[Advanced] Kronos and Kaylee's Firefly Mafia Won

[Sili Quirrels]

I... think(?)

[Tommyrod]

Gonna need more people to pitch in here. I can't carry the entire game.

[Andrej]

Fwiw if I could vote two people it would be Wombat and Hallia

[Andrej]

I kinda see what you're saying about Despot. The way he described me when Csarmi asked sounded like a generic description of town play instead of specific examples. I'm not putting him as a scum lean yet though as I'd rather reconcile on some other players first

 

Clov I think could be a villa

[Alanna]

 

 

 

Completely muddled on AJ.

Kinda thinking he's LOCK CLEAR

Good for you. Care to say why?

His perspective on the game seems wide open and easy to read- he looks objective and isn't trying to twist things to fit a narrative or anything and seems to be considering others POV's in different manners to determine their alignments

 

 

Bold is mine - I feel this too.

 

Right now my top suspects are probably Hallia and csarmi.

 

Leaning townish on AJ and Nyn.

 

Null to town on Leelou and Wombat.

 

Null to scum on Thane. I'd like to hear more from him on some of the recent turns in the game.

 

Otherwise, pretty much null on everyone else.

[csarmi]

Alanna, care to give some reasonings?

 

Like... Why? Don't have to be very elaborate but this won't do.

[csarmi]

I call sheenanigans.

[csarmi]

Hmm.

[csarmi]

Null on Clov and Wombat?

[Alanna]

Alanna, care to give some reasonings?

 

Like... Why? Don't have to be very elaborate but this won't do.

 

I gave my reasons earlier, around page 32 or 33, I think, but it mostly has to do with your voting and then backing off of Leelou in response to Clov's initial vote on Leelou. My opinion hasn't really changed since then.

 

[csarmi]

So.

 

Gut feel on Hally.

Mostly my Leelou vote - why is that a scum behaviour btw?

Mostly implies you got something more. Also, what's the point of your post then? If you add nothing more... And your opinion hasn't "really" changed. Why bother posting at all?

[csarmi]

"I agree with Despo on AJ - I also feel he's being..."

 

One sentence. Instead you add a long quote, a bunch of useless reads, a distancing from your own post by adding the "probably".

 

You get my point right?

[csarmi]

Oh and you make sure only to elaborate on why you have me as scum lean... Which is useless again cause i don't need your help in figuring out MY alignment.

[csarmi]

I... think(?)

You do that too?

[Hallia]

Morning;

 

What can I do to change that scum feel?

 

@Tommy - I agree, it is odd that so many are saying I'm scummy, but no one's feeling brave enough to vote.

[Alanna]

So.

 

Gut feel on Hally.

Mostly my Leelou vote - why is that a scum behaviour btw?

Mostly implies you got something more. Also, what's the point of your post then? If you add nothing more... And your opinion hasn't "really" changed. Why bother posting at all?

 

 

"I agree with Despo on AJ - I also feel he's being..."

 

One sentence. Instead you add a long quote, a bunch of useless reads, a distancing from your own post by adding the "probably".

 

You get my point right?

 

My opinion on you hasn't really changed, but I wanted to give an updated list of my reads in general. What do you not get about that?

 

I'm not trying to distance anything. I'm almost never very sure of any reads on Day 1. Most of the time I would prefer to sit back and say close to nothing on Day 1, but others have (understandably) expressed their dislike of my doing that in the past, so I try more to form some reads on Day 1.

[csarmi]

They're a bunch of weaklings.

 

What's your take on Alanna?

[csarmi]

I'm sorry Alanna but that's not a read list.

[Alanna]

What does a read list look like then? I'm seriously asking.

[Hallia]

Sili, being that you're unfamiliar with most of these players, my advice is to try and not rely on meta that much. I don't really play often enough to be very familiar with people's metas either, and I dislike relying much on what someone tells me about other players' metas.

 

I kind of feel like there's a little too much talk about meta around here anyway.

 

I have now typed "meta" so many times that it's lost all meaning to me lol.

 

 

I'm caught through page 27, mostly just need to read through all Despo's reaction posts now :P Some thoughts:

 

I'm not liking Hallia, mostly gut feeling. I have a tendency to not like Hallia though (I mean, I like her, but her posts often seem scummy to me :D). I mostly didn't like how she made sure to reiterate that she wasn't "rustled" after several people pointed out AJ had turned up before she voted him (when she'd said he'd turned up after).

 

There's a lot I'm not liking on csarmi, too. He sheeps Clov's reasoning for voting Leelou (though Clov's reasons weren't really clear), then when pushed about it, changes tack and backs off Leelou. Shortly after Nyn posts her suspicions about him, he makes sure to say that he likes Nyn so far this game - comes off to me like he's making sure he doesn't get defensive at her.

 

I also didn't like - and I don't really mean it seems scummy, I just mean I don't like it, especially if he's town - that he seems to think he should be obviously town to everyone just because he says so. I have played with him before, but not really in a while - I certainly have no idea what his town game looks like.

 

People that seem to be talking sense so far - Clov, Wombat, Nyn

 

These two things clash in my head.

 

Vote: Alanna

[csarmi]

Morning;

 

What can I do to change that scum feel?

 

@Tommy - I agree, it is odd that so many are saying I'm scummy, but no one's feeling brave enough to vote.

My girl

My girl

Don't lie to me

Tell me are you the wolf this time

In the thread

In the thread

Where the Tommeh's on the loose

I'm feeling like I'm all

Alone

 

My girl

My girl

Where will you vote?

Are you going

Where the flow takes you

In your eyes

In your eyes

Is that wolfness that we see

Come here and show

Your soul

[csarmi]

What does a read list look like then? I'm seriously asking.

Depends on the player in question. Leans, explanation, new information integrated and in general something that doesn't look like a homework you just had to make.

[Andrej]

What is happening

[Alanna]

@ Hallia - they don't clash in my head. I didn't FoS you because I always find you scummy. That would be silly, actually. In fact, I was saying that I'm being cautious about feeling suspicious of you because I tend to feel suspicious about you a lot, and I want to be sure that that's not the only reason I feel that way now.

[csarmi]

What is happening

I'm trying to figure out Alanna and questioning Hally. Care to join the party?

 

We got snacks.