[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia - Game Over

[Pralaya]

These are the scenarios..

 

There are 8 left right now and I am assuming 1 scum and 1 third-party.

 

This is the worst case. If we don't lynch either of Peace or GE, and mis-lynch a town, that will leave us with 4-1-1 tomorrow morning. With the day-killers, it could be down to 2-1-1. Then we will be down to Peace-GE wifom again. 

 

On the other hand, if we resolve the Peace-GE situation now, if we mislynch, we start with 4-1-1 tomorrow down to 2-1-1 with a definite scum/3rd party kill. Even them we may not have a chance.

 

Of course, these are the worst cases but still I would do away with the Peace-GE now rather than tomorrow.

[AVM]

The Force, these two are not strong with.

 

So, Peace had the aforementioned momentum push against GE on D1...and was the only one to vote Pral and side with Mish, who flipped scum....

 

Unvote vote Peace

 

 

 

That's what I was thinking. Probably Palpatine as a Godfather and Fett as the SK.

I'd be willing to bet you hit both on possible roles left and the characters

 

So, Peace had the aforementioned momentum push against GE on D1...and was the only one to vote Pral and side with Mish, who flipped scum....

 

Unvote vote Peace

 

That makes sense to me. 

 

Vote Peace

 

 

 

 

 

The Force, this one is strong with.

So, Golden's interactions with the two known mafia make me wonder - especially the fact that Hallia seemed to be leading up to a vote on Golden but instead voted Pral with no real justification, avoiding the train that looked most likely to take off (already at 3 votes) and instead joining her scum mate on Pral's train.

 

Peace's play has been pretty much overtly scummy - which could be because he was trying to draw a cop view as Godfather.  I have an alternate explanation in mind, but I'm torn.  I've tried to figure out why Peace does the things he does before and been utterly wrong.

 

I think I'm good with voting either one of them today, but I'm going with my gut right this second.

 

Vote Golden

 

 

UNVOTE

 

VOTE GOLDEN.

 

 

Peace is NOT Yoda

[AVM]

You can lynch me first if you'd prefer, we have the numbers.  I'm pretty sure GF is the other anti-town role, fwiw.

[Songstress]

These are the scenarios..

 

There are 8 left right now and I am assuming 1 scum and 1 third-party.

 

This is the worst case. If we don't lynch either of Peace or GE, and mis-lynch a town, that will leave us with 4-1-1 tomorrow morning. With the day-killers, it could be down to 2-1-1. Then we will be down to Peace-GE wifom again.

 

On the other hand, if we resolve the Peace-GE situation now, if we mislynch, we start with 4-1-1 tomorrow down to 2-1-1 with a definite scum/3rd party kill. Even them we may not have a chance.

 

Of course, these are the worst cases but still I would do away with the Peace-GE now rather than tomorrow.

What if they're both telling the truth? Who else do you think is scum?

[AVM]

I'm Obi-Wan, btw

[GoldeneyesND]

Peace-GF for anti-town? Also yes, if I were to fake claim Luke would be stupid and I would absolutely not call him a VT. 

[Pralaya]

And, GE would not claim Luke and VT if he was scum. I find peace's counter claim weak

 

unvote vote peace

[Pralaya]

 

These are the scenarios..

 

There are 8 left right now and I am assuming 1 scum and 1 third-party.

 

This is the worst case. If we don't lynch either of Peace or GE, and mis-lynch a town, that will leave us with 4-1-1 tomorrow morning. With the day-killers, it could be down to 2-1-1. Then we will be down to Peace-GE wifom again.

 

On the other hand, if we resolve the Peace-GE situation now, if we mislynch, we start with 4-1-1 tomorrow down to 2-1-1 with a definite scum/3rd party kill. Even them we may not have a chance.

 

Of course, these are the worst cases but still I would do away with the Peace-GE now rather than tomorrow.

What if they're both telling the truth? Who else do you think is scum?

 

 

How can both be true? How can both be Luke?

 

The other one with FoS is GF

[Pralaya]

Sorry, I think i misunderstood what Peace said :)

 

unvote

[Songstress]

 

The Force, these two are not strong with.

 

So, Peace had the aforementioned momentum push against GE on D1...and was the only one to vote Pral and side with Mish, who flipped scum....

 

Unvote vote Peace

 

 

 

That's what I was thinking. Probably Palpatine as a Godfather and Fett as the SK.

I'd be willing to bet you hit both on possible roles left and the characters

 

So, Peace had the aforementioned momentum push against GE on D1...and was the only one to vote Pral and side with Mish, who flipped scum....

 

Unvote vote Peace

 

That makes sense to me. 

 

Vote Peace

 

 

 

 

 

The Force, this one is strong with.

So, Golden's interactions with the two known mafia make me wonder - especially the fact that Hallia seemed to be leading up to a vote on Golden but instead voted Pral with no real justification, avoiding the train that looked most likely to take off (already at 3 votes) and instead joining her scum mate on Pral's train.

