the Hunt for the Dragon Reborn [Standard Mafia] Game Over town wins

[Darthe]

Weak town read on Zander. I don't think he would keep his vote on me as a wolf, knowing it would be a mislynch and scrutiny would follow.

 

Shad has a bit of an "eager puppy" vibe going on right now, and he hasn't to my knowledge taken any stances on anyone. This makes me suspicious of him.

 

I don't know how I feel about Turin's town lean on me. That alone doesn't make me want to accuse him of TMI, and given his suspicions of Shad I'll leave him as neutral at this point. Like, there are things telling me he's town and things telling me he's scum, but right now nothing weighs more than the other in my eyes anyway.

 

Dice is similarly quite null for me, given him saying he doesn't think it's alignment indicative and hasn't made a conclusion based on it.

 

Cory I have no clue on (I literally typed your name as Cosy). Could go either way at the moment.

 

That's it at the moment.

[V] sooh [/v] I remember teaching you to do this as a wolf. Commit to something but tone it down.if If people challenge it, so you dont backtrack but also soften them up some. Tends to work over time and youve been consistent in it.

[Darthe]

Yep this has been a town Cory game so far.

Who are you?

[Cory Caboose]

You just wait, I'll be burying SickPuppets any minute now

[Darthe]

You just wait, I'll be burying SickPuppets any minute now

SP is here? =)

[Cory Caboose]

No he's dead

 

I mislynched him n0 for participating because he only does it as a wolf

[Calder]

 

Yep this has been a town Cory game so far.

Who are you?

I am what I am. Someone has to be.

[Darthe]

In intensely fewer words: I think if Sooh is scum there was definitely town spew in those two posts. I don't have any lean one way or the other on her atm. I don't think #94 was indicative of jack, because town!Sooh rolls into games with a chip on her shoulder sometimes for reasons I will never understand, while scum!Sooh is pretty jacked because people are already looking at her slanteyed and she doesn't recognize the game-related reason for it.

 

The takeaway is I'm null on her moving forward and, if she's scum, Cory Zander and Turin are all > rand town.

Pick a side for the point of arguing thks.next thing or, hell, both for all I care. You're saying Sooh is null but if wolf then c+z+t town% ^. If you extrapolate that all of those are true then what would that indicate to you about the rest of the players in the game?

[Darthe]

I'll do you better, here's four:

 

Turin middling v

Thane light v

Zander light v

Hallia light v

 

Off the top of my head.

 

I reserve the right to change this later as these are all players I read far better with more volume, but this is my inkling.

K this is comfy enough, but how do you get thane to light as opposed to muddled? Also, already trying to ignore scum sweep vibes from this game. Its a personal problem

[Shad_]

I'm...  not sure what you're getting at.

 

That 2 out of 8 of them are scum.  ..... ?

[Darthe]

I really liked what Cory said. It comes from a good place, I think.

Yeah this is town hally

[Darthe]

I'm... not sure what you're getting at.

 

That 2 out of 8 of them are scum. ..... ?

Play it out. If she is a wolf and they are town how does it inform your reads list as a whole?

[Darthe]

Gut, for now, says:

 

Zander good

Hallia good

Sooh frustrated townie

Turin looking ok, but still cautious

Shad alright; for now

Cory (Wanna make Zan jealous)

Taking the "everyone is town" route. Subtle.

[Cory Caboose]

 

I'll do you better, here's four:

 

Turin middling v

Thane light v

Zander light v

Hallia light v

 

Off the top of my head.

 

I reserve the right to change this later as these are all players I read far better with more volume, but this is my inkling.

K this is comfy enough, but how do you get thane to light as opposed to muddled? Also, already trying to ignore scum sweep vibes from this game. Its a personal problem

 

 

Thane has a leak I don't feel like discussing right now and I've seen bits of it and I'll be 100% sure by EOD I think.

 

This is a "trust me on this for now" type read and I'll reassess as I feel necessary.

[Darthe]

By page 13 I kinda wanna roll with sooh as wolf just cause it's simple and I can see it. Id also go Thane or Dice.

[Darthe]

Sick, love that myndshare

[Cory Caboose]

There is exactly one dice post I am struggling with that makes me think he could be a villager.

Literally the rest of his posts make me want to bury him and never look back.

[Cory Caboose]

I'm through page 13:

 

Zander

Shad

 

Hallia

Thane

 

Turin

 

everyone else

 

Dice

[Shad_]

 

I'm... not sure what you're getting at.

 

That 2 out of 8 of them are scum. ..... ?

Play it out. If she is a wolf and they are town how does it inform your reads list as a whole?

 

It would leave two scum in Tina, Hallia, Kat, Verb, Dice, Darthe, Turin, Calder

 

Of which I have Tina you Calder and maybe Hallia leaning townish, so remaining POE of Kat Verb Dice Turin.

 

And I think I'm hedging towards town with Turin but I need to take my time and reread his case on me.

 

But I feel silly speculating this far in advance, and I have a feeling this isn't the sort of answer you're getting at anyway.

[Darthe]

I think this game has significant GOAT village equity as well as potential WOAT village equity.

 

Should be a fun game.

By this post ive decided to call you town today and reassess later

[Cory Caboose]

So you're killing me tonight?

Good to know

[Verbal32]

Thru p16 - I have not read anything since my last post.

 

 

Well that's part of what I'm saying

 

She goes from:

 

Excited about the game let's post -> Why are people townreading Cory? What's this Cory/Shad/Zander/Thane/Hallia thing?  -> This game pisses me off because people are being inclusive and biased

 

It's such a quick tonal switch it's totally got my brain running in circles

 

Again I don't believe in condemning someone for a single post because sometimes stuff happens and sometimes I can't see things correctly, but I'm absolutely not going to village read her for it.

 

I understand your point here, but I disagree with it.  I think she's probably town because of that post.  There is literally no reason a scum player would post something like that if they think about it before they post.  And I feel that townies are more likely to make posts without thinking about them in advance.  I may be grossly over-simplifying my thoughts about this, but that's my read.

 

 

 

I would apologize for just dropping in now. But that was a horrible read so i say we are even.

Dice is most likely to be scum from the read. Not bc of the defense being fishy or anything, but that for me it feels like exactly what scumCalder would want to defend. Sooh's posting felt obv non game related and not indicative, so as scum i would want to be on the side to call people out for not seeing that.

 

Ironic, because as scum I'd want to call people out for 'calling people out for not seeing that'.  ;-)

 

 

^ I think that made sense.  Maybe.

 

 

 

Now that we have some real content let's try to keep the volume manageable for those who are multi-tabling / haven't check in yet / have missed most of the game (Verb/Kat/Tina/Darthe)

 

I think I want a fresh perspective on things before I go much further and I don't want them drowned out because we suddenly have 30 pages before they even get in the game.

 

 

I understand the irony. Some of this is a note to self.

 

 

Appreciate that, and I chuckled at the spoiler, heh.

 

 

 

Wait, did you just say you would call someone on arguing over who is online when?

 

I cringed IRL.

 

 

 

That said, maybe I do have a read after all.

 

Shad: slight mafia.

 

It´s strange that he didn´t comment on Turin´s post at first and his reason for voting Dice is a bit thin.

 

This is a very vague read. I´m not at all ready to vote for him yet. But it´s all I have right now.

 

 

Turin - I see what you are saying about Thane. I will think about it.

 

The only thing I noticed with Shad is that he was very happy to joke around with Cory, Zander, etc. and make the "let's wreck wolves" kinda posts......which is fine.....but then he seems to step back and want to very lightly go back and forth with Cory and if I read deeper into that, maybe it stems from Sooh's post.  Actually, I think I'm reading too much into that - I'm going to look back as some posts are blurring together.

[Shad_]

And I think I'm hedging towards town with Turin but I need to take my time and reread his case on me.

Probably not going to happen before my kid goes to bed tonight fwiw

[Cory Caboose]

I understand your point here, but I disagree with it.  I think she's probably town because of that post.  There is literally no reason a scum player would post something like that if they think about it before they post.  And I feel that townies are more likely to make posts without thinking about them in advance.  I may be grossly over-simplifying my thoughts about this, but that's my read.

 

I think this is totally fair BTW.

 

I literally have no clue on Sooh but my complete lack of desire to pursue her is probably meaningful.

 

I just don't know.

[Shad_]

The only thing I noticed with Shad is that he was very happy to joke around with Cory, Zander, etc. and make the "let's wreck wolves" kinda posts......which is fine.....but then he seems to step back and want to very lightly go back and forth with Cory and if I read deeper into that, maybe it stems from Sooh's post.  Actually, I think I'm reading too much into that - I'm going to look back as some posts are blurring together.

This is a pretty keen observation.

[Darthe]

 

 

I'm... not sure what you're getting at.

 

That 2 out of 8 of them are scum. ..... ?

Play it out. If she is a wolf and they are town how does it inform your reads list as a whole?

It would leave two scum in Tina, Hallia, Kat, Verb, Dice, Darthe, Turin, Calder

 

Of which I have Tina you Calder and maybe Hallia leaning townish, so remaining POE of Kat Verb Dice Turin.

 

And I think I'm hedging towards town with Turin but I need to take my time and reread his case on me.

 

But I feel silly speculating this far in advance, and I have a feeling this isn't the sort of answer you're getting at anyway.

Nah, I just wanted to see the follow through for now and see if youd be able and validate that train of thought. It works for now though maybe later id like something else.