[Basic]Spirited Away Mafia - Game over mafia wins

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

Sili is my biggest one. He has steered this lynch toward me since d1. He said earlier I wouldn't let go of the laine thing but if you Isi him you will see he kept on and kept on bringing it up and ignoring any of my current posts. All he's done all game is drag people through the mud until recently. He decid d to sheep Cory he didn't care. Why? Because the other 2 mafia aren't in the scum pool any more.

Dont bloody tdome me. U know where that goes dont you? Just lolcat pls. Less stress.

Not t-Domingo. And if you mean it ends with a mislynched vt so be it but at least then maybe my argument will be looked back at

You are.

 

No one will look back at your arguments. No villaher thinks thatll happen

[Cory Caboose]

My guess right now would be Kat/Hallia fwiw even though the latter breaks my heart to say

 

Though I need to look at Hallia's d1 again but on phone basically all day

 

Hallia is generally very reluctant to bus unless it's thread consensus so that's important to consider

 

A decent reason for Hallia/Wifi to be ruled out, and IIRC the WiFi push on d1 was while the BFG wagon still in the lead and Hallia actively pushed

 

I need to put time aside to reread. Would have to be tom. morning

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Well ya. I kind of do. Im best equipped to rd ppl like seph. I was constantly reevaluating him.

I meant if you think that somebody scumreading you is valid justification for voting them. Ever. Whether you can read him correctly doesn't matter.

Oh.

 

No.

[Cory Caboose]

I would wager that's why Clov has Hallia/Wifi unlikely or ruled out which I agree with

 

Which means Kat is a wolf in a vast majority of worlds

 

IIRC Halli's stance on Kat up until like late d2 was "Kat gets easier to read with time" framed in a sort of protective way

 

Also I think WiFi is a villager though I can't believe I am saying that

[Clovdyx]

 

There's a reasonable chance its kat/WF for horribly stupid reasons I probably won't ever discuss. But I still feel seph is the most 'correct' lynch

Now I'm curious :D

 

 

I mulled this over while I was laying down.  I figure the best to discuss it is probably sometime on D4 (besides postgame, maybe?), but I'll get it out of the way.

 

My thinking was basically...that Darthe shot seemed like a really, really poor kill.  I have a hard time imagining that it comes from a particularly experienced player more often than not.  And I know Kat has played quite a bit, I feel she's relatively inexperienced recently...and she was seemingly inactive, whereas we know Seph had been around quite a bit and I was thinking he would have pushed it in a difference direction.

 

TL;DR - newer mafia submitted a kill.  Team is either lacking leadership, or the more experienced people weren't available to help.

[Cory Caboose]

I could see Kat submitting the Darthe kill

 

She's from the era that respected Darthe greatly, he was pushing her IIRC and its likely Kat as a wolf hadn't digested enough of the thread to make a better shot

 

I imagine if WiFi was a wolf with her she wouldn't have argued with her

 

Doubt Hallia would as well bc she's a sweetheart

 

AJ, Sili or Clov almost certainly would override it

[Clovdyx]

I would wager that's why Clov has Hallia/Wifi unlikely or ruled out which I agree with

 

Which means Kat is a wolf in a vast majority of worlds

 

IIRC Halli's stance on Kat up until like late d2 was "Kat gets easier to read with time" framed in a sort of protective way

 

Also I think WiFi is a villager though I can't believe I am saying that

 

More of that Hallia seemed offended that Wifi's justification for scumreading her was that Hallia hadn't been active.  I would argue Hallia has been more active this game than she has in a lot of games.  She's been quieter lately and that's kind of why I'm not feeling nearly as good about her as I was early on, but Hallia early game was doing really well.

 

It's entirely possible Mafia!Hallia gets offended at being accused of being inactive if she felt she was playing a strong game.  I'm not sure possible Mafia!Hallia gets offended when she knows the person making it is her teammate (especially one who is new to THIS game, and the game as a whole) and therefore presumably just saying words.

