[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

[WWWwombat]

Why are people town reading Sili btw?

[Clovdyx]

Darthe. You keep saying that you both want to lynch him and don't at the same time. It can't be both.

 

You're not wrong in the most literal sense, but you kinda are IMO.  Understanding why someone is a valid candidate and agreeing that they are playing in a way that warrants votes doesn't necessarily mean you should vote them - or that you want to.  

 

I also think the post you're replying to from Darthe is a hell of a lot more likely to come from a townie than mafia.

[Darthe]

IDK maybe Leelou is town.

 

I read her ISO just now and she is so consistent that she basically hasn't moved in this game.  She got a crapton of early reads and they've shifted but glacially it seems.  

[Darthe]

Why are people town reading Sili btw?

He is entertaining and engaged and clear and present.

 

Not really any of those things.  Maybe a bit.

 

Mostly it's that, and I'm not exaggerating, what you saw of him in that last game where he was a wolf is the height of his wolf effort.  

[Darthe]

Null as in 25%.   Everyone is 75% likely to be town and 25% to be wolf so if they start T---------------_------W and move T----------_----------W they're trending town

[Talya]

I have not seen Sili as wolf, his posts here feel the same as last game. Except the vote switching, he did that a lot. He was also cop in that game.

[Clovdyx]

"Null" = "Rand" then?

[WWWwombat]

 

Why are people town reading Sili btw?

He is entertaining and engaged and clear and present.

 

Not really any of those things.  Maybe a bit.

 

Mostly it's that, and I'm not exaggerating, what you saw of him in that last game where he was a wolf is the height of his wolf effort.  

 

 

I don't trust it.

[WWWwombat]

IDK maybe Leelou is town.

 

I read her ISO just now and she is so consistent that she basically hasn't moved in this game.  She got a crapton of early reads and they've shifted but glacially it seems.  

 

Is her reads changing slowly villagery or wolfy?

[Talya]

Why?

[Talya]

To Womby

[Darthe]

Who are your wolf reads, Darthe?

Honestly not really sure.

 

Dice/Salami can pull this as town.  

Leelou prob needs more content to accurately judge.

Verb/Thane are still on my wolf list

AH hasn't done anything to warrant not being there it was just a thin train that built moderatly quickly.

Zander I'm tinfoily on

Sooh hasn't struck me as particularly townie.

 

I'd think that I prob have two or three wolves in that list but I'm waffling on them all enough that it's hard to say.

[WWWwombat]

I have a hard time believing that Sili would essentially throw his scum games.

[Darthe]

 

 

Why are people town reading Sili btw?

He is entertaining and engaged and clear and present.

 

Not really any of those things.  Maybe a bit.

 

Mostly it's that, and I'm not exaggerating, what you saw of him in that last game where he was a wolf is the height of his wolf effort.  

 

 

I don't trust it.

 

Yeah I know it can be manipulated.  

 

 

IDK maybe Leelou is town.

 

I read her ISO just now and she is so consistent that she basically hasn't moved in this game.  She got a crapton of early reads and they've shifted but glacially it seems.  

 

Is her reads changing slowly villagery or wolfy?

 

I am not sure.  I really would love if our village made themselves a bit more obvious but atm the wolves aren't remotely standout.

[Darthe]

I have a hard time believing that Sili would essentially throw his scum games.

I said that and he said he was trying his best.  Called me condescending actually in our QT.  

 

That meta has panned out so far. 

[seph]

I have sili somewhere in the middle, I expected more from him as town, but it isn't anything close to his last wolf game I was in

[Talya]

What is his wolf game like?

[WWWwombat]

[unvote]

[v]Laine[/v]

 

I don't remember enough from her given her post count.

[Talya]

Eh?

[Darthe]

BTW Laine has been gone for a bit but she has been pretty clearly town this game.  Props to her, even if she is a wolf she is doing a good job of it.

[Darthe]

Damn that's an X post.

[Eldrick4221]

Sometimes I like to withhold things I think because I recognize that they are going to look bad on me to say even though they're true.  This is one of those things.

 

I'd really rather not lynch Seph.  I get why he is being - read and it's warranted and I don't even disagree with the lynch.  As a matter of fact I could make a really strong argument for it.

 

But I don't want to see him lynched today.  I think that we are lost but that there are better candidates out there vastly more likely to flip wolf than him and my reasons for thinking so are all individually weak but they add up to a lot.  

 

stagnant train all day, even though it looks all town

votes everywhere

low effort on his part but much better posting than in the past

some of my wolf reads have pushed him without voting him

people throw a lot of snipy comments at him

seriously he has had some good (albeit safe) posts

the reasons people have for voting him are reasons I've had for voting him in the past when he flipped town

 

All the above said, the reasons people want to vote him are valid and idk, I think there is a greater than null chance that he is a wolf.  I just think that it remains more likely that he is town.  Say 65/35.  

 

 

 

Who are your wolf reads, Darthe?

Honestly not really sure.

 

Dice/Salami can pull this as town.  

Leelou prob needs more content to accurately judge.

Verb/Thane are still on my wolf list

AH hasn't done anything to warrant not being there it was just a thin train that built moderatly quickly.

Zander I'm tinfoily on

Sooh hasn't struck me as particularly townie.

 

I'd think that I prob have two or three wolves in that list but I'm waffling on them all enough that it's hard to say.

 

 

Bolded is why I asked. You should have wolf reads if you're going to mention that you notice them doing something.

 

Who were you referring to with the sentence?

[Darthe]

No way we are going Laine.  Her content has been on point in ISO, I just think she has been gone for the 30 page afternoon we have had.  

[WWWwombat]

Guess people might just be more willing to give competence passes than I am.

[Clovdyx]

 

Bolded is why I asked. You should have wolf reads if you're going to mention that you notice them doing something.

 

Who were you referring to with the sentence?

 

 

I am literally never lynching you this game.