[Basic] I <3 the 90's Mafia: Music Edition - TOWN WINS!

[wish-tree]

 

 

But why then bring it up at all? You brought it up as a way to doubt my doc claim. Which means that you believed in the cop claim. If you hadn´t believed my cop claim then you shouldn´t have brought it up at all.

 

 

I´m sure you will want to go back and forth about this but I´m sure that I´m right about this. If you want to talk about it more then do so to get others on your side. I won´t change my mind about you. 

because I thought you were scum at that point.

 

When you claimed doc, with reasons for thinking Hallia was town

 

No doc I've ever played with treated a save as lock town - and that's how I thought you were implying that Hallia was your save. But to me it looked like a more TMI relationship, which I found wolfy. 

 

 

If Niniel had protected Hallia, she would have no way of knowing whether she saved her or not.  This doesn't make any sense.

 

save = she put a protect on Hallia, not a successful protection from a NK, idk if phrasing was off or not

[Darthe]

That is so wrong. So you choose to turn my non excisting cop claim that you didn´t believe in against a doc claim that you didn´t believe in as a proof for not believing my doc claim? No, this is just wrong.

 

I hope someone understands my logic in this.

Yeah we do, its just bad play all around. Thats a hard pill to swallow as a result

[Darthe]

Dont worry, theres no way I let them kill you today

[Guest]

We have an hour left. 

 

I think I'm wtl Kat or Wish

[wish-tree]

We have an hour left. 

 

I think I'm wtl Kat or Wish

explain this?

 

Do you think we're both mafia?

[wish-tree]

this is why people think I'm bonkers

[wish-tree]

>.<

 

no bully pls

[wish-tree]

does any of that make sense to you guys?

[Clovdyx]

hm...

 

if anyone wants my 2 cents, and i dont put a lot of value in this

 

but lynch dice.

 

that's all i have to say.

 

This is where I'm at.  I'm still waiting for somebody to give me a reason to think anything I've said is wrong.  But I guess that would require people reading what I've said.

 

I'd be content with lynching Wish.  I think she's played it poorly either way, but in some weird fashion, everything she said at least fits with what's happened in the thread.  I think it's a lot of broken logic and really bad leaps.  But I will say this - I've played with Lenore very little, but she isn't exactly the most linear thinker.  So as much as it pains to me say it, I actually think she could be telling the truth.  I'm just not sold she is.

 

Kat would be my third choice.  She moved onto Besie after Niniel's claim, which makes a lot of sense if she believes it and Besie was her #2 candidate.  What is wrong is the fact she spoke out against other people doing the same.  If she actually believed that Besie is scum, she's not going to make people who are trying to lynch her look bad.

[BFG]

Besie, why did you change your mind on me?

[Sili Quirrels]

there is a distinction to be made between dropping an idea and dismissing it as implausible and it sounds as if wish wants to say the former sometimes when people are thinking she means the latter.

[wish-tree]

lol >.<

 

If you want to hear further things I've been thinking since day 1, I can share

 

day 1 I thought that BFG was always town because if dice really has really great gut reads, then as town he will read BFG as town, and as mafia, he TMI spewed her, to align with how he would play as town, but I believed in the first option b/c dice also thought Zander was scummy and that made a lot of sense in my mind. Also, Zander went after BFG, and they had a huge spat, with mostly inconclusive results, which made me think that dice was right about BFG being town, because I didn't think Zander and BFG were ever teamed. 

[Guest]

 

We have an hour left. 

 

I think I'm wtl Kat or Wish

explain this?

 

Do you think we're both mafia?

 

 

Not sure. 

 

Kat started feeling scummy to me on p147 - where she stated false facts about my actions. I asked her about it and I accepted her reasoning, but later on she brought one of these up again in a read list - which obviously meant what she had said wasn't true. I further didn't like some of her posts on p155.

 

With you it's just been the last few pages. I don't really make sense of the N0 stuff, and if you voted your thoughts of a cop which later change to doc or something which stiiillll makes no sense to me (that whole situation is a blob of goo) then... meh.

 

Of the two of you, I'd rather

 

[v]Katiora[/v], but I definitely have to find time to look into you.

[Hallia]

That's a throwaway vote imo, Besie

[wish-tree]

which is why I kept saying BFG was spewed town

 

and town read her >.<

[Darthe]

 

hm...

 

if anyone wants my 2 cents, and i dont put a lot of value in this

 

but lynch dice.

 

that's all i have to say.

This is where I'm at. I'm still waiting for somebody to give me a reason to think anything I've said is wrong. But I guess that would require people reading what I've said.

 

I'd be content with lynching Wish. I think she's played it poorly either way, but in some weird fashion, everything she said at least fits with what's happened in the thread. I think it's a lot of broken logic and really bad leaps. But I will say this - I've played with Lenore very little, but she isn't exactly the most linear thinker. So as much as it pains to me say it, I actually think she could be telling the truth. I'm just not sold she is.

 

Kat would be my third choice. She moved onto Besie after Niniel's claim, which makes a lot of sense if she believes it and Besie was her #2 candidate. What is wrong is the fact she spoke out against other people doing the same. If she actually believed that Besie is scum, she's not going to make people who are trying to lynch her look bad.

Your second choice sucks and completely countermends your past.

 

This list has no lenlo. No liz. This is a wolf clov list

[wish-tree]

 

hm...

 

if anyone wants my 2 cents, and i dont put a lot of value in this

 

but lynch dice.

 

that's all i have to say.

 

This is where I'm at.  I'm still waiting for somebody to give me a reason to think anything I've said is wrong.  But I guess that would require people reading what I've said.

