[Advanced]Lost mafia - Game over - Sili, SK wins!

[Darthe]

Darthe...have you read the thread, yet? A lot of your posts have been responding to something without reading the thread.

That's what I do, I pop in and go to whatever I see on my way to the ladylast page and I respond to it. It's a simple way to go.

[Zander?]

 

Hi Darthe. Have you posted your WTL yet? Or did i miss it

Nope, dont have enough handle to do one right yet

 

 

How about now?

 

 

 

You really like that post? Its kinda rote isnt it?

That depends. What's rote?

By the numbers

 

 

You got a read on me yet?

[Zander?]

 

 

It's not what I'd expect you to say, it's how is expect you to interact. And I'm not seeing it

 

 

 

This is what I get for passing on mobile with a now-mobile one year old distracting me. Meant to finish that first sentence with "anyone else"? Or are the rest of us here?

 

For now: [v]zander[/v]

Raisins?

You and Hally seem to be avoiding each other. Considering how well you read each other, that suggests one or both of you may be a wolf

Spoilered below is Hallia's ISO.

 

What do you expect me to say atp?

 

Her activity level is off from what I expect Town!Hallia to be.

 

But I've misread Hallia twice. 1st was in Friends, right after GnD where she powered hard as a Doc in that game and then lands a PR in Friends and completely slow rolls it. The other was where I was playing a game I shouldnt have been with RL stuffs, Darthe and Lainey misread me as Town vote me and then just stop doing stuff without real cases and Hallia buddied me and I just kept going after her.

 

As Ive said in the last game and many times before that, Hallia becomes very easy to read as the game progresses.

 

And the bold would NEVER happen. If we were w/w we'd intsa buddy Town read each other and I think everyone here who knows that.

 

 

Checking in. Will read up when I get home.

Only caught up to page 5

 

 

Similarly town, nice to have you shad! And... Nyn?

Hey pooper face

THAT IS MY LINE, NYN

Bessie, if you actually randed town you would tell us, right?

I don't know that I like this question, as it has been said by Nynners, what do you expect her to say??

 

I don't like this, I am already agreeing with darthe. I also like him the best so far.

eww

Agree. Prolly gonna vote Seph again.

 

That entire post made me laugh thane. I have to be more wary of you now, you tricked me pretty well last game.

 

 

Bessie, if you actually randed town you would tell us, right?

I'd give you the same answer I would as wolf, yes.

Which is also the answer I gave you when we first played together.

Wolfy imo

I don't like this, I am already agreeing with darthe. I also like him the best so far.

It's really cute how you always try to find the wolves between the actual active posters.

Not sure what this mean; are you saying he should look from the inactive posters? o.O

Turin and Seph initial good feelz for a spot of shop talk and getting things going.

 

Darthe trolling accomplished.

 

 

Now where's my Halli?

I'm heeeeere

 

 

 

That entire post made me laugh thane. I have to be more wary of you now, you tricked me pretty well last game.

 

 

Bessie, if you actually randed town you would tell us, right?

I'd give you the same answer I would as wolf, yes.

Which is also the answer I gave you when we first played together.

Wolfy imo

I don't like this, I am already agreeing with darthe. I also like him the best so far.

It's really cute how you always try to find the wolves between the actual active posters.

So would you rather me not question anyone?

I am pointing out a resemblance is all, but I find this reaction pretty cute as well :)

 

wtf is Saiyan?

GET OUT ZANDER, HOW DARE YOU. Saiyans are amazing.

Gotta cut it short tonight but I'll keep reading up tomorrow.

Trying to read up on the way to work. Too much I wanna quote. Will do so at work.

 

 

Im not really following, I cant interact when the person isnt here.

 

But let me ask you this then, youre voting me and not Hallia so what else have I done to ping you and why are you not voting Hallia instead?

 

 

1) Sure you can.  That's basically the definition of "message board"

 

2) Nothing else, and no reason at all.

 

 

 

Meh

 

Have you mentioned anyone else this game?

 

Cause Ive not seen the Town!Kiv from last game at all here.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

You really like that post? Its kinda rote isnt it?

That depends. What's rote?

By the numbers

 

 

I still don't get it, but okay.

 

Looks to me like under Kiv's consideration, Halli and Zander are like the new Verbal and Leelou, which is sort of accurate (minus the googly eyes). But him focusing on Zander without addressing Halli at all (at least, I don't remember he did) is a good point and I liked that Zander made it. 

