A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

Askthepizzaguy · May 18, 2015

Wolf team Alot thinks Hallia is a wolf, village couldn't pose a threat to the wolves if they tried, regardless of my claimed power due to me being outed.

They are not bussing one of their own, there is no purpose in doing so, but using the wolves' better vantage point than my own, and the fact that I have peeks clearing others, Hallia likely is a wolf.

I was halfway through reading her villager here, when it finally dawned on me what is happening.

This is fantastic. This is why village will win this game now. This is as good as three guilty peeks.

Gabriel Kross · May 18, 2015

and for those that didn't get the hint I'm Ecthelion I vanilla town who couldn't care less what happens anymore. There was a reason I quit in the first place and it seems some things never change around here.

Askthepizzaguy · May 18, 2015

3 scums down, and that's ALOT of spew to go back and re-read, if you'll pardon the pun.

Not only that, probably an entire half of one wolf team, but a likely member of another in the mix as well.

There literally couldn't be a worse outcome for wolves than this blunder. I am so pumped right now, if I can iso the involved likely guilty parties I might be able to get things wrapped up or at the very least, strongly solved, by the end of today alone.

I have alot of people to thank for this opportunity. The wolves, and the other wolves.

And the villagers who decided to act like villagers this game. I just kept bumping into them, one after another, like the roomba king always does.

Gabriel Kross · May 18, 2015

Wolf team Alot thinks Hallia is a wolf, village couldn't pose a threat to the wolves if they tried, regardless of my claimed power due to me being outed.

They are not bussing one of their own, there is no purpose in doing so, but using the wolves' better vantage point than my own, and the fact that I have peeks clearing others, Hallia likely is a wolf.

I was halfway through reading her villager here, when it finally dawned on me what is happening.

This is fantastic. This is why village will win this game now. This is as good as three guilty peeks.

oh and goodluck selling this theory when I flip exactly what I said I am, all you managed to do was cement my desire to not want to play mafia anymore.

Talya · May 18, 2015

@EP -my bad I read it wrong.

Will have t look closely at you two when home tonight, seems contrived. But I am reading quickly on my phone.

Need to think about EP claim and Hally's

Askthepizzaguy · May 18, 2015

Wolf team Alot thinks Hallia is a wolf, village couldn't pose a threat to the wolves if they tried, regardless of my claimed power due to me being outed.

They are not bussing one of their own, there is no purpose in doing so, but using the wolves' better vantage point than my own, and the fact that I have peeks clearing others, Hallia likely is a wolf.

I was halfway through reading her villager here, when it finally dawned on me what is happening.

This is fantastic. This is why village will win this game now. This is as good as three guilty peeks.

oh and goodluck selling this theory when I flip exactly what I said I am, all you managed to do was cement my desire to not want to play mafia anymore.

No sale-

Firstly, this is my first ever game playing with you. So you have not grown weary of me yet, seeing as I have accused your for what, an hour or so, so far, in one game where you already died on my team and replaced in to help someone out.

So, you have very little vested interest in what happens to your role. If anyone was keeping track of the stats, if thats a thing here, if you replace in on a different team, then you should either get marked down as a draw or a win regardless, unless both of those teams lost.

Basically you got a chance to continue play and you agreed, and under the severe pressure of one whole vote and a tinfoil hat case and zero evidence, you collapse and don't want to play mafia anymore.

Okay sure, that makes sense.

Except it's also very true that mafia will want to lynch people that the village suspects are wolves, especially if the wolf team thinks it is actually a member of the opposing wolf team.

But it wouldn't matter that much, they'd also love to lynch a villager that the village strongly suspects.

The day just began and I laid out almost nothing condemning you, and acted more confident than I was.

Your response is to flinch pretty hard and play the victim card.

It's not persuasive for the reasons listed. You appeared to be having a decent time earlier in the game, and were not emotional at all.

You replace in, and someone who suspected the person you replaced voted for you, and said they were going to find your wolf buddies.

The villager response to that is to laugh, not hint you're Ecthelion I, as if that meant anything. You almost can't possibly be a valuable village power, so the name is meaningless.

So why drop it? It does nothing.

This is to distract those who are impressed by such things. If you're a vanilla villager you claim that before you drop your name. The name is just fluff at that point.

Well, you're leaving mafia forever anyway so I'm assuming you're reading none of this, but for the record, it's bad form regardless of role to play such a card.

It makes the game less enjoyable for others. You'd bum them out for the horrific crime of actually playing the game and voting for their suspects.

Something you know is a slimy thing to do, but did it anyway because it's not illegal and it might win for your team.

Nothing personal, I've had a great time playing with you so far, and assuming you were telling the truth about your reaction to me, I'm sorry you feel that way.

At the same time, you have to realize it's beyond unreasonable to say these things and for me to go "oops I might have voted a villager" for the ten thousandth time in my mafia playing career.

That danger is always there, and if village truly is losing anyway, I haven't really done anything to affect the status quo.

Your reaction indicates I just struck wolf blood with my pickaxe. Sorry if that hurts. Shake hands after the game or don't, I'll be sad if we don't, but I won't stop legally playing the game, and honorably playing the game, by voting for people I think it would win the game if they're the people I voted for.

