between me and you on our read on AJ is that you're taking AJ's openness to conversation as being town-related whereas I don't think he's been particularly helpful to town all things considered.

I do take his openness to conversation as town related. And he seems to be trying to solve. These are points that make me think someone is town.

 

What makes you think he isn't being helpful?

[Eldrick4221]

I'm not sure how I feel about Darthe atm but I feel like it's a waste of time to look at him closely today without prompting people to claim so unless something whacky happens I won't be voting him today.

This one probably.

[Tiinker]

 

I think the difference between me and you on our read on AJ is that you're taking AJ's openness to conversation as being town-related whereas I don't think he's been particularly helpful to town all things considered.

I do take his openness to conversation as town related. And he seems to be trying to solve. These are points that make me think someone is town.

 

What makes you think he isn't being helpful?

 

 

 

There's many ways to help town and providing direction is one of them through claims, strong reads, and changing the overall pace and of the game. The only direction AJ has provided is by nudging along direction that is already there. Waiting for him to flip and vote me now.

[Tiinker]

 

I'm not sure how I feel about Darthe atm but I feel like it's a waste of time to look at him closely today without prompting people to claim so unless something whacky happens I won't be voting him today.

This one probably.

 

 

The claim can be verified later on in the game when we can start piecing together people's roles so I'm fine leaving it where it is. Why is this tilting?

[Wildfire Sedai]

 

 

Wow. So much of that needs to be explained.

 

Why does if shad tried to pocket you it succeeded mean he's nice?

 

Why does bop's "view" of Notbob mean Notbob is nice?

 

How am I "setting up calder"? And even if I were how does that make calder nice because of it?

1. Well isn't the definition of pocketing mean that the person you pocketed leans you nice?? and/or follows your lead??

 

2. Well bop viewed notbob as naughty and usually the viewer/cop is nice. However, I think bop is naughty, so that would make notbob nice.

 

3. Well for one thing: I don't believe your claim FULLY yet. If it is true Calder could be naughty/nice (vanilla). No PR. If it isn't true then you could be setting calder up to be seen as a teammate and your naughty. At least I think that is how I was thinking about it when I did the list.

1. Ok worded badly I guess. What does the "blueness in his reads" have to do with your read on him?

 

2. Yeah. One doesn't mean the other. Bop's "read" was obviously fake. Nobody starts the game with a red read.

 

Bop being naughty doesn't mean Notbob is nice because of his fake read. Assuming so it bad. It could just as easily be a ploy and they are both naughty.

 

3. I get ya. I don't expect you to take me on my word. Willing to prove it in any way you guys think I should.

 

 

1. He put me as bold blue Usually used as full nice lean in this forum.  Has to do with pocketing.

 

2. why not?? nvm I get it. You would get an IC but not a goon.  and I get the other part too, where bop and notbob could both be naughty.  

 

3. Good response.  you got some nice points.   

[Eldrick4221]

1. He put me as bold blue Usually used as full nice lean in this forum. Has to do with pocketing.

Again. That's his read on you. Why does his read on you affect your read on him?

[Eldrick4221]

I'm comfortable putting wiffy down as nice. She's obviously trying to figure the game out.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

It is really just down to figuring out AJ's teammates. There are some options.

 

 

If AJ is a wolf,

 

then I think notbob is a wolf based solely on AJ's defense of notbob when i was suspecting him, other teammates in random/BFG/lenlo.

 

 

Your fixation with me is sweet.

[Eldrick4221]

DPR's last scum game here was a lot more linear.

I'm fairly sure this is the start of talking about dpr's game. As good a start as any. Not digging through the fluff.

 

I have literally read the same page 3 times somehow. Click next page. Get distracted. Come back and read the SAME PAGE. It's kinda demotivating.

[Eldrick4221]

Shad and I have a love-hate relationship of sorts.

I somehow missed this the first time around. Was it supposed to be nonsense?

[Eldrick4221]

[V]marsh [/v]

 

Random was decidedly null to me. Slot could still easily be scum and needs resolving. Either Marsh has to come in and clear this up, or we should probably take care of it ourselves.

[Eldrick4221]

As of page 42, aj's push on dpr makes sense. Namely, ..

 

 

 

 

The quips about Shad needing to get out more are probably nothing more than that so I wouldn't take those too highly into consideration. They don't bother me at least, I think that's just his personality to bust balls so null.

The part about him seemingly having no read is my problem currently as well. The back and forth reads more like deflection if he's not actually taking anything away from it. I'll wait for him to respond though.

I agree with the bold. That's how I read it too.

I'm ok with him not having a read yet, though. It's still very early and several reads aren't developed yet.

Not having fully developed reads by now is fine, yeah.

 

What I'm talking about is more like this:

I get the impression Shad is focussing on rep more than this game. I say that because we are in d1, barely past (or maybe not even) the shitposting and it would be silly to spec on player's alignments so early because of the high-percentage chance that you'll be wrong.

 

What's his take away from all that? I can probably assume but what I want to see is the connecting of the dots and follow through otherwise it reads more like he's just deflecting and arguing to counter punch rather than actually try to resolve Shad. It's the progression that matters imo.

 

 

Shad's is acceptable so far too. It's not a push as much as a trying to understand atp.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

Thread felt pretty villagery on that read just now.

 

I like it

and now?

Things are starting to warm up

 

What have you got?

I see too many posturing...not enough hunting...meh it's Day 1...we need some blood...string up Darthe?

 

I should probably just blame Darthe.

FOS...for the nudge without the vote.

Yeah this is still bugging me.

 

FOS for hypocritical fos

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Pretty sure I'm only voting Eldrick or Darthe today.   The rest of you look town for now.  I'll read as you post...not really in the mood to contribute more than that...

 

@pral...you're my weather vane this game...tell me your thoughts...

 

@AJ & Calder....make good use of the day.

[Eldrick4221]

Top of page 45 and barely retaining what I'm reading. Time for a break.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

 

 

 

Thread felt pretty villagery on that read just now.

 

I like it

and now?

Things are starting to warm up

 

What have you got?

I see too many posturing...not enough hunting...meh it's Day 1...we need some blood...string up Darthe?

 

I should probably just blame Darthe.

FOS...for the nudge without the vote.

Yeah this is still bugging me.

 

FOS for hypocritical fos

 

 

Vote Eldrick

[Eldrick4221]

Pretty sure I'm only voting Eldrick or Darthe today. The rest of you look town for now. I'll read as you post...not really in the mood to contribute more than that...

 

@pral...you're my weather vane this game...tell me your thoughts...

 

@AJ & Calder....make good use of the day.

So many questions.

 

Why Darthe or myself? Noticing that you are only targeting the claimed players there.

 

Why is pral such a strong read for you?

 

What do you mean by the last line?

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

 

 

Thread felt pretty villagery on that read just now.

 

I like it

and now?

Things are starting to warm up

 

What have you got?

I see too many posturing...not enough hunting...meh it's Day 1...we need some blood...string up Darthe?

 

I should probably just blame Darthe.

FOS...for the nudge without the vote.

Yeah this is still bugging me.

 

FOS for hypocritical fos

Vote Eldrick

Yea. Not helping you look better.

[Eldrick4221]

That's as close to omgus as it gets without my not voting you yet.

 

I fos you for being a hypocrite and you vote me over it.

[Shad_]

 

Shad and I have a love-hate relationship of sorts.

I somehow missed this the first time around. Was it supposed to be nonsense?

 

 

I take it you missed the post prior where I was comparing my scum hunting techniques to sodomy.

[Eldrick4221]

Notbob is probably naughty. This knee-jerk reaction to pressure just looks really bad.

 

He got some nice credit for doing what he did last game, but that's not a nice-only play.

 

After I finish getting through my reread, whenever that ends up happening, I'm probably gonna move to notbob.

[Shad_]

Notbob's probably fine

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

Shad and I have a love-hate relationship of sorts.

I somehow missed this the first time around. Was it supposed to be nonsense?

I take it you missed the post prior where I was comparing my scum hunting techniques to sodomy.

...probably. I tend to glaze over apparent fluff on reread.

[Shad_]

lynch SoohBFG and if scum AJ looks pretty awful so probably there