[Advanced] Gods and Demons Mafia - All your souls belong to Shad (Triads win)

Zander? · January 24, 2016

100% villager tell from bfg

"OK I'm leaving

Wait hang on here's another 300 words of things"

Almost as good as a peek imo

I love you.

Zander? · January 24, 2016

Really atp is anyone other then Nol...possibly Pral gonna be lynched before tomorrow 's dl of 12 est I think?

If not lets just get the votes there so we can see a flip and reevaluate if necessary.

BFG · January 24, 2016

I want to ISO half the thread, and read D1 slowly.

*snip*

Sooh's the one I may be clearing too easily in that group, but I stand by she's more engaged/involved with the game than I've seen her manage as mafia, so unless someone can point me to a similarly engaged game as mafia I'm going to keep her as town. Slightly disappointing that we don't seem to be on the same page as much as the last couple of games

I'm with you on the ISO idea. I feel like I have a good idea about Hallia, Shad and you now, but yes, it is strange that we're not in agreement. I do listen to your cases as much as I can, but I don't know why you have cleared Csarmi and Celeste. I can see your point on Dice, while I think it's very meta reliant there's really no other way to read him as far as I can tell.

I think I tend to rely less on meta and more on in thread stuff, so that may explain our differences.

I use both, I rely on meta more for low volume posters, and am happiest if I can confidently clear/condemn them. What I'm curious with you about Dice is that last game you were clearing him on early involvement before Cory or I were ready to, and your read was one of the things that made me just go, 'ok let's go with it and keep an eye on him', and honestly it's probably this more than anyone else making me doubt my read the most this time :unsure:

BFG · January 24, 2016

100% villager tell from bfg

"OK I'm leaving

Wait hang on here's another 300 words of things"

Almost as good as a peek imo

So much for being strict :sad:

BFG · January 24, 2016

I want to ISO half the thread, and read D1 slowly.

*snip*

Sooh's the one I may be clearing too easily in that group, but I stand by she's more engaged/involved with the game than I've seen her manage as mafia, so unless someone can point me to a similarly engaged game as mafia I'm going to keep her as town. Slightly disappointing that we don't seem to be on the same page as much as the last couple of games

I'm with you on the ISO idea. I feel like I have a good idea about Hallia, Shad and you now, but yes, it is strange that we're not in agreement. I do listen to your cases as much as I can, but I don't know why you have cleared Csarmi and Celeste. I can see your point on Dice, while I think it's very meta reliant there's really no other way to read him as far as I can tell.

I think I tend to rely less on meta and more on in thread stuff, so that may explain our differences.

I use both, I rely on meta more for low volume posters, and am happiest if I can confidently clear/condemn them. What I'm curious with you about Dice is that last game you were clearing him on early involvement before Cory or I were ready to, and your read was one of the things that made me just go, 'ok let's go with it and keep an eye on him', and honestly it's probably this more than anyone else making me doubt my read the most this time

I guess what I'm curious about is afaict you used meta for him last game, yet you're ignoring it this game

Sooh · January 24, 2016

I want to ISO half the thread, and read D1 slowly.

*snip*

Sooh's the one I may be clearing too easily in that group, but I stand by she's more engaged/involved with the game than I've seen her manage as mafia, so unless someone can point me to a similarly engaged game as mafia I'm going to keep her as town. Slightly disappointing that we don't seem to be on the same page as much as the last couple of games

I'm with you on the ISO idea. I feel like I have a good idea about Hallia, Shad and you now, but yes, it is strange that we're not in agreement. I do listen to your cases as much as I can, but I don't know why you have cleared Csarmi and Celeste. I can see your point on Dice, while I think it's very meta reliant there's really no other way to read him as far as I can tell.

I think I tend to rely less on meta and more on in thread stuff, so that may explain our differences.

I use both, I rely on meta more for low volume posters, and am happiest if I can confidently clear/condemn them. What I'm curious with you about Dice is that last game you were clearing him on early involvement before Cory or I were ready to, and your read was one of the things that made me just go, 'ok let's go with it and keep an eye on him', and honestly it's probably this more than anyone else making me doubt my read the most this time

Wait what? My clearing Dice? I did that? lol! Was I sheeping someone?

BFG · January 24, 2016

Really atp is anyone other then Nol...possibly Pral gonna be lynched before tomorrow 's dl of 12 est I think?

