[Advanced]Lost mafia - Game over - Sili, SK wins!

[seph]

Good point, though we don't know if that is town based or not.

[dicetosser1]

im concerned with the amount of pr's we have.

 

masons shad-thane

bus driver- turin

investigation role

sili-

me-

 

That leaves

 

Dice

lenlo

z2

darthe

eldrick

celeste

so what ure saying is u have no reason for voting me.

 

noted

[Celeste]

IT WORKS! I only have an hour at most and need to catch up.

[Shad_]

Yeah I'm going to catch-up/reply and peace out for the night.

[Celeste]

Eldrick that is a horrible reason to vote me. Have you not noticed I have been saying "I'm busy this game and low activity" I don' like the reason you have.

[Celeste]

@Seph what are your reads currently?

[Shad_]

 

Oh. Shad. You asked something about feelings between Zander1.0 and Zander2.0

 

I feel like Zander2.0 hasn't been around much, and that worries me.

 

Zander 457 Shad_ 399 Sili Quirrels 327 BlomBesie 282 Lenlo 236 Eldrick4221 205 Turin Turambar 191 seph 186 Darthe 136 Nynaeve 101 dicetosser1 96 Thane Vakarian 95 Celeste 69 Sooh 50 Hallia 35 Kivam 30

 

Wanna try that again Eld?

 

Also according to the CCSoHW Penny prolly Scum.

 

 

Quoting your total posts for both slots in response to an accusation that your second slot has been less active doesn't make any sense.

 

Zander 1 posted 275 times from start of D1 to end of N1.  Zander 2 posted 202 times from the start of D2 to the end of N2 (and only 161 times when Eldrick made his comment).  It was a noticeable difference.

[Sili Quirrels]

what's eldrick's reason to vote you celeste?

[Thane Vakarian]

She hasn't been obvious town throughout the game and her EoD was bad, IF I got that right. Fwiw, he's right, though.

[Sili Quirrels]

She hasn't been obvious town throughout the game and her EoD was bad, IF I got that right. Fwiw, he's right, though.

I know he is, and Celeste didn't respond to the crux of Eldrick's 'case' - not really a case though. Therefore I asked her, and therefore you gave her the answer. Congrats.

[Thane Vakarian]

i'm just stating the obvious. IMO, it's a weak defense that she has. She is on the WTL list of a lot of people, and I do think there's a wolf in her slot. 

 

She was more... fiesty... as town the previous games she was in, in my opinion.

 

[v] Celeste [/v]

[Sili Quirrels]

I'm starting my reread. Going to put severl ppl on ignore for this.

[Thane Vakarian]

I'm starting my reread. Going to put severl ppl on ignore for this.

i don't even know how to do that... 

[Thane Vakarian]

now... DM must have been down, seeing the 'low' number of posts after the nightphase had ended...

 

No real speculation yet about why nobody died... hm... Doc could have protected one. but SK holstering? That'd be unlikely imo. If both scum and SK (speculating) would target the same player, he'd still be dead, right? Makes me wonder if scum could have had 1 extra shot and there's no SK. 

[Shad_]

i already know it turin   i only argued about how often you see a town BD

 

on DM ive only seen one i can think of

 

I can get you an official answer on that.

 

Gimme like... four months.  Pause game?

[Thane Vakarian]

 

i already know it turin   i only argued about how often you see a town BD

 

on DM ive only seen one i can think of

 

I can get you an official answer on that.

 

Gimme like... four months.  Pause game?

 

It would be the longest game ever on DM if we pause for 4 months

[Eldrick4221]

I didn't get a chance to clarify before work because of cloudflare. Gonna pop in quickly while at work.

 

It's not zander2.0's post count that bothers me. I wanted to compare the 2 just to know the numbers, but it's his comparative thread presense that is the issue. D1 Zander was noticable. D2 not so much.

[Shad_]

You could divide by half so a per day total.

 

Then take away 100 posts and say they were d1 extras

You can surely understand that a 100 post difference will stand out, and the content of the posts matter too. I think for all the D1 joking you were pretty on point with trying to discern people's alignment, vs D2 you spoke on a number of tangents.

[Eldrick4221]

The thing that sticks out to me about nyn/Zander though is nyn's initial post.

 

It feels to me like she was referring to getting town. I'm not usually one to look into initial reactions, but I keep seeing it when I go back to pg1 for player list.

 

It's a point in zander's favor for me.

[Shad_]

[V]celeste

 

Glad noone got killed. Yes, all I have to stick her with is her slimy eod, but it was bad enough for a vote.

 

She hasn't been town this game. I really think she's scum.

Any thoughts on her posts since EoD?

[Shad_]

 

masons mightt be the investigation role.

nope. 

If they are in fact just masons, we have a investigation role.

 

Good luck explaining this post if you turn out to be mafia lol.

[Thane Vakarian]

 

 

masons mightt be the investigation role.

nope. 

If they are in fact just masons, we have a investigation role.

 

Good luck explaining this post if you turn out to be mafia lol.

 

odd wording indeed.... slip?

[Shad_]

@ Thane I don't think scum waste a shot on a lynchable vanilla town Kivam. I mean, it's possible but really really derp.

 

Doc save could stop doubletaps. I've seen it often enough. Kiv could have been a town vig shot. Kiv could have been from an SK who's holstering to claim town vig later. SK could be holstering because they're as screwed as the rest of us if mafia gain majority and they wanted another phase to think about it. Mafia could have hit a SK with a bpv and SK could have hit a docced target. Etc etc etc there are a ton of possibilities and I think scum burning a 1x bonus kill on Kivam is towards the bottom of them.

[Shad_]

 

 

If they are in fact just masons, we have a investigation role.

Good luck explaining this post if you turn out to be mafia lol.

 

odd wording indeed.... slip?

 

I'm an idiot.

 

I missed the word "If" when I read it the first time.

 

I thought he was claiming hard knowledge of other people's roles. Nevermind.

[Shad_]

I still think it's a bold assumption but whatever.