Escape From The Carnival Of Horrors! Game Thread [Mafia Win]

[Leelou]

Verb <3 - Verb's posts have been decent. I liked his exchange with Tina, but the Spidey could use some work. Hon, what do you think of Nolder? Also, don't ignore me. 

Sili  - Got people to start talking, but generally null with a sprinkling of both town and scum. I don't like the fact that he tried to say he wouldn't be picked and his reads list isn't very captivating. I find it easier to read Sili when he's starting to get pressure and see how he reacts. To answer your question - I was back at work after being off for a week and had a project dumped in my lap that was due by COB. 

Thane - Thane is Thane. Only really interacting with Sili. Need to see more here, actual commentary on the game. Null, Null, Null 

Hallia - Made a few posts, didn't really say a lot. Has Nyn and AJ as townies. Seems to feel strongly enough that Nol's comment was odd and voted him. The vote has a slight omgus feel to it, slight scum to null. 

Nol - Nothing wrong with his posts before 3:41 pm EST yesterday. I don't really agree with his reads on Hallia (she tends to disappear, no offence) and Crusher. Crusher isn't really adding anything of value to the game besides his lovable self. 

Tina - I don't really like how easily she's clearing Sili, but I do like that she is asking lots of questions and has a thread presence. She seems to be trying to figure out the game, but I will have to watch her posts going forward. For the moment, slight town lean. 

Crushlove - I know Boo Boo isn't here, I miss him dearly, but I'm need more from you. What are your thoughts on some of the players? You know a few of us enough. 

Nyn - Nyn's posts are solid, nothing seems out of place. I'll be looking as the game goes on to see if she is more guarded with her words, but she's in my town pile. Plus, busty. 

Kaylee - Answered Sili right off the bat. Seems to be coming up with town reads, but not really much for scum reads. Meh, I'll see how I feel after she catches up. 

AJ - Seems to be interacting well with who questions him, no squirming. 

dice - Not a lot to go on here, got defensive about saying he gave reads in his first post. His reads were meh, not really much of anything to them. Starting to focus on me, me, me and not picking up anything and running with it. Getting a slight scum feel. 

Red - going after people for the wrong things, really not liking the small things she is pushing over. Looks like she is trying to find anything to fling around and make stick. Null to scum lean. 

 

[v]Red[/v]

[Thane Vakarian]

working on something, just hard to do at work (and it takes time)

[Leelou]

working on something, just hard to do at work (and it takes time)

 

Indeed. 

[Verbal32]

Until it was pointed out I didn't notice how he called himself weak, and then he says something about being able to make strong reads on people. That contradicts so I wanted to add a pressure vote. I was wanting to see how he responded. With his recent posts I think he's sounding better. More genuine.

 

[unvote/]

 

I don't follow - how does he sound different now from yesterday?  This kinda looks like an unvote because both Nyn also moved her vote and you're getting attention for yours.

 

 

 

Verb <3 - Verb's posts have been decent. I liked his exchange with Tina, but the Spidey could use some work. Hon, what do you think of Nolder? Also, don't ignore me. 

Sili  - Got people to start talking, but generally null with a sprinkling of both town and scum. I don't like the fact that he tried to say he wouldn't be picked and his reads list isn't very captivating. I find it easier to read Sili when he's starting to get pressure and see how he reacts. To answer your question - I was back at work after being off for a week and had a project dumped in my lap that was due by COB. 

Thane - Thane is Thane. Only really interacting with Sili. Need to see more here, actual commentary on the game. Null, Null, Null 

Hallia - Made a few posts, didn't really say a lot. Has Nyn and AJ as townies. Seems to feel strongly enough that Nol's comment was odd and voted him. The vote has a slight omgus feel to it, slight scum to null. 

Nol - Nothing wrong with his posts before 3:41 pm EST yesterday. I don't really agree with his reads on Hallia (she tends to disappear, no offence) and Crusher. Crusher isn't really adding anything of value to the game besides his lovable self. 

Tina - I don't really like how easily she's clearing Sili, but I do like that she is asking lots of questions and has a thread presence. She seems to be trying to figure out the game, but I will have to watch her posts going forward. For the moment, slight town lean. 

Crushlove - I know Boo Boo isn't here, I miss him dearly, but I'm need more from you. What are your thoughts on some of the players? You know a few of us enough. 

Nyn - Nyn's posts are solid, nothing seems out of place. I'll be looking as the game goes on to see if she is more guarded with her words, but she's in my town pile. Plus, busty. 

Kaylee - Answered Sili right off the bat. Seems to be coming up with town reads, but not really much for scum reads. Meh, I'll see how I feel after she catches up. 

AJ - Seems to be interacting well with who questions him, no squirming. 

dice - Not a lot to go on here, got defensive about saying he gave reads in his first post. His reads were meh, not really much of anything to them. Starting to focus on me, me, me and not picking up anything and running with it. Getting a slight scum feel. 

