[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

dicetosser1 · June 17, 2015

Zander I will expand AFTER i hear from Shad on why he thought it was a joke and why seph thought it wasnt tho he has answered that a little already

Zander? · June 17, 2015

I'll follow up tomorrow. Essentially I think attacking Seph like AJ has been isn't productive, and I don't really see a reason why town him or town wombat would find it acceptable to assume someone who is essentially null from what I can tell, is scum. I don't like the approach. I actually wanted to hear why AJ was reading Dice town, but AJ changed the topic and Seph didn't press AJ far as I know.

I will probably be taking seph's side in this unless I think Seph is a wolf later. Right now I'm somewhere between null and town on him.

Seph AJs little book costs $9.99 plus delivery.

i will let AJ answer this

@ Sili i think you should ISO seph again and re-evaluate him imo.

@Dice is your AJ related posts just meta stuff's or do you have a read on him?

dicetosser1 · June 17, 2015

Peeked Darthe N0.

Result:

vote Durin

@Dice Why did you vote for that?

I think my role fits btw cause i do hate my character. Jar Jar Binks has no place in Star Wars. Supposed to be funny i know... It isn't.

Not saying I don't believe him but anyone think Jar Jar would be a PERFECT fake claim for Mafia especially with the role claim which i dislike that early....

Csarmi not looking towny thus far imo.

Wrong. Csarmi is right on towny meta

dicetosser1 · June 17, 2015

Eldrick4221, on 17 Jun 2015 - 6:57 PM, said:

dicetosser1, on 17 Jun 2015 - 1:12 PM, said:

Turin Turambar, on 17 Jun 2015 - 11:24 AM, said:

Peeked Darthe N0.

Result:

Spoiler

vote Durin

@Dice Why did you vote for that?

Thank you for actually asking. I suggest you look at that post and try to figure it out.

Otherwise I will tell you after i hear from shad and seph

dicetosser1 · June 17, 2015

Right now my WTL is Durin and Seph

dicetosser1 · June 17, 2015

I have a list with me so I can check who is with who.

I was going to vote joke AJ because he wanted to be JarJar, but CS has claimed him.

I saw Dice's vote and thought it was a joke. He quoted Turin's peek on Darthe, seems obvious. Null on Dice.

Tunnelling by wombyAJ - don't get this.

I think Seph is trying to do what others have done in games I've seen.

The only thing that pings slightly is that he KNOWS Durin is town...could be him still pushing his peek, but no one else has done this.

Sili - liking so far and have agreed with some of his stuff, where are the vote switches?

Alanna, heart, Sooh, Thane, Eld all at null

Shad - liking his posts more control to them (being mentored) - feeling a town lean

Durin - no bloody idea, different Darthe to last two games, but I saw boredom there last time - Darthe feels towny, Turin - null

AwombyJ - don't like the tunnelling on Seph, AJ looked like he was looking for an excuse to vote Seph w/w?

Turin and Darthe ARE Durin.....

Zander? · June 17, 2015

Peeked Darthe N0.

Result:

vote Durin

@Dice Why did you vote for that?

I think my role fits btw cause i do hate my character. Jar Jar Binks has no place in Star Wars. Supposed to be funny i know... It isn't.

Not saying I don't believe him but anyone think Jar Jar would be a PERFECT fake claim for Mafia especially with the role claim which i dislike that early....

Csarmi not looking towny thus far imo.

Wrong. Csarmi is right on towny meta

dont have any meta on Csarmi....just not seeing the reason for char and role claim atp.

dicetosser1 · June 17, 2015

I'll follow up tomorrow. Essentially I think attacking Seph like AJ has been isn't productive, and I don't really see a reason why town him or town wombat would find it acceptable to assume someone who is essentially null from what I can tell, is scum. I don't like the approach. I actually wanted to hear why AJ was reading Dice town, but AJ changed the topic and Seph didn't press AJ far as I know.

I will probably be taking seph's side in this unless I think Seph is a wolf later. Right now I'm somewhere between null and town on him.

Seph AJs little book costs $9.99 plus delivery.

i will let AJ answer this

@ Sili i think you should ISO seph again and re-evaluate him imo.

@Dice is your AJ related posts just meta stuff's or do you have a read on him?

Meta stuff tho i am softly leaning town

csarmi · June 17, 2015

Well how would you play Hated, Zander?

alannalynn · June 17, 2015

Sorry for the wot... Kinda.

