Hackers Mafia - Game Thread [Game Over]

[Darthe]

 

im not close to caught up and am back on the phones.

 

Can someone give me a rundown on how NB ended up the lynch? I assume the last 10 pages shad asked about are important but a for zanders version would be nice

You asking me for a recap?

 

Notbob just started calling people Scum with no reasoning

 

He said he was caught at one point and seemed to be basically lolcatting.

It's becoming hard to take this game seriously.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

so far with those who have answered the WTL question, notbob has been the common name

if you get very many more who want to lynch NB, odds are that he's town.

Huh?

 

What I meant was that when there's a runaway train on D1, odds are extremely likely that it's a townie. Especially when there's no specific defense given of that slot. No scum team of 3 (2+1) would want to lose a teammate D1. 

 

That being said, I'm not sure I would have reacted differently at EOD than what people in the thread did. NB was really not very forthcoming in his communication this game, and it has been long enough for me not to remember exactly what to expect of him as either alignment. 

 

 

This creeps me out and I dont know why.

 

It was like Sooh called it in advance.

[Zander?]

 

 

Odds we get a Darthe check in?

 

Darthe is scum.

 

Worth taking a look into this now. 

 

Calder's comment makes me sorta think that Darthe and Calder aren't w/w

 

 

Why would that comment make you think that?!?!?!

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

 

Has Cass placed a vote on anyone besides amega, or given reads?

 

I know she has asked a lot of questions, but no idea where she stands.

 

She voted Amega then built a bit of a Meta case on her.

 

Shes given some flimsy Town reads on Darthe and Sock as well iirc.

 

 

Tressface

 

I voted Amega because the 5 posts s/he had were crap/lack content and I wanted pressure/asked them to join

 

They didn't join

 

I went back and looked at previous games for comparison

 

I decided they should've had more content/had no reason to be stuck and left my vote

 

Mod said they'd be replaced

 

I said I could still vote there on Amega only/find them scum but ? and prefer to wait for replacement input

 

 

Problem?

 

 

 

Also, no Town READS on Sooh and Darthe

 

And something else you commented on was similar - a work in progress and you called it reads? 

 

I'm giving you thoughts as I have them

 

I know Zander asked, but what does this mean exactly. If you have town FEELS about us, isn't that also kind of like reads?

 

I'd like to see what you're thinking other than what you're wondering about soon, Cass. 

 

 

Will def be looking for a response to this.

 

She was around at DL I figured shed def respond to this or even the flip but nothing yet.

 

Cass is legit sketching me out.

[Zander?]

Dice's effort level seems to be dropping..

 

 

Not passing judgement on that quite yet, though. Could just be busy.

 

Dice, I gave you what you asked for. Would like your input on the events when you get back.

 

Agree on Dice.

 

He's dropping quickly, he seems to only be doing JUST enough and its weird.

 

He said he's been busy in rl so im taking that into account but still need to see more from him.

[Ironeyes]

^^^^^^Saved Darthe's cop life last time I had town powers.

 

Dice murdered me for it though also helping Darthe's point.

I was a terrible Jailkeeper in FF but a great Vig in TG. Mixed record I guess

[Ironeyes]

I'm inclined to ignore all of NB's late reads since at that point he was basically just lolcatting. His Sock read is more credible but I'm still not going to treat it like gospel

[Zander?]

Glad I was right and held to my guns on NotBob. Guy never felt like scum.

 

Your stance on him was legit sketchy AF.

 

Good morning, zander why do you think I was here last night?

 

Also the Notbob flip doesn't really bother me, considering the accusation.

 

Cause you were online and ITT when I said it.

 

And thats a poor attitude man.  People can be wrong on people. so if youre Town this is a strange reaction imo.  I mean man we both been wrong enough times to be able to appreciate it.

 

I have more of an issue with him not really giving reasons for his reads but Id still would rather not have mislynched yesterday.

[Zander?]

 

 

Scum from here: darthe, shad and zander. two out of three guaranteed. see you all later

Will miss you NotBob

Calder. What's your read on these 3?

 

When it was clear Notbob was going to be the lynch, you quoted his scum reads here.

 

I feel like there's a connection between your reads and his from this post. Am I wrong?

 

 

What connection are you seeing from this post because Im not seeing one?!!?!?

[Darthe]

 

Glad I was right and held to my guns on NotBob. Guy never felt like scum.

Your stance on him was legit sketchy AF.

Good morning, zander why do you think I was here last night?

 

Also the Notbob flip doesn't really bother me, considering the accusation.

Cause you were online and ITT when I said it.

 

And thats a poor attitude man. People can be wrong on people. so if youre Town this is a strange reaction imo. I mean man we both been wrong enough times to be able to appreciate it.

 

I have more of an issue with him not really giving reasons for his reads but Id still would rather not have mislynched yesterday.

Suite, but I explained that a bit more later on. You'll catch up there in a few I'd say. As for me being online, I'm near always online when I'm off work, cause as you know I leave a tab open. Weve talked about that before.

[Darthe]

Sure not suite

[Calder]

 

Glad I was right and held to my guns on NotBob. Guy never felt like scum.

 

 

Your stance on him was legit sketchy AF.

 

Good morning, zander why do you think I was here last night?

