[Advanced] Lost Mafia--Game Over!

[Eldrick4221]

If there's a cult, wiffy is also a good target. Because she's consensus town.

 

We still need to watch her and make sure it stays that way.

[Eldrick4221]

FYI I legit have no idea how to figure you out bfg.

 

I still have your slot in my wtl because of sooh.

 

Your contribution so far hasn't been bad, but I can't really trust that too much. You are a really good player.

[BFG]

Maybe not copying per say, but he is noticeably lacking from these groups.

 

Your scum list is like half of the game. After excluding the 3 claimed roles you were left with 4 people and named everyone but him.

 

With 15 players to start there were likely 4 none town to start probably 3 mafia and 1 independent, so there are likely at least 3 none town left

[BFG]

If there's a cult, wiffy is also a good target. Because she's consensus town.

 

We still need to watch her and make sure it stays that way.

The reads list was good, but theres relatively little, and the way she's trying to be more restrained makes reading her this game hard

[BFG]

Got to run, meetings for most of the day and I need to get to the post office at lunch, but will be around later and as I can

[Eldrick4221]

 

Maybe not copying per say, but he is noticeably lacking from these groups.

 

Your scum list is like half of the game. After excluding the 3 claimed roles you were left with 4 people and named everyone but him.

 

With 15 players to start there were likely 4 none town to start probably 3 mafia and 1 independent, so there are likely at least 3 none town left

List felt longer. 4 on WTL is fine.

[Tiinker]

Got lunch, dinner, and seeing Rogue One tonight. Catch ya guys later.

[Eldrick4221]

Thanks for the update?

[Eldrick4221]

I can't be mad cuz I update like that too, but the phrase "wolfy pop-in" comes to mind.

[Calder]

The fact that so many people were wary of him was why I was going to track him. I was convinced he was town, but that obviously doesn't mean I'm right.

 

And the fact that he knew I felt that way would mean he shouldn't suspect me to track him

Are all these posts just to save your ego for being massively wrong on AJ?

 

Bc I dont know what other purpose they serve the thread. Why does it matter what you would do if he is still alive, now that you saw his flip.

[Calder]

Vig should kill Pral. He is the new scum now.

[Eldrick4221]

 

The fact that so many people were wary of him was why I was going to track him. I was convinced he was town, but that obviously doesn't mean I'm right.

 

And the fact that he knew I felt that way would mean he shouldn't suspect me to track him

Are all these posts just to save your ego for being massively wrong on AJ?

 

Bc I dont know what other purpose they serve the thread. Why does it matter what you would do if he is still alive, now that you saw his flip.

Yeah, basically. Sorry to bother you with it.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

shad/eldrick/darthe

 

I don't think you should broadcast your target tonight. And if you have broadcasted it and don't wanna change it lie and say your changing it.

 

Thanks friends

 

or just shoot this dude.

[Eldrick4221]

Vig should kill Pral. He is the new scum now.

Vig should kill whoever the vig wants to kill. I'm sure there's more than one non-town out there still.

[Eldrick4221]

 

shad/eldrick/darthe

 

I don't think you should broadcast your target tonight. And if you have broadcasted it and don't wanna change it lie and say your changing it.

 

Thanks friends

or just shoot this dude.

Why?

[Calder]

 

Vig should kill Pral. He is the new scum now.

Vig should kill whoever the vig wants to kill. I'm sure there's more than one non-town out there still.

The Vig gets to shoot whoever they choose.

 

That doesnt mean town shouldnt tell him who they suspect and desire shot.

[Calder]

 

shad/eldrick/darthe

 

I don't think you should broadcast your target tonight. And if you have broadcasted it and don't wanna change it lie and say your changing it.

 

Thanks friends

or just shoot this dude.

Watch out nonbob. The vig gets to shoot whoever he wants. You dont get any say in it.

[Darthe]

So Darthe. That was a test.

 

And you failed it miserably.

 

I wasn't asking your permission. I was asking your opinion.

 

You are a big ? because your claimed kill on sooh/bfg didn't happen. You are the only one that knows your role (unless of course you're mafia then your teammates obv do too)

 

I was asking something that I felt a Town vig would be willing to go along with. To probe he was telling the truth by another source.

