Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[Tsukibana]

Care to elaborate? Or just gonna do a no-explanation vote and expect it to fly?

[Pralaya]

 

 

 

Analyze this too

 

Nice remark. As  if I hadn't already said that when you and thane finally posted your lists that they wouldn't be wildly different from those of Chae, Hallia, and CSarmi....

 

And yet, upon analyses, you have as Town everyone I just accused you of being scum with...

 

 

And what does that tell you?

[csarmi]

You sound too much. And too self-centered.

[csarmi]

That was at Ts

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

vote count:

 

Chae (2): Len, Che

Hally (3): Turin, Tsuki, des

Thane (1):Dice

Tina (1): pral

Len (1): Che

Thrice (1): 鲍勃不是我的

Tsuki (1): csarmi

 

Not voting (5): Ithi, Tina, BFG, Thane, Hally

 

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch. DL is Sun. June 22nd at 9 PM EST.

 

http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140622T21&p0=422

[Tsukibana]

You sound too much. And too self-centered.

Uh, what? Yes, indeed. Point?

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

NotBob, what did the 8-ball say again?

 

You come off looking scummy for this.  Lazy and concerned all at the same time.

 

NotBon, is it public who you are on JN?

 

Have no idea...nor do I care.  How about a nice game of chess?

[Tsukibana]

 

 

 

 

Analyze this too

 

Nice remark. As  if I hadn't already said that when you and thane finally posted your lists that they wouldn't be wildly different from those of Chae, Hallia, and CSarmi....

 

And yet, upon analyses, you have as Town everyone I just accused you of being scum with...

 

 

And what does that tell you?

 

 That you did so deliberately, in order to throw Wine - "Well, If I was scum, there would be know way I would do this, but since I did, he must be nuts."

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Tsuki it is a wonderful case you are making against me, and it makes me think you are mafia. At first i thought you could be town because what you held against me (my use of english) was soooo big that it could only be a joke in my eyes. This is still going on, and i think that you have an agenda behind it.

 

I have not made huge wall of texts here and i am playing with my impressions because i don't have the time to do better. I'd love to be able to make re-reads and build up cases but work and family are in the way. You don't like it fine. Call me scum all you want.

 

Now as far was i can say, i see that people are on my back because of the oracle construction that some of you are putting on me.

 

I asked questions about someone being able to have info about the set up because Thane mentioned my role in his first post and it suprised me. Yes i am a Town Joat.

 

I am quite suprised that no one has mentioned what i said at the beginning of this day : my action has failed and 2 votes against me popped up. SSeeing i won't have much time lately and that i am not sure i will be able to play during the weekend

 

i will unvote

[v] Chaelca [/v]

 

As for Despo usually i see him on the back of way more people than this time. THis was what made me think about him as scum.

 

 

does my decision hurt town ? maybe but i am not a good player. At least the other townies around will be able to read something after i am dead

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

please people, follow the train

 

 

 

 

 

I stil lcon

 

Poor play here...my policy is to lynch all self voters...so yeah...good luck with this plan.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Why would anyone care if your action failed? You were Roleblocked. It happens.  By stating you are JOAT, you just ensured yoe ARE RBed for the rest of the game, assuming you survive the day... Put your money where your mouth is - what action did you try?? Nice way to make it seem I am casing YOU, instead of your whole team. In fact, during the case, I never mentioned your English mistake even once. I DARE YOU TO FIND IT.

 

Nice that my main 3 scum show up. Where's the HubbyScum?

 

Poor Hallia. GF to this group... at least CS has avoided blatant misrepping to OMGUS me. Again, Chae, go find anywhere in my WoT where I mentioned your grammar issue. I will wait.

 

Real life reference?  Anything I need to know?

[Tsukibana]

Chaelca and Thane are married. Thane has been a scum read since day one.

[Pralaya]

 

 

 

 

 

Analyze this too

 

Nice remark. As  if I hadn't already said that when you and thane finally posted your lists that they wouldn't be wildly different from those of Chae, Hallia, and CSarmi....

 

And yet, upon analyses, you have as Town everyone I just accused you of being scum with...

 

 

And what does that tell you?

 

 That you did so deliberately, in order to throw Wine - "Well, If I was scum, there would be know way I would do this, but since I did, he must be nuts."

 

 

No, it just means that you are wrong :)

 

Have you made up your mind whether Hallia is a governor, GF, JOAT- what else?

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

I notice Ithis awful quiet.

 

I completely disagree with Des, I'm never hesitant to claim. I thought claiming at the time would help, as I thought they were both town initially. Knowing we could save them should've brought about good conversation but all it brought about was sassyness.

 

Conspicuous by her absence.  Yes, indeed. 

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Chaelca and Thane are married. Thane has been a scum read since day one.

 

Agreed.  Both self voted.  I can move to either.

[Tsukibana]

@ Pral - Defense Noted. I have already stated what I said I think she is.

[Pralaya]

 

 

For the Record:

Thane - a relative newcomer, mentions JOATS.

A JOAT would be an awesome scum balance in a Role Madness game.

Accepting that Sources outside Canon are possible, Moriarty has shown himself to be a master of disguise, capable of faking his own death, a genius to match Holmes.

A JOAT, whose role involved Cheating Death, would have a Pardon ability - Hallia claimed this.

A JOAT, while having each ability only 1x, would have several SHOTS - Hallia said what, again?? Oh yeah, BUSTED.

 

Therfore, I submit:

Hallia is Moriarty. A GF/JOAT. The strongest counter I can imagine in a Role Madness game.

 

 

Interesting theory indeed...

 

 

 

For the record, if this post doesn't lock scum Despo, I don't know what will.

 

Since when have you seen Des accept a GF/JOAT as an interesting theory? A town Des would have ripped this to pieces. I don't believe it is a de-motivated Des. It is just him trying to buddy Tsuki hard.

[Tsukibana]

But nice way to try to deflect my case with humor and hand-waving.

[Tsukibana]

 

Since when have you seen Des accept a GF/JOAT as an interesting theory? A town Des would have ripped this to pieces. I don't believe it is a de-motivated Des. It is just him trying to buddy Tsuki hard.

 

Since when has GF/JOAT been proposed to someone. I will wait while you look it up.

[Pralaya]

Exactly my point. It is so absurd that Des coming in saying "Wow, interesting" is totally out of place.

[Tsukibana]

How is it absurd? ROLE MADNESS... duh.

 

How would YOU counter 10-12 Power Roles with 4-5 scum, Hmm? (yeah, there is room in there for 3rd party, don't act slick because you thought you had me)

[Tsukibana]

Wanna know how I would do it?

Bodyguard, GF/GOAT, Roleblocker... leaving one for fun.

[Pralaya]

Role madness doesn't mean absurd roles. It just means everyone has a role.

[Tsukibana]

*JOAT, not GOAT. Stupid phone.

[csarmi]

 

 

NotBob, what did the 8-ball say again?

You come off looking scummy for this. Lazy and concerned all at the same time.

NotBon, is it public who you are on JN?

Have no idea...nor do I care. How about a nice game of chess?

Maybe sometime. These weeks won't work. I have problems. Can't even sit anymore, apparently. Not spending time on comps when possible.

[Tsukibana]

Scum Thread...