 

Peace's play has been pretty much overtly scummy - which could be because he was trying to draw a cop view as Godfather.  I have an alternate explanation in mind, but I'm torn.  I've tried to figure out why Peace does the things he does before and been utterly wrong.

 

I think I'm good with voting either one of them today, but I'm going with my gut right this second.

 

Vote Golden

 

 

UNVOTE

 

VOTE GOLDEN.

 

 

Peace is NOT Yoda

 

 

OK, this looks like a counterclaim...

 

 

I'm Obi-Wan, btw

 

But then you give us this.  

 

What makes you think Peace is lying?

[keyholder21]

I'm not sure if I will be able to be around again before deadline; I'm in like a billion meetings today. I'll try to though.


Vote GF.

 

 

Also curious about AVM's claim that peace is lying.

[AVM]

IGNORE ME I'M AN IDIOT

 

I read Ishy's post and did the math wrong.  Was thinking Yoda wasn't in the game based off the numbers, but he definitely is.

 

I'd say based off all deaths being vanilla (save for R2) or goon mafia, it's pretty safe to say the SK is a one man team -- not the Boba/Jabba combo we tossed out there on D1.  Here's what we know:

 

2. Peace -- claims Yoda

9. Goldy -- claims Luke

10. AMV -- claims Obi Wan

 

3. Ishy

5. Key

7. Pral

11. Tress

12. GF

 

That leaves C3PO, Han, Lando? (or Admiral Ackbar?), Boba Fett,  and the Emperor for those 5.  Yoda has to be in here, I just suck at math.

 

unvote vote GF

[AVM]

 

 

The Force, these two are not strong with.

 

So, Peace had the aforementioned momentum push against GE on D1...and was the only one to vote Pral and side with Mish, who flipped scum....

 

Unvote vote Peace

 

 

 

That's what I was thinking. Probably Palpatine as a Godfather and Fett as the SK.

I'd be willing to bet you hit both on possible roles left and the characters

 

So, Peace had the aforementioned momentum push against GE on D1...and was the only one to vote Pral and side with Mish, who flipped scum....

 

Unvote vote Peace

 

That makes sense to me. 

 

Vote Peace

 

 

 

 

 

The Force, this one is strong with.

So, Golden's interactions with the two known mafia make me wonder - especially the fact that Hallia seemed to be leading up to a vote on Golden but instead voted Pral with no real justification, avoiding the train that looked most likely to take off (already at 3 votes) and instead joining her scum mate on Pral's train.

 

Peace's play has been pretty much overtly scummy - which could be because he was trying to draw a cop view as Godfather.  I have an alternate explanation in mind, but I'm torn.  I've tried to figure out why Peace does the things he does before and been utterly wrong.

 

I think I'm good with voting either one of them today, but I'm going with my gut right this second.

 

Vote Golden

 

 

UNVOTE

 

VOTE GOLDEN.

 

 

Peace is NOT Yoda

 

 

OK, this looks like a counterclaim...

 

 

I'm Obi-Wan, btw

 

But then you give us this.  

 

What makes you think Peace is lying?

 

 

He's Yoda.  Ignore my stupidity.

[Songstress]

Ok. I have a pretty good idea of what we're looking at if GF is mafia.

[John E. Kelley]

We can just break the game open with a mass claim you know....

 

I'm Han, three shot Vig. I shot Despo and Hobbit.

 

Anyone who refuses to claim or offers a sketchy claim is our remaining scum.

[John E. Kelley]

Darthe's Mason partner (Threepio I'm assumig) should reveal asap.

[Leelou]

Vote Count

 

GF (4) - Tress, Ishy, Key, AVM

Goldy (2) - Peace, GF

Peace (1) - Goldy

 

Not voting - Pral

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Deadline Friday 6 pm EST.

 

Please let me know if not correct - babysitting and modding from a kindle

[GoldeneyesND]

I'd like to hammer GF, but I presume we're waiting for a claim? 

[Pralaya]

Might as well. I am Lando, cop.

I viewed Mish N1. 

[John E. Kelley]

I'd like to hammer GF, but I presume we're waiting for a claim?

 

It would be good form to let him claim first before hammering him, yeah. That being said, if he doesn't claim soon, he's shit outta luck.

[GoldeneyesND]

Yeah I only ask because he's just as likely to just not show up before any deadline. But I agree we need to give him time.  

[Leelou]

3 hours to deadline

[Songstress]

Darthe's Mason partner (Threepio I'm assumig) should reveal asap.

Darthe sends his love. I am C3P0.

[Songstress]

GF already claimed vanilla without a character claim.

 

We won't lose much if he doesn't get back in time to character reveal, and if he is vanilla that means there have to be safe fake claims because at this point Key is the only one who hasn't claimed.

[Graendals favourite]

I am vanilla, Mon Mothma.