[Basic] Christmas Mentors & Maffia

[Nolder]

Too bad. I would have liked to see the advice.

Ditto. Mostly because I am a big fat ego head and want to fact check advice given to see if I agree or disagree with any of it.

[peacesells]

I don't think your are a cheater Nolder.  Nor would I ever hold someone "faking RL" against them or consider someone doing that being a cheater.  It's part of the game that happens.  Some people do it.  Some don't.  I don't, but that is just me. 

[BFG]

Ditto, but need the advice

[Nolder]

Really impressed with Cloud's and Tommy's play and I have to admit Nolders as well.

 

I have to find a way to not come across as scummy when I lock on to a read.  It's a problem I've had for a long time..and I think it gets manipulated at bit. 

Thanks. For what it's worth you, Leelou, and BFG all had me sweating bullets in the early game.

Very impressed with the fact that you and Leelou took down Golden with a meta read after only having played a game with him.

Kind of why I kept trying to discredit that fact because I found it really pretty crazy.

[peacesells]

Man..Golden just screamed scum at me with just one post.   In his first game, I was scum and I commented several times on just how well thought out his posts and reasonings were.  He was the complete opposite here. 

 

He really has great potential if he keeps to his first game style.

[Tommyrod]

Hallia was the most inexperienced player but overall quality of play is impressively high on DM; town lost to mid game inactivity more than anything else I think.

[Nolder]

I don't think your are a cheater Nolder.  Nor would I ever hold someone "faking RL" against them or consider someone doing that being a cheater.  It's part of the game that happens.  Some people do it.  Some don't.  I don't, but that is just me. 

Really, this is all I wanted you to say.

Your implication was like a cloud I felt was going to follow me around. In an honor system all you have is your reputation.

In another forum with a different community I might agree with you but DM isn't the cut throat no hold's barred type of place for mafia.

I don't think anyone should be lying about RL stuff because it's emotionally manipulative in a very grey area.

I don't want someone's grandmother to die and not be able to express anything but suspicion when they're away for the funeral and I think most people feel the same.

 

I do apologize for bringing my real life into the game though.

I also think that's not something people should do normally.

I felt pressured to not be a detriment to my team which is why I brought it up but that was my mistake and if I hadn't it wouldn't have caused all these problems.

I really am sorry for that and apologize to you and Csarmi for disrupting the game with our arguing and to anyone who was put off by it.

[BFG]

It's depressing to realise we lost to someone who didn't read the thread :(

 

That was to Tommy

[csarmi]

Mafia Qt: http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/xnvPqdTdmNEng

[Nolder]

It's depressing to realise we lost to someone who didn't read the thread :(

 

That was to Tommy

If it makes you feel any better, I was skimming a lot more than I let on.

I really didn't want to reread for this game and put minimal effort into that.

You guys should have kept on me about getting my thoughts and analyzing posts and stuff.

I didn't know what anyone was talking about half the time and I'm not even sure I read more than half of any post Via made...

[Tommyrod]

It's depressing to realise we lost to someone who didn't read the thread :(

 

That was to Tommy

I was playing 4 games, days were very long, and people weren't very active. It was an ideal environment for me to just coast. Usually I don't do that as scum though.

[csarmi]

Nolder -

 

I don't think your are a cheater Nolder.  Nor would I ever hold someone "faking RL" against them or consider someone doing that being a cheater.  It's part of the game that happens.  Some people do it.  Some don't.  I don't, but that is just me.

Really, this is all I wanted you to say.

Your implication was like a cloud I felt was going to follow me around. In an honor system all you have is your reputation.

In another forum with a different community I might agree with you but DM isn't the cut throat no hold's barred type of place for mafia.

I don't think anyone should be lying about RL stuff because it's emotionally manipulative in a very grey area.

I don't want someone's grandmother to die and not be able to express anything but suspicion when they're away for the funeral and I think most people feel the same.

 

I do apologize for bringing my real life into the game though.

I also think that's not something people should do normally.

I felt pressured to not be a detriment to my team which is why I brought it up but that was my mistake and if I hadn't it wouldn't have caused all these problems.

I really am sorry for that and apologize to you and Csarmi for disrupting the game with our arguing and to anyone who was put off by it.

 

Apology accepted. Let's move on guys.

 

Peace: sorry if I didn't handle it the best way. I really did try my best. I didn't wanna throw your game off.

[peacesells]

Nolder -

 

I don't think your are a cheater Nolder.  Nor would I ever hold someone "faking RL" against them or consider someone doing that being a cheater.  It's part of the game that happens.  Some people do it.  Some don't.  I don't, but that is just me.

Really, this is all I wanted you to say.

Your implication was like a cloud I felt was going to follow me around. In an honor system all you have is your reputation.

In another forum with a different community I might agree with you but DM isn't the cut throat no hold's barred type of place for mafia.

I don't think anyone should be lying about RL stuff because it's emotionally manipulative in a very grey area.

I don't want someone's grandmother to die and not be able to express anything but suspicion when they're away for the funeral and I think most people feel the same.

 

I do apologize for bringing my real life into the game though.

I also think that's not something people should do normally.

I felt pressured to not be a detriment to my team which is why I brought it up but that was my mistake and if I hadn't it wouldn't have caused all these problems.

I really am sorry for that and apologize to you and Csarmi for disrupting the game with our arguing and to anyone who was put off by it.

 

Apology accepted. Let's move on guys.

 

Peace: sorry if I didn't handle it the best way. I really did try my best. I didn't wanna throw your game off.

 

 

I know you didn't want to influence the game.  Was just giving you a heads up for future reference since you asked.  No biggie.

 

And I'm very happy Nolder and I can be on good terms. 

 

I too apologize for the influence on the game.

[csarmi]

I'll look into the masons QT posting soon. Remember, the QT links are all listed in page 1 (post #5)

[csarmi]

Cool.

 

For future reference to self as mod.

 

If your instincts say you shouldn't intervene: don't

If you don't know what to do: don't do anything.

If you aren't 100% sure you shoudl say something: keep your mouth shut.

[Nolder]

Cool.

 

For future reference to self as mod.

 

If your instincts say you shouldn't intervene: don't

If you don't know what to do: don't do anything.

If you aren't 100% sure you shoudl say something: keep your mouth shut.

I've been there before.

 

And IIRC I think it may have been Peace who got mad at me for getting too involved too.

Can't remember which game it was though.

[BFG]

Nolder, case wasn't about inactivity, as I said you had one of the highest post counts, it was because you were being more passive than I was expecting.

 

Sorry reading QT. Also lol at Golden's early posts

[csarmi]

General warning. The QT's might contain non-PG13 posts. You've been warned - proceed at your own risk. They do NOT have a bad language at all, just a couple of "bad" words here and there.

[Hallia]

Thanks for running this Csarmi!

[csarmi]

Masons QT: http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/BpXy9BhTX8q

[csarmi]

Thanks for running this Csarmi!

Thanks for playing in this Hally! I feel honored.

[Hallia]

^_^ One day I'll be the very best, like no one ever was

[csarmi]

Note to other players:

 

Hally's reads were scary good. I was there in the mentor QT and saw them. I can't tell anything more though.

 

I swore secrecies!

[csarmi]

All QT's are up. I don't think any more will be posted. Things are summarized in the first couple of posts.

[Nolder]

Oh another thing I just thought of.

I was, for the most part, purposely avoiding lynches so I wouldn't be held responsible for townie deaths.

I figured this would get suspicious eventually so I went on Krak since he didn't seem to want to fight back.

Was kind of worried someone would notice this trend and bury me for it but no one ever really brought it up other than to note it as a minor point.