[Advanced] Revenge of the Marlfox

[hazelkrs1]

You're lying to fit a narrative.

 

I've arguably done more to help this town win than anyone else in the game.

 

When you start participating regularly and actually try to clear villagers and POE the game down instead of calling villagers scum because they don't agree with you, you can talk. Until then -- zip it.

Reported. And quit trying to bully people- your weak and pathetic attempts to do so just straight up don't work with someone like me. You should know this by now.

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

 

 

Could go all the way back around and lynch Verb...

No. Key or Berf.

Key? Did you read her last huge post?

Yeah, and? People can compose themselves and make big long posts as scum.

^^^ Looks real good for Yates/Leelou imo

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

if town plays well, survivor can be a powerful ally.

Well, considering he just pushed me and you for no reason... and town usually loses very badly...

 

Well I'm sure you're right. Let's keep a possible scum alive just because he could be a powerful ally, but hasn't actually ever stepped up to the plate.

Not sure how anyone ever actually "cleared" Sili btw- he easily has the most number of "wow that's a crazy ridic scummy post right there" type posts in the game

[Arsis]

You know how Sili was cleared? He kept talking about hiw everyone had him as town and people believed him and put him as town because people like to agree and not stick out.

[Tommyrod]

 

You're lying to fit a narrative.

 

I've arguably done more to help this town win than anyone else in the game.

 

When you start participating regularly and actually try to clear villagers and POE the game down instead of calling villagers scum because they don't agree with you, you can talk. Until then -- zip it.

Reported. And quit trying to bully people- your weak and pathetic attempts to do so just straight up don't work with someone like me. You should know this by now.

It's my real opinion of your play. In short: it's not good.

[hazelkrs1]

You know how Sili was cleared? He kept talking about hiw everyone had him as town and people believed him and put him as town because people like to agree and not stick out.

This must be why I didn't go along with it- I DESPISE agreeing and not sticking out

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

You're lying to fit a narrative.

 

I've arguably done more to help this town win than anyone else in the game.

 

When you start participating regularly and actually try to clear villagers and POE the game down instead of calling villagers scum because they don't agree with you, you can talk. Until then -- zip it.

Reported. And quit trying to bully people- your weak and pathetic attempts to do so just straight up don't work with someone like me. You should know this by now.

It's my real opinion of your play. In short: it's not good.

You can give your opinion of my play all you want. Telling me to "zip it" is a kindergarten tier bullying tactic.

[hazelkrs1]

And with that I really need to crash. I'll try and focus on this game a lot more at work tonight.

[Tommyrod]

It's a lot nicer than what I wanted to say.

[Tommyrod]

Which is that you're a big dumb poo poo head dumb face jerk shrimp from the dingus planet where a statue of your head is idolized as the embodiment of all that is evil and bad

[Arsis]

:yawn:

[Andrej]

Hope everyone had a fun Halloween.

 

I feel like crap

[Sili Quirrels]

You know how Sili was cleared? He kept talking about hiw everyone had him as town and people believed him and put him as town because people like to agree and not stick out.

I don't think that's how it worked XD

[Andrej]

I agree with Despot that Key's post was kind of bizarre. I had the same thought as I was reading it a while ago.

[Andrej]

Also Rags and Arsis, do you guys even lift?

[Sili Quirrels]

Despothera accosted tomcat for not scum hunting despite tomcat's 1 or 2 page spread scum hunting.

 

I kind of don't want to speculate.

[Krakalakachkn]

Hope everyone had a fun Halloween.

I feel like crap

Seconded

[keyholder21]

@ Des - when it is EVER a good idea to give away a tell on someone before they actually commit it? How is it helpful? It’s like you weren’t/aren’t trying to figure out what we are, but were just throwing something out there on thread.  

 

Edit: Same first two sentences to you, AJ. 

 

Page 55 – 83

 

 

#1108 – Tommy has us as teal.  Why? When does this change? Arsis and Berf as Orange.

 

 

#1151 – Alanna doesn’t see Berf’s post as scummy.

 

#1165 – feistiness looks townie for Alanna

 

#1169 – Alanna will go back and look at Thane and Arsis  Does she?

 

#1191 – Tommy speculating that Pral might be a wolf because he hasn’t caught up yet.  Is this normal townie thought?  Does he come back to it?

 

#1192 – Sili asking about the wagon on Berf. Null point.

 

#1206 – Bringing up BFG being busy as an attempt to avoid posting as scum is incorrect and low.  She posted in the SIGNUP about her busy work schedule, and I mentioned it as well.

 

#1234 – Tommy’s claim.  Why claim here? Some people thinking he’s scummy so far seems like the ultimate goal for BP.  Better than usual when he’s been OMG OBVIOUS TOWN and mafia would want to shoot him.

 

#1236 – If he IS town, as if a doctor wouldn’t want to protect you anyway?  Especially since he soft hinted at a PR.

 

Page 63- Sili telling Des he’s annoying is weird since I don’t see ANYTHING that Des did that was annoying.  He was posting about the game and not even in a crazy way.

 

#1333 – Now gets “competent wolf” vibes from me.  What changed between this and 1108?  I hadn’t even posted in between. “Bang on” in response to monstr’s list of people.  Appealing to him?

 

#1355 – Mostly agree with Alanna here, except that Arsis’s CC makes Tommy’s claim more believable, I don’t see it.

 

#1370 – I do NOT see how this is baiting.

 

#1391 – Has Sili mentions QT orchestration.  Has Sili played a game where there have been QTs?  If so, why ask about how scum communicate earlier?

 

#1400 – Berf still isn’t here.

 

#1402 – No, this is not you.  This is the OPITOME of being me.  People think I’m scummy when I’m town, and town when I’m scummy.

 

#1403 – Is a weird statement, “I don’t always have to jump on everything that happens”.  No one accused him of this, did they?Would scum Tommy say this?  What would be the point from either alignment?

 

#1405 – Leelou calls out for Pral, again with inactives – second time?  Again, is this normal?  Need to check Firefly.

 

#1422 – Weird responses from Thane re: Des, by saying des wasn’t so pleasant. Looks like working thoughts out on thread. 

 

*****The above is what I had been through before EOD and the Thane flip.*****

 

#1438 -1445 – Verb enters back into the thread with a comment about EDT = EST.  Would be easy to reenter the thread this way as scum or town, but doesn’t talk about anything super game related until asked by Tommy.   

 

#1458 – Would Hallia have the ease of this statement as scum? Possibly, if Tommy were town and townreading her.  Also, Cory to consider.

 

#1461 – Verb thinks Thane is scum.  In light of Thane flip, must consider.  Would scumVerb bring up a non-consensus suspect but not vote him?  In my experience scum!dice tunnels,  how does scumVerb react to challenge of his reads? Check Firefly.

 

#1474 – Would be ok with a Thane lynch.  How does he act at EOD? Check.

 

#1520-1 – Further cements my view that manbat is town.

 

#1526 – Jokey- tone makes me think town on Yates, because it’s similar, iirc, to Dr. Who and Avengers.  What would be the point of singling these things out as scum?  Unless Rags and Yates are teammates.

 

#1544 – Sili ties Thane (town) and Tommy together.  The phrasing “thane is more sus if I am right about Tom” looks more townie than scum since Tom was in much more heat at that moment than Thane.  Even if scum, and Tom were lynched would there be a point to tying Thane to Tom for D2?

 

#1545 – Is going out on a limb for Thane, when he isn’t in trouble, typical for wolf Cory?  In light of flip, this argument looks good. 

 

#1555 – Logical fallacy, imo.  If you were scum together, you could make any kind of gambit and state the opposite of what was going to happen, on thread.

 

#1556 – Sili asks about “wolf chat” but doesn’t mention a QT.  Earlier in game mentioned QT.  Weird.

 

Pg 78-79 – Yates questioning Tommy.  Can’t decide if scummy or townie.  I am skeptical of Tommy’s claim as well, but he had already explained the lynch/NK a few times, and the questioning could be Yates trying to bait Tommy into making a mistake in description that he can jump on.  Baiting is bad, although a mistake could be telling.  Seesawing here.

 

#1588 – Sili starts talking about the “push” BFG made on Tommy.  I don’t see what he’s talking about. Refers back to this later. Is he under pressure yet at this time?

 

#1592 – Leelou’s thoughts after Tommy asks for them.  Generally agree with her list at that point in the game, other than Thane. Don’t like that she didn’t give them before he asked.  Need to look at their interaction in Firefly.  Also, would Lee and Verb push the same person (Thane) as scum?

 

è Need to keep in mind whether how Verb and Lee interact as reading.

 

#1593 – Tommy pushes on Verb, Is he voting him at the time?

 

#1595 – Reads okay by Alanna, Could easily come from scum, especially if on a team with Verbal.

 

#1604 – Nothing inherently wrong with this, but easy post for scum to make

.