Also the Notbob flip doesn't really bother me, considering the accusation.

 

 

Cause you were online and ITT when I said it.

 

And thats a poor attitude man.  People can be wrong on people. so if youre Town this is a strange reaction imo.  I mean man we both been wrong enough times to be able to appreciate it.

 

I have more of an issue with him not really giving reasons for his reads but Id still would rather not have mislynched yesterday.

If being the voice of reason in an otherwise floundering town then I accept.

[Calder]

I meant if being the voice of reason makes me sketchy then I accept.

[Calder]

When Lucifer built scum lolcatters he created me then broke the mold.

 

What NotBob was doing was guaranteed to get him lynched. But purposeful scum lolcatting it was not.

[Darthe]

What are you trying to say calder?

[Calder]

What are you trying to say calder?

That I am scum. Therefore I was at least 80% sure that NotBob was innocent.

[Calder]

^^^^For future reference - That is lolcatting.

[Darthe]

Im scum too dude, and when he called me out I had no choice but to lurk.

 

#thuglife

[Ironeyes]

 

 

Glad I was right and held to my guns on NotBob. Guy never felt like scum.

Your stance on him was legit sketchy AF.

Good morning, zander why do you think I was here last night?

 

Also the Notbob flip doesn't really bother me, considering the accusation.

Cause you were online and ITT when I said it.

 

And thats a poor attitude man. People can be wrong on people. so if youre Town this is a strange reaction imo. I mean man we both been wrong enough times to be able to appreciate it.

 

I have more of an issue with him not really giving reasons for his reads but Id still would rather not have mislynched yesterday.

Suite, but I explained that a bit more later on. You'll catch up there in a few I'd say. As for me being online, I'm near always online when I'm off work, cause as you know I leave a tab open. Weve talked about that before.

I do the same thing. I've always got the tab open on my phone and on my laptop

[Ironeyes]

 

What are you trying to say calder?

That I am scum. Therefore I was at least 80% sure that NotBob was innocent.

I'm totes scum and I'm 99% sure he was innocent.

[Calder]

It is a scum block party right now.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

I didn't even take his scum read on you seriously. I thought he was floundering scum.

Now I wish I had cuz I have no idea why he was saying it. :/

I guess it's moot tho. He has already proven bad reads by tunneling me. Snap read on you shouldn't be that much different.

Lol your still alive Eldrick. None of NotBob's reads have been proven anything. Nice try to discredit dead town.

He had a bad read by tunneling me. Spent most of the game doing so.

As such, I don't give much credit to his read on Darthe out of nowhere.

He didn't give a reason for it. If he saw something, we have no idea what.

The information is useless.

The information is far from useless. Bc you saying his tunnel was bad is meaningless. You are still alive. If your scum he had a correct read.

 

 

All we know is that Notbob BELIEVED what he was saying.

 

Notbob didnt put much into the game but he's not a bad player.

 

Only read I know hes wrong about is me.

 

As for the rest only time will tell.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Scum from here: darthe, shad and zander. two out of three guaranteed. see you all later

Will miss you NotBob

Calder. What's your read on these 3?

When it was clear Notbob was going to be the lynch, you quoted his scum reads here.

I feel like there's a connection between your reads and his from this post. Am I wrong?

Eldrick I have lost track of how many things you claim to see a connection with.

So there's not a connection between his scum reads and anything?

Why did you quote it, then?

Bc I wanted to know if he stood by his reads as you were all about to incorrectly lynch him.

You admit you werent even paying attention to his reads. Someone had to.

That doesn't even make sense. You didn't address the reads.

I asked him if he stood by his read on you at the end bc he was also accusing Darthe I believe Zander/Shad. That is too many to accuse. How is that not addressing?

 

What you did was lynch someone and not care what they had to say.

 

 

Well he voted Sock EoD iirc so he prolly did stand by it.

 

But the 2nd line I dont think is fair because Eldrick wasnt the only person who thought he was just lolcatting.

 

I dont think we should dismiss what Notbob said and see how it relates or disagrees with our own but it would be better if he left some reasoning to help make more sense of things.

[Calder]

Well of course reasoning would have been preferred.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Scum from here: darthe, shad and zander. two out of three guaranteed. see you all later

Will miss you NotBob

Calder. What's your read on these 3?

When it was clear Notbob was going to be the lynch, you quoted his scum reads here.

I feel like there's a connection between your reads and his from this post. Am I wrong?

Eldrick I have lost track of how many things you claim to see a connection with.

So there's not a connection between his scum reads and anything?

Why did you quote it, then?

Bc I wanted to know if he stood by his reads as you were all about to incorrectly lynch him.

You admit you werent even paying attention to his reads. Someone had to.

That doesn't even make sense. You didn't address the reads.

I asked him if he stood by his read on you at the end bc he was also accusing Darthe I believe Zander/Shad. That is too many to accuse. How is that not addressing?

 

What you did was lynch someone and not care what they had to say.

 

 

Why is a 4 person PoE too many?!?!?!

 

Especially on D1 imo

 

 

On the Darthe read itself he didnt give a reason. On that any stance would be speculation.

 

My speculation though would be it is a paranoia deep wolf read of his. I doubt he had a true reason.

 

He really didnt give reasons for anything iirc except he felt Eld was defensive.