Red - going after people for the wrong things, really not liking the small things she is pushing over. Looks like she is trying to find anything to fling around and make stick. Null to scum lean. 

 

[v]Red[/v]

 

No....nonononononono.  Don't do this to me.  Don't be scum.  That blue bold is something you do a lot when you're scum and I haven't been speaking with you.  You haven't been active in the thread - how the hell am I supposed to not being effectively ignoring you?  That was your quick way to "interact" with me and fire out the first "don't ignore me" - you'd use that later if you're scum to case me and show how you tried to interact and I didn't, yadda yadda.

 

I'm sad now.  FoS Leelou.

[Verbal32]

^ also, this list it too easy to make with a simple ISO skim.  I know you're busy, so some slack is warranted for now.......but I'm at the "significant worry" stage here, and it's still D1 dammit.

[Leelou]

You were ignoring me by not mentioning me anywhere. 

 

I'm not scum, nor am I FoSing you. 

 

What do you think of Nolder? You didn't answer the question. 

[Thane Vakarian]

So, here it is. Trying to get things here that stick out to me for each player. I can miss things.. still human.. my apologies. 

 

1. Verbal32: Comes in page 4, sorta nullifies the discussion of the previous 3 pages. Seems he thinks the discussion about the ongoing topic is irrelevant. Is it? Asks who didn't check in yet, but doesn't acknowledge the reply to it, nor mentions it again. post 80 for me feels like a soft defense of dice. Little FoS in post 90 directed at Tina. Convo between him and Crusher about BooBoo.. which is null to me. Ongoing, i find it odd that, even when he said 'start over' in his opening post, he's still going on about the first couple of pages.. Post 155, finally, SPIDEY! And, finally, a FoS at Kaylee after she reacted on Nyn's iso of Sili, followed by a suspicious look at Red.

2. Sili Quirrels:starts the first discussion of the game, and basically takes a lot of heat for it afterwards up to the point where he genuinly gets annoyed and angry. That's my impression. I do agree with his post #24, with which Nyn and Kaylee disagree. Posting on a phone does change your style some. Tends to be shorter post than usual, imo. Mentions he doesn't like my first post, too sure-footed. Red votes me for the opposite reason..... i do want to believe he's town here... but i can't be sure (yet). Seems to want to solve the game. Annoying skittle post...  

4. Hallia: comes in on page 6, asking if we can't agree we're all strong players. Dunno what to make of  that... looking to end conflict/discussion about the ongoing topic? Agrees with Verb next post, then is absent. Votes Nolder, over something i don't think a big deal. If you want people to read you better, post more content. 

5. Nolder: Like Red, votes me. Ok, no problem, i understand. But yeah, not many posts to work with, actually. Comes in and participates in Sili's famous discussion early game. Explains his playstyle in post 146, and in post 147 votes. Little FoS at Tina... but, imo, nothing wrong with being cautious early game. Defends his suspicion of Hallia post 204

6. TinaHel: here goes: this post seems like a lot of words to say: Sili seems town, but i'm not sure. Seems to be focused on SIli early game. Why him? Some more Sili posts, then asks AJ about 'clearing Kaylee', which earns her a FoS by AJ later on. Agrees with Nyn that Nolder is odd. Continues convo with AJ about Kaylee.Ends up voting AJ, adding a reads list. 

7. The Crusher: some joking with verbal, which is null. Other than that, left no particular impression on me. Null at best for the moment.

8. Nynaeve: page one, something stands out... Sili saw it too... opening post said it was D1, and she still assumed it was N0. Seems unlikely mistake for her... less posts than i'd have expected from her by now. Agrees with Verbals take on the early game discussion, which is in line with her thoughts page 1. Questions Leelou about her liking Nolder, which is absolutely legit imo. Nyn easily accepts that Leelou 'will be back later for indepth thoughts' though... , so yeah... seems off. Questions Kaylee for her reads, kaylee replies here (will come back to that). Doesn't follow up on the questioning.. the answer was enough, or the question just for show? Doesn't like Nolder this game, as seen here. Asks Crusher for reads. Don't remember seeing any elaborate reads from her though. 

9. Leelou: Likes Nolders posting here, but, based om what? Admitted she just skimmed through the thread, so it seems very odd that it looks good for her. 

10. Kaylee: Jumps into the discussion with Sili from page one on. Works the same way i do, not trusting anybody untill cleared for her.  So, here, explains why she likes Nyn, verb and AJ. But, if Verb is in townrange for her, and says Nyn could be either alignment, shouldn't she be more wary of Nyn? Continues "Sili's chat" with AJ. Says Tina is town. Later, follows Nyn in her vote on Sili. What i lack from her are elaborate reads, her own casing. Seems more likely to follow than to scumhunt.   

