[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

[csarmi]

@Seph - would you like lists, or lists with reasoning?

[csarmi]

Current PoE is Eldrick, Talya, Wombo, AH.

 

In no particular order.

[Yates]

3rd Bold FWIW you and Sili seem to be protecting each other quite a bit.

We do? I wonder why.

 

Seph knows why. You can ask him.

[seph]

I just want everyone's thoughts currently tbh

I just want to try to narrow down the pool. 

[csarmi]

I also have some theories I'd share later. On the setup, on some roles.

[Talya]

Not sure about tomorrow...

 

I'm partial to a Heart lynch.

 

@Talya:

Conversation 1:
He's saying Durin wasn't doc. He's saying Durin wasn't doc because it looks like the scum were still doc hunting even after Durin was dead.

Conversation 2:
He asked me *IF* I was mafia, why would I have killed him. I said because they were doc hunting. Then I provided the quote where it looks like he could have been doc hinting.

So, in essence, conversation 2 supports conversation 1. I'm agreeing with him that it looked like a doc hunt and thus Durin was almost certainly not the Doc.

Conversation 3:
In the "things didn't go down the way I thought last night" post I was doing the same thing. I was trying to subtly hint at being the doc while not the ACTUAL doc. In other words, I was trying to draw a NK even though I was consensus poe. Which is hard.

 

Thank you, that makes much more sense.

[Zander?]

 

3rd Bold FWIW you and Sili seem to be protecting each other quite a bit.

We do? I wonder why.

 

Seph knows why. You can ask him.

 

 

 

He does funny why hes asking me to help him get his vote on you.  2nd not buying mason here brother.  your scum and when you flip it sili looks bad for not distancing if he doesn't /

[seph]

I was only kinda sus of him for his activity, so I threw in a case on him with Thaneballs as my bottom two to see where people would fall. I feel like he's genuinely frustrated with how wordy this game is and can't catch up, which really sucks. I also felt that the interaction between him and Andrej had a town/town feel to it. I mean, of course it's still possible for him to be scum and just floating, but I just don't see it, unless the scum team has lost their WiM with these lynches and town core

zander how do you interpret this post of alannas?

[seph]

 

 

3rd Bold FWIW you and Sili seem to be protecting each other quite a bit.

We do? I wonder why.

 

Seph knows why. You can ask him.

 

 

 

He does funny why hes asking me to help him get his vote on you.  2nd not buying mason here brother.  your scum and when you flip it sili looks bad for not distancing if he doesn't /

 

So you think we have 5 scum?

[csarmi]

Seph: I don't really have anything for you that I didn't share before. I can't clear Wombo. Eldrick and AH I still don't have reads on some vague impressions - never been at focus for me. Talya I got mixed. I don't think I know how to clear her. Once I caught her as mafia but my experience playing with her is very limited.

 

NotBob is gut read only (don't really know). Zander, Dice pretty clear. Sili/Yates I believe to be town.

[csarmi]

@Seph - Five wolves are not out of the question, but we need to go into setup and role speculation to judge that. I'm willing to go there if you want me to - but I thi nk that'd better wait.

[Talya]

I could also go with NotBob, and WombyAJ and Eld. But these are not strong at the moment. Heart isn't that strong...so they are all there.

 

TOWN: Dice, Seph

 

Slight town: Zander, Sili and Yates (if Seph can confirm about them.) If so that is quite powerful.to know, because it limits the field. 

 

CS I would be interested to hear more.

[Yates]

I just want everyone's thoughts currently tbh

 

I just want to try to narrow down the pool.

I think Heart was kind of consensus next lynch.

Eldrick took a beating for flubbing a VT claim but was trending Town until then.

I'm going to trust you on Zander until I don't.

Talya hard defending me feels a little weird.

Wombocombo is an outside shot at scum. I'd probably lynch Zander before Wombo at this point, though.

 

Dice is conf Town. Has been the whole game, really, but I think we can all agree he WAS a peek of Laine's.

Csarmi is pretty much conf Town. This is based on Dice's read + claim + meta. POSSIBLY a Lainey peek.

NB is conf not scum. I kind of don't want to elaborate on what he *could* be but he's basically either an SK or a Town PR.

[Yates]

 

Seph knows why. You can ask him.

He does funny why hes asking me to help him get his vote on you.

 

LOL - what is it with reading comprehension. He's making you think it through because he isn't going to vote for me.

[Sili Quirrels]

Its probably heart. Ill check her iso in a bit when im free.

[Zander?]