This: Kinda freaks me out when Darthe is two people. Spring rolls are fabulous

Seph feels town with his responses to Andrej up through p2 (#40) I don't really like much after that.

Note: Andrej is really holding a grudge? I only skimmed HoC, so *shrug* Focus on this game, guys

/snip bc quotes are annoying/

r u familiar with csarmi actually?

I actually mentored Csarmi in his first game on DM lol

Only if you direct it towards someone more....mortal.

Yes dark master

Alanna can I ask for a villagery game like you played against me last week?

Of course. Is this in response to anything though?

AJ w?

Laine w?

Heart w

Why? I think Andrej started in a little hard on Seph, and Heart's posts aren't bothering me, but that doesn't really equal wolf on either of them.

Whether it is or it isn't a real thing, it is still nice to provide.

For the same reason a op gets a vote, and I am sure for reasons others vote for people.

I didn't like it.
Dice could have missed my post just like you did.
I know turdarthin is town and I do not want people voting for them.

I don't really like this post at all. It feels overdone by Seph, maybe a little defensive.

I think Seph emphasizing that his vote on page 4 was serious is a little... awkward. That's all I've got so far, and it might have been a joke that went wooosh.

Shad I am just trying to provide cover if there is a seer. I know a lot of people don't do it, but I find it fun and I think it helps me play better.

Meh

I don't think dice vote was a joke. Can you explain you you do?

Shad I am voting dice because I know Durin is town, and I didn't like his vote. usually don't see dice just drop a vote.

The other part was me explaining why I was doing a seer cover.

Highly dislike this post. Over-explaining. Also, one vote a lynch does not make. You're over-defending your peek.

At this point, nobody is doing seer cover, so the only thing you've really established is that you're not the seer, right?

Seph's subsequent vote on Shad for calling him out feels defensive

Wombat comes in calling everyone wolfy lol

Btw, it's 6AM and I'm off work and eating ice cream, if anyone wants to know. Pretty sure being an adult is awesome

I think my role fits btw cause i do hate my character. Jar Jar Binks has no place in Star Wars. Supposed to be funny i know... It isn't.

I was really hoping this would be AJ danggit

I really like Eldrick's post 176 (and I promise not to lynch you d1 again :wink: )

dicetosser1 · June 17, 2015

I think my role fits btw cause i do hate my character. Jar Jar Binks has no place in Star Wars. Supposed to be funny i know... It isn't.

Not saying I don't believe him but anyone think Jar Jar would be a PERFECT fake claim for Mafia especially with the role claim which i dislike that early....

Csarmi not looking towny thus far imo.

Wrong. Csarmi is right on towny meta

dont have any meta on Csarmi....just not seeing the reason for char and role claim atp.

Csarmi makes a practice of claiming early

Zander? · June 17, 2015

Well how would you play Hated, Zander?

has nothing to do with how to play it, it was the claim i that pinged me. but below....

I think my role fits btw cause i do hate my character. Jar Jar Binks has no place in Star Wars. Supposed to be funny i know... It isn't.

Not saying I don't believe him but anyone think Jar Jar would be a PERFECT fake claim for Mafia especially with the role claim which i dislike that early....

Csarmi not looking towny thus far imo.

Wrong. Csarmi is right on towny meta

dont have any meta on Csarmi....just not seeing the reason for char and role claim atp.

Csarmi makes a practice of claiming early

seems to clear things up a bit.

alannalynn · June 17, 2015

Also, Shad is becoming one of my favorite people.

Zander, I'm only a little bothered by Csarmi's revealing; did you make a case on this?

Relax Zander, I'm almost through the pages. I'm at pg 8, not really liking Seph, he feels a little over done. But I'll give you relevant quotes in a moment

puts down the crack pipe and waits for Alanna. lolol

You're so hyperactive for my poor tired brain this early in the morning lol

alannalynn · June 17, 2015

Okay I think I'm caught up

csarmi · June 17, 2015

@Zander - it IS how you'd play it... it's a pretty serious negative utility: the question is whether it should be mentioned and when.

Zander? · June 17, 2015

Also, Shad is becoming one of my favorite people.

Zander, I'm only a little bothered by Csarmi's revealing; did you make a case on this?