[Cory Caboose]

I am pretty much ready to double down on it being either Kat/Hallia or Kat/Wifi

 

Which mean Kat is always a wolf

[Clovdyx]

I guess what I'm saying is Hallia's reaction seemed natural.  That doesn't make her town, but it suggests Hallia believed Wifi really felt that way.  If Hallia is town, she wouldn't know Wifi's alignment.  If Hallia is mafia, she's going to assume that Town!Wifi isn't lying about her thoughts.  

 

Mafia!Hallia knows Mafia!Wifi is being dishonest, at least to some level. 

[Clovdyx]

I would also argue it takes a ton of guts for somebody with 3 posts to call out their most active teammate for inactivity.  But I don't know Wildfire as a player or a person to say whether or not that applies.

[Cory Caboose]

#LynchAllLadies

[Cory Caboose]

Inb4 Clov's "but that's my least favorite thing to do"

[Regy Rusty]

Would Hallia accept a Darthe kill

 

I find it hard to believe Kat would send the request in without a consult

 

Would Hallia see value in shaking it up like that?

[Regy Rusty]

Or maybe she'd just do it purely to force us to think this way? Idk

 

Hallia/Kat sounds good to me

[Wildfire Sedai]

I would wager that's why Clov has Hallia/Wifi unlikely or ruled out which I agree with

 

Which means Kat is a wolf in a vast majority of worlds

 

IIRC Halli's stance on Kat up until like late d2 was "Kat gets easier to read with time" framed in a sort of protective way

 

Also I think WiFi is a villager though I can't believe I am saying that *

 

 

   your saying it cause its true...

 

 

#LynchAllLadies

 

Just remember to start at the beginning of the alphabet  

[Cory Caboose]

Hallia is a sweetheart and would probably not argue with a teammate and would go along with their wishes if they weren't totally crazy

 

I could see Kat being super nervous of Darthe and Hallia being happy to help alleviate whatever stress that caused, she's not a super crazy competitive type like me :D

 

If she is a wolf she gets props for an excellent game though, but with her volume level I feel like I'd be able to clear her by now and I can't :|

[Cory Caboose]

Funnily enough the post where Hallia laughs about the Darthe kill right after it happens is my only point of consternation regarding her slot right now

 

And I KNOW a wolf could fake that, but would Hallia?

[Regy Rusty]

If it is Hallia I'm mildly impressed with myself on picking up on SOMETHING all the way back on day 1

 

Lord knows I have no idea what it was tho -_-

[Cory Caboose]

WiFi I thought you had me as a wolf o.o

[Hallia]

And my opinion I clarified re:Kat today.

 

She's gotten easier alright, but I think she's scum. With the Seph flip, she could easily be scum with Wifi.

[Regy Rusty]

Funnily enough the post where Hallia laughs about the Darthe kill right after it happens is my only point of consternation regarding her slot right now

 

And I KNOW a wolf could fake that, but would Hallia?

Why wouldn't she?

[Hallia]

Hallia is a sweetheart and would probably not argue with a teammate and would go along with their wishes if they weren't totally crazy

 

I could see Kat being super nervous of Darthe and Hallia being happy to help alleviate whatever stress that caused, she's not a super crazy competitive type like me :D

 

If she is a wolf she gets props for an excellent game though, but with her volume level I feel like I'd be able to clear her by now and I can't :|

Sure I've been a bit quieter, but still active and giving my thoughts and opinions.

[Regy Rusty]

 

Hallia is a sweetheart and would probably not argue with a teammate and would go along with their wishes if they weren't totally crazy

 

I could see Kat being super nervous of Darthe and Hallia being happy to help alleviate whatever stress that caused, she's not a super crazy competitive type like me :D

 

If she is a wolf she gets props for an excellent game though, but with her volume level I feel like I'd be able to clear her by now and I can't :|

Sure I've been a bit quieter, but still active and giving my thoughts and opinions.

 

Probably a pointless question but I want an off the hip response:

 

If you'd gotten back and saw Seph's posts from this morning what would you have done?

[Wildfire Sedai]

WiFi I thought you had me as a wolf o.o

 

I did but then you explained why the others had cleared you, remember! we had a conversation about it.

[Clovdyx]

#LynchAllLadies

 

I'm DTF.

 

 

 

Doubting The Females.