Jump to content
We have a Patreon! Support this website and get exclusive content ×

DRAGONMOUNT

 A WHEEL OF TIME COMMUNITY

[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

Hallia

By Hallia
in DM Mafia Games

Recommended Posts

WWWwombat Spam Master

WWWwombat

Posted
Posted

 

 

 

Seph I told you from the beginning I was gonna ride you. There really isn't much else to consider imo.

Seeing all the claims and knowing my role, I don't think Heart is the doc. I didn't really believe she was when she first claimed because of the situation and sketchy reasoning around missing obvious protects.

She hasn't done anything to change my mind and her posts in defense sound like a caught wolf. That one she did with the Princess Bride wifom guy picture was legit bad.

You wanna complain because I'm not doing anything. Well guess what? The work is done. Just like it was in American Gods. The wolves are outed. We just need to lynch them now

 

Say again what he lesson learned was from that game?  Specifically what towns should learn?  Probably best relegated to end game...but I have my own thoughts...and right now I'm seeing something similar.

 

Towns should learn to sheep AJ and Wombat.  Duh.

You want to be town leader but are currently in the poe, which is why I am worried.

 

I will place my vote back on heart tomorrow pending dice response

 

 

Look at D3 and tell me I'm int he PoE.

  • Replies 8.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
WWWwombat Spam Master

WWWwombat

Posted
Posted

I don't especially believe Heart without a good alibi. I don't think I've seen a doc who couldn't protect someone twice in a row before, except in mish mashes. (but mish mashes are different). DM, apparently doesn't use them?

 

As to Laine not dying n2, it could be for any reason. 

 

I've seen it before, but it's rare.

WWWwombat Spam Master

WWWwombat

Posted
Posted

 

 

 

This is relevant:

 

giphy.gif

 

Im reading this as before. I right?

 

 

Naww, I was just tickled when I realized Chris Pratt was in Moneyball.

 

 

LMAO  i watched it last night thanks to you and had the same realisation!

 

Han Solo, Town Commuter

 

 

Unvote vote Heart

 

 

DiceGOAT in the house.

Sili Quirrels Master

Sili Quirrels

Posted
Posted

I really don't get it.

I understand you think heart is mafia. And you want 4/4 but sili is safer imo.

 

By killing sili we confirm yates

Zander views heart. If he dies she is mafia.

If she lives and zander lives, we know hearts alignment.

 

So by going sili we

Clear or condemn 2 players

We know yates alignment

we know heart alignment

We know dice align

We know my alignment

 

Poe is aj, tayla, Eld and town wins

 

 

 

Lynching heart

Possibly ly win game.

Possibly kills doc and cop on same day

Does not give us info on mason claims

Makes aj look suspicious and more tinfoils, so we are back to where we started today with a BIGGE poe.

 

How is heart more beneficial? The other way yields better results. I just don't get it.

 

[unvote]

I want to hear why heart is a better lynch.

Through sili we get hearts, and yates alignment, while possibly keeping doc, and cop.

 

 

I am trying to come around on heart 1st but it is -EV compared to sili..... don't don't get it.... ugh sorry if I am makin this more difficult but weigh the pros and cons.

Heart wins or kills 2 prs

Sili confirms 2 people and win us the game still? Or am I looking at this wrong.

 

This is mainly to dice, but would love to hear other input.

 

mate, just play to win the game. ask yourself who is most likely to be scum, and then you vote that person.

WWWwombat Spam Master

WWWwombat

Posted
Posted

 

i think you are wrong. I think sili screwed up his claim but he does have a history of doing that     especially if Yates is around lol

 

sili does what sili does. sometimes i don't know if i should even bother randing anything other than vanilla if i'm going to be lynched anyway :dry:

 

 

I think you are a terrific vanilla if I don't mislynch u FWIW

WWWwombat Spam Master

WWWwombat

Posted
Posted

Heart essentially can't not call me scum right now. It would be too unnatural not to scum read me considering my slot is the loudest voice for her lynch.

 

Remember earlier when I said about the inevitable scum read angle she was working to? Yeah.