#1606 – Easy tone, Rags also had easy tone in Avengers when he replaced in.  Null tell, imo.

 

#1608 – Sili rebringing up Krak’s post has me thinking town.  IMO, scum would not want to admit that they didn’t get one, for fear of that being an auto obvious point they are different.

 

#1613- Don’t actually like Hally’s response here, since she is not the first person to bring the packages being missing up.

 

#1629 – Tommy hints that BFG being away might be because she doesn’t like being

scum.  Scummy, since she said repeatedly that she would be busy with work.  “Sili reminded me” looks like trying to shed blame in the event of a town flip.  

 

#1630 – Cory also states about BFG being absent as scummy.  Scummy again, for the same reason listed above. Fair points about me.

 

#1641 – Sili’s BFG “egg”.  Odd evidence.  Why would he use this as scum? Though, why would he use this as town?  Especially if he thinks Tom is scum….which I can’t tell anymore.

 

#1643- I think AJ’s comments about me are interesting, since in Darthe’s game, he was using my “flustered” or non-cool tone as thinking I was town, not the other way around.  I remember him mentioning how much smoother I sounded as scum.  Third party.  Doesn’t really care what happens.  

 

àNoting that at least Tommy, Lee, and AJ have Berf as suspect/at the bottom of their list by this point.

 

 

TL; DR

 

Verb still looks town to me, if not posting overly much.  I want to check back on how he reacted at EOD with the Thane CFD since he had mentioned fairly early on about being suspicious of Thane.

 

Sili looks town through here (not until later does he start looking less so, imo).  Especially his tying Thane to looking scummy IF Tommy flips scum.  With Thane’s flip, this seems unnecessary/unlikely tie if he were scum.  Also rebringing up Krak’s post regarding gifts in 48 hours.  I don’t think scum would want to point out on thread that they didn’t get one for fear of singling themselves out.

 

Cory and Tommy bringing up BFG being absent because she doesn’t like to be scum is irritating because she mentioned her being gone in the signups, in game, and I had also mentioned it.  Mildly scummy, because could be pushing an agenda.   Also don’t like Hally’s response to Sili bringing up the packages since she’s piggybacking on his statement about not getting one. 

 

I hope to have more time after the baby is in bed this evening.  Have to drop this for now because he’s waking up from his nap.  Will be in and out on mobile. 

 

[Pralaya]

This is where I am now. Especially looking at the wagonomics last day. More details she D2 starts but for now these are my reads.

 

Town:

 

Arsis

Tommy

Dice

Berf

 

Null/?:

Des

Rags

Manbat

AJ

 

Slightly scummy:

Verbal

Lates

Cory/Halley

 

Scum:

Key

Alanna

Sili

[Sili Quirrels]

Sili looks town through here (not until later does he start looking less so, imo).  Especially his tying Thane to looking scummy IF Tommy flips scum.  With Thane’s flip, this seems unnecessary/unlikely tie if he were scum.  Also rebringing up Krak’s post regarding gifts in 48 hours.  I don’t think scum would want to point out on thread that they didn’t get one for fear of singling themselves out.

 

I remember something like that but I forget the context. I probably just meant I would consider it.

[Sili Quirrels]

This is where I am now. Especially looking at the wagonomics last day. More details she D2 starts but for now these are my reads.

 

Town:

 

Arsis

Tommy

Dice

Berf

 

Null/?:

Des

Rags

Manbat

AJ

 

Slightly scummy:

Verbal

Lates

Cory/Halley

 

Scum:

Key

Alanna

Sili

This is a very convenient list. Care to go into detail with your reads?

[monstrman]

Sometimes I wonder if people can't read me because they don't try to

[Sili Quirrels]

@Key, I've never been in a wolfpack before. When I look for wolves I try to see patterns, hence the ring of small pushes on tommy that I was slightly miffed by. Sort of like all the wolves got together and thought up a plan to deconstruct tom and mislynch him.

 

 

It's probably a ghost though so I haven't brought it up since

 

[Sili Quirrels]

Pral probably won't respond. If he does, it won't be very wholesome.

 

I think his list puts all but a couple scums as town, most of the scum in the rift raft/null space, and 3 towns in the scum pocket.

[Yates]

This is where I am now. Especially looking at the wagonomics last day. More details she D2 starts but for now these are my reads.

Your reads are uncharacteristically terrible and have no reasons attached. Not sure why you think you're going to live to see Day 2. Unless you have information we don't?