11. Andrej: how'd he get so many posts? seems to be agreeing to a lot of people in general. Asks around, goes into conversations, but i lack the fulltownAJ for the moment. As i said before, most of his posts flew right under my radar. Either i naturally don't suspect him (which would be dangerous) or he deliberately posts so he doesn't stand out much.... 

12. dicetosser1: Still an ongoing struggle with Sili. Feels like town vs town to me for now. Other then the discussion with Sili, not much to go on. based on that, townish pile for now though.

13. Red2111: not a LOT of posts... we'll see where we'll get to. Votes me to get talking. Well, i'm working on it. Doing this entire thing at work, is not easy. In my defense: i could just slack it off and be done with it, but i'm still trying to play the game. Hopefully you'll see that soon. Said here who your top candidates were.20 posts later, none of those are in your pool of suspects... not a lot of posts between  first suspects and second suspects... makes me wary. Misunderstanding between her and Sili over the go-getter.... or overly defensive? Last post looks a bit better, but yeah... not convinced of town, at all.

[Verbal32]

You were ignoring me by not mentioning me anywhere. 

 

I'm not scum, nor am I FoSing you. 

 

What do you think of Nolder? You didn't answer the question. 

 

You had not yet participated in the game.  Same reason I didn't mention Hallia or Crusher.

 

I didn't say you were FoS'ing me - I said you're planting a seed for a future case.  You've done it before - and I have as well to you when I've been scum and you town.  Just sayin'.

 

Re: Nolder - I'm currently leaning town on him.  As scum I don't believe he would have mentioned the "lulz vote" - too risky to get attention.  That's a small detail, true, but he currently isn't on my list to keep an eye on.

[Thane Vakarian]

based on all of that, my main scum suspects, in no particular order: Red, AJ, Kaylee, Leelou.

[Kaylee]

Verb: I'll be answering that in a minuet.

[Andrej]

Good morning everyone.

Late start to my day

 

The coffee's on, gonna re-read through the last few pages.

[Leelou]

 

You were ignoring me by not mentioning me anywhere. 

 

I'm not scum, nor am I FoSing you. 

 

What do you think of Nolder? You didn't answer the question. 

 

You had not yet participated in the game.  Same reason I didn't mention Hallia or Crusher.

 

I didn't say you were FoS'ing me - I said you're planting a seed for a future case.  You've done it before - and I have as well to you when I've been scum and you town.  Just sayin'.

 

Re: Nolder - I'm currently leaning town on him.  As scum I don't believe he would have mentioned the "lulz vote" - too risky to get attention.  That's a small detail, true, but he currently isn't on my list to keep an eye on.

 

 

Okay. What about his reads on Hallia and Crusher? 

 

Also, more Spidey please? 

[Nynaeve]

8. Nynaeve: page one, something stands out... Sili saw it too... opening post said it was D1, and she still assumed it was N0. Seems unlikely mistake for her... less posts than i'd have expected from her by now. 

 

First of all, don't note things without saying what you make of them. It's useless. Yes, I thought it was N0, because I could have sworn I saw Cory say it was N0. I was wrong. It was like 3 am, so I prolly misread. So... what's your point? I mean it's all fine and well that you're pointing it out but what do you make of it? Why would I lie about it? Secondly, I've offered all my thoughts openly and with detail. So I think your remark about expecting more from me is pretty ridiculous.

[Leelou]

Thane, I take it you didn't read my most recent post in your catch up? 

[Nynaeve]

 

1. Verbal32: Comes in page 4, sorta nullifies the discussion of the previous 3 pages. Seems he thinks the discussion about the ongoing topic is irrelevant. Is it? Asks who didn't check in yet, but doesn't acknowledge the reply to it, nor mentions it again. post 80 for me feels like a soft defense of dice. Little FoS in post 90 directed at Tina. Convo between him and Crusher about BooBoo.. which is null to me. Ongoing, i find it odd that, even when he said 'start over' in his opening post, he's still going on about the first couple of pages.. Post 155, finally, SPIDEY! And, finally, a FoS at Kaylee after she reacted on Nyn's iso of Sili, followed by a suspicious look at Red.

 

So you know what I'm thinking? That I read this entire paragraph and I still have no idea what read you have on Verbal.

[Nynaeve]

Nyn easily accepts that Leelou 'will be back later for indepth thoughts' though... , so yeah... seems off.

 

Nyn easily accepts that Leelou will post more thoughts later because Nyn knows Leelou's schedule and general RL constraints that she's not a total b*tch about it and doesn't expect people to post on command.

[Andrej]

Kinda busty so it'll take me a while to catch up properly.