If not lets just get the votes there so we can see a flip and reevaluate if necessary.

I don't see this going any other way at this point. I also want to see what he comes in thread with.

I'll be back at least once before deadline and can vote then, but I probably won't be about to shift it if required

BFG · January 24, 2016

I want to ISO half the thread, and read D1 slowly.

*snip*

Sooh's the one I may be clearing too easily in that group, but I stand by she's more engaged/involved with the game than I've seen her manage as mafia, so unless someone can point me to a similarly engaged game as mafia I'm going to keep her as town. Slightly disappointing that we don't seem to be on the same page as much as the last couple of games

I'm with you on the ISO idea. I feel like I have a good idea about Hallia, Shad and you now, but yes, it is strange that we're not in agreement. I do listen to your cases as much as I can, but I don't know why you have cleared Csarmi and Celeste. I can see your point on Dice, while I think it's very meta reliant there's really no other way to read him as far as I can tell.

I think I tend to rely less on meta and more on in thread stuff, so that may explain our differences.

I use both, I rely on meta more for low volume posters, and am happiest if I can confidently clear/condemn them. What I'm curious with you about Dice is that last game you were clearing him on early involvement before Cory or I were ready to, and your read was one of the things that made me just go, 'ok let's go with it and keep an eye on him', and honestly it's probably this more than anyone else making me doubt my read the most this time

Wait what? My clearing Dice? I did that? lol! Was I sheeping someone?

Lol maybe you didn't mean it as a 'clear' but you said something along the lines of 'Dice's early engagement is good', this was after Cory/Pizza argued about it I think, and I read it and went 'yup'

XD

BFG · January 24, 2016

I guess you could have been sheeping Pizza, but it didn't sound like it

Zander? · January 24, 2016

Really atp is anyone other then Nol...possibly Pral gonna be lynched before tomorrow 's dl of 12 est I think?

If not lets just get the votes there so we can see a flip and reevaluate if necessary.

I don't see this going any other way at this point. I also want to see what he comes in thread with.

I'll be back at least once before deadline and can vote then, but I probably won't be about to shift it if required

Are you voting someone??

Sooh · January 24, 2016

I want to ISO half the thread, and read D1 slowly.

*snip*

Sooh's the one I may be clearing too easily in that group, but I stand by she's more engaged/involved with the game than I've seen her manage as mafia, so unless someone can point me to a similarly engaged game as mafia I'm going to keep her as town. Slightly disappointing that we don't seem to be on the same page as much as the last couple of games

I'm with you on the ISO idea. I feel like I have a good idea about Hallia, Shad and you now, but yes, it is strange that we're not in agreement. I do listen to your cases as much as I can, but I don't know why you have cleared Csarmi and Celeste. I can see your point on Dice, while I think it's very meta reliant there's really no other way to read him as far as I can tell.

I think I tend to rely less on meta and more on in thread stuff, so that may explain our differences.

I use both, I rely on meta more for low volume posters, and am happiest if I can confidently clear/condemn them. What I'm curious with you about Dice is that last game you were clearing him on early involvement before Cory or I were ready to, and your read was one of the things that made me just go, 'ok let's go with it and keep an eye on him', and honestly it's probably this more than anyone else making me doubt my read the most this time

I guess what I'm curious about is afaict you used meta for him last game, yet you're ignoring it this game

I have never ever claimed to have been good at reading Dice. I haven't even really focused on him this game yet. I can't even remember doing this last game.

*refreshed for new posts*

oh yes, I did say his level of engagement was good, and I maintain that it is, but I haven't even really noticed him this game, which is what puzzles me a bit. D0 I remember him. D1 not at all. I'm trying to throw out D0 reads just in case.

Perhaps that's why our reads differ so much too. You count D0 and I don't.

Shad_ · January 24, 2016

Aaaaaaand nothing worth watching on TV again until September. -_-

BFG · January 24, 2016

Really atp is anyone other then Nol...possibly Pral gonna be lynched before tomorrow 's dl of 12 est I think?

If not lets just get the votes there so we can see a flip and reevaluate if necessary.

I don't see this going any other way at this point. I also want to see what he comes in thread with.

I'll be back at least once before deadline and can vote then, but I probably won't be about to shift it if required

Are you voting someone??

