[Advanced] Arthurian Mafia

[Yates]

So, where I come from sometimes roles have multiple win-cons that can be met.

Not in this game. It's a partially open setup and the win conditions were given in the OP.

[Sili Quirrels]

So, where I come from sometimes roles have multiple win-cons that can be met. For example Player A can meet win-condition 1 or 2... 

 

Is that a thing here?

 

If so, Sili is it part of your win-con to have to get Dice out of the game because of his character? Because if so your actions towards him now make sense. 

It isn't my win condition to specifically track down morgan le fe and kill her, no.

 

But I think it's to town's win condition we get him out of the game just in case, yes. And I think it makes perfect sense why a villager would want to make the safe play today.

[BFG]

Ugh, sorry DM has switched to html format. So my reply box is the size of a postage stamp. I'll go and grab another code off reception so I can try using my mobile, back in 5 minutes.

[MrsClov]

I still say we need to get actual mafia to flip today. 

[dicetosser1]

 

 

 

if anybody wants to ask somethingi'll be here for a few minutes.

You have a gun and two bullets.

 

Who do you shoot and why?

 

2 bullets?

 

first one: Eldrick: he's pushing his innocence and ignorance a bit too hard for the moment. 

 

second one: myself, so i don't have to read through pages of Sili's game scratch that, hesitating between Sili and Darthe. Sili for his approach on the game for the moment. It's all over the place and confusing the [censored] out of me. Darthe for the simple reason that, after reading through the recent gameplay, i'm no longer really convinced he actually is town. Do you really think scum would simply keep you alive to take town down, or is this of your own doing? 

 

If you think that isn't accurate then explain how the NKs make sense.

 

 

They make sense if Darthe and sili are mafia too.

 

That sounds like a role hint.  This is an opportune time to remove yourself from the poole yates.

role fishing

 

 

 

 

I just think it's interesting that so far everyone's claimed presumably good characters.

Take claims out of it - because you pretty much have to at this point - which two players have PLAYED the scummiest, in your opinion?

 

Recently? Sili and Eldrick.

Why lol. Ive done nothing wrong except been direct.

 

 

you dont know the meaning of the word

 

I protected Nyn n1, Clov n2.

 

I was not able to protect Clov from an evil priest, but I will have vengeance I swear it

 

convienant. nyns dead and clov cant be proven to be shot at

 

and, if you look for post 2003, you'd actually see my claim. Which, nobody here has yet, i think

 

i saw it. i think it could be a fake claim, tho if it is its not the best one.

[Sili Quirrels]

yeah, of course it's convenient I'd claim my role. What are you guys even saying?

[Yates]

I can't find lovers.

Oh. This is the old version. I'd have to find a link to the newer one. This one's missing like 75% of the roles. And some of the existing roles were re-calibrated.

[Sili Quirrels]

Will someone tell me the percent likelyhood Merlin isn't in this agme, there is no doctor, and Merlin is evil?

 

Can someone please tell me how that's a world we might be living in???

 

If you can't, then I demand you stop tinfoiling.

[Thane Vakarian]

@dice: The mod made me royalty without a PR, i was quite disappointed

[Sili Quirrels]

Also, another reason I want to kill dice is because he wants me dead in every post, yet he claims to be working for town.

 

That just doesn't fly in my opinion. If he was actually going to keep to his word, he'd care more than this.

[MrsClov]

Also, another reason I want to kill dice is because he wants me dead in every post, yet he claims to be working for town.

 

That just doesn't fly in my opinion. If he was actually going to keep to his word, he'd care more than this.

 

So you're reasons for lynching him are a personal vendetta.

[Yates]

Will someone tell me the percent likelyhood Merlin isn't in this agme, there is no doctor, and Merlin is evil?

1. % Likelihood [<- that's how you spell it] Merlin isn't in the game? 50%

2. % Likelihood there is no Doctor? 50%

3. % Likelihood Merlin is scum in this game? 0%

4. % Likelihood scum were given fake claims? 99.9%

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Also, another reason I want to kill dice is because he wants me dead in every post, yet he claims to be working for town.

 

That just doesn't fly in my opinion. If he was actually going to keep to his word, he'd care more than this.

