Escape From The Carnival Of Horrors! Game Thread [Mafia Win]

[Andrej]

FTR you aren't my top suspect atm Verb but I do have you rather high.

 

Doing jack all D1 I would probably say is null and despite how sharp you appeared to come out in the beginning I think you fell flat pretty quickly as D1 progressed, which is one of the reasons why I'm not feeling as good about you as others express.

[Leelou]

Well, Verb doesn't always vote on D1, so his non voting activity doesn't seem out of place. 

[Andrej]

That's more or less what I meant Leelou. We've played in games where he was town and didn't vote D1 so I'm not saying it's a scum tell or something, but does make his statement less sincere in context imo

[Nynaeve]

 

 

 

[Sili Quirrels]

Well, Verb doesn't always vote on D1, so his non voting activity doesn't seem out of place. 

I know you think you're supposed to be a really good Verb Reader. So it seems to me if you're both town you might say a little more about Verb and his progression so far, but you don't.

 

If I hadn't read you wrong initially in the two last games I would be all over this stuff.

[Verbal32]

FTR you aren't my top suspect atm Verb but I do have you rather high.

 

Doing jack all D1 I would probably say is null and despite how sharp you appeared to come out in the beginning I think you fell flat pretty quickly as D1 progressed, which is one of the reasons why I'm not feeling as good about you as others express.

 

I'm calling you on this one.  You mentioned SEVERAL times yesterday about how I made points that made you reconsider things you hadn't noticed, yadda yadda.  And you liked my posts, you liked my focus........and you even said I was one of your greener reads.

 

This was all while I was around and posting.  When I left work, this is where we were at.  Now I come back today and we've had a deadline and flip.  I haven't said anything because I wasn't around - which was noted.

 

So I ask - how the hell are you now going to say I'm one of your top suspects now after all those nice things you said about/to me yesterday?

[Sili Quirrels]

Aj said at the beginning of night he'd need to rethink his reads list some.

[Leelou]

 

Well, Verb doesn't always vote on D1, so his non voting activity doesn't seem out of place. 

I know you think you're supposed to be a really good Verb Reader. So it seems to me if you're both town you might say a little more about Verb and his progression so far, but you don't.

 

If I hadn't read you wrong initially in the two last games I would be all over this stuff.

 

 

I'm not focusing just on him, and I'll give updated reads/thoughts in the morning. 

 

And yeah, you read me wrong, you might want to work on that. 

[Sili Quirrels]

No, initially I read you wrong. Usually I can see the town in you by the end of day 1.

[Andrej]

Pretty simple. I did think you had points of merit and was content to proceed through D1 having you in my group of non suspects. That's with no information to go on and mostly looking at everyone from a face value aspect. The game has progressed and I am allowing my reads to develop further. Just because I had you in green D1 doesn't mean you'll stay there for the entirety of the game. I've noticed things such as what I mentioned before and I thought Crusher was pretty insightful with his content regarding you - which I kind of alluded to after he posted it.

 

You're playing a super clean game, I'll give you that. But it also kind of puts my back up. For players of your experience level it's not hard to put on a good face for short periods of time whenever you're present in the thread. So like I said - you aren't #1 but my suspicion of you is growing, especially after the jab you took earlier.

 

I meant to ask before. Would you consider that sort of statement something you'd make exclusively as scum?

[Verbal32]

Pretty simple. I did think you had points of merit and was content to proceed through D1 having you in my group of non suspects. That's with no information to go on and mostly looking at everyone from a face value aspect. The game has progressed and I am allowing my reads to develop further. Just because I had you in green D1 doesn't mean you'll stay there for the entirety of the game. I've noticed things such as what I mentioned before and I thought Crusher was pretty insightful with his content regarding you - which I kind of alluded to after he posted it.

 

You're playing a super clean game, I'll give you that. But it also kind of puts my back up. For players of your experience level it's not hard to put on a good face for short periods of time whenever you're present in the thread. So like I said - you aren't #1 but my suspicion of you is growing, especially after the jab you took earlier.

 

I meant to ask before. Would you consider that sort of statement something you'd make exclusively as scum?