No, and I still want to see what Nolder comes in with. I think his stance on Hallia is pretty bad, not the policy vote as such, although it's still bad that he's voting to force a claim and not because he's finding her scummy, but the passiveness with which he's not (visibly) doing anything else is worse. ~~At the same time it feels too easy. Crossed out because I can practically hear the derision from certain people in the DT~~

Zander? · January 24, 2016

Really atp is anyone other then Nol...possibly Pral gonna be lynched before tomorrow 's dl of 12 est I think?

If not lets just get the votes there so we can see a flip and reevaluate if necessary.

I don't see this going any other way at this point. I also want to see what he comes in thread with.

I'll be back at least once before deadline and can vote then, but I probably won't be about to shift it if required

Are you voting someone??

No, and I still want to see what Nolder comes in with. I think his stance on Hallia is pretty bad, not the policy vote as such, although it's still bad that he's voting to force a claim and not because he's finding her scummy, but the passiveness with which he's not (visibly) doing anything else is worse. ~~At the same time it feels too easy. Crossed out because I can practically hear the derision from certain people in the DT~~

you know if he flips scum its gonna look bad right.

BFG · January 24, 2016

I want to ISO half the thread, and read D1 slowly.

*snip*

Sooh's the one I may be clearing too easily in that group, but I stand by she's more engaged/involved with the game than I've seen her manage as mafia, so unless someone can point me to a similarly engaged game as mafia I'm going to keep her as town. Slightly disappointing that we don't seem to be on the same page as much as the last couple of games

I'm with you on the ISO idea. I feel like I have a good idea about Hallia, Shad and you now, but yes, it is strange that we're not in agreement. I do listen to your cases as much as I can, but I don't know why you have cleared Csarmi and Celeste. I can see your point on Dice, while I think it's very meta reliant there's really no other way to read him as far as I can tell.

I think I tend to rely less on meta and more on in thread stuff, so that may explain our differences.

I use both, I rely on meta more for low volume posters, and am happiest if I can confidently clear/condemn them. What I'm curious with you about Dice is that last game you were clearing him on early involvement before Cory or I were ready to, and your read was one of the things that made me just go, 'ok let's go with it and keep an eye on him', and honestly it's probably this more than anyone else making me doubt my read the most this time

I guess what I'm curious about is afaict you used meta for him last game, yet you're ignoring it this game

I have never ever claimed to have been good at reading Dice. I haven't even really focused on him this game yet. I can't even remember doing this last game.

*refreshed for new posts*

oh yes, I did say his level of engagement was good, and I maintain that it is, but I haven't even really noticed him this game, which is what puzzles me a bit. D0 I remember him. D1 not at all. I'm trying to throw out D0 reads just in case.

Perhaps that's why our reads differ so much too. You count D0 and I don't.

I'm trying not to just in case, but it's hard :dry:

Sooh · January 24, 2016

I want to ISO half the thread, and read D1 slowly.

*snip*

Sooh's the one I may be clearing too easily in that group, but I stand by she's more engaged/involved with the game than I've seen her manage as mafia, so unless someone can point me to a similarly engaged game as mafia I'm going to keep her as town. Slightly disappointing that we don't seem to be on the same page as much as the last couple of games

I'm with you on the ISO idea. I feel like I have a good idea about Hallia, Shad and you now, but yes, it is strange that we're not in agreement. I do listen to your cases as much as I can, but I don't know why you have cleared Csarmi and Celeste. I can see your point on Dice, while I think it's very meta reliant there's really no other way to read him as far as I can tell.

I think I tend to rely less on meta and more on in thread stuff, so that may explain our differences.

I use both, I rely on meta more for low volume posters, and am happiest if I can confidently clear/condemn them. What I'm curious with you about Dice is that last game you were clearing him on early involvement before Cory or I were ready to, and your read was one of the things that made me just go, 'ok let's go with it and keep an eye on him', and honestly it's probably this more than anyone else making me doubt my read the most this time

I guess what I'm curious about is afaict you used meta for him last game, yet you're ignoring it this game

I have never ever claimed to have been good at reading Dice. I haven't even really focused on him this game yet. I can't even remember doing this last game.

*refreshed for new posts*

oh yes, I did say his level of engagement was good, and I maintain that it is, but I haven't even really noticed him this game, which is what puzzles me a bit. D0 I remember him. D1 not at all. I'm trying to throw out D0 reads just in case.

Perhaps that's why our reads differ so much too. You count D0 and I don't.

I'm trying not to just in case, but it's hard

Yeah I know.

BFG · January 24, 2016

Really atp is anyone other then Nol...possibly Pral gonna be lynched before tomorrow 's dl of 12 est I think?

If not lets just get the votes there so we can see a flip and reevaluate if necessary.

I don't see this going any other way at this point. I also want to see what he comes in thread with.

I'll be back at least once before deadline and can vote then, but I probably won't be about to shift it if required

Are you voting someone??

No, and I still want to see what Nolder comes in with. I think his stance on Hallia is pretty bad, not the policy vote as such, although it's still bad that he's voting to force a claim and not because he's finding her scummy, but the passiveness with which he's not (visibly) doing anything else is worse. ~~At the same time it feels too easy. Crossed out because I can practically hear the derision from certain people in the DT~~

you know if he flips scum its gonna look bad right.

/shrug

Superficially maybe, but not in the guts of the game

BFG · January 24, 2016

Really atp is anyone other then Nol...possibly Pral gonna be lynched before tomorrow 's dl of 12 est I think?

If not lets just get the votes there so we can see a flip and reevaluate if necessary.

I don't see this going any other way at this point. I also want to see what he comes in thread with.

I'll be back at least once before deadline and can vote then, but I probably won't be about to shift it if required

Are you voting someone??

No, and I still want to see what Nolder comes in with. I think his stance on Hallia is pretty bad, not the policy vote as such, although it's still bad that he's voting to force a claim and not because he's finding her scummy, but the passiveness with which he's not (visibly) doing anything else is worse. ~~At the same time it feels too easy. Crossed out because I can practically hear the derision from certain people in the DT~~

you know if he flips scum its gonna look bad right.

/shrug

Superficially maybe, but not in the guts of the game

And you have no idea how amusing this is to me given how long you've been sussing me because I did vote yesterDay

Zander? · January 24, 2016

@ BFG

Im starting the shrug jar. It works the same as the swearing jar. Every time you /shrug you have to put a quarter in.

The money raised goes to my favorite humanitarian effort.....

The Beer For Zander Foundation!!!!

lolololololololol

Zander? · January 24, 2016

And you have no idea how amusing this is to me given how long you've been sussing me because I did vote yesterDay

I know right.

lolololololol

Sooh · January 24, 2016

@ BFG

Im starting the shrug jar. It works the same as the swearing jar. Every time you /shrug you have to put a quarter in.

The money raised goes to my favorite humanitarian effort.....

The Beer For Zander Foundation!!!!

lolololololololol

@Zander

I'm starting the lololol jar. It works the same as the shrug jar. Every time you lololol you have to put a quarter in.

The money raised goes to my favorite humanitarian effort....

The Therapy for Mafia Players Foundation!!!!

monstrman · January 24, 2016

I have a soft spot in my heart for the /shrug

It illustrates my opinion toward so many things so well

Zander? · January 24, 2016

@ BFG

Im starting the shrug jar. It works the same as the swearing jar. Every time you /shrug you have to put a quarter in.

The money raised goes to my favorite humanitarian effort.....

The Beer For Zander Foundation!!!!

lolololololololol

@Zander

I'm starting the lololol jar. It works the same as the shrug jar. Every time you lololol you have to put a quarter in.

The money raised goes to my favorite humanitarian effort....

The Therapy for Mafia Players Foundation!!!!

lolololololololol is a TM of Zander Bobby Inc

Clovdyx · January 24, 2016

Aaaaaaand nothing worth watching on TV again until September. -_-

Pretty damn much.

Everybody post your role PM's so I can light you on fire.

(Don't actually post your role PM's)

Zander? · January 24, 2016

@ BFG

Im starting the shrug jar. It works the same as the swearing jar. Every time you /shrug you have to put a quarter in.

The money raised goes to my favorite humanitarian effort.....

The Beer For Zander Foundation!!!!

lolololololololol

@Zander

I'm starting the lololol jar. It works the same as the shrug jar. Every time you lololol you have to put a quarter in.

The money raised goes to my favorite humanitarian effort....

The Therapy for Mafia Players Foundation!!!!

lolololololololol is a TM of Zander Bobby Inc

A subsidiary of Taco Corp

[Advanced] Gods and Demons Mafia - All your souls belong to Shad (Triads win)

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook