American Gods Mafia [Advanced] - mafia win

[Thane Vakarian]

i'm somewhere on page 38.. i'll try to read up asap (@ work)

 

morning all (or, evening, flaming timezones)

[Darthe]

also on a side note, I was thinking about the reporter thing earlier and when comparing it with the theme I think that's almost ALWAYS a scum role here. The whole premise of the game is the Old Gods warring with the newer powers and the media is considered a bad guy. The reporter thing comes across as a way to spew mod confirmed wifom.

That would be interesting.  Could be OP for a wolf team but yeah.

[Darthe]

Sili you look really reactive here.  Even if you're kind of blegh on the game you still haven't shown depth.  You do get why you're a wolf read for many players, right?

[Sili Quirrels]

 

also on a side note, I was thinking about the reporter thing earlier and when comparing it with the theme I think that's almost ALWAYS a scum role here. The whole premise of the game is the Old Gods warring with the newer powers and the media is considered a bad guy. The reporter thing comes across as a way to spew mod confirmed wifom.

That would be interesting.  Could be OP for a wolf team but yeah.

 

 

what is wrong with my list and my op?

[Andrej]

Sili you were modkilled D2 and still had over 200 posts. Don't give me this crap about skimming and getting by.

 

I think you either over estimate your assertion or seriously underestimate how much thought I put into perception as a wolf. I wanted to look like a tunneling villager, especially after his claim. That's why I doubled down in it. Initially I was legitimately suspicious that Yates could've been a wolf on the other team but once he claimed I didn't think pulling a 180 would save me much face and my teammate was next on the block. Executing him there probably won us the game in the long run tbh - but that's not important this game.

[Andrej]

 

also on a side note, I was thinking about the reporter thing earlier and when comparing it with the theme I think that's almost ALWAYS a scum role here. The whole premise of the game is the Old Gods warring with the newer powers and the media is considered a bad guy. The reporter thing comes across as a way to spew mod confirmed wifom.

 

That would be interesting.  Could be OP for a wolf team but yeah.

Did you see Kaylee's ventriloquist role? I've seen weirder

[Darthe]

Reads are low effort and just sort of shrugged out, like you don't really care where they are.  

 

TBH I can't really remember about the OP... I just recall thinking it was off at the time and saying so then.

[Darthe]

 

 

also on a side note, I was thinking about the reporter thing earlier and when comparing it with the theme I think that's almost ALWAYS a scum role here. The whole premise of the game is the Old Gods warring with the newer powers and the media is considered a bad guy. The reporter thing comes across as a way to spew mod confirmed wifom.

That would be interesting.  Could be OP for a wolf team but yeah.

Did you see Kaylee's ventriloquist role? I've seen weirder

 

Hah that one game ithi was a voodoo doll and took over Red was pretty great.  Yeah, point made.  

 

Why did you make it though?

[seph]

Hmmmmmmmmmm sili is notbob your teammate?

POE leaves sooh or wombat.

 

Doubtful dice. But i Don't remember his opinions on you

[Andrej]

Felt pertinent. I probably spend an unhealthy/abnormal time thinking about these games and while I was mulling over some stuff during some down time at work this afternoon the idea came to mind. After reading the wiki on my character and getting an overall feel for the plot of the story this is based on I figured anything dealing with the media wouldn't be a good thing.

[Sili Quirrels]

Reads are low effort and just sort of shrugged out, like you don't really care where they are.  

 

TBH I can't really remember about the OP... I just recall thinking it was off at the time and saying so then.

-_-

 

They're the best i got in me before reading the last 8 or so pages, and 5 pages or so i missed from the weekend.

 

Sili you were modkilled D2 and still had over 200 posts. Don't give me this crap about skimming and getting by.

 

I think you either over estimate your assertion or seriously underestimate how much thought I put into perception as a wolf. I wanted to look like a tunneling villager, especially after his claim.

 

I feel like you're tunneling me. i was active last game for long stretches, which is why i had that many posts. But I'm pointing out to you that I do however post a lot less when my energy level is low and you're not listening to me. :/

[Darthe]

Hmmmmmmmmmm sili is notbob your teammate?

POE leaves sooh or wombat.

 

Doubtful dice. But i Don't remember his opinions on you

Am I suddenly not on your list?

[Darthe]

Felt pertinent. I probably spend an unhealthy/abnormal time thinking about these games and while I was mulling over some stuff during some down time at work this afternoon the idea came to mind. After reading the wiki on my character and getting an overall feel for the plot of the story this is based on I figured anything dealing with the media wouldn't be a good thing.

Cool.  I don't know the theme.  Anything else you think the reporter could be?