 

And someone that was lying about their role would try to dodge or not give a straight answer.

 

 

And which did you do?

This may as all be in Spanish for ask the sense I can make of it, what are you even responding to?

[Darthe]

Got lunch, dinner, and seeing Rogue One tonight. Catch ya guys later.

Not much point in coming back yo

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

Also curious where bop falls on your list.

 

Because it very much looks like you are quoting his list to agree with it and then copying his list to answer me.

Bop is someone I need to look into more closely.

 

Outside claims, I agree that Calder (in particular) and Tiinker are unlikely to be teamed with AJ.

 

WiFis list and posts quoted by Shad ~sound like town!Wifi (another lazy read though), I still haven't come across a post that screams town for her, but a quiet shout is still pretty good. I also haven't ISOd her yet so the possibility that I've missed it is high.

 

 

That's basically Bops town list, people who have claims made in a way that implies town (Shad never fake claims to kill a teammate, you probably don't claim to help Calder if mafia, Darthe is unlikely to fake claim vig since it's a proveable role), the 2 players who are most spewed by AJs death and a consensus town, whose there because concensus not because he's reading her town

 

So the generic list is fine.

 

His posts generically are fine, from what I recall he was (very?) early calling you town and I always like early game play. He tangled with DPR(?) Day 1 as opposed to being more passive

 

Gut vibe from Day 1 would be town, but I want to check his reactions to Calders case

 

He's also ideal recruit material, and the fact that there's been so much discussion about a cult without either panic or a complete shut down of it, coupled with AJ flipping Other instead of mafia implies at the least a faction game and likely a cult :/

 

 

Darthe as Cult Leader fake claims role with two kills to ensure he gets as many recruits as possible.  Not sure why you folks don't see that.

[Darthe]

Sure, call whoever you want me to sit. I'm cool with it.

[Darthe]

Shoot

[Calder]

 

So Darthe. That was a test.

And you failed it miserably.

I wasn't asking your permission. I was asking your opinion.

You are a big ? because your claimed kill on sooh/bfg didn't happen. You are the only one that knows your role (unless of course you're mafia then your teammates obv do too)

I was asking something that I felt a Town vig would be willing to go along with. To probe he was telling the truth by another source.

And someone that was lying about their role would try to dodge or not give a straight answer.

And which did you do?

This may as all be in Spanish for ask the sense I can make of it, what are you even responding to?

His test, you took, results = no bueno

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

 

shad/eldrick/darthe

 

I don't think you should broadcast your target tonight. And if you have broadcasted it and don't wanna change it lie and say your changing it.

 

Thanks friends

or just shoot this dude.

Watch out nonbob. The vig gets to shoot whoever he wants. You dont get any say in it.

 

 

He doesn't have a shot...scum would have killed him.

[Calder]

 

 

Also curious where bop falls on your list.

Because it very much looks like you are quoting his list to agree with it and then copying his list to answer me.

 

Bop is someone I need to look into more closely.

Outside claims, I agree that Calder (in particular) and Tiinker are unlikely to be teamed with AJ.

WiFis list and posts quoted by Shad ~sound like town!Wifi (another lazy read though), I still haven't come across a post that screams town for her, but a quiet shout is still pretty good. I also haven't ISOd her yet so the possibility that I've missed it is high.

That's basically Bops town list, people who have claims made in a way that implies town (Shad never fake claims to kill a teammate, you probably don't claim to help Calder if mafia, Darthe is unlikely to fake claim vig since it's a proveable role), the 2 players who are most spewed by AJs death and a consensus town, whose there because concensus not because he's reading her town

So the generic list is fine.

His posts generically are fine, from what I recall he was (very?) early calling you town and I always like early game play. He tangled with DPR(?) Day 1 as opposed to being more passive

Gut vibe from Day 1 would be town, but I want to check his reactions to Calders case

He's also ideal recruit material, and the fact that there's been so much discussion about a cult without either panic or a complete shut down of it, coupled with AJ flipping Other instead of mafia implies at the least a faction game and likely a cult :/

 

Darthe as Cult Leader fake claims role with two kills to ensure he gets as many recruits as possible.  Not sure why you folks don't see that.

I see it as a strong possibility. I was just gonna stay quiet and wait to be selected.