[Basic] Disney Heroes vs. Villains Mafia C9++ Town Wins

[Shad_]

Shad has coffees and at least ten minutes before his wife notices him sitting at a computer instead of getting up.

[Shad_]

p40 I'm not sure where Tiink gets to Believer wanting to lynch Dice regardless of Dice's alignment.

 

Yes Believer stated that if Dice is a villager he thinks he's playing poorly, but he was pretty clear about calling him a wolf. He's either a villager who thinks Dice is a wolf or a wolf lying about the same. Turning it into something other than that is maybe a little spinny?

 

I dunno, Tiink is the only person here I have zero experience with so I'm hoping others can read him decently.

[Hallia]

Tiink is a sneaky, sneaky sneakity.  I have a hard time trusting him.

 

I don't like the Believer train.  

[Nynaeve]

I dunno, Tiink is the only person here I have zero experience with so I'm hoping others can read him decently.

 

I've never played with him before. Halli's description in one word or less is "sly". lol

[Nynaeve]

Tiink is a sneaky, sneaky sneakity.  I have a hard time trusting him.

 

I don't like the Believer train.  

 

heh

[Shad_]

And the whole argument about is Dice scummy or not for not pulling up Believer's post is just silly when you can easily quote yourself to force accountability. Dice, this is Believer's post:

 

...apparently it was at exactly quote cap so I'll have to split it up....

 

Okay, joking aside. Time to play.

 

Dark colored hair best hair!

Joking intro post, also objectively wrong. Slight scum read.

 

 

 

Cause I promised Celeste I would lynch her first.

 

Look whos here! [v]Celeste[/v]

R00d! Celeste knows best! Take it little Lenlo, I'm totally harmless!

 

"I'm totally harmless" can be read as a joke, but is unnecessary to write, are you trying to convince me or yourself?

 

 

I'd like to inform everyone that I haven't played a C++ game ever, nor a game with majority lynch.

 

 

For transparancy's sake.

How many games have you played? Same to Tinker.

 

Trying to find info on a new player, null post.

 

Nyn is always spicy

Joke post, null.

 

@believer On DM only?

I'm hurt that you don't remember me instantly, will remember this.

 

 

I've never played a game on this forum before.

Then which forums? Your name looks familiar..

 

Again, you hurt the fee-fees.

 

 

Do explain.

because I didn't get to vote Sili in a mash and now I can vote him. :p

 

If you truly are Alette on MU, I can see you doing this as either alignment. Null post.

 

 

I currently play exclusively on MU (http://www.mafiauniverse.com) but I originally started playing on The Org (http://forums.totalwar.org). I use the same nick on both of those sites as here.

WERE YOU IN STAR FOX THEN?! HI, THIS IS ALETTE!

 

Enthusiasm noticed and appreciated, will remember.

 

Also <3 to Cass!

Null post, everybody loves everybody on this site it appears.

 

[Shad_]

 

 

I'm turning this into a cass appreciation thread too.

Not sure if intentional derailing of discussion or genuine happiness.

My nihilism tells me it's derailing, we're going with that.

 

 

I should start a fan club.

I'm pretty sure the only games I have played with you are when your mafia. The nonchalant attitude is noticed...

 

Easy town points to make a post like this as scum. Not ruling out town alignment, but the extra 2 dots at the end makes it likelier to be scum.

 

Shad > Rand Town usually

Everyone is >rand town at the start of the game. This post suggests pocketing to me, scum points added.

 

 

 

Shad > Rand Town usually

wtf is this???

 

He is one of those good town reads based on intro.

 

From what I've read on Shad and the limited exposure I've had to him on MU (ATPG's Star Fox game) I couldn't disagree more.

 

@Andrej No, i'm not telling you it's a scum tell but it is something to watch more of.

Weak and fence-sitting. Everyone is worth watching more of at the moment. Posting just for the sake of posting.

 

 

Whats your read on me?

I don't know Zander, i usually wait for a flip to read you

 

Pocketing noted.

 

 

You know me and SHad are a Hydra right?

Yes, I acknowledged this before the rand so personally I will look at Shad mostly to read your slot.

 

Pocketing/derp clear attempt noticed, now backing off. Scum points added accordingly.

 

 

are you guys seriously going to vote me again for no reason -in fact before i've said anything?

 

btw thanks znader, i guess.

It was a joke vote and it's perfect for getting out of the blue reactions. It's helpful, and this is just a bit townie.

 

Not sure what a scum reaction would be. Do you give Sili so little credit as to out him/herself with their first post?

Reads fake.

 

 

thanks...was getting confused at first.

Just to let you know I have many more nicknames across the forum mafia world... Any hunches?

 

Trying to derail the thread again.

 

 

 

Conclusion, Celeste is scum.

 

[unvote]

[v]Celeste[/v]

 

[Shad_]

Tiink is a sneaky, sneaky sneakity.  I have a hard time trusting him.

 

I don't like the Believer train.

Yeah I'm not a huge fan of it.  He's weird but a playstyle I'm not accustomed to doesn't automatically = wolf.  If he is a wolf he's banking on massive WIFOM to bail him out after intentionally painting a dozen targets on his chest.

[Celeste]

Moderately awake now and caught up

[Hallia]

In discussing Dice, I can see him getting frustrated if he is at work by Believer not pulling up the quote for him, and voting.  Dice is a lot like me, emotional.  I could see him doing that as scum or town.

