[Basic]: Be Nice Mafia

[Sili Quirrels]

I tend to try and gut-read like this too, but (the red) didn't you just say "I don't build a case on clov..." ? (see above)

 

I don't get what you're implying?

[Sili Quirrels]

Ok. i) you still didn't explain what you meant by the 'logic' I originally questioned/didn't understand - the part where you said your interactions were 'likely v/v violence', but that you'd be 'spewed' clear if he is Scum. 

And ii) I thought the part  "Clov also nudged me repeatadly[sic] and took me to task quite readily. "  was you voicing your opinion/potentially suggesting Clov could be to blame for the off vibe I was getting from the interaction. Tbh the rest of it makes no sense to me.

 

 

i) guess i don't see the contradiction. 'clov is likely a v' and i'm a 'v', so v/v violence. then, clov and me went at each other hard, so if he is 's' then i'm probably spewed clear.

 

ii) I'm not going to over-think it. the quoted excerpt is more relevant to i.

[Niniel]

The ponies were worried. Who could have eaten the cake? Actually, most of them had thought about taking a small bite because the cake looked delicious, but that wouldn´t have been nice to Fluttershy. A pony should have the first piece of the birthday cake. They wandered around the room searching for clues when they heard the door shut. They all looked up, they hadn´t even noticed that the door had opened. Beside the door was a letter. Pinkie Pie read it.

 

Dear friends. I will go to the bakery and buy another cake. Let it be known that I never ruined the first one. 

 

/Shining Armour

 

 

 

Jmm, Shining Armour, has left the building (= have been nk´d). 

 

It´s now D2. Deadline is Wednesday 9 PM CET. http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20150114T21&p0=292&msg=Deadline+D2

 

With 7 ponies alive it takes 4 to lynch. 

[Sili Quirrels]

haha ~ 'i'm scum again' ~ if only that were true.

 

there's an old pog guideline which says when a person frequently regresses to complacency when otherwise they are skeptical and wary they are a wolf.  it's hard to pretend to be someone you aren't all the time, so where it concerns high content or a broad focus, most players tend to be intermittent about pretending to scum hunt.

fyi, i started writing this before cass. it might seem pointless but it's relevant to reading clov, tress, and thane.

[Sili Quirrels]

don't know why the wolves thought jmm would be a power role.

[Niniel]

Added the countdown to the OP and the last post.

[Songstress]

don't know why the wolves thought jmm would be a power role.

 

You don't?  Thane certainly thought he was.

 

cop yates, vig clov, doc jmm

 

That's what my gut tells me.

 

 

in a game this small, i'm just deleting people off my scum list when i think they are town.

 

Thane: town, i know

Cass: playing like i've seen her do before, and inthat game, she was town. I doubt she would be a wolf here.

jmm: hinted at town PR, so i'm going to buy it for now.

Sili: looked bad at the beginning, but he improved his game the past 24 hours.

Tress: feels more townie than wolfie to me, though i'd wish her stomach bug would go away so she'd be in here more.

BFG: plays well, is present a lot, reacts to posts. For me, that feels like town BFG

 

that leaves 2: Yates and Clov.

[Clovdyx]

[v]Thane[/v]

[Songstress]

[v]Thane[/v]

 

Think he'd be that obvious?

[Sili Quirrels]

i thought about it. there are 8 players, so what power roles can you even fit?

 

maybe this implies there's only 1 wolf.

[Clovdyx]

 

[v]Thane[/v]

 

Think he'd be that obvious?

 

 

I think he's where I want to start today.

[Songstress]

i thought about it. there are 8 players, so what power roles can you even fit?

 

maybe this implies there's only 1 wolf.

 

So you're thinking zero power roles, 1 mafia?

 

That would certainly be interesting.

[Niniel]

Jmm was vanilla. *tired mod*

 

Going to sleep now. See you tomorrow. 

[Songstress]

Jmm was vanilla. *tired mod*

 

Going to sleep now. See you tomorrow. 

 

Sleep well and stay warm!

[Clovdyx]

Sili - Did you ever answer my question about why you changed your stance on Tress?

[Sili Quirrels]

there could be

 

 

i thought about it. there are 8 players, so what power roles can you even fit?

 

maybe this implies there's only 1 wolf.

 

So you're thinking zero power roles, 1 mafia?

 

That would certainly be interesting.

if scum think there's a power role maybe they have good reason to.

 

as an aside, i thought you thought i was a wolf.

[Sili Quirrels]

Sili - Did you ever answer my question about why you changed your stance on Tress?

uh, no. i need to educate myself before i feel comfortable saying more.

[Songstress]

there could be

 

 

i thought about it. there are 8 players, so what power roles can you even fit?

 

maybe this implies there's only 1 wolf.

 

So you're thinking zero power roles, 1 mafia?

 

That would certainly be interesting.

if scum think there's a power role maybe they have good reason to.

 

as an aside, i thought you thought i was a wolf.

 

I'm in the process of recalibrating my reads.

 

You're still a strong possibility IMO.

 

Assuming your theory of one mafia, who would you say is the most likely?

[Sili Quirrels]

it's not a theory.

 

thane and you?

 

uh, doesn't seem like it's clov or yates but it could be. i would need to reread to get a better picture.

[Songstress]

it's not a theory.

 

thane and you?

 

uh, doesn't seem like it's clov or yates but it could be. i would need to reread to get a better picture.

 

Why Thane?

[Songstress]

Also... "It's not a theory."

 

So you brought it up out of the blue but don't actually think it's true?  Just trying to make sure I'm understanding you here.

[Sili Quirrels]

lack of volume. yates says that's a scum tell. plus some of his reads are a little hollow compared to what they purport, like the ones on me and jmm.

 

well i feel that way anyway.

[BFG]

Good evening :)

[Clovdyx]

lack of volume. yates says that's a scum tell. plus some of his reads are a little hollow compared to what they purport, like the ones on me and jmm.

 

well i feel that way anyway.

 

How do you figure?  His read on Jmm at least seems pretty solid.  

[Songstress]

lack of volume. yates says that's a scum tell. plus some of his reads are a little hollow compared to what they purport, like the ones on me and jmm.

 

well i feel that way anyway.

 

So you're basing your read heavily on what Yates thinks?  What if Yates is mafia, would that change your opinion of Thane's play?