 

If Heart were town, she'd be mad at us but wouldn't OMGUS us imo

Andrej Spam Master

Andrej

Posted
Posted

 

 

Heart essentially can't not call me scum right now. It would be too unnatural not to scum read me considering my slot is the loudest voice for her lynch.

 

Remember earlier when I said about the inevitable scum read angle she was working to? Yeah.

you talking about when she said it would be too omgus-y if she voted u right away?

What?

Andrej Spam Master

Andrej

Posted
Posted

 

 

 

 

Seph I told you from the beginning I was gonna ride you. There really isn't much else to consider imo.

 

Seeing all the claims and knowing my role, I don't think Heart is the doc. I didn't really believe she was when she first claimed because of the situation and sketchy reasoning around missing obvious protects.

 

She hasn't done anything to change my mind and her posts in defense sound like a caught wolf. That one she did with the Princess Bride wifom guy picture was legit bad.

 

You wanna complain because I'm not doing anything. Well guess what? The work is done. Just like it was in American Gods. The wolves are outed. We just need to lynch them now

Say again what he lesson learned was from that game? Specifically what towns should learn? Probably best relegated to end game...but I have my own thoughts...and right now I'm seeing something similar.

Towns should learn to sheep AJ and Wombat. Duh.

This is what I wanted to say but refrained.

 

But yeah. Wolves are dead. We've helped find and lynch them. When we point the heavy finger it should be considered always imo.

Andrej Spam Master

Andrej

Posted
Posted

Seph you're completely disregarding that AH as a wolf could shoot elsewhere to "prove" herself.

 

Just because she and Zander both live doesn't mean she's telling the truth.

 

The only way I agree to lynching anyone other than Heart today is if Zander swears to view her.

Sili Quirrels Master

Sili Quirrels

Posted
Posted

 

 

Heart essentially can't not call me scum right now. It would be too unnatural not to scum read me considering my slot is the loudest voice for her lynch.

 

Remember earlier when I said about the inevitable scum read angle she was working to? Yeah.

you talking about when she said it would be too omgus-y if she voted u right away?

What?

 

I

 

re.

 

 

Going to have to sleep before I can trust my brain to look at any of this correctly (sorry seph), but basically anyone not purple could be the scum (obviously a somewhat deep wolf in here somewhere) and I really do find it unlikely it is a blue as well. Will have to look at the green and yellow especially close in the morning. Right now no one is particularly jumping out as "look at me! I'm scum!!" I don't like the way Wombo has been handling me, but want to take time to analyze that so it isn't just a natural OMGUS getting a hold of my judgement. 

 

I'm not opposed to heart. Just if she isn't mafia where does that leave us...

Still well enough off, in a situation similar to the alien game, except with 4 ppl we know can't be scum, and a couple others that are really unlikely to be scum.

dicetosser1 Spam Master

dicetosser1

Posted
Posted

I didnt like hearts post regarding the janitor.

I DID like Darthes point that she may have got stuck on the leelou lynch. As others have pointed out she tried to get off it  screwed the unvote up and then went "whatever"

 

Then we have her claim  

 

Doc is feasible at the time.

Even cant protect every night is feasible.

 

But mods who do theme games DO try to match things with the theme.  Obi Laine makes sense THEMATICALLY as a cop. Yoda does as stump. 

 

Han as COMMUTER makes thematic sense. imagine leaving the village by hyperspace.

 

Qui Gon Jinn a renowned swordsman as a DOC??  that DOESNT make sense.

dicetosser1 Spam Master

dicetosser1

Posted
Posted

setting things out to see them

 

We go No lynch.  Zander views someone. Heart if she IS Doc HAS to protect zander. in this scenario Zander  if telling the truth gets a view. This may confirm 2 people even. Heart probably gets dead. If Heart IS mafia she CANT kill Zander  she would be immediately outted. She'd have to kill someone else. So we still get a view from a non liar zander.

 

We lynch Heart.  if she flips Doc Zanders either a dead man or useless.  She flips mafia we either win or SK hunt. 

 

Im seriously not seeing the downside to a no lynch here. Does anyone else? and dont give me we can win this right here. We are not CERTAIN. We may be wrong.

 

unvote

 

vote no lynch

 

 

anyone willing to follow?

Sili Quirrels Master

Sili Quirrels

Posted
Posted

I didnt like hearts post regarding the janitor.

