[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

[Talya]

In case you haven't noticed, i'm not buying the mason claim. I just don't see them as scum either. I actually do believe they are lovers.

 

then one might be town and one might wolf...

[seph]

If ah is doc why would she lie here and not jump on with me and zander?

That doesn't make any sense to me

[csarmi]

If everyone claims, and noone else claims a killing role, then notbob is lying.

Or someone else is lying. Or mafia had a 1 shot vig.

 

Let us go back to gameplay guys. Read and all. Gaming has perils.

[Talya]

Zander please answer the questions!

[Eldrick4221]

Eldrick that argument has some flows. Like mafia obviously killing a doc just because they think the doc cant self prot. BTW AH could easily be doc here AND lying about not bein able to protect the same target twice.

 

Nope. Don't buy that. She would have protected Laine again.

[Zander?]

@ Zander...so you had no idea you would get it after she was dead...so what was your role before hand. Why did you get it?

 

No i didnt.

I was VT town

I have NO IDEA why i got it.

[seph]

 

Eldrick that argument has some flows. Like mafia obviously killing a doc just because they think the doc cant self prot. BTW AH could easily be doc here AND lying about not bein able to protect the same target twice.

 

 

Nope. Don't buy that. She would have protected Laine again.

 

Eldrick she protected laine N2 which wasn't a bad idea. You can't protect the same person twice

[csarmi]

 

In case you haven't noticed, i'm not buying the mason claim. I just don't see them as scum either. I actually do believe they are lovers.

 

 

then one might be town and one might wolf...

Have you seen the series? You kidding right :)

[Eldrick4221]

 

In case you haven't noticed, i'm not buying the mason claim. I just don't see them as scum either. I actually do believe they are lovers.

 

then one might be town and one might wolf...

 

Did not think of that...

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

Eldrick that argument has some flows. Like mafia obviously killing a doc just because they think the doc cant self prot. BTW AH could easily be doc here AND lying about not bein able to protect the same target twice.

 

Nope. Don't buy that. She would have protected Laine again.

 

Eldrick she protected laine N2 which wasn't a bad idea. You can't protect the same person twice

 

Responding to the bolded. not buying that.

[Zander?]

 

In case you haven't noticed, i'm not buying the mason claim. I just don't see them as scum either. I actually do believe they are lovers.

 

then one might be town and one might wolf...

 

 

exactly!!!!  one lynch 2 answers!!!  lynch sili

[seph]

He'll WE can have zander view heart tonight if you guys want... but that I'd a waste.

If zander is alive it's because mafia are scared of ah being a doc.

If ah is mafia she has to kill the cop or she is going to lose anyways.

[Zander?]

 

If everyone claims, and noone else claims a killing role, then notbob is lying.

 

wrong

 

someone else could be lying

 

 

this ^^^^^

[Talya]

 

@ Zander...so you had no idea you would get it after she was dead...so what was your role before hand. Why did you get it?

 

No i didnt.

I was VT town

I have NO IDEA why i got it.

 

 

So you didn't ask the Mod?

[Zander?]

VOTE SILI!!!!

[Eldrick4221]

Eldrick that argument has some flows. Like mafia obviously killing a doc just because they think the doc cant self prot. BTW AH could easily be doc here AND lying about not bein able to protect the same target twice.

True. So let's say Heart is the doc for some reason the mafia lets her live. Zander still checks someone and we go into tomorrow with a result and a live doc.

[Talya]

 

 

In case you haven't noticed, i'm not buying the mason claim. I just don't see them as scum either. I actually do believe they are lovers.

 

then one might be town and one might wolf...

Have you seen the series? You kidding right :)

 

 

One of those could have been a safe claim obviously! They had Leia as one

[Zander?]

 

 

@ Zander...so you had no idea you would get it after she was dead...so what was your role before hand. Why did you get it?

 

No i didnt.

I was VT town

I have NO IDEA why i got it.

 

 

So you didn't ask the Mod?

 

 

to what end?  why is that even important?

[Eldrick4221]

VOTE SILI!!!!

No.

[Talya]

I don't how those claims work...but could they be assigned their own ones or is there usually a pool to chose from?

[seph]

 

 

 

Eldrick that argument has some flows. Like mafia obviously killing a doc just because they think the doc cant self prot. BTW AH could easily be doc here AND lying about not bein able to protect the same target twice.

 

 

Nope. Don't buy that. She would have protected Laine again.

Eldrick she protected laine N2 which wasn't a bad idea. You can't protect the same person twice

Responding to the bolded. not buying that.

Look at how ah spoke it seemed genuine to me, and I saw little bits of trail like how she asked of my pheonix role would work when I died, then today says she didn't know if she would have to doc me.

 

That was a genuine question and I believe her. So should you.

 

Voting sili clears or condemn yates. They do not look like masons.

 

If ah is doctor scum have to kill her.

Otherwise zander lives, gets a peek then dies.

And our doctor has a chance to self protect or save any cleared towny.

[Zander?]

 

Eldrick that argument has some flows. Like mafia obviously killing a doc just because they think the doc cant self prot. BTW AH could easily be doc here AND lying about not bein able to protect the same target twice.

True. So let's say Heart is the doc for some reason the mafia lets her live. Zander still checks someone and we go into tomorrow with a result and a live doc.

 

 

 

SO VOTE SILI and it makes things SO MUCH EASIER!!!

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

@ Zander...so you had no idea you would get it after she was dead...so what was your role before hand. Why did you get it?

 

No i didnt.

I was VT town

I have NO IDEA why i got it.

 

 

So you didn't ask the Mod?

 

 

to what end?  why is that even important?

 

1. it was his role all along, and he didn't know it until Laine died.

2. Laine dying triggered a random assign.

 

Either way, doesn't matter. Drop this.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

In case you haven't noticed, i'm not buying the mason claim. I just don't see them as scum either. I actually do believe they are lovers.

 

then one might be town and one might wolf...

Have you seen the series? You kidding right :)

 

 

One of those could have been a safe claim obviously! They had Leia as one

 

 

this ^^^^^^

[csarmi]

Okie.

 

Dice, Seph i will need your input tomorrow. You should lead the discussion and all. Until then i suggest taking Seph's advice and read the game and let's help them with input.

 

In thr meantime we might herw more from Sili/Yates.

 

@Sili/Yates: pls be to the point here

@Zander: really appreciate your enthusiasm. Let's sleep on this though. There is no need to hurry.