 

I was only kinda sus of him for his activity, so I threw in a case on him with Thaneballs as my bottom two to see where people would fall. I feel like he's genuinely frustrated with how wordy this game is and can't catch up, which really sucks. I also felt that the interaction between him and Andrej had a town/town feel to it. I mean, of course it's still possible for him to be scum and just floating, but I just don't see it, unless the scum team has lost their WiM with these lynches and town core

zander how do you interpret this post of alannas?

 

 

 

vote Yates.

[Zander?]

 

 

Seph knows why. You can ask him.

He does funny why hes asking me to help him get his vote on you.

 

LOL - what is it with reading comprehension. He's making you think it through because he isn't going to vote for me.

 

 

so far youve implied im im weird ridiculous strange and now i can't read.  i think your frustrated cause im on to you.  and others will soon see it for themselves

[seph]

 

 

I was only kinda sus of him for his activity, so I threw in a case on him with Thaneballs as my bottom two to see where people would fall. I feel like he's genuinely frustrated with how wordy this game is and can't catch up, which really sucks. I also felt that the interaction between him and Andrej had a town/town feel to it. I mean, of course it's still possible for him to be scum and just floating, but I just don't see it, unless the scum team has lost their WiM with these lynches and town core

zander how do you interpret this post of alannas?

 

 

 

vote Yates.

 

make a case besides vote counts and I might.

the cfd and the thaneballs lynches happened rather quickly he could have not had time to play, or get a voice in.

 

I am still looking at yates currently and I need to iso him. But if you lead the lynch and he flips town then what? who is your next suspect?

 

[seph]

 

 

 

Seph knows why. You can ask him.

He does funny why hes asking me to help him get his vote on you.

 

LOL - what is it with reading comprehension. He's making you think it through because he isn't going to vote for me.

 

 

so far youve implied im im weird ridiculous strange and now i can't read.  i think your frustrated cause im on to you.  and others will soon see it for themselves

 

I will keep an eye open, but I want to go elsewhere for now I think.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

I was only kinda sus of him for his activity, so I threw in a case on him with Thaneballs as my bottom two to see where people would fall. I feel like he's genuinely frustrated with how wordy this game is and can't catch up, which really sucks. I also felt that the interaction between him and Andrej had a town/town feel to it. I mean, of course it's still possible for him to be scum and just floating, but I just don't see it, unless the scum team has lost their WiM with these lynches and town core

zander how do you interpret this post of alannas?

 

 

 

vote Yates.

 

make a case besides vote counts and I might.

the cfd and the thaneballs lynches happened rather quickly he could have not had time to play, or get a voice in.

 

I am still looking at yates currently and I need to iso him. But if you lead the lynch and he flips town then what? who is your next suspect?

 

 

 

why does he keep implying YOU KNOW about him?

[Yates]

so far youve implied im im weird ridiculous strange and now i can't read.  i think your frustrated cause im on to you.  and others will soon see it for themselves

Welp. I'm stepping away for a bit but you only have me for another hour until Vacation Yates replaces Yates.

[Yates]

why does he keep implying YOU KNOW about him?

I shared some meta knowledge with him when I was his mod confirmed mentor.

[Sili Quirrels]

You are being strange zander. Im trying to wrap my head around it too. I dont know where u r coming from

[WWWwombat]

@ Talya what im saying is i DO NOT believe WOMBO vs Yates is town vs town.  I dont think a wolf WOmbo comes in and drops a vote on Hart that quickly as a wolf.  i think yates is trying to clear himself through Alanna.  i dont believe it.

 

Why are you so committed on this not town on town thing?  It's weird.  I think Yates is kinda slimy today, but not in a wolfy way.  I haven't checked back, but assuming Yates is right about Laine pulling a 180 on him, then if he's town here, it's reasonable for him to think that Laine viewed him.  Him trying to clear himself is opportunistic but not inherently wolfy.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

I was only kinda sus of him for his activity, so I threw in a case on him with Thaneballs as my bottom two to see where people would fall. I feel like he's genuinely frustrated with how wordy this game is and can't catch up, which really sucks. I also felt that the interaction between him and Andrej had a town/town feel to it. I mean, of course it's still possible for him to be scum and just floating, but I just don't see it, unless the scum team has lost their WiM with these lynches and town core

zander how do you interpret this post of alannas?

 

 

 

vote Yates.

 

make a case besides vote counts and I might.

the cfd and the thaneballs lynches happened rather quickly he could have not had time to play, or get a voice in.

 

I am still looking at yates currently and I need to iso him. But if you lead the lynch and he flips town then what? who is your next suspect?

 

 

 

 

he;s not...but probably eldrick.  but im NOT moving my vote

 

believe in me.