 

But for now... [unvote]

 

*busy lol

 

[Nynaeve]

Questions Kaylee for her reads, kaylee replies here (will come back to that). Doesn't follow up on the questioning.. the answer was enough, or the question just for show? Doesn't like Nolder this game, as seen here. Asks Crusher for reads. Don't remember seeing any elaborate reads from her though. 

 

Yes, Kaylee did reply. I didn't have anything to say about her reply. It was not indicative to me so I had nothing to say. I have offered my reads on players plenty. I might not have done a neat little list, but I have spoken my mind. Crusher has NO posts where he actually expresses any sentiment about liking or disliking people's posts. Nada. So it was a valid request. Still is.

[Thane Vakarian]

 

8. Nynaeve: page one, something stands out... Sili saw it too... opening post said it was D1, and she still assumed it was N0. Seems unlikely mistake for her... less posts than i'd have expected from her by now. 

 

First of all, don't note things without saying what you make of them. It's useless. Yes, I thought it was N0, because I could have sworn I saw Cory say it was N0. I was wrong. It was like 3 am, so I prolly misread. So... what's your point? I mean it's all fine and well that you're pointing it out but what do you make of it? Why would I lie about it? Secondly, I've offered all my thoughts openly and with detail. So I think your remark about expecting more from me is pretty ridiculous.

 

I have an axplanation now why you thought it was N0. At 3:00 am, a misread is likely. It just struck me as odd, that's why i put it there. As for your postcount. It has nothing to do with content, i'm just used to you being in the top posters of any game. Didn't say i was expecting more. 

 

Thane, I take it you didn't read my most recent post in your catch up? 

took me 4 hours to make that post, so i could have missed it. Sorry if i have.

 

 

 

1. Verbal32: Comes in page 4, sorta nullifies the discussion of the previous 3 pages. Seems he thinks the discussion about the ongoing topic is irrelevant. Is it? Asks who didn't check in yet, but doesn't acknowledge the reply to it, nor mentions it again. post 80 for me feels like a soft defense of dice. Little FoS in post 90 directed at Tina. Convo between him and Crusher about BooBoo.. which is null to me. Ongoing, i find it odd that, even when he said 'start over' in his opening post, he's still going on about the first couple of pages.. Post 155, finally, SPIDEY! And, finally, a FoS at Kaylee after she reacted on Nyn's iso of Sili, followed by a suspicious look at Red.

 

So you know what I'm thinking? That I read this entire paragraph and I still have no idea what read you have on Verbal.

 

Basically, you nail it. I don't know wether he's pointing fingers everywhere on purpose or not... Not really taking any full stances up untill my post. 

[Andrej]

Fwiw I think Thane is probably a townie and him being the leader wagon on D1 is pretty lame.

[Thane Vakarian]

 

Nyn easily accepts that Leelou 'will be back later for indepth thoughts' though... , so yeah... seems off.

 

Nyn easily accepts that Leelou will post more thoughts later because Nyn knows Leelou's schedule and general RL constraints that she's not a total b*tch about it and doesn't expect people to post on command

yet people vote me to do just that...... everybody always pushes and expects more from me. And that's not against you personally, don't get me wrong. 

[Thane Vakarian]

 

Questions Kaylee for her reads, kaylee replies here (will come back to that). Doesn't follow up on the questioning.. the answer was enough, or the question just for show? Doesn't like Nolder this game, as seen here. Asks Crusher for reads. Don't remember seeing any elaborate reads from her though. 

 

Yes, Kaylee did reply. I didn't have anything to say about her reply. It was not indicative to me so I had nothing to say. I have offered my reads on players plenty. I might not have done a neat little list, but I have spoken my mind. Crusher has NO posts where he actually expresses any sentiment about liking or disliking people's posts. Nada. So it was a valid request. Still is.

 

indeed it still is, i agree on that. 

[Thane Vakarian]

AJ, we'll see if the players voting me because they want more are satisfied or not. Honestly, i have other things on my mind right now than playing mafia, but when i say i'll play, i try to stick to that. And as long as i can. 

[Nynaeve]

 

 

Nyn easily accepts that Leelou 'will be back later for indepth thoughts' though... , so yeah... seems off.

 

Nyn easily accepts that Leelou will post more thoughts later because Nyn knows Leelou's schedule and general RL constraints that she's not a total b*tch about it and doesn't expect people to post on command

yet people vote me to do just that...... everybody always pushes and expects more from me. And that's not against you personally, don't get me wrong. 

 

 

Look, Thane. Leelou is a close friend. I know for a fact that when she says she's busy she's not lying. So if she asks for time to reply, I give it to her. She did reply later and I asked her to look into Nolder's posts. So she came through. I don't understand why it seems off that I waited for her to have the time to answer me properly. And I really don't understand why you're comparing that to the reasons behind the votes on you.

[Nynaeve]

 

Fwiw I think Thane is probably a townie and him being the leader wagon on D1 is pretty lame.

 

What specifically makes you think that?