[Advanced] Lost Mafia--Game Over!

[Darthe]

ok, then eldrick's point of view makes no sense.

 

 

I get being suspicious of darthe,

 

there are three scenarios

 

He is a liar and a wolf;

 

He is telling the truth and was roleblocked,

 

He was telling the truth and shot a wolf possibly protected by some sort of protection role(not sure what flavors you typically use here but there are several i'm familiar with).

 

 

To say that, oh he shot nyn is pretty awkward and then say it doesn't matter about a team kill, that's darthe's kill. I can't even

Theres a fourth, im a liar and town. That happens woth me yo, but not this time.

 

Bfg shoulda died

[Darthe]

though darthe just saying 'lol' and nothing else for the last 20 minutes isn't exactly making me more confident that tiink's scenario is the most likely

Gumme the benefit of the doubt. Everyone knows im at work til 5:30 (10 min from now) then ive a 40 min commute.

[bopolis]

 

though darthe just saying 'lol' and nothing else for the last 20 minutes isn't exactly making me more confident that tiink's scenario is the most likely

Gumme the benefit of the doubt. Everyone knows im at work til 5:30 (10 min from now) then ive a 40 min commute.

 

 

fair enough

[Darthe]

 

 

Darthe - Who did you target?

Bfg

Can we get a little more, ya know, reasoning? Why BFG specifically?

I dodnt like sooh, my top townies wanted bfg dead and I got scared off my top choice. I was never gonna shoot nb or wifi and I decided I wanted to see more of you.

 

Additionally, bfg shouldnt have automatically believed me claiming vig was a full clear, but she did.

 

Thats my line of thought.

[Eldrick4221]

The most obvious answer is Darthe RB'd and mafia killed Nyn/Hallia. If we can get confirmation from Darthe then we can start analyzing the DPR train.

This is the meat of what I was getting at. I wanted to prompt discussion.

 

The way I see it, the most likely scenarios are he was lying or he was blocked. If he was blocked by mafia, he was probably right with his reads.

[Eldrick4221]

[unvote]

[Tiinker]

 

The most obvious answer is Darthe RB'd and mafia killed Nyn/Hallia. If we can get confirmation from Darthe then we can start analyzing the DPR train.

This is the meat of what I was getting at. I wanted to prompt discussion.

 

The way I see it, the most likely scenarios are he was lying or he was blocked. If he was blocked by mafia, he was probably right with his reads.

 

 

So, you voted him to prompt discussion? Bold strategy Cotton.

[bopolis]

 

The most obvious answer is Darthe RB'd and mafia killed Nyn/Hallia. If we can get confirmation from Darthe then we can start analyzing the DPR train.

This is the meat of what I was getting at. I wanted to prompt discussion.

 

The way I see it, the most likely scenarios are he was lying or he was blocked. If he was blocked by mafia, he was probably right with his reads.

 

 

how is coming in and voting darthe supposed to relay that him getting RB'd is what you were getting at?

[Tiinker]

[unvote]

 

You voted him cause you suspected him. He comes in and states the obvious that you claim to have known anyway. And then you unvote. Why.

[bopolis]

jinx tiink

[Lenlo]

im good with voting Sooh/BFG today. Calder is also in my top.

[bopolis]

talk tpo me aboitu calder lenlo,

 

whats your concerns with him

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

The most obvious answer is Darthe RB'd and mafia killed Nyn/Hallia. If we can get confirmation from Darthe then we can start analyzing the DPR train.

This is the meat of what I was getting at. I wanted to prompt discussion.

 

The way I see it, the most likely scenarios are he was lying or he was blocked. If he was blocked by mafia, he was probably right with his reads.

how is coming in and voting darthe supposed to relay that him getting RB'd is what you were getting at?

It wouldn't by itself. If anyone had just accepted the reasoning that would be a thing too.

[Tiinker]

 

 

 

The most obvious answer is Darthe RB'd and mafia killed Nyn/Hallia. If we can get confirmation from Darthe then we can start analyzing the DPR train.

This is the meat of what I was getting at. I wanted to prompt discussion.

 

The way I see it, the most likely scenarios are he was lying or he was blocked. If he was blocked by mafia, he was probably right with his reads.

how is coming in and voting darthe supposed to relay that him getting RB'd is what you were getting at?

It wouldn't by itself. If anyone had just accepted the reasoning that would be a thing too.

 

 

Is this you?

 

[Eldrick4221]

So, you voted him to prompt discussion? Bold strategy Cotton.

Not really. Votes are the most noticeable discussion points, and can be changed.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

The most obvious answer is Darthe RB'd and mafia killed Nyn/Hallia. If we can get confirmation from Darthe then we can start analyzing the DPR train.

This is the meat of what I was getting at. I wanted to prompt discussion.

 

The way I see it, the most likely scenarios are he was lying or he was blocked. If he was blocked by mafia, he was probably right with his reads.

how is coming in and voting darthe supposed to relay that him getting RB'd is what you were getting at?

I was gonna talk about it but was beaten to the punch.

[Lenlo]

talk tpo me aboitu calder lenlo,

 

whats your concerns with him

This game is very reminiscent of Gods and Demons, another game I had with him, where he was a cult/mafia leader. Lots of posts. Little work. Lots of quips. Somehow no one called him on it. Add to that I am very very sure there is some kind of cult in this game cause of my role, and I am rightfully worried about Calder.

[Eldrick4221]

Ok. A part of me feels like it's still way too early to reveal, but I gotta nab that in the butt before it gets traction.

 

I was paranoid about Calder being cult leader too. You made sense in your reason to think he was.

 

I am a Tracker. I watched Calder. He stayed home last night.

 

He could still ofc be mafia and didn't do anything last night, but it's very unlikely he's cult leader. (He could have been blocked)

[Eldrick4221]

Be gone Eldrazi menace.

Eldrazi made me stop playing.

[Lenlo]

Ok. A part of me feels like it's still way too early to reveal, but I gotta nab that in the butt before it gets traction.

 

I was paranoid about Calder being cult leader too. You made sense in your reason to think he was.

 

I am a Tracker. I watched Calder. He stayed home last night.

 

He could still ofc be mafia and didn't do anything last night, but it's very unlikely he's cult leader. (He could have been blocked)

If this is true, ill withdraw the worry about Calder then. Atleast with him being Cult. Other than that Sooh/BFG is my number one today.

[Eldrick4221]

Blah. Dpr train isn't in order. Darthe was listed first, so I thought he was first to vote him. Shad was clearly before darthe

[Wildfire Sedai]

Okay, gonna throw out an impromptu reads list.  Know that I will probably/more than likely/almost positively be mistakenly mixing up people in my reasonings.  Just saying

 

1. Darthe - nice - for one more day cause of his claim and that he hasn't been so uhm "pissy" for most of game.  Though he was also "pissy" when he was town too.  So not sure if I want to rely on his "pissiness."  Just saying.   darthe.  

2. Shad_ - nice - If he was trying to pocket me with the blueness in his reads, succeeded.   well for now, anyways.  Maybe, possibly.  But srlsy he has been pushing through the thread to find wolves.  iirc.

3. Tiinker - null

4. BEWBS MCGEE (AKA Nynaeve + Hallia Hydra)-Walt-Town-Vanilla-Killed Night 1
5. Pralaya - null
6. Randomh3r0 Ironeyes - null
7. Sooh BFG - naughty - I know coming in as a sub SUCKS.  Especially over 90p in BTDT.  anyway, I am going to believe darthe when he says he targeted bfg, because she was a topic of discussion for some people. However, she is not my first WTL candidate today.

 

8. Andrej - null

9. Not Bob (鲍勃不是我的名字)  -  nice- I am basing this off of bops "view" of him, as I don't believe in bop.

10. Calder - null/nice - I am not sure. well maybe because I think dricky is naughty, and trying to set up calder.

11. Wildfire Sedai - NICE QUEENIE
12. Lenlo - town - I can't believe I am saying this about lenlo but yeah...though I am not sure why as of yet.

13. DreadPirateRoberts-Shannon-Town-Vanilla-Lynched Day 1
14. bopolis - naughty - his fake view of not bob though I get that it could be legit, even though he said it wasn't (trying to keep from getting NK)

15. Eldrick4221 - naughty - his fake claim.  This is one thing that I have seen in at least 3 games and that is fake claims as trackers, and two this game.  Though bop did admit that it was just fluff. I suppose dricky could be telling the truth. I will give him the benefit of the doubt.

[Darthe]

 

talk tpo me aboitu calder lenlo,

 

whats your concerns with him

This game is very reminiscent of Gods and Demons, another game I had with him, where he was a cult/mafia leader. Lots of posts. Little work. Lots of quips. Somehow no one called him on it. Add to that I am very very sure there is some kind of cult in this game cause of my role, and I am rightfully worried about Calder.

That seems to describe you this game.

 

I wonder if I lost a shot

[Darthe]

Ok. A part of me feels like it's still way too early to reveal, but I gotta nab that in the butt before it gets traction.

 

I was paranoid about Calder being cult leader too. You made sense in your reason to think he was.

 

I am a Tracker. I watched Calder. He stayed home last night.

 

He could still ofc be mafia and didn't do anything last night, but it's very unlikely he's cult leader. (He could have been blocked)

I'm shooting you, shooting me, then flaming you in DT

[Darthe]

Okay, gonna throw out an impromptu reads list. Know that I will probably/more than likely/almost positively be mistakenly mixing up people in my reasonings. Just saying

1. Darthe - nice - for one more day cause of his claim and that he hasn't been so uhm "pissy" for most of game. Though he was also "pissy" when he was town too. So not sure if I want to rely on his "pissiness." Just saying. darthe.

 

2. Shad_ - nice - If he was trying to pocket me with the blueness in his reads, succeeded. well for now, anyways. Maybe, possibly. But srlsy he has been pushing through the thread to find wolves. iirc.

 

3. Tiinker - null

4. BEWBS MCGEE (AKA Nynaeve + Hallia Hydra)-Walt-Town-Vanilla-Killed Night 1

5. Pralaya - null

6. Randomh3r0 Ironeyes - null

7. Sooh BFG - naughty - I know coming in as a sub SUCKS. Especially over 90p in BTDT. anyway, I am going to believe darthe when he says he targeted bfg, because she was a topic of discussion for some people. However, she is not my first WTL candidate today.

8. Andrej - null

9. Not Bob (鲍勃不是我的名字) - nice- I am basing this off of bops "view" of him, as I don't believe in bop.

 

10. Calder - null/nice - I am not sure. well maybe because I think dricky is naughty, and trying to set up calder.

 

11. Wildfire Sedai - NICE QUEENIE

12. Lenlo - town - I can't believe I am saying this about lenlo but yeah...though I am not sure why as of yet.

 

13. DreadPirateRoberts-Shannon-Town-Vanilla-Lynched Day 1

14. bopolis - naughty - his fake view of not bob though I get that it could be legit, even though he said it wasn't (trying to keep from getting NK)

 

15. Eldrick4221 - naughty - his fake claim. This is one thing that I have seen in at least 3 games and that is fake claims as trackers, and two this game. Though bop did admit that it was just fluff. I suppose dricky could be telling the truth. I will give him the benefit of the doubt.

I hate all of you so very much sometimes