 

So you're reasons for lynching him are a personal vendetta.

 

 

 

My justification is I completely believe Dice is at best a liability. i.e. His poor casing and erratic voting record are just the surface of what's wrong about him.

 

But I'd be lying if I said I wasn't biased.

[MrsClov]

Can I just vote for everyone? 

[Yates]

Can I just vote for everyone?

What does your role pm say on the subject?

[Yates]

 

Can I just vote for everyone?

What does your role pm say on the subject?

 

EBWOP:

9. DO NOT quote your Role PM, or any communication from the Mod, in the thread.

[MrsClov]

 

Can I just vote for everyone?

What does your role pm say on the subject?

 

 

It was rhetorical. I'm just frustrated because I can't figure this game out.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Will someone tell me the percent likelyhood Merlin isn't in this agme, there is no doctor, and Merlin is evil?

1. % Likelihood [<- that's how you spell it] Merlin isn't in the game? 50%

2. % Likelihood there is no Doctor? 50%

3. % Likelihood Merlin is scum in this game? 0%

4. % Likelihood scum were given fake claims? 99.9%

 

Arthur, Lancelot, and Morgan le Fe are in the game, so it isn't a stretch to assume Merlin is too.

 

Like Arthur, Merlin's best bud. And Morgan le Fe Merlin's arch nemesis.

 

+Lancelot who is a main character too.

[Sili Quirrels]

I don't know if scum were given fake role claims, but I doubt they were given healer in this set up.

[Darthe]

 

Also, another reason I want to kill dice is because he wants me dead in every post, yet he claims to be working for town.

 

That just doesn't fly in my opinion. If he was actually going to keep to his word, he'd care more than this.

 

So you're reasons for lynching him are a personal vendetta.

 

I'm pretty against your reasoning for wanting to keep him alive tbh.  Dice claimed the main villain of the series when he thought he had been cop viewed and in that scenario a survivor claim is a safe response (seems to have worked so far).

 

My thoughts on it are this:

 

If mafia has safe claims I'd assume Dice would have as well.  By claiming 3p he could circumvent the day/game becoming about him vs what he thought was a cop.

If we eliminate non-town we don't accidentally eliminate town meaning that this gets us closer to winning.

Maintaining that extra space equates to losing a townie.  While that sounds negative it can help us by clearing up some of the confusion in the game.  

There is little consensus on who to lynch and the odds of hitting mafia are... not great still.

[Darthe]

I don't know if scum were given fake role claims, but I doubt they were given healer in this set up.

You can't prove that you're a healer.  Even should there be no NK it could be mafia withholding a kill.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

I don't know if scum were given fake role claims, but I doubt they were given healer in this set up.

You can't prove that you're a healer.  Even should there be no NK it could be mafia withholding a kill.

 

 

I know.

[Sili Quirrels]

Hey, and let's not forget I hinted at being merlin day 1.

[Sili Quirrels]

I will pull up a quote. just a moment.

[MrsClov]

 

 

Also, another reason I want to kill dice is because he wants me dead in every post, yet he claims to be working for town.

 

That just doesn't fly in my opinion. If he was actually going to keep to his word, he'd care more than this.

 

So you're reasons for lynching him are a personal vendetta.

 

I'm pretty against your reasoning for wanting to keep him alive tbh.  Dice claimed the main villain of the series when he thought he had been cop viewed and in that scenario a survivor claim is a safe response (seems to have worked so far).

 

My thoughts on it are this:

 

If mafia has safe claims I'd assume Dice would have as well.  By claiming 3p he could circumvent the day/game becoming about him vs what he thought was a cop.

If we eliminate non-town we don't accidentally eliminate town meaning that this gets us closer to winning.

Maintaining that extra space equates to losing a townie.  While that sounds negative it can help us by clearing up some of the confusion in the game.  

There is little consensus on who to lynch and the odds of hitting mafia are... not great still.

 

 

I'll give you that it could be a fake claim. I just don't think it buys as much information as you and Sili are saying it will. Next day phase, depending on who dies we'll still be in this exact spot arguing about who we think is scum, getting know where.