 

 

Agreed.  Zander was around, so he was the one I picked to vote, to see how he reacted to pressure.  I've generally liked his response - and genuinely dislike [v]Hally's[/v].  Maybe I'm wrong, but she is not coming across very genuine to me, and even when she is around she's really not doing the type of interacting I typically see from her as town.  Zander is more in his normal town range, AFAICT on D1, so of the two I'll vote her.

 

Don't really have strong feelings on anyone as scum right now, so this is the best I've got.  And now I'm out, and since it's a Friday, probably won't be back before deadline

 

 

You should be cause I think I kinda might wanna lynch you.

[Darthe]

 

Wolves have the least say on D1 usually, so id argue that they havent had a ton of impact on the votes being spread. Theyre more likely just being opportunistic here.

 

Which begs rhe question of which of those votes are opportunistic.

Darthe you wolfing?

Maybe, but if so it's a poor reflection of my alignment

[Zander?]

Very nice, drop say vote and run without commenting on why my catchup was ungenuine.

 

:eyeroll:

 

Hallia why am I not Town reading you yet iyo?

[Darthe]

 

 

Hi Darthe. Have you posted your WTL yet? Or did i miss it

Nope, dont have enough handle to do one right yet

How about now?

 

 

You really like that post? Its kinda rote isnt it?

That depends. What's rote?

By the numbers

You got a read on me yet?

Dont badger me for reads, you know fully well im capable.

[Darthe]

Z y u try take over thread?

[Zander?]

Was gut feeling at that time.

 

Now... I don't know.

 

Is Hallia still your top Scum read?

 

Thoughts on Kiv and Darthe?

[Zander?]

 

 

Wolves have the least say on D1 usually, so id argue that they havent had a ton of impact on the votes being spread. Theyre more likely just being opportunistic here.

 

Which begs rhe question of which of those votes are opportunistic.

Darthe you wolfing?

Maybe, but if so it's a poor reflection of my alignment

 

 

I dont know if i wanna lololololol or vote you....or both,

[Zander?]

 

 

 

Hi Darthe. Have you posted your WTL yet? Or did i miss it

Nope, dont have enough handle to do one right yet

How about now?

 

 

You really like that post? Its kinda rote isnt it?

That depends. What's rote?

By the numbers

You got a read on me yet?

Dont badger me for reads, you know fully well im capable.

 

 

You are capable.

 

Give some.

[Zander?]

Z y u try take over thread?

 

Because someone has to.

 

I prefer to be more supportive or secondary Town leader but I will step up and do what I need to do for my Town.

[seph]

[Darthe]

 

 

 

 

Hi Darthe. Have you posted your WTL yet? Or did i miss it

 

Nope, dont have enough handle to do one right yet

How about now?

 

 

You really like that post? Its kinda rote isnt it?

 

That depends. What's rote?

By the numbers

You got a read on me yet?

Dont badger me for reads, you know fully well im capable.

 

You are capable.

 

Give some.

Youll get them when im ready and not before.

[Darthe]

 

Z y u try take over thread?

 

 

Because someone has to.

 

I prefer to be more supportive or secondary Town leader but I will step up and do what I need to do for my Town.

I disagree. Let the thread exist in its natural state, you're forcing things atm.

[Zander?]

Just went through Shad's ISO.

 

 

 

I humbly accept Seph as the intro phase boss of my village.

 

 

Thoughts on anyone besides Besie/Seph/Thane?  What is your take on me atm?

 

 

 

ya hurt mah feelz ...

Ugh... I feel like I've been reading you scum lately no matter what you rand. Maybe soon I'll figure out some substantial means to solve you, and not only something arbitrary mate. I dunno. For now, sleep!

 

 

 

 

 

Zander, I feel pretty good about calling you a villager.  Solve me so we can get something productive going today.

 

Thoughts on Thane?

 

I think you said you wanted to hear my response to Kiv irt Hallia, thoughts on that as well?

 

 

I think the "if we were w/w we'd town read each other" statement is probably true, and tbf Hallia has posted very little regardless of how I felt about it.  I kind of expected more of an opinion out of you irt her multi-quote post, but we'll see what happens when she has more to say.

 

Thane reads me a lot better than I read Thane, and really well in general.  He knows that, and I suppose he might call me town here whatever his alignment, but it hasn't felt like buddying at all.  It's felt like standing behind a strong opinion, not directly sucking up to me.  I'm not feeling any agenda in him and I want to call him town.

 

 

 

People who are probably villagers:

Zander
Turin
Eldrick
Seph
Besie? -- want to skim an ISO of her last game
Thane

 

 

I added the seph comment for context.

 

Anyone thinking a Shad/Thane Mason team makes sense still......

[Zander?]

 

 

Z y u try take over thread?

 

Because someone has to.