I DID like Darthes point that she may have got stuck on the leelou lynch. As others have pointed out she tried to get off it  screwed the unvote up and then went "whatever"

 

Then we have her claim  

 

Doc is feasible at the time.

Even cant protect every night is feasible.

 

But mods who do theme games DO try to match things with the theme.  Obi Laine makes sense THEMATICALLY as a cop. Yoda does as stump. 

 

Han as COMMUTER makes thematic sense. imagine leaving the village by hyperspace.

 

Qui Gon Jinn a renowned swordsman as a DOC??  that DOESNT make sense.

c3po and r2d2 as masons too.

Eldrick4221 Master

Eldrick4221

Posted
Posted

Just another post asking her to improve...why post these comments?

 

 

The only reason I was scumreading her was her lack of contribution. If she was town, I wanted her to prove it by improving. I don't see what the issue is here.

 

 

First...unvote

 

Second...your case did not fall apart...in fact it gained steam and the you inexplicably remove your vote...in hindsight of the flip...along with your slip...I'm leaning toward moving my vote this way.

 

 

My case did fall apart. At the point of my unvote, the only thing I had left on them was Leelou's scum list. That wasn't enough IMO. I don't know what you're referring to with it building steam.

 

So pretty Sure the only two people who won't vote sili atm is wombo and heart. Or at least considered it

 

And me.

 

Seph you're completely disregarding that AH as a wolf could shoot elsewhere to "prove" herself.

 

Just because she and Zander both live doesn't mean she's telling the truth.

 

The only way I agree to lynching anyone other than Heart today is if Zander swears to view her.

 

He already did.

dicetosser1 Spam Master

dicetosser1

Posted
Posted

 

I didnt like hearts post regarding the janitor.

I DID like Darthes point that she may have got stuck on the leelou lynch. As others have pointed out she tried to get off it  screwed the unvote up and then went "whatever"

 

Then we have her claim  

 

Doc is feasible at the time.

Even cant protect every night is feasible.

 

But mods who do theme games DO try to match things with the theme.  Obi Laine makes sense THEMATICALLY as a cop. Yoda does as stump. 

 

Han as COMMUTER makes thematic sense. imagine leaving the village by hyperspace.

 

Qui Gon Jinn a renowned swordsman as a DOC??  that DOESNT make sense.

c3po and r2d2 as masons too.

 

 

True  and NB claimed Mace Windu. Another that doesnt fit thematically. 

 

 

Oh and 

I wasnt going to vote sili or yates after that claim

Eldrick4221 Master

Eldrick4221

Posted
Posted

Wombo's game this day has been horrible IMO

 

First they pushed for Heart lynch, admitting that they weren't reading what she has to say and just bulldozing for her death.

 

Then, after the doc claim, they still want her dead. Even if she is mafia, it should be decided tonight. I don't think she is, and niether so many other people. Your tunneling is not changing my opinion on you.

 

And then the commuter claim. Highly suspicious to claim something that can't be proven, except by kill or cop view.

 

At no point in this game has Wombo been better than null to me. They have been varying degrees of scummy, and are stinking of it right now.

 

I still believe that there is mafia between Heart and Wombo, because of Leelou's list. This is the way to go today. If they aren't mafia, Heart will be resolved tonight anyway.

 

I'm also happy with lynching notbob. The N2 kill is unexplained, unless Dice wants to claim it.

Eldrick4221 Master

Eldrick4221

Posted
Posted

i killed no one eldrick

 

Sili who do you think?

Cool. Then someone is lying about their role. Big shock there.

 

Did you claim, dice? Everyone else has.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

About Dragonmount

Dragonmount is a fan-maintained website dedicated to Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time fantasy series. It is an online community of people from all over the world who have come here to experience the series to the fullest.

Twitter

Facebook

Copyright © 2024, Dragonmount Powered by Invision Community

© All borrowed artwork is used with permission. The Wheel of Time books & franchise are © Robert Jordan & the Bandersnatch Group.

The phrases "The Wheel of Time‚" and "The Dragon Reborn", and the snake-wheel symbol are trademarks of Robert Jordan & the Bandersnatch Group.

×
×
  • Create New...