Relax Zander, I'm almost through the pages. I'm at pg 8, not really liking Seph, he feels a little over done. But I'll give you relevant quotes in a moment

puts down the crack pipe and waits for Alanna. lolol

You're so hyperactive for my poor tired brain this early in the morning lol

no not a case having no meta on Csarmi just noted that the early char and role claimed pinged me. Dice explained it was in his meta (which i have 0 meta on Csarmi)

so until i do get meta on those i have none on just gonna put things out there that stick out and give a chance for someone to prove or dispel it.

lolol could be the crack doing it!!

alannalynn · June 17, 2015

@Zander - it IS how you'd play it... it's a pretty serious negative utility: the question is whether it should be mentioned and when.

I'd be a little annoyed if you were getting run up and got lynched before we could stop it. Also, might be more suspicious if you did it while you were being lynched.

At the same time, while it could be a mafia ploy, I don't see any reason scum would need to come straight out and say a claim like that.

Talya · June 17, 2015

I have a list with me so I can check who is with who.

I was going to vote joke AJ because he wanted to be JarJar, but CS has claimed him.

I saw Dice's vote and thought it was a joke. He quoted Turin's peek on Darthe, seems obvious. Null on Dice.

Tunnelling by wombyAJ - don't get this.

I think Seph is trying to do what others have done in games I've seen.

The only thing that pings slightly is that he KNOWS Durin is town...could be him still pushing his peek, but no one else has done this.

Sili - liking so far and have agreed with some of his stuff, where are the vote switches?

Alanna, heart, Sooh, Thane, Eld all at null

Shad - liking his posts more control to them (being mentored) - feeling a town lean

Durin - no bloody idea, different Darthe to last two games, but I saw boredom there last time - Darthe feels towny, Turin - null

AwombyJ - don't like the tunnelling on Seph, AJ looked like he was looking for an excuse to vote Seph w/w?

Turin and Darthe ARE Durin.....

I know, which is why I thought yours was a joke vote, because that was obviously a joke

Zander? · June 17, 2015

@Zander - it IS how you'd play it... it's a pretty serious negative utility: the question is whether it should be mentioned and when.

i meant i had no problem with how you played, just didnt understand why you claimed both char and role that early. also i think Jar Jar would be a pretty solid Mafia fake claim as it would be quite believable imo.

Dice did mention its in your Meta to claim early so I'll take the claim as is for now.

csarmi · June 17, 2015

#Laine - she was my mentor in my firat mafia game ever but that was a long time ago. She knows nothing of my meta.

In that game I fakw claimed cop as a doc.

alannalynn · June 17, 2015

#Laine - she was my mentor in my firat mafia game ever but that was a long time ago. She knows nothing of my meta.

In that game I fakw claimed cop as a doc.

I'm pretty sure I have a general idea of your personality and that's good enough for me lol

alannalynn · June 17, 2015

#Laine - she was my mentor in my firat mafia game ever but that was a long time ago. She knows nothing of my meta.

In that game I fakw claimed cop as a doc.

I'm pretty sure I have a general idea of your personality and that's good enough for me lol

Long time ago = 4 years?

I at least agree your maths are a little strange

csarmi · June 17, 2015

Well 4 years is a long time. I have quit mafia and came back since and so did you.

Talya · June 17, 2015

@ Zander - my first reaction to Seph and his peek is that he was trying to act like some of the other top guys here having seen it being done, I thought he was quite new to Mafia...the tunnel info I didn't like because too many times I have seen this on day 1 and ended in disaster...not everyone had come into the thread. It was Seph's in insistance that he knows Durin is town that pings me more.

The w/w bit had a questionable fore as it was a thought that crossed my mind. I felt AJ trying to find an excuse to vote Seph, he might do that if he was a wolf partner or thought that Seph had a role, hence the question mark.

I hope that makes sense

alannalynn · June 17, 2015

Csarmi: true that, I guess haha Life kinda takes over sometimes

@ Zander - my first reaction to Seph and his peek is that he was trying to act like some of the other top guys here having seen it being done, I thought he was quite new to Mafia...the tunnel info I didn't like because too many times I have seen this on day 1 and ended in disaster...not everyone had come into the thread. It was Seph's in insistance that he knows Durin is town that pings me more.
The w/w bit had a questionable fore as it was a thought that crossed my mind. I felt AJ trying to find an excuse to vote Seph, he might do that if he was a wolf partner or thought that Seph had a role, hence the question mark.

I hope that makes sense

Underlined: I agree with this. It's one thing to defend your peek, but then proclaiming that is just seer cover and still being so certain is odd

[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook