[Advanced] Gods and Demons Mafia - All your souls belong to Shad (Triads win)

[Lenlo]

Sounds like a hard place to sleep

[csarmi]

No monstrman

No cry

[monstrman]

[v]Turin[/v]

[Lenlo]

[v]Turin[/v]

There goes my one and only admirer. I will miss you. Come again!

[monstrman]

 

[v]Turin[/v]

There goes my one and only admirer. I will miss you. Come again!

 

 

Don't think I've forgotten about the fact that you said that me gauging people's reactions was a bad thing

[monstrman]

That said, I don't have any real reason to believe you're more likely scum than not right now and I want to pursue other options

[Lenlo]

 

 

[v]Turin[/v]

There goes my one and only admirer. I will miss you. Come again!

 

 

Don't think I've forgotten about the fact that you said that me gauging people's reactions was a bad thing

 

Its kinda worrying if its all youve done. I look forward to your results from the gauging.

[Hallia]

So going back on Calder - Spoilered for size.

 

 

 

 

 

And I realized I have an answer.

Scummiest to me was calder. I don't know him. I don't know if that talk of having a mafia qt was a joke or not, but it was really weird, and it might be a joking not joking ploy.

Calder is like that. He naturally plays scummy. If you want to go look at him in the other game he played where he was town, we kinda lynched him for saying those types of things. But they're pretty much null.  http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/95406-age-of-legends-standard-mafia-day-3/
 

 

Initially I agreed on the null.  I didn't know how to read his play with the claiming.

 

 

It is prob John Snow. Chief evidence = we all think its Pral.

Considering my read on Snow I don't hate this.

Everyone is getting distracted from the true enemy. Manbat. Trying to insert himself as the voice of reason. I know what he is selling. It may be discounted, but I still aint buying.

I didn't really see him as the voice of reason, but meh.

 

As a side note, Laine!

 

I'M GOING TO BE IN SC IN THREE MONTHS!

Oohhhh where you going? Near meee?

 

Everyone is getting distracted from the true enemy. Manbat. Trying to insert himself as the voice of reason. I know what he is selling. It may be discounted, but I still aint buying.

What's your case against Monstr? I think he's been pretty townie thus far, he tends to fit in that voice of reason spot from when I've played with him before.

 

I would like to know as well, but it gets answered:

 

 

Everyone is getting distracted from the true enemy. Manbat. Trying to insert himself as the voice of reason. I know what he is selling. It may be discounted, but I still aint buying.

Ive not cleared him but why do you feel hes scummy?

Also to Laine's question. Bc he felt "too towny" to me. More like scum trying to show how helpful they are than actually being naturally helpful.

But, I always think the most outwardly helpful person on day 1 is scum.

 

He was more berating other people than being helpful.

 

 

Still no John Snow?

Right?

 

Nobody answered my why is Snow scummy comment. Anyone?

I ventured Snow earlier as an alternative to Pral. Bc it seemed odd that of the low posters lots of mentions of Pral suspicion, but only 1 or 2 Snow mentions. I would rather lynch someone more under the radar than the lurker getting potential mafiaso backing.

 

I agree.

 

 

 

Nobody answered my why is Snow scummy comment. Anyone?

I ventured Snow earlier as an alternative to Pral. Bc it seemed odd that of the low posters lots of mentions of Pral suspicion, but only 1 or 2 Snow mentions. I would rather lynch someone more under the radar than the lurker getting potential mafiaso backing.

I think they're both null until they start posting. Yes there's a likelihood that they are mafia lurking, but there's more of a possibility that they're inactive town. We wont know that until we get them in here and start engaging them.

Completely agree. Just acknowledging the 1 of the 2 that was going more under the radar.

 

Calder inching up.

 

Calder why did you vote Pral yesterday?

Preferred Pral over the Eldrick option. Mostly due to one post in particular that was just a grouping of votes against Zander if I remember right. Felt like an odd mix of saying are scum in this group without actually commenting.

 

Considering the Eld flip (barring us all being town)  I like this.

 

 

 

 

 

Calder why did you vote Pral yesterday?

Preferred Pral over the Eldrick option. Mostly due to one post in particular that was just a grouping of votes against Zander if I remember right. Felt like an odd mix of saying are scum in this group without actually commenting.

So what's changed between then and now? I know you say people Pral more and Snow's UTR, but Laines saying that more people are finding Snow scummy?

Pral hasnt checked in and its questionable how much matters from D0 at this point. I still feel like Pral has more people suspecting him, but I could be wrong there. Basically the only change is D0 is all we have on him, which is hugely significant.

 

Especially considering he was looking around on the site for a bit.

 

 

 

Calder so agreeable.

Disagree

Calder thoughts on Len?

Quieter today. But he can't really go after you today so it is kind of expected. Probable town read for me.

 

 

 

 

Considering how his reads coincide a lot, I have pushed him up into my townish pile.  Thank you for asking Csarmi, you made me feel better about a slot.

[dicetosser1]

 

 

 

 

Monstr? Who would you say are the people you have an opinion of and what is that opinion?

I've made tons of opinions in my posts

 

They're in the thread open for you to read

 

You were in fact one of them at slightly villager

 

If you want me to make a list organizing all my suspects and clears that's not going to happen because that's not how I play.

 

I have seen your opinions. I was just looking for an easier format to remember, but I'll be able to go back and look anyway. At this point it's more about me trying to read you than seeing your opinions. 

 

How about the people you currently have no opinion of? Who are they?

 

 

I don't even know the full player list, to be honest

 

I just read along until I find a post that I agree with/suspect someone for and then call it out

 

I believe I've made my reads on lenlo, BFG, you, Shad, Turin and Alanna and decided the group of you was probably either mostly or all villagers and I've just been going from there

 

I made a point about alanna agreeing with me that I still find weird which brought her down from "probably town" to "likely town" and I don't believe she's ever on a team with Eldrick

 

I made a point about Shad being a deepwolf

 

I voted Eldrick

 

Anyone else just hasn't really jumped out at me or anything. Maybe I made a read on a player I already forgot too, who knows. It doesn't matter because with every passing second my reads are liable to change

 

So I don't put them in a list, I don't categorize them and I let what is going to come come naturally.

 

 

You missed this whole post, in fact.

 

 

 

 

That's the post I've been referring to where you said she was "likely town". -_-

Then you're reading it wrong

 

 

all right monstr i want you to gimme a class in reading monstr. you say   often   that u are self resolving yet without a cory type or a mechanical clear I cant think of a time i thought you clearly town. you throw out short posts that expect us to infer whats in ure head posts that have sentences that just make my eyes roll back in their head and that i cant follow the logic in. possible because they are short

 

 

Now shad is asking you about why u wanted to cfd on laine who   in the post quoted you said was likely town,  And yet you tell him he is reading it wrong.

 

How is he reading it wrong? Why would you cfd on someone YOU listed as likely town? was it because that was a down grade? was it a test?

 

how does someone accurately read you? or are supposed to just guess?

 

I actually want to know cause ive never been able to read you and it frustrates the hell outta me.

[monstrman]

 

 

 

 

 

Monstr? Who would you say are the people you have an opinion of and what is that opinion?

I've made tons of opinions in my posts

 

They're in the thread open for you to read

 

You were in fact one of them at slightly villager

 

If you want me to make a list organizing all my suspects and clears that's not going to happen because that's not how I play.

 

I have seen your opinions. I was just looking for an easier format to remember, but I'll be able to go back and look anyway. At this point it's more about me trying to read you than seeing your opinions. 

 

How about the people you currently have no opinion of? Who are they?

 

 

I don't even know the full player list, to be honest

 

I just read along until I find a post that I agree with/suspect someone for and then call it out

 

I believe I've made my reads on lenlo, BFG, you, Shad, Turin and Alanna and decided the group of you was probably either mostly or all villagers and I've just been going from there

 

I made a point about alanna agreeing with me that I still find weird which brought her down from "probably town" to "likely town" and I don't believe she's ever on a team with Eldrick

 

I made a point about Shad being a deepwolf

 

I voted Eldrick

 

Anyone else just hasn't really jumped out at me or anything. Maybe I made a read on a player I already forgot too, who knows. It doesn't matter because with every passing second my reads are liable to change

 

So I don't put them in a list, I don't categorize them and I let what is going to come come naturally.

 

 

You missed this whole post, in fact.

 

 

 

 

That's the post I've been referring to where you said she was "likely town". -_-

Then you're reading it wrong

 

 

all right monstr i want you to gimme a class in reading monstr. you say   often   that u are self resolving yet without a cory type or a mechanical clear I cant think of a time i thought you clearly town. you throw out short posts that expect us to infer whats in ure head posts that have sentences that just make my eyes roll back in their head and that i cant follow the logic in. possible because they are short

 

 

Now shad is asking you about why u wanted to cfd on laine who   in the post quoted you said was likely town,  And yet you tell him he is reading it wrong.

 

How is he reading it wrong? Why would you cfd on someone YOU listed as likely town? was it because that was a down grade? was it a test?

 

how does someone accurately read you? or are supposed to just guess?

 

I actually want to know cause ive never been able to read you and it frustrates the hell outta me.

 

 

I've seen plenty of people doing it very easily but that's still not the point.

 

I know you want to be able to read me regardless of whether you're town or mafia here, and to be honest I'm not really capable of reading you either, so I understand how that feels. The only answer I can give you is that you have to learn.

My style of play is really different from a lot of people's and it gets me in trouble pretty quickly, but I have no idea of how else to play and only the truth on my side.

[monstrman]

I recall one game I hardclaimed serial killer because I was the town vigilante and I thought that the town would at least leave me alive for one more day (I was positive I was going to otherwise die to lynch)

They lynched me, obviously. It was bad. I felt bad.

[monstrman]

I have since changed my views on caring about whether the scums nk me or not

[monstrman]

And also yes, inside of every one of my "opinions" are about six other opinions that haven't quite resolved yet. 

I do imply things with my posts and it's often with purpose, mostly for myself.

[monstrman]

For example

 

Dice: Gun to head if you were at f3 and you had to lynch between me and lenlo, who would you pick?

[Hallia]

Alrighty fellas, g'night.  I'll be back in 8 hours, try not to do anything crazy

[monstrman]

Alrighty fellas, g'night.  I'll be back in 8 hours, try not to do anything crazy

 

I make no promises at all

[dicetosser1]

guess i continue to muddle thru then

 

 

 

For example

 

Dice: Gun to head if you were at f3 and you had to lynch between me and lenlo, who would you pick?

 

you

 

lenlo was pretty townie i thought D0 and im not seeing a change so far  he gave me one puase when he said something that felt VERY similar to something Zander said to him in matrix but thats it.  Y

 

 

 

the above is how far i got before my gut told me im wrong   id now vote len cause len CAN say things on purpose that i will town read him for   you cant.

[Celeste]

I want everyone to weigh in on this.

 

Please quote the post when answering:

 

Who thinks D0 is relevant and who doesnt.

I don't think it is because I had a feeling on read that everybody was town.

[dicetosser1]

Alrighty fellas, g'night.  I'll be back in 8 hours, try not to do anything crazy

 

runs thru the game in a Harley Quinn outfit

[monstrman]

guess i continue to muddle thru then

 

 

 

For example

 

Dice: Gun to head if you were at f3 and you had to lynch between me and lenlo, who would you pick?

 

you

 

lenlo was pretty townie i thought D0 and im not seeing a change so far  he gave me one puase when he said something that felt VERY similar to something Zander said to him in matrix but thats it.  Y

 

 

 

the above is how far i got before my gut told me im wrong   id now vote len cause len CAN say things on purpose that i will town read him for   you cant.

 

Do you understand why I asked that question now?

[monstrman]

 

I want everyone to weigh in on this.

 

Please quote the post when answering:

 

Who thinks D0 is relevant and who doesnt.

I don't think it is because I had a feeling on read that everybody was town.

 

 

It's possible. I'd like to see how alanna reacts coming into today.

 

To be honest that means we basically just have to do what we did yesterday all over again and hope for the best.

 

That said I don't think it's unlikely that there were vanilla scum/lone wolves d0 that formed into a team or changed into prs, so I haven't ruled it out.

[monstrman]

 

 

I want everyone to weigh in on this.

 

Please quote the post when answering:

 

Who thinks D0 is relevant and who doesnt.

I don't think it is because I had a feeling on read that everybody was town.

 

 

It's possible. I'd like to see how alanna reacts coming into today.

 

To be honest that means we basically just have to do what we did yesterday all over again and hope for the best.

 

That said I don't think it's unlikely that there were vanilla scum/lone wolves d0 that formed into a team or changed into prs, so I haven't ruled it out.

 

I just realized that first sentence makes no sense, but it made sense to me as I was typing it

[monstrman]

I guess put that first bit at the end and add "because I think today she has been acting starkly different than yesterday"

[monstrman]

Because I did that implying thing again that gets me into trouble
 

and probably will do the hyperbole thing that gets me into trouble again too

[Celeste]

 

 

 

I want everyone to weigh in on this.

 

Please quote the post when answering:

 

Who thinks D0 is relevant and who doesnt.

I don't think it is because I had a feeling on read that everybody was town.

It's possible. I'd like to see how alanna reacts coming into today.

 

To be honest that means we basically just have to do what we did yesterday all over again and hope for the best.

 

That said I don't think it's unlikely that there were vanilla scum/lone wolves d0 that formed into a team or changed into prs, so I haven't ruled it out.

I have seen a setup before on my site where all of the players were town and then assigned roles and the person who was lynched got to pick the team. It looks like eldrick gets to stay but I don't know Chris well enough to see if he would pull a cue5c move.