 

Oh I know you were referring to me when Crusher made his "too townie" allegation towards me.  You made it obvious with your next few posts, which I'm sure was your intent.

 

But you can't sit here and say I'm green and have maybe 8-10 posts of literally agreeing with practically everything I say, and then turn around and say I fell flat D1 when those agreements of yours came while I was around.  After I left, there is no way to fall flat - I simply wasn't here.

 

I get your read can change - but you're saying I'm a top suspect when I was (the last time I was online) a greener read.

[Verbal32]

Basically, it looks like you've been buddying me D1, with the small breadcrumb of cryptic (again) agreement with Crusher on "some of the things he said".....this allows you to come at me later on.

 

And when you say something I consider scummy and I call you on it, you resort to that breadcrumb to attempt to turn it around on me.

 

 

So yeah, I'm not liking this turn from you.

[Nynaeve]

I can loan you my shovel

[Verbal32]

I'm going to try very hard to be online at times this weekend.  I know I'm not normally, but I feel like D2 might be pretty active and I don't want to miss the first part of it.

[Verbal32]

I can loan you my shovel

 

I can't believe I used to like snow.

[Leelou]

 

I can loan you my shovel

 

I can't believe I used to like snow.

 

 

I hate snow. I'm moving far, far away. 

[Nynaeve]

It's even snowing in Israel. Basically everywhere that isn't Eilat :/   

[Leelou]

It's even snowing in Israel. Basically everywhere that isn't Eilat :/   

 

Mr. Pants is going to Israel tonight. 

[Nynaeve]

I'll remember to wear my sunglasses

[Andrej]

Oh I know you were referring to me when Crusher made his "too townie" allegation towards me.  You made it obvious with your next few posts, which I'm sure was your intent.

 

But you can't sit here and say I'm green and have maybe 8-10 posts of literally agreeing with practically everything I say, and then turn around and say I fell flat D1 when those agreements of yours came while I was around.  After I left, there is no way to fall flat - I simply wasn't here.

 

I get your read can change - but you're saying I'm a top suspect when I was (the last time I was online) a greener read.

The absence is what I'm characterizing as falling flat. I get that we have schedules and lives and what not, but idk. With how you came out I guess I expected more from you rolling into EOD. You made good points throughout the Day but in the end your presence wasn't really felt. You're not really on record for anything as far as voting patterns go and I personally don't think any of the arguments you made would be hard to make for you as either alignment. As I've said already, and a point you've stressed yourself, good scum players can come across as sensible.

 

We'll see how things progress after Night ends if we're both still around.

[Andrej]

Basically, it looks like you've been buddying me D1, with the small breadcrumb of cryptic (again) agreement with Crusher on "some of the things he said".....this allows you to come at me later on.

 

And when you say something I consider scummy and I call you on it, you resort to that breadcrumb to attempt to turn it around on me.

 

 

So yeah, I'm not liking this turn from you.

As far as the cryptic thing goes it's more my way of ensuring I live longer. I have a tendency to play a lot of my cards early on and then get NK'd.

 

You weren't the only person I was agreeing with when it came to Crusher's post fwiw.

 

Anyway, I'm at work now so I've got to run. I'll be back later tonight around when Night is scheduled to end.

[Nolder]

 

 

I can loan you my shovel

 

I can't believe I used to like snow.

 

 

I hate snow. I'm moving far, far away. 

 

Move to the sun.

[Nolder]

I was thinking about waiting for D2 but something's been bugging me since yesterday and I wanna get it off my chest both before I forget and in case I die.

 

I don't like that Sili said he'd vote for Dice but never actually did. It's like he's accepting responsibility now thinking that it looks and hoping we'll forget later when we examine lynch trains. Maybe that's way off you know. He might even be scum but not doing that intentionally. It's just a thought I had and I wanted to get it out.

 

So, yeah.

 

What's everyone doing this weekend?

[Sili Quirrels]

I accept responsibiility for Dice's lynch. I fully accepted it, thought he was scum, and it didn't pan out like id hoped.

[Nolder]

Yeah...but you never voted him. And that's my point.

I fully admit this might just be paranoia and not at all your intentions.