[Advanced] Lost Mafia--Game Over!

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

lol speaking of which

 

BFG you caught up? What's my alignment?

if you mean read through in detail then no and that's unlikely at this point. I'll read via ISOs and bits that seem interesting from that, but am mostly trying to pick up from here

 

And /shrug lol, gun to head tentative town based on your push of DPR, which is at least more aggressive than I remember you last game, I want to check how many 'diplomatic' posts there are compared to aggressive, but I think the assertiveness is more telling

Can you explain that please?

 

What makes it an aggressive towny push and not a scum mislynch push iyo?

Because mafia!Shad is diplomatic and making friends. Whereas I think he was poking DPR all day and well before he became a lynch possibility

Good answer :thumbsup:

[Eldrick4221]

Darthe. You listed wiffy and sooh as a possible target originally, but not now.

 

Why?

[bopolis]

 

 

If bop is scum, random is probably town. This feels like scum getting off one train to start pushing another, once he sees that the villa train he was on is getting traction.

i would agree

Interesting. What's your read on Random, then?

 

 

i feel like i'm in the twilight Zone.

 

I was pushing him to get lynched at the end of the day.

 

You just mentioned i was pushing for him at the end of dasy and if i'm scum he's probably a villager.

 

What do you think my read on him is?

[Eldrick4221]

I believe your words were "someone on my train or WiFi or sooh"

[bopolis]

Kill submitted on 

 

 

 

Bop

 

 

Or Tink

 

 

Or maybe Notbob

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

my buns are buttered and ready

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

If bop is scum, random is probably town. This feels like scum getting off one train to start pushing another, once he sees that the villa train he was on is getting traction.

i would agree

Interesting. What's your read on Random, then?

i feel like i'm in the twilight Zone.

 

I was pushing him to get lynched at the end of the day.

 

You just mentioned i was pushing for him at the end of dasy and if i'm scum he's probably a villager.

 

What do you think my read on him is?

You pushed several people this game without the intent to get them lynched. Why should random be different?

[Darthe]

Darthe. You listed wiffy and sooh as a possible target originally, but not now.

 

Why?

I was never actally gonna kill wifi, I wanted to see her respond.  

 

Sooh, the replacement factor with BFG.  

 

I'm just playing the game man, and that requires that you not always know whats on my mind.

[Eldrick4221]

It was just really weird for you to agree with the idea that if you were scum then random is probably town.

 

Trying to see how that could come from a Town pov of thinking random is scum is hurting my head.

[bopolis]

 

 

 

 

If bop is scum, random is probably town. This feels like scum getting off one train to start pushing another, once he sees that the villa train he was on is getting traction.

i would agree

Interesting. What's your read on Random, then?

i feel like i'm in the twilight Zone.

 

I was pushing him to get lynched at the end of the day.

 

You just mentioned i was pushing for him at the end of dasy and if i'm scum he's probably a villager.

 

What do you think my read on him is?

You pushed several people this game without the intent to get them lynched. Why should random be different?

 

 

Which people am i reading villager have I pushed. 

[Eldrick4221]

 

Darthe. You listed wiffy and sooh as a possible target originally, but not now.

 

Why?

I was never actally gonna kill wifi, I wanted to see her respond.

 

Sooh, the replacement factor with BFG.

 

I'm just playing the game man, and that requires that you not always know whats on my mind.

I get that.

 

I'm also playing and that requires asking questions when your actions change.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

 

 

If bop is scum, random is probably town. This feels like scum getting off one train to start pushing another, once he sees that the villa train he was on is getting traction.

i would agree

Interesting. What's your read on Random, then?

i feel like i'm in the twilight Zone.

 

I was pushing him to get lynched at the end of the day.

 

You just mentioned i was pushing for him at the end of dasy and if i'm scum he's probably a villager.

 

What do you think my read on him is?

You pushed several people this game without the intent to get them lynched. Why should random be different?

Which people am i reading villager have I pushed.

Fair point

[bopolis]

It was just really weird for you to agree with the idea that if you were scum then random is probably town.

 

Trying to see how that could come from a Town pov of thinking random is scum is hurting my head.

 

im saying if i die and flip scum then random is town.

 

When i say this comment, do you think i'm saying there is a chance i'm going to flip scum or do you think i'm being facetious

 

honest question.

 

If you think i'm saying it's possible i'm flipping scum then you need to take a time out and marinate on things for a bit.

[Andrej]

 

@Bop

 

If aj and calder are both nice, is tink nice or naughty iyo and why

if they are v/v i don't think you can derive tiink's alignment form that alone.

 

I liked tiink's explanation for pushing darthe even though i disagreed with it. It made me think he was villagy. I also liked his tone when he came in last night complaining about people shadily pushing him. However im nowhere near confident enough to call him a villa for those reasons alone

I don't hate your logic here. Tiink's tone was good, yeah, but that alone doesn't save him from his overall body of work imo.

[Andrej]

last spoiler was supposed to say maybe

Just hero shoot me and then speed lynch Calder tmrw

[bopolis]

WRT my tiink associative reads from earlier;

 

It is possible that bussing could happen but my initial observations was from taking the interactions at face value

[Darthe]

It was just really weird for you to agree with the idea that if you were scum then random is probably town.

 

Trying to see how that could come from a Town pov of thinking random is scum is hurting my head.

I don't have a clue what this is a response to?

 

 

 

Darthe. You listed wiffy and sooh as a possible target originally, but not now.

 

Why?

I was never actally gonna kill wifi, I wanted to see her respond.

 

Sooh, the replacement factor with BFG.

 

I'm just playing the game man, and that requires that you not always know whats on my mind.

I get that.

 

I'm also playing and that requires asking questions when your actions change.

 

Sure, but I hope you'll not take it amiss if I ignore you in favor of doing something that actually helps win.

[bopolis]

 

It was just really weird for you to agree with the idea that if you were scum then random is probably town.

 

Trying to see how that could come from a Town pov of thinking random is scum is hurting my head.

 

im saying if i die and flip scum then random is town.

 

When i say this comment, do you think i'm saying there is a chance i'm going to flip scum or do you think i'm being facetious

 

honest question.

 

If you think i'm saying it's possible i'm flipping scum then you need to take a time out and marinate on things for a bit.

 

 

 

or i need to be more clear when im saying things with a tongue in my cheek ; probably a bit of both

[Eldrick4221]

I find it interesting that town!you wouldn't say that the person you are pushing for being scum wouldn't still be scum should you flip scum.

 

Since it would be moot if you flipped town.

 

I hope that made sense.

 

Why did you agree with something if you know it isn't a possibility? Especially since it goes against your read of him.

[Andrej]

DM needs a sarcasm font.

[Eldrick4221]

DM needs a sarcasm font.

+1

[Darthe]

 

It was just really weird for you to agree with the idea that if you were scum then random is probably town.

 

Trying to see how that could come from a Town pov of thinking random is scum is hurting my head.

 

im saying if i die and flip scum then random is town.

 

When i say this comment, do you think i'm saying there is a chance i'm going to flip scum or do you think i'm being facetious

 

honest question.

 

If you think i'm saying it's possible i'm flipping scum then you need to take a time out and marinate on things for a bit.

 

Oh.

 

Eldrick, we need to have a real talk about this man.  You gotta think a bit more because it is seriously prohibitive to have to explain and analyze stuff that's this simple.

 

It'd be like every time someone wants to play basketball you have to explain to them how points work and that they've gotta dribble etc.  

[bopolis]

I find it interesting that town!you wouldn't say that the person you are pushing for being scum wouldn't still be scum should you flip scum.

 

Since it would be moot if you flipped town.

 

I hope that made sense.

 

Why did you agree with something if you know it isn't a possibility? Especially since it goes against your read of him.

 

twofold

 

1)if any player is seriously pushing someone to get lynched, than the pusher flips scum, the person they pushed is probably town. 

 

2) i enjoy messing with you

[Darthe]

DM needs a sarcasm font.

We could all collectively agree to be less robots, alternatively.

[BFG]

That wasn't as helpful as I wanted :/

 

A number of people weren't really around at end of day and I have no idea what to make of it, but will have to call it null based on sheer number. A lot of votes were placed early and didn't shift which indicates that reads haven't been shifting much

 

Accepting Darthes claim, and is probably self resolvable anyway

 

Tentative town lean on Eldrick and Shad and would guess Nyn's thread presence/early game play indicates she's town

 

Beyond that I have a number of players that sound good and a number of players that I don't remember

 

Want to look into AJ/Calder tomorrow

[BFG]

I find it interesting that town!you wouldn't say that the person you are pushing for being scum wouldn't still be scum should you flip scum.

 

Since it would be moot if you flipped town.

 

I hope that made sense.

 

Why did you agree with something if you know it isn't a possibility? Especially since it goes against your read of him.

except this is similar to what you do when you talk about yourself in a third party/neutral observer way?