[Andrej]

I feel like you're tunneling me. i was active last game for long stretches, which is why i had that many posts. But I'm pointing out to you that I do however post a lot less when my energy level is low and you're not listening to me. :/

You're deserving of the pressure imo. I'm pointing out how your play looks low effort right now which I don't associate with your villager game. Pulling quotes from other games isn't going to change that perception. I don't think I've ever had trouble town reading you in the past for the exception of Kaylee's game which had a weird role in it. Am I supposed to just take what you say at face value and give you a pass? If I'm wrong about you then I need you to prove that.

[Andrej]

 

Felt pertinent. I probably spend an unhealthy/abnormal time thinking about these games and while I was mulling over some stuff during some down time at work this afternoon the idea came to mind. After reading the wiki on my character and getting an overall feel for the plot of the story this is based on I figured anything dealing with the media wouldn't be a good thing.

 

Cool.  I don't know the theme.  Anything else you think the reporter could be?

Idk. I guess we'll see as the game progresses and we get more "reports" but going off flavor I don't think it's town motivated.

[seph]

If sili is wolf darthe, I don't see how you fit in. Or aj for that matter.

I am re adjusting my list with my current reads, I am not afraid to be wrong. But this is were I am leaning currently.

If sili is wolf I think he is on a team with not bob, and POE points to wombat from memory.

[WWWwombat]

 

Sili can we get a reads list from you

Ya sure.

 

Town wombat

Null to town dice notbob

Null thane sooh

Null to scum aj darthe

 

 

This list is interesting.  Not sure if I like it or not.

 

 

 

Care to explain why you guys don't like my case? Looks pretty suggestive to me.

I get where you're coming from and I think you put a fair amount of thought into it but I don't think things he's said, as contradictory as them may seem, make him a wolf. You acknowledged yourself that he says/does scummy and weird things and they don't always mean he's scum.

 

If you think Thane hasn't done anything for the game where are you regarding Sili? Give me your opinion on him.

 

 

Null to town lean.  He hasn't posted much, but most of the posts of his I read, I think, this could come from a townie.  Given that I've heard the 3 games thing from a couple of people now, I'm sort of giving them all the benefit of the doubt for a bit on "WiM," but I want to see a lot more posting from all of them.

[WWWwombat]

Darthe, stop the S group thing.  You're not Mynd.

[seph]

I keep forgetting about thane somehow....

Thane or sooh could be in wombat place.

[WWWwombat]

 

 

Isn't that what everyone does anyway?

Typically yes. That sort of info coming from the mod could likely skew some people's perspective though. Eventually people will start to hunt the supposed Indy player specifically.

 

On pog they always laugh at ppl who hunt for the hardest to hunt anti-town.

 

 

I just lynch them.

[WWWwombat]

 

also on a side note, I was thinking about the reporter thing earlier and when comparing it with the theme I think that's almost ALWAYS a scum role here. The whole premise of the game is the Old Gods warring with the newer powers and the media is considered a bad guy. The reporter thing comes across as a way to spew mod confirmed wifom.

That would be interesting.  Could be OP for a wolf team but yeah.

 

 

I've seen anonymous announcements as a wolf power before.  It was a pretty role madness game though.

[WWWwombat]

Don't like this extended discussion about a game I haven't read.

[Andrej]

If sili is wolf darthe, I don't see how you fit in. Or aj for that matter.

I am re adjusting my list with my current reads, I am not afraid to be wrong. But this is were I am leaning currently.

If sili is wolf I think he is on a team with not bob, and POE points to wombat from memory.

I doubt Wombat is a wolf. If Sili is a villager I could maybe see a Darthe/Not Bob combo for the avoidance that Darthe was pointing out. The issue with this is that Sooh remains a question mark, who is the person Not Bob has focused on toDay.

 

I think you're more likely a villager than not. I don't believe Thane is a wolf unless he's just intentionally trying to clear himself by showing us how shiny his tinfoil hat is.

 

With my thought in mind regarding the Reporter I will recant my statement earlier about Dice being Indy seeing as how I'm starting to believe it's just a false trail

[Andrej]

 

 

 

Sili can we get a reads list from you

Ya sure.

 

Town wombat

Null to town dice notbob

Null thane sooh

Null to scum aj darthe

This list is interesting. Not sure if I like it or not.

 

 

Care to explain why you guys don't like my case? Looks pretty suggestive to me.

I get where you're coming from and I think you put a fair amount of thought into it but I don't think things he's said, as contradictory as them may seem, make him a wolf. You acknowledged yourself that he says/does scummy and weird things and they don't always mean he's scum.

 

If you think Thane hasn't done anything for the game where are you regarding Sili? Give me your opinion on him.

Null to town lean. He hasn't posted much, but most of the posts of his I read, I think, this could come from a townie. Given that I've heard the 3 games thing from a couple of people now, I'm sort of giving them all the benefit of the doubt for a bit on "WiM," but I want to see a lot more posting from all of them.

I get the WIM thing but idk how long I'm willing to let that slide.

[seph]

Wombat is my deep wolf.

 

I thought I remember him arguing for not job and sili. So was just a poe.

Only way I would vote him I think is if the other two show up.