So I'll take your reaction as either unfortunate but very little to do with me personally and none of my business if you choose to react that way in a game of suspicion, or a wolf claim.

If you choose to return to play I'll ignore the tactic you just used, as a courtesy. But I'm still voting for you.

Gabriel Kross · May 18, 2015

Wolf team Alot thinks Hallia is a wolf, village couldn't pose a threat to the wolves if they tried, regardless of my claimed power due to me being outed.

They are not bussing one of their own, there is no purpose in doing so, but using the wolves' better vantage point than my own, and the fact that I have peeks clearing others, Hallia likely is a wolf.

I was halfway through reading her villager here, when it finally dawned on me what is happening.

This is fantastic. This is why village will win this game now. This is as good as three guilty peeks.

oh and goodluck selling this theory when I flip exactly what I said I am, all you managed to do was cement my desire to not want to play mafia anymore.

No sale-

Firstly, this is my first ever game playing with you. So you have not grown weary of me yet, seeing as I have accused your for what, an hour or so, so far, in one game where you already died on my team and replaced in to help someone out.

So, you have very little vested interest in what happens to your role. If anyone was keeping track of the stats, if thats a thing here, if you replace in on a different team, then you should either get marked down as a draw or a win regardless, unless both of those teams lost.

Basically you got a chance to continue play and you agreed, and under the severe pressure of one whole vote and a tinfoil hat case and zero evidence, you collapse and don't want to play mafia anymore.

Okay sure, that makes sense.

Except it's also very true that mafia will want to lynch people that the village suspects are wolves, especially if the wolf team thinks it is actually a member of the opposing wolf team.

But it wouldn't matter that much, they'd also love to lynch a villager that the village strongly suspects.

The day just began and I laid out almost nothing condemning you, and acted more confident than I was.

Your response is to flinch pretty hard and play the victim card.

It's not persuasive for the reasons listed. You appeared to be having a decent time earlier in the game, and were not emotional at all.

You replace in, and someone who suspected the person you replaced voted for you, and said they were going to find your wolf buddies.

The villager response to that is to laugh, not hint you're Ecthelion I, as if that meant anything. You almost can't possibly be a valuable village power, so the name is meaningless.

So why drop it? It does nothing.

This is to distract those who are impressed by such things. If you're a vanilla villager you claim that before you drop your name. The name is just fluff at that point.

Well, you're leaving mafia forever anyway so I'm assuming you're reading none of this, but for the record, it's bad form regardless of role to play such a card.

It makes the game less enjoyable for others. You'd bum them out for the horrific crime of actually playing the game and voting for their suspects.

Something you know is a slimy thing to do, but did it anyway because it's not illegal and it might win for your team.

Nothing personal, I've had a great time playing with you so far, and assuming you were telling the truth about your reaction to me, I'm sorry you feel that way.

At the same time, you have to realize it's beyond unreasonable to say these things and for me to go "oops I might have voted a villager" for the ten thousandth time in my mafia playing career.

That danger is always there, and if village truly is losing anyway, I haven't really done anything to affect the status quo.

Your reaction indicates I just struck wolf blood with my pickaxe. Sorry if that hurts. Shake hands after the game or don't, I'll be sad if we don't, but I won't stop legally playing the game, and honorably playing the game, by voting for people I think it would win the game if they're the people I voted for.

So I'll take your reaction as either unfortunate but very little to do with me personally and none of my business if you choose to react that way in a game of suspicion, or a wolf claim.

If you choose to return to play I'll ignore the tactic you just used, as a courtesy. But I'm still voting for you.

not even going to bother reading this whole post. I quit due to multiple factors, 1 players were skating due to inactivity, 2 the same person singled me out day 1 in every game, 3 I felt no enjoyment in the game anymore

of the three reasons I quit 1 and 3 are still an issue. I was fine with my original death. I even called it. I would even say it was an enjoyable game up to that point, but in the almost 24 hours since I replaced back in only HALF of the players have even posted seriously? I don't see any angle where that's enjoyable. All I've done is gone on hunches because even the people who are posting are barely interacting with each other.

Also to be fair I didn't even read your "case" on me.

Gabriel Kross · May 18, 2015

okay so I read a little bit of it, and for the record you're the one discouraging people from posting.

Basically every thing I've said you've twisted into saying I'm mafia. I'm active and hunting so I must be mafia? right?

Thane Vakarian · May 18, 2015

3. ~~Alot~~ Eternal Phoenix 2.0

15. Andrej

these two can bump up. list of suspects is getting thinner

2. Sooh - mentored by Corn
4. ~~Alanna~~ Aiel Heart
5. Dice
6. ~~John Snow~~ Yates 2.0d

9. Talya

14. Taborline
16. Alannalynn

19. seph - mentored by Kaylee

21. TinaHel

23. Cass

Gabriel Kross · May 18, 2015

Where has Krak been since Pizza's "so-called clear"

Where has Taborline been all game?

How about Yates? he posted all of what maybe 2 posts today one to vote Hallia one to point out that it showed him and I think Talya as voting and not voting in a previous vote count?

Gabriel Kross · May 18, 2015

you know what [unvote] [v]Taborline[/v] not a single post of content all game if that's not anti-town I don't know what is

Gabriel Kross · May 18, 2015