 

I prefer to be more supportive or secondary Town leader but I will step up and do what I need to do for my Town.

I disagree. Let the thread exist in its natural state, you're forcing things atm.

 

 

Are you even reading the thread?

[Celeste]

Part two of reread (I don't want to make a massive wall of text, so I'm breaking it up)

 

 

 

 

It's really cute how you always try to find the wolves between the actual active posters.

 

Why is this a bad thing?

It isn't.

 

 

 

 

It's really cute how you always try to find the wolves between the actual active posters.

 

Not sure what this mean; are you saying he should look from the inactive posters?  o.O

Euhm.... just lol.

We literally just played a game with him where he was town. What did he do? He tried to find out who the scum were. That's kinda the point, right? So that's the first part of my sentence.

Second part of the sentence is referring to, once again, the game we just played (and pretty much all mafia games ever). When someone is inactive it does not make them town. We are 15 people in this game atm. At that point in time like 5 people (#themathishard) were actively talking.

My post didn't say anything alignment - wise. It simply stated the obvious.

Which apparently isn't very obvious to you.

 

 

Your post about seph looking for wolves in the active players is still bugging me, and I clearly wasn't the only one that it bothered. Yes, you were pointing out the obvious. The question is why. What was the point of mentioning this? Of course he's going to look for scum in the active players.

  Is it just looking at the active players though sometimes I find the inactive players need the same pushes active players get at times.

 

 

 

 

 

It's really cute how you always try to find the wolves between the actual active posters.

Why is this a bad thing?

It isn't.

 

 

It's really cute how you always try to find the wolves between the actual active posters.

Not sure what this mean; are you saying he should look from the inactive posters? o.O

Euhm.... just lol.

We literally just played a game with him where he was town. What did he do? He tried to find out who the scum were. That's kinda the point, right? So that's the first part of my sentence.

Second part of the sentence is referring to, once again, the game we just played (and pretty much all mafia games ever). When someone is inactive it does not make them town. We are 15 people in this game atm. At that point in time like 5 people (#themathishard) were actively talking.

My post didn't say anything alignment - wise. It simply stated the obvious.

Which apparently isn't very obvious to you.

Your post about seph looking for wolves in the active players is still bugging me, and I clearly wasn't the only one that it bothered. Yes, you were pointing out the obvious. The question is why. What was the point of mentioning this? Of course he's going to look for scum in the active players.

What's the point of mentioning anything? Have you not been giving your opinion on random posts? Or are you just critisizing one of the few people that actually do? I do not think the same way you do. I look for reads in different places; in different ways.

And that, is what makes mafia work. We're supposed to work together and find the one person that everyone has as scum, albeit for different reasons. If you are completely against a vote because you don't like their reasoning, rather than having your own reasons for thinking them town? Then I have nothing to say to you.

  

This makes me feel a bit better about Besie

 

The above post alone practically guarantees town elrick. Havent read up yet, just saw that and wanted to comment.

I haven't played with Eldrick enough but how does that "guarantee" him?

[seph]

lynch all masons imo. no but if they claim I will still unvote and let night actions sort it out. even if shad had thane at the bottom of his town list...

[Zander?]

Penneh Ive noticed youve gone anonymous this game....

 

Any particular reason....

[Zander?]

lynch all masons imo. no but if they claim I will still unvote and let night actions sort it out. even if shad had thane at the bottom of his town list...

 

What????

[seph]

im not going to lynch a maso claim on d1 lol. sorry, but i think it is dumb.
do I think there ever masons, no. But it doesn't mean thane isn't a pr.
also [unvote] for now

[Celeste]

 

 

Bessie, if you actually randed town you would tell us, right?

 

Do you honestly think she would just state it?

 

besie is the new cass

 

vote wolfqueen 

 

 

 

gives nyn a shoulder massage to help her stay zen

 

Are you really doing policy lynches now?

 

 

then why do it?

 

Because we all instinctively get a few positive and negative vibes right off the bat and have learned to disregard them, but when asked we can still state them?

I think disregarding those vibes lead to bad judgement by end game.

 

Thats all you have to say?

I'm doing it in parts. Just the quotes that stand out to me.

[Eldrick4221]

Not feeling Darthe. I don't like his pop in posts, and I count at least 2 questions directed at him that he hasn't responded to.

 

Not getting a towny vibe from him at all. It's of course possible that he's unhelpful town. It happens. But I think he might be scum.

 

[V]Darthe [/v]

[Zander?]

im not going to lynch a maso claim on d1 lol. sorry, but i think it is dumb.

do I think there ever masons, no. But it doesn't mean thane isn't a pr.

also [unvote] for now

 

Have they claimed tho?