[Shad_]

Sili's sounded like his villager self when he gets into it with people but the lack of a broad focus is still sketching me out.  I think it's atypical of him and I've actually gotten a good night's sleep for a few consecutive days now so hopefully I'll be able to reread him tonight without spacing out every ten seconds.

[Shad_]

Out for a while though.

 

Penneh I need a lot more thoughts from you atp.

[Hallia]

We're discussing him.  I want to vote Sili, but I don't know that I have energy to go at it with him once I do.

[Celeste]

 

 

zander i can't even tell what you think my reasons for voting cass are, but it's self-contained in one post i make at the beginning, and it's real easy to follow. cass' reads were too strong for what she had to go on and i didn't like it.

 

and she hasn't changed my mind yet.

 

 

You said it was fluff at first, then she backtracked iirc?

no and no.

 

whether or not she technically backtracked has nothing to do with why i voted her since she backtracked after i voted her.

 

and i do not think you can cal much of cass' content fluff unless you mean she has fluff reasons for some reads and for voting me.

 

and as to her questioning me: i think the wildfire one is understandable.

 

as to her vote of me: it's clearly omgus, and afaict she's actually accusing me of poor progression: i'm not working enough with her and other people to advance my understanding of the thread.

Can you show the quote you think is poor progression?

[Celeste]

@Hallia What are your reads?

[Hallia]

1. Shander the DragonHawk (Shad_/Zander) - Townish

3. Sili Quirrels - Gut says scum.  Acting pretty sketch

4. Katiora - Null

5. Cass - Leaning town, I like her posts.

6. Andrej - Leaning town; defending himself pretty well, posts sound good (they always do, though)

7. Believer - Don't like the train building on him; I feel townish kinda on him, Nyn a bit less so, but we are not ready to lynch him.

8. Darooh (Darthe/Sooh) - Need more.

9. Tiinker - Need more, have only played the tail end of one game with him.  Not trusting by a long shot

10. Wildfire Sedai - NO CLUE

11. Lenlo - Need more, but what he has posted hasn't been terrible

12. Celeste - Null

13. dicetosser1 - On the fence about for both of us - He has done some things that we could see as coming from either alignment 

 

This is me off the cuff without recently discussing with my other head.  I will consult with her to see what she would change.

[Hallia]

@Celeste what are yours?

[Believer]

actually i DID iso you. Three times. I got no result every time. Why?? probably cause  i suck at isoing.

It is by far my longest post, I'll find it for you now if you can't see it.

 

As for time   while ure sitting at home twiddling ure thumbs waiting for morning its day time for me and im working in a 4000 call a day call centre for the courts. I type a few words here and there in the few seconds i get between calls. I post during my 10 min breaks and my lunch time. So if you wanna throw disinterested around I suggest you throw it else where.

I didn't assume the worst of you, I ask you to do me the same favour.

 

As for the vote. You say vote celeste but the thing i remember most is you just telling people to take it on faith. Thats really it. So i asked you to lay out your case in one simple post.

 

Apparently thats too hard.

I could say "I don't like her posting and I think it makes her scum."

 

Would that really sway your opinion though? Or would it be better to read my analysis of 90% of her posts up until that time?

 

Im failing to see the town train of thought in ure actions. You dont want to help me see the logic in ure thinking. So im thinking its NOT town thinking. Thasts why you dont want to explain it cause itd show up the flaws.

That's fine, that's your opinion. Ask yourself this though, would scum really put themselves out there as I have? What is there to gain?

 

then theres the fact that you FOS or Vote anyone who looks at you sideways   even your "TOP TOWN READ"

My top town read halfway into D1 with players I've never seen before is a pretty weak read, to be sure.

 

When it comes to mafia I'm more of "guilty until proven innocent" kind of guy. It helps me think.

[Hallia]

That's a pretty solid response, Bee

[Believer]

That's a pretty solid response, Bee

I've decided that I like good cop the best.

 

What up?

[Hallia]

Trying to sort through the hostility up in this mess to find some scumz. I really want to see Celeste's list.

[Nynaeve]

words hurt

[Hallia]

 

That's a pretty solid response, Bee

I've decided that I like good cop the best.

 

What up?

Better watch out, I can be feisty!

[Nynaeve]

Though I'm not exactly surprised. Halli is a a lot more popular in these parts for obvious reasons.

[Shad_]

 

1. Shander the DragonHawk (Shad_/Zander) - Townish

3. Sili Quirrels - Gut says scum.  Acting pretty sketch

4. Katiora - Null

5. Cass - Leaning town, I like her posts.

6. Andrej - Leaning town; defending himself pretty well, posts sound good (they always do, though)

7. Believer - Don't like the train building on him; I feel townish kinda on him, Nyn a bit less so, but we are not ready to lynch him.

8. Darooh (Darthe/Sooh) - Need more.

9. Tiinker - Need more, have only played the tail end of one game with him.  Not trusting by a long shot

10. Wildfire Sedai - NO CLUE

11. Lenlo - Need more, but what he has posted hasn't been terrible

12. Celeste - Null

13. dicetosser1 - On the fence about for both of us - He has done some things that we could see as coming from either alignment 

 

This is me off the cuff without recently discussing with my other head.  I will consult with her to see what she would change.

 

 

I can agree with pretty much all of that.  Wifi a little towny but not by much.  AJ closer to null for me.  A little paranoid that Cass is going all-in on buddying people but I think she's been generally villagery.  Penny sort of trending back down to null for me, still kinda maybe slight villa but I think I'm just destined to always find her early posts villagery whatever she rands.  Don't trust Believer but he's done more than anyone to generate discussion and I don't think that warrants being the top wagon.