 

I'd be content with lynching Wish.  I think she's played it poorly either way, but in some weird fashion, everything she said at least fits with what's happened in the thread.  I think it's a lot of broken logic and really bad leaps.  But I will say this - I've played with Lenore very little, but she isn't exactly the most linear thinker.  So as much as it pains to me say it, I actually think she could be telling the truth.  I'm just not sold she is.

 

Kat would be my third choice.  She moved onto Besie after Niniel's claim, which makes a lot of sense if she believes it and Besie was her #2 candidate.  What is wrong is the fact she spoke out against other people doing the same.  If she actually believed that Besie is scum, she's not going to make people who are trying to lynch her look bad.

 

 

omg it's not BROKEN LOGIC

I'm just making Ne leaps that you ENTJ with your lack of Ne can't understand :////

[Darthe]

Besie, why did you change your mind on me?

No choice if she wants to maintain any cover

[Sili Quirrels]

 

hm...

 

if anyone wants my 2 cents, and i dont put a lot of value in this

 

but lynch dice.

 

that's all i have to say.

 

This is where I'm at.  I'm still waiting for somebody to give me a reason to think anything I've said is wrong.  But I guess that would require people reading what I've said.

 

I'd be content with lynching Wish.  I think she's played it poorly either way, but in some weird fashion, everything she said at least fits with what's happened in the thread.  I think it's a lot of broken logic and really bad leaps.  But I will say this - I've played with Lenore very little, but she isn't exactly the most linear thinker.  So as much as it pains to me say it, I actually think she could be telling the truth.  I'm just not sold she is.

 

Kat would be my third choice.  She moved onto Besie after Niniel's claim, which makes a lot of sense if she believes it and Besie was her #2 candidate.  What is wrong is the fact she spoke out against other people doing the same.  If she actually believed that Besie is scum, she's not going to make people who are trying to lynch her look bad.

 

*shrug.

 

kat's been sort of in the background. its a warm and cozy place for wolves to hang out. seems a little circumstantial though.

 

if she's attacking ppl who also think besie is scum, and not their reasons for thinking besie is scum, then i have less of a problem with that than it seems you do.

 

 

i think the case might be superficial, personally, so i won't press for dice's lynch, but it seems to be the best one on market and dice is certainly acting weird.

 

different weird, but the sort of weird i could see him pursuing if he was a wolf and wanted to look like aggressive dice.

[Guest]

Besie, why did you change your mind on me?

 

Originally; because my strong town reads believed you town.

 

Now...

 

I'd say that it feels like you're trying to solve the game, but that statement doesn't fully cover it.

It just feels like you're looking at everything from perspectives that the rest of us are not seeing, or at least not stating out loud. ... I don't know. This means something to me.

[Clovdyx]

 

We have an hour left. 

 

I think I'm wtl Kat or Wish

explain this?

 

Do you think we're both mafia?

 

 

This wasn't to me, but I basically said the same thing, so I'm going to address where I'm at.

 

I don't think you two are scum together.  If you were, she's not going to vote somebody and see you immediately vote the same person and try to make you look bad - especially before the flip.  The "townie" (read: teammate) thing to do might be to make you look bad when Besie flips town, but she's not while Besie's alignment is still up in the air.  

 

I think the way you've played certain things this game - your reasons for the Seph vote, following Darthe and then apparently flipping on him and not really doing much to try to get him lynched, the whole trust/suspect/tinfoil/trust/lynch thing with Niniel - give you a pretty reasonable chance to be mafia.  

[Guest]

That's a throwaway vote imo, Besie

 

What do you mean? 

[wish-tree]

that's why still idk on Dice

 

but regardless of his alignment, I think BFG is town

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

hm...

 

if anyone wants my 2 cents, and i dont put a lot of value in this

 

but lynch dice.

 

that's all i have to say.

This is where I'm at. I'm still waiting for somebody to give me a reason to think anything I've said is wrong. But I guess that would require people reading what I've said.

 

I'd be content with lynching Wish. I think she's played it poorly either way, but in some weird fashion, everything she said at least fits with what's happened in the thread. I think it's a lot of broken logic and really bad leaps. But I will say this - I've played with Lenore very little, but she isn't exactly the most linear thinker. So as much as it pains to me say it, I actually think she could be telling the truth. I'm just not sold she is.

 

Kat would be my third choice. She moved onto Besie after Niniel's claim, which makes a lot of sense if she believes it and Besie was her #2 candidate. What is wrong is the fact she spoke out against other people doing the same. If she actually believed that Besie is scum, she's not going to make people who are trying to lynch her look bad.

Your second choice sucks and completely countermends your past.

 

This list has no lenlo. No liz. This is a wolf clov list

 

thanks for the water darthe. needed it.

 

frowns at clov* =/

[Clovdyx]

 

 

hm...

 

if anyone wants my 2 cents, and i dont put a lot of value in this

 

but lynch dice.

 

that's all i have to say.

This is where I'm at. I'm still waiting for somebody to give me a reason to think anything I've said is wrong. But I guess that would require people reading what I've said.

 

I'd be content with lynching Wish. I think she's played it poorly either way, but in some weird fashion, everything she said at least fits with what's happened in the thread. I think it's a lot of broken logic and really bad leaps. But I will say this - I've played with Lenore very little, but she isn't exactly the most linear thinker. So as much as it pains to me say it, I actually think she could be telling the truth. I'm just not sold she is.

 

Kat would be my third choice. She moved onto Besie after Niniel's claim, which makes a lot of sense if she believes it and Besie was her #2 candidate. What is wrong is the fact she spoke out against other people doing the same. If she actually believed that Besie is scum, she's not going to make people who are trying to lynch her look bad.

Your second choice sucks and completely countermends your past.

 

This list has no lenlo. No liz. This is a wolf clov list

 

 

